Yu v STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd (South Korea)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Yu v STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd (South Korea), in the matter of STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd (receivers appointed in South Korea) [2013] FCA 680

Citation: Yu v STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd (South Korea), in the matter of STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd (receivers appointed in South Korea) [2013] FCA 680
Parties: CHUN IL YU IN HIS CAPACITY AS FOREIGN REPRESENTATIVE OF STX PAN OCEAN CO LTD (SOUTH KOREA) v STX PAN OCEAN CO LTD (RECEIVERS APPOINTED IN SOUTH KOREA)
File number: NSD 1178 of 2013
Judge: BUCHANAN J
Date of judgment: 11 July 2013
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – cross-border insolvency – recognition of foreign proceedings – rights of secured creditors – right to commence proceedings with leave

ADMIRALTY – maritime lien – actions in rem – whether “additional orders” under the Model Law concerning cross-border insolvency

Legislation: Admiralty Act1988 (Cth)
Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth)
Cases cited: Aichhorn & Co KG and Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd v The Ship MV “Talabot” (1974) 132 CLR 449
Re Aro Co Ltd [1980] Ch 196; 1 All ER 1067
The “Bold Buccleugh” (1851) 13 ER 884; 7 Moo PC 267
Johnson v Black; The “Two Ellens” (1872) LR 4 PC 161
Date of hearing: 9 July 2013
Date of last submissions: 8 July 2013
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 48
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Ms C Amato
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Watson Mangioni Lawyers Pty Limited
Solicitor for the Defendant: No appearance

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1178 of 2013

IN THE MATTER OF STX PAN OCEAN CO LTD (SOUTH KOREA) (RECEIVERS APPOINTED IN SOUTH KOREA)

BETWEEN:

CHUN IL YU IN HIS CAPACITY AS FOREIGN REPRESENTATIVE OF STX PAN OCEAN CO LTD (SOUTH KOREA)
Plaintiff

AND:

STX PAN OCEAN CO LTD (RECEIVERS APPOINTED IN SOUTH KOREA)
Defendant

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 JULY 2013

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The originating process, interlocutory process and affidavit of Chun Il Yu filed 25 June 2013 are taken to have been served on the defendant on 5 July 2013 in accordance with the steps deposed to in the affidavit of Jin Kook Lee filed 9 July 2013.

2.The rehabilitation proceedings in the Seoul Central District Court, Bankruptcy Department, Case 2013hoehab110 hoesaeng, by which the plaintiff was appointed receiver of the defendant on 17 June 2013 (“the Korean Proceeding”), be recognised as a foreign proceeding within the meaning of paragraph (a) of Article 2 of Schedule 1 to the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) (“the Model Law”).

3.Chun Il Yu be recognised as a foreign representative within the meaning of paragraph (d) of Article 2 to the Model Law.

4.The Korean Proceeding be recognised as a foreign proceeding pursuant to Article 17(1) of the Model Law.

5.The Korean Proceeding be recognised as a foreign main proceeding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yu v STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd (South Korea) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 680
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Chun Il Yu, as the foreign representative of STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd, applied to the Federal Court of Australia for provisional relief in respect of the company's assets in Australia. The company, a South Korean shipping corporation, had commenced rehabilitation proceedings in South Korea, and Mr Yu sought to prevent Australian creditors from arresting or attaching the company's assets in Australia and interfering with its ability to trade. The court was required to decide whether the orders sought by Mr Yu should be made. The court found that the company did not have assets permanently situated in Australia but its vessels regularly called into Australian ports. There was a risk that Australian creditors could arrest vessels in Australian ports, which would prevent the company from trading and likely result in its liquidation. The court also found that one creditor had already arrested one of the company's vessels in Queensland. The court found that it was appropriate to make the orders sought by Mr Yu to protect the company's assets in Australia and its ability to trade. The court ordered that the administration and realisation of all of the company's assets located in Australia be entrusted to Mr Yu. The court also ordered that no person may enforce a charge on the property of the company, and no proceeding in any court against the company, or in relation to any of its property, may be begun or proceeded with. The court further ordered that the owner or lessor of property used or occupied by, or in the possession of, the company, cannot take possession of the property or otherwise recover it, and that no enforcement process in relation to property of the company may be begun or proceeded with. Finally, the court ordered that Mr Yu must publish and notify creditors of the making of this order.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd, a South Korean company, and its financial difficulties leading to the initiation of rehabilitation proceedings in South Korea. The Plaintiff, Chun Il Yu, a creditor of the Defendant, seeks orders under the Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency for the administration and realisation of the Defendant's assets located in Australia. The Plaintiff argues that there is a risk that Australian creditors may arrest the Defendant's vessels when they call into Australian ports, which would hinder the Defendant's ability to continue its business and negatively affect its ongoing rehabilitation proceedings in South Korea. Additionally, the Plaintiff mentions that the Defendant's ship, MV "New Joy," has already been arrested in Queensland by a creditor, Sea Trader International Ltd. The Plaintiff believes that if the rehabilitation proceedings are not successful, it would be detrimental to the interests of the Plaintiff and other creditors.

The matter is before the court on an application by the Plaintiff, Chun Il Yu, seeking orders under Article 21 of the Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency for the administration and realisation of the Defendant's assets located in Australia. This application follows the initiation of rehabilitation proceedings for the Defendant in South Korea. The Plaintiff has provided evidence in support of the application, including affidavits and annexes outlining the Defendant's business activities in Australia, the risks of asset arrest by Australian creditors, and the ongoing "New Joy" proceeding in Queensland. The court is now required to determine whether to grant the relief sought by the Plaintiff.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The orders sought in the originating process pursuant to Article 21 of the Model Law are as follows:5.Pursuant to paragraph (e) of Article 21(1) of the Model Law, the administration and realisation of all of the Defendant’s assets located in Australia be entrusted to the foreign representative.6.Pursuant to Article 21 of the Model Law, except with the leave of this court or with the foreign representatives’ written consent:a.No person may enforce a charge on the property of the Defendant.b.If:i.property of the Defendant is subject to lien or pledge; and ii.property of the Defendant is in the lawful possession of the holder of the lien or pledge; thenthe holder of the lien or pledge:iii.may continue to possess the property; andiv.cannot sell the property or otherwise enforce the lien or pledge.c.The owner or lessor of property that is used or occupied by, or in the possession of, the Defendant, cannot take possession of the property or otherