| CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER | |
| CITATION: | Zahrouni v BSV Tyre Recycling Australia Pty Ltd [2024] NSWPIC 409 |
| APPLICANT: | Abdollah Zahrouni |
| RESPONDENT: | BSV Tyre Recycling Australia Pty Ltd |
| MEMBER: | John Wynyard |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 30 July 2024 |
| CATCHWORDS: | WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workers Compensation Act 1987; claim for declaration pursuant to section 60(5); whether applicant satisfied his onus that left shoulder surgery be approved; medical evidence inconsistent and contradictory; clinical notes referred to by expert not lodged; about 2 year lacuna between occurrence of injurious event and first report by medical practitioner who was applicant’s second GP; claim form signed during that lacuna nominated a different GP who did not supply evidence; no explanation given; Jones v Dunkel applied; Held – applicant did not injure his left shoulder; application rejected. |
| DETERMINATIONS MADE: | The Commission determines: 1. The applicant did not injure his left shoulder on 11 November 2015. 2. The condition of the applicant’s left shoulder is not consequential to the events of 11 November 2015, nor the surgery to his right shoulder on 23 October 2018. 3. The claim for a declaration pursuant to s 60(5) of the 1987 Act is accordingly rejected. |
STATEMENT OF REASONS
BACKGROUND
Mr Abdollah Zahrouni, the applicant, brings an action against BSV Tyre Recycling Australia Pty Ltd, the respondent for a declaration pursuant to s 60(5) regarding proposed surgery on the applicant’s left shoulder.
Dispute notices were issued and the Application to Resolve a Dispute (ARD) was duly lodged.
ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION
The parties agree that the following issues remain in dispute:
(a) did the applicant injure his left shoulder on 11 November 2015?
(b) If not, did he sustain a consequential condition to his left shoulder as a result of the event on 11 November 2015?
PROCEDURE BEFORE THE PERSONAL INJURY COMMISSION
This matter was heard in the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) on 26 June 2024. Mr Boris Necovski of counsel instructed by Mr Ankit Karanwal from Messrs John & Co lawyers appeared for the applicant. Mr Tom Grimes of counsel appeared for the respondent instructed by Ms Holly Easy from Messrs Hicksons Lawyers. Mr Haiman Hammo appeared as the interpreter and Ms Madeline Can appeared for the insurer.
I am satisfied that the parties to the dispute understand the nature of the application and the legal implications of any assertion made in the information supplied. I have used my best endeavours in attempting to bring the parties to the dispute to a settlement acceptable to all of them. I am satisfied that the parties have had sufficient opportunity to explore settlement and that they have been unable to reach an agreed resolution of the dispute.
EVIDENCE
Documentary evidence
The following documents were in evidence before the Commission and considered in making this determination:
(a) ARD and attached documents, and
(b) Reply and attached documents.
Oral evidence
No application was made in relation to oral evidence.
FINDINGS AND REASONS
At the commencement of the proceedings Mr Necovski amended without objection the ARD form to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Zahrouni v BSV Tyre Recycling Australia Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWPIC 409
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the applicant had satisfied his onus to prove that the surgery should be approved, given the inconsistent and contradictory medical evidence. Another issue was whether the clinical notes referred to by the expert witness had actually been lodged, and if not, what impact this had on the applicant's claim. The court also needed to consider the about two-year gap between the injurious event and the first report by a medical practitioner, as well as the lack of explanation for the absence of evidence from the nominated GP in the claim form.
The court found that the medical evidence was inconsistent and contradictory, and that the clinical notes referred to by the expert witness had not been lodged. The court also noted the significant gap between the injurious event and the first medical report, as well as the absence of evidence from the nominated GP. The court applied the principles from Jones v Dunkel, concluding that the applicant had not satisfied his onus that he had injured his left shoulder. The application was rejected.
No further orders were made by the court.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi