Yule v Chief Executive, Office of Fair Trading

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Yule v Chief Executive, Office of Fair Trading & Ors [2018] QCATA 189

PARTIES:

LESLIE EDWARD YULE
JAN MARIE YULE

(applicants/appellants)

v

CHIEF EXECUTIVE, OFFICE OF FAIR TRADING
(first respondent)
D J STRINGER PROPERTY SERVICES PTY LTD
(second respondent)
DAVID JOHN STRINGER

(third respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

APL408-17

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO:

GAR160-16

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

25 September 2018

HEARING DATE:

30 July 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Howard, presiding
Member Olding

ORDERS:

1.   The application by Leslie Edward Yule and Jan Marie Yule to admit fresh evidence is refused.

2.   The application for leave to appeal is refused and the appeal is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – ADMISSION OF FURTHER EVIDENCE – IN GENERAL – where applicant sought leave to admit as fresh evidence a previous decision of the tribunal on another matter involving the same party – whether evidence – whether leave should be granted

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – where applicants claimed against claim fund for loss suffered as a result of error in sales brochure – where tribunal below decided loss attributable to lack of basic inquiries - whether leave to appeal should be granted – where no error in decision below

Agents Financial Administration Act 2014 (Qld), s 78, s 82(1), s 103
Property Occupations Act 2014 (Qld), s 212
Queensland Civil and Administrative Act 2009 (Qld), s 20, s 24, s 142, s 146, s 147

Bradlyn Nominees Pty Ltd v Saikovski [2012] QCATA 39
Clarke v Japan Machines (Australia) [1984] 1 Qd R 404 Ericson v Queensland Building Services Authority [2013] QCA 391
Haritos v Commissioner of Taxation (2015) 233 FCR 315
Pickering v McArthur [2005] QCA 294
RCW Plumbing & Excavations v Camporeale Holdings Pty Ltd [2017] QCATA 48
Seirlis v Bengston & Ors [2013] QSC 240
The Chief Executive, Department of Justice and Attorney-General v D J Stringer Property Services Pty Ltd and Anor [2012] QCAT 27
Yule v The Chief Executive, Department of Justice and Attorney-General, Office of Fair Trading & Ors [2017] QCAT 399

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicants:

Self-represented

First respondent:

Second respondent:

Third respondent:

Mr A Tan, Senior Collections Officer

Mr D J Stringer

Self-represented

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Mr and Mrs Yule (the Yules) have applied for leave to appeal, and to appeal, a decision of a Member of the tribunal confirming a decision of the Chief Executive to refuse their claim against the ‘claim fund’ established under s 78 of the Agents Financial Administration Act 2014 (Qld) (AFAA).

  2. They have also applied for leave to admit fresh evidence that was not before the tribunal below.

  3. For the reasons that follow, we refuse the application for leave to admit fresh evidence and the application for leave to appeal.

    Background

  4. The claim against the claim fund related to an error in a sales brochure obtained from a real estate agent, D J Stringer Property Services Pty Ltd, in relation to a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yule v Chief Executive, Office of Fair Trading and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCATA 189
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Leslie Edward Yule and Jan Marie Yule appealed against a decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) that rejected their claim against the claim fund for loss suffered as a result of an error in a sales brochure obtained from a real estate agent. The applicants sought leave to admit a 2012 QCAT decision as fresh evidence, in which the same real estate agent was found to have breached predecessor legislation. The applicants argued that this prior decision demonstrated the agent’s untruthfulness in the present proceeding. The applicants also sought leave to appeal the QCAT’s decision on the basis that the Tribunal had erred in its findings.

The court had to determine whether the 2012 QCAT decision could be admitted as fresh evidence and whether leave to appeal should be granted. The court considered the usual principles for admitting fresh evidence, which require that the evidence could not have been available with reasonable diligence for the original hearing, would probably have an important impact upon the result, and is credible. The court found that the 2012 decision was a matter of public record and readily available, and that its consideration would not have had a major impact on the result of the case. The court also found that there was no error in the QCAT’s decision, as the Tribunal was not satisfied that any loss suffered by the applicants was due to the error in the brochure.

The application to admit fresh evidence and the application for leave to appeal were refused. The appeal was dismissed. The court held that the applicants’ submissions about the Chief Executive’s response to the earlier matter were irrelevant to the issue of whether the applicants suffered loss because of the misleading brochure. The court also held that the tribunal on a referral from the Chief Executive, determined the outcome in the earlier case.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application by Leslie Edward Yule and Jan Marie Yule to admit fresh evidence is refused.

2. The application for leave to appeal is refused and the appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, we refuse the application for leave to admit fresh evidence and the application for leave to appeal. Background The claim against the claim fund related to an error in a sales brochure obtained from a real estate agent, D J Stringer Property Services Pty Ltd, in relation to a home unit purchased by the applicants as their retirement home. It was important to the Yules that they have two car parking spaces. When they contracted to purchase the unit they mistakenly thought that there were two car spaces allocated to the unit, but in fact there was only one. It was common ground that the sales brochure mistakenly represented that the unit had two car spaces. The Yules first identified that the unit was of interest to them through a search that Mrs Yule conducted on an online website, realestate.com. There was no evidence that the error on the brochure also appeared in the realestate.com listing. The Yules then visited the agent’s office and collected the brochure with the mistaken reference to two car spaces. Before they signed the contract to purchase the unit, an employee of the agent, Ms Bingle, conducted a site inspection with them. Ms Bingle showed the applicants the parking space, numbered 36, that is allocated to the unit. She did not represent that there was any other car space allocated to the unit and the applicants did not query this or ask to see the second car space. They mistakenly assumed that another space, marked 7, the same number as the unit they ultimately purchased, must also be allocated to the unit. The contract and associated documents, including a community management scheme (CMS) showing only one car space allocated to the unit, was sent to their conveyancer. There was a cooling off period under the contract, but the conveyancer did not provide the applicants with a copy of the CMS, and the Yules did not read it, before completing the purchase. The Yules submitted that they suffered loss because of the misrepresentation in the brochure. However, the Tribunal was not satisfied that any loss suffered by the applicants was due to the error in the brochure, which the Tribunal found could have been corrected in essence had the Yules been ‘diligent in their enquiries’.[1][1]Yule v The Chief Executive, Department of Justice and Attorney-General, Office of Fair Trading & Ors [2017] QCAT 399, [57].Statutory framework A person who suffers a financial loss because of an event listed s 82(1) of the AFAA may claim against the claim fund. One of the listed events is a contravention of s 212 of the Property Occupations Act 2014 (Qld). That provision prohibits a licensee or real estate salesperson from representing to someone else anything that is false or misleading relating to the sale of real property. Section 103 of the AFFA provides that a person dissatisfied with a decision of the Chief Executive in relation to a claim may apply to the tribunal for review of the decision under the Queensland Civil and Administrative Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act). The Tribunal must hear and decide the review by way of a fresh hearing on the merits. The purpose of the review is to produce the correct and preferable decision.[2] [2]QCAT Act, s 20.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The appeal process is for correcting error by the original decision-maker. It is not an opportunity for a party to present their case again, or reargue it, merely because the party does not like or agree with the decision of the original tribunal.[8][8]Bradlyn Nominees Pty Ltd v Saikovski [2012] QCATA 39.Application to admit fresh evidence Early in the hearing below, when the member was explaining the nature of the review hearing before the tribunal, the following exchange occurred:MEMBER: Have you been through a QCAT hearing before?MR STRINGER: Only some tenancyMEMBER: Okay.MR STRINGER: basic tenancy ones.MEMBER: All right.MR STRINGER: Yes.MEMBER: They’re a bit more brutal than today’s going to be.MR STRINGER: Right. Okay. Mr and Mrs Yule seek leave to admit as evidence a 2012 decision of the tribunal[9] in an unrelated disciplinary case also involving Mr Stringer and D J Stringer Property Services Pty Ltd. The matter was referred to the tribunal for the determination of a disciplinary referral for breaches of predecessor legislation involving pre-drawing of commissions totalling over $250,000. They say that the prior decision demonstrates Mr Stringer’s untruthfulness in the proceeding about their claim against the fund. [9]The Chief Executive, Department of Justice and Attorney-General v D J Stringer Property Services Pty Ltd and Anor [2012] QCAT 27. The usual principle is that an applicant seeking to admit fresh evidence must usually show that the evidence: (A) could not have been available with reasonable diligence for the original hearing; (B) if allowed, would probably have an important impact upon the result; and (C) is credible.[10] For obvious reasons, credibility of the earlier decision is not an issue.[10]Clarke v Japan Machines (Australia) [1984] 1 Qd R 404 at 408. The earlier decision could readily have been discovered by the Yules. It is a matter of public record and is published on the Supreme Court Library website. The ready availability of the decision counts against admitting it as evidence at this stage. We are also not persuaded that consideration of the decision would probably have had a major impact on the result of the case. From the transcript as extracted above, it is clear that the Member was exploring whether the parties were familiar with tribunal processes. The 2012 decision followed a hearing on the papers after the matter was referred by the Chief Executive for decision by the tribunal: it is apparent that there was no oral hearing in that matter. Viewed in that context, Mr Stringer’s response was not misleading. It seems that Mr and Mrs Yule would also seek to submit that the Chief Executive should have cancelled Mr Stringer’s and his company’s real estate licences after the 2012 case and that by not doing so failed to protect them from loss. Such a submission would not assist them in an appeal where the issue would be whether the applicants suffered loss because of the misleading brochure. The Chief Executive’s response to the earlier matter is irrelevant to that issue and in any case, it was the tribunal on a referral from the Chief Executive, that determined the outcome in the earlier case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established