Zancolich v Bluescope Steel Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Zancolich v Bluescope Steel Limited [2007] NSWWCCPD 138

APPELLANT:  Paul Zancolich

RESPONDENT:  Bluescope Steel Limited

INSURER:Bluescope Steel Limited (self insurer)

FILE NUMBER:  WCC17950-05

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          4 December 2006

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  13 June 2007

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Adequacy of evidence in respect of an award pursuant to section 40 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987; adequacy of reasons.

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Russell McLelland Brown

Respondent:   Sparke Helmore

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  1.         The decision of the Arbitrator dated 4  December 2006 is revoked.

2.The matter is remitted to the Arbitrator at first instance for reconsideration of the source material and, if applicable, any relevant awards attached to the occupations identified in the vocational assessment report, dated 1 February 2006, as suitable, for the purposes of recalculation of the Appellant’s entitlements to a section 40 award.

3.The Respondent is to pay the costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. On 27 December 2006, Paul Zancolich (‘the Appellant’) sought leave to bring an ‘Appeal Against Decision of Arbitrator’ in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) against a decision of a Commission Arbitrator dated 4 December 2006.

  1. The Respondent to the appeal is Bluescope Steel Limited (‘the Respondent’).

  1. The Appellant commenced employment with the Respondent in 1986 as an apprentice fitter and turner, subsequently progressing to the position of crane driver/operator in 2001. His employment was terminated on 16 June 2005.

  1. The Appellant claimed that on 6 December 2003 whilst operating a crane he suffered an injury to his back. He was absent from work until May 2004 during which time, he received weekly benefits compensation from the Respondent. In May 2004 he returned to work on selected duties until 28 October 2004 when he suffered a further injury to his back. Following that incident, he was again paid weekly benefits of compensation pursuant to section 38 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’) until 16 June 2005 when his services were terminated since he was unable to resume his duties as a crane driver.

  1. On 16 August 2005 the Respondent advised the Appellant that it denied ongoing liability for his claim, and weekly benefits continued to be paid up until 26 September 2005.

  1. On 20 October 2005 the Appellant lodged an ‘Application to Resolve a Dispute’ in the Commission seeking weekly benefits compensation, medical expenses and non-economic loss compensation.

  1. The parties attended an arbitration hearing on 10 February 2006. On 14 February 2006 the Arbitrator issued a ‘Certificate of Determination’ together with a ‘Statement of Reasons – Ex Tempore Orders’. The decision of the Arbitrator was as follows:

“1.That the Respondent pay the Applicant weekly compensation from 26 September 2005 to 28 November 2005 of $560.00 per week under section 38 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

2.That the Respondent pay the Applicant weekly compensation at the maximum…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zancolich v Bluescope Steel Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWWCCPD 138
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Zancolich v Bluescope Steel Limited, the appellant, Paul Zancolich, sought leave to appeal against the decision of the Workers Compensation Commission's Arbitrator, which had been rendered on 4 December 2006. The primary issue in dispute was the adequacy of the evidence in respect of an award pursuant to section 40 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 and the adequacy of the reasons provided. The appellant argued that the Arbitrator erred in fact in finding that he was capable of earning a certain amount in suitable employment and that the Arbitrator failed to consider relevant factors set out in section 43A of the 1987 Act. The respondent, Bluescope Steel Limited, opposed the appeal and submitted that the Arbitrator's award was proper in the circumstances.

The Acting Deputy President, Deborah Moore, granted leave to appeal and reviewed the matter on the papers. The court admitted fresh evidence in the form of a document from the Australian Bureau of Statistics, but refused to admit the statement from the appellant and annexures as it would be unfair to the respondent and turn the appeal into a de novo hearing. The court found that the Arbitrator's determination as to the appellant's ability to earn in suitable employment appeared to be based on flawed source material and constituted an error of fact. However, the Arbitrator's determination in all other respects was found to be sound, and her reasons were adequate.

