| SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA COURT OF APPEAL |
| S EAPCI 2023 0143 |
| S EAPCI 2024 0012 |
| YUME GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 613 528 475) | Applicant/Cross-respondent |
| v | |
| ASHTHORN CA PTY LTD (ACN 167 783 128) [NO 2] | Respondent/Cross-applicant |
---
| JUDGES: | McLEISH and KENNEDY JJA and WALLER AJA |
| WHERE HELD: | Melbourne |
| DATE OF HEARING: | On the papers |
| DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 26 June 2024 |
| MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2024] VSCA 148 |
| JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: | [2023] VCC 1945; [2023] VCC 2419 (Judge Burchell) |
---
COSTS – No point of principle.
---
| Counsel | ||
| Applicant/Cross-respondent: | Mr B Petrie | |
| Respondent/Cross-applicant: | Ms FJ Bentley with Mr L Freckelton | |
Solicitors | ||
| Applicant/Cross-respondent: | K&L Gates | |
| Respondent/Cross-applicant: | Peak Legal | |
MCLEISH JA
KENNEDY JA
WALLER AJA:
On 14 June 2024 we published reasons allowing the appeal and cross-appeal in these matters and made orders for written submissions as to the orders that should be made to give effect to those reasons and in relation to costs.[1]
[1]Yume Group Holdings Pty Ltd v Ashthorn CA Pty Ltd [2024] VSCA 134 [103]–[104] (McLeish, Kennedy JJA and Waller AJA).
The appeal extended beyond the orders made on the trial, to include an appeal against costs orders made by the judge in an antecedent preliminary discovery proceeding. Those costs orders reflected the costs orders made at trial. The parties are agreed that orders should be made setting aside the judge’s orders in both proceedings. They also agree that the costs of the preliminary discovery proceeding should be borne by Ashthorn. We will make those orders.
The parties also agree that Ashthorn should pay Yume’s costs of the appeal, which was wholly successful.
There is disagreement as to the costs of the successful cross-appeal. Yume submits that the cross-appeal was minor in the larger scheme of things, and redundant once the appeal succeeded because the advisory retainer fees exceeded the amount in issue in the cross-appeal, against which those fees were rebated. As a result, Ashthorn’s success in the cross-appeal made no difference to the ultimate result of the trial, namely that Ashthorn’s proceeding was dismissed. Yume therefore says Ashthorn won a pyrrhic victory only and that Ashthorn should have to pay Yume’s costs of the cross-appeal. Yume notes that counsel for Ashthorn accepted that the cross-appeal concerned an ‘extremely low’ amount and would be ‘wholly cancelled out’ unless Ashthorn succeeded in respect of the SUEZ matter.
Ashthorn points out that the Salu Folk claim, the subject of the cross-appeal, potentially had a material impact on costs because of the offer of compromise in respect of the trial (which was close to the judgment sum but put aside by the judge in any event).[2] Further, when the cross-appeal was instituted Ashthorn had judgment in respect of the SUEZ matter and therefore stood to gain the amount in issue if the cross-appeal succeeded and the appeal failed.
[2]Ashthorn CA Pty Ltdv Yume Group Holdings Pty Ltd [2023] VCC 2419 [103]–[104] (Judge Burchell).
In our view it would be wrong to require Yume to pay Ashthorn’s costs…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Yume Group Holdings Pty Ltd v Ashthorn Ca Pty Ltd [No 2] and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] VSCA 148
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine two main legal issues. Firstly, whether the defendant's actions constituted a breach of contract or any other legal obligation that would make them liable for damages. Secondly, the court had to assess the fairness and reasonableness of the costs claimed by Yume Group Holdings, particularly in light of the outcome of the case and the conduct of both parties throughout the litigation process.
The court found that the defendant's actions did not breach any contractual or legal obligations that would result in liability for damages. Regarding the costs, the court noted that while there was no point of principle involved in the decision, the costs claimed by the plaintiff were not entirely reasonable or necessary. The court considered the conduct of both parties during the litigation and found that the plaintiff's costs were not entirely justified given the outcome of the case. Consequently, the court ordered that the plaintiff bear a proportionate share of the costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi