Yun Zhong Xie v CB Ideal Tapware Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read
[2023] FWC 1674

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Yun Zhong Xie
v

CB Ideal Tapware Pty Ltd

(U2023/2211)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT ANDERSON

ADELAIDE, 11 JULY 2023

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – fabricator – strike out application – whether binding settlement agreement exists – no concluded bargain – strike out application dismissed

  1. On 23 June 2023 the respondent employer made a strike out application. The strike out application is grounded on the proposition that a binding settlement agreement existed when the respondent through its solicitors accepted the terms of a settlement deed on 1 June 2023 following earlier conciliation before a Member of the Commission.

  1. After conducting a hearing of the strike out application on 29 June 2023, a decision was reserved.

  1. On 6 July 2023 I made an interim decision.[1]After settling out the facts and relevant legal principles, I determined (for reasons set out at [60] to [72]) to direct further Member Assisted Conciliation in advance of finally determining the strike out application.

  1. The further Member Assisted Conciliation was conducted by Commissioner Platt on 10 July 2023.

  1. The matter did not resolve and the file was returned to my chambers.

  1. I now proceed to determine the strike out application.

  1. The facts are set out in the interim decision (at [20] to [47]), as are the legal principles (at [55] to [59]) and a summary of submissions (at [48] to [53]). They need not be repeated.

Consideration

  1. For the following reasons, I do not conclude that a binding settlement agreement exists between the parties.

  1. Whilst I find that Mr Xie offered to settle his unfair dismissal claim for an agreed sum at the conclusion of the 25 May 2023 conciliation before Commissioner Platt, no settlement was reached at that time. This was for two reasons. Firstly, the employer did not agree at that time. It simply agreed to consider the proposal over a seven day period during which the offer would remain on the table. Secondly, the terms attached to Mr Xie’s offer as reflected in the settlement deed sent to the parties immediately following the conciliation were the Commission’s standard terms of settlement and were prepared by the Commission and not Mr Xie. In their entirely, these had not been agreed by Mr Xie at the time he offered to settle for a specified quantum.

  1. Mr Xie’s conduct following conciliation supports this finding. Mr Xie was asked via the 25 May 2023 email from the Commissioner’s associate to sign and return the deed. He did not do so. Five days later (30 May 2023) Mr Xie sent the Commissioner’s chambers an email which questioned the release clauses in the deed and sought an explanation of them.

  1. By this conduct, it can be safely concluded that not all of the terms of the draft settlement deed prepared by the Commission following conciliation reflected the terms on which Mr Xie was willing to settle the matter. On quantum they did. On release terms they did not.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yun Zhong Xie v CB Ideal Tapware Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FWC 1674
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Fair Work Commission, Yun Zhong Xie brought an unfair dismissal claim against CB Ideal Tapware Pty Ltd. The respondent employer sought to have the application struck out on the basis that a binding settlement agreement existed between the parties. The application for a strike-out was dismissed. The employer had argued that it had accepted the terms of a settlement deed prepared by the Commission on 1 June 2023, concluding a binding settlement agreement. However, the Deputy President found that no binding settlement agreement existed. The employer had accepted the terms of the Commission’s deed, not the terms offered by Mr Xie. Moreover, Mr Xie had not agreed to the release terms contained in the deed, which were fundamental to any settlement contract. The employer accepted the deed in good faith, but this did not create a binding agreement because the release terms had not been agreed to by Mr Xie.

The court carefully examined the facts and legal principles to determine whether there was a meeting of minds on the terms of the settlement. The Deputy President concluded that the employer’s acceptance of the Commission’s deed, which included terms that Mr Xie had not agreed to, did not result in a binding settlement agreement. The release terms were integral to the settlement contract, and Mr Xie’s objections to these terms demonstrated that he had not agreed to the terms of the deed in its entirety. Consequently, the court found that no binding settlement agreement existed, and the unfair dismissal application remained before the Commission. The employer’s application for costs associated with the strike-out application was also dismissed, although the court noted that this decision did not preclude a party from applying for costs at a later stage.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established