The decision of the Arbitrator dated 4 December 2006 was revoked, and the matter was remitted to the Arbitrator at first instance for reconsideration of the source material and, if applicable, any relevant award attached to the occupations identified in the vocational assessment report as suitable for the purposes of recalculation of the appellant's entitlements to a section 40 award. The respondent was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Paul Zancolich commenced employment with Bluescope Steel Limited in 1986 as an apprentice fitter and turner, progressing to the position of crane driver/operator in 2001. His employment was terminated on 16 June 2005. Zancolich claimed that on 6 December 2003 he suffered an injury to his back while operating a crane. Following this incident, he was absent from work until May 2004, during which time he received weekly benefits compensation from Bluescope Steel Limited. In May 2004, Zancolich returned to work on selected duties until 28 October 2004 when he suffered another back injury. Following this second incident, he was paid weekly benefits of compensation until his employment was terminated on 16 June 2005. On 16 August 2005, Bluescope Steel Limited denied ongoing liability for Zancolich's claim. Zancolich lodged an 'Application to Resolve a Dispute' in the Workers Compensation Commission on 20 October 2005. The parties attended an arbitration hearing on 10 February 2006. On 14 February 2006, the Arbitrator issued a 'Certificate of Determination' together with a 'Statement of Reasons - Ex Tempore Orders'. Zancolich subsequently sought to appeal the Arbitrator's decision.

Paul Zancolich sought leave to appeal a decision of the Workers Compensation Commission Arbitrator dated 4 December 2006. The matter came before the Commission as an appeal against the decision of the Arbitrator. Prior to this appeal, Bluescope Steel Limited had already appealed a decision of the Arbitrator dated 14 February 2006, which was determined on 13 July 2006. The earlier appeal resulted in the revocation of the Arbitrator's decision in relation to orders 1 and 2 and the matter was remitted to the Arbitrator for determination afresh. Following this, a further arbitration hearing was held on 10 November 2006, resulting in the Arbitrator's decision dated 4 December 2006, which is the subject of the current appeal. The Appellant filed a Notice of Appeal on 27 December 2006 and the Respondent filed a Notice of Opposition to Appeal on 13 February 2007.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Arbitrator err in fact in finding that Paul Zancolich was able to earn, in suitable employment, $1,023.00 per week?
2. Did the Arbitrator fail to have regard to factors set out in section 43A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 in particular, Zancolich’s age, education, skills and work experience?
3. Did the Arbitrator fail to provide adequate reasons for her findings and “… failed to make the Appellant aware of her views of his case in failing to state why she rejected it.”?

Held
1. The decision of the Arbitrator dated 4 December 2006 is revoked.
2. The matter is remitted to the Arbitrator at first instance for reconsideration of the source material and, if applicable, any relevant awards attached to the occupations identified in the vocational assessment report, dated 1 February 2006, as suitable for the purposes of recalculation of the Appellant’s entitlements to a section 40 award.
3. The Respondent is to pay the costs of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In reviewing the Arbitrator's decision, the court considered the Appellant's contentions regarding the Arbitrator's determination of the Appellant's ability to earn in suitable employment, the consideration of factors set out in section 43A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, and the adequacy of the reasons provided. The Arbitrator's determination was based on the vocational assessment report by Ms. Michelle Danforth, which identified six occupations suitable for the Appellant and the corresponding average weekly earnings. However, the court found that the figures provided by Ms. Danforth did not correspond with the source document to which she referred, leading to an error in fact. Consequently, the court set aside the Arbitrator's determination on this issue.

Regarding section 43A factors, the court found that the Arbitrator adequately considered the Appellant's age, education, skills, and work experience in determining suitable employment. The occupations identified by Ms. Danforth were in line with the Appellant's restrictions, age, skill, and experience, and the Arbitrator's acceptance of Ms. Danforth's assessment was appropriate.

Finally, the court concluded that the Arbitrator provided adequate reasons for her decision, consistent with the requirements of the Workers Compensation Commission Rules 2006. While the Arbitrator did not explicitly reject the Appellant's submission on earning capacity, her acceptance of Ms. Danforth's assessment implicitly rejected it.

In light of the error of fact identified, the court remitted the matter to the Arbitrator at first instance for reconsideration of the source material and any relevant awards attached to the identified occupations for the purpose of recalculating the Appellant's entitlements to a section 40 award. The Respondent was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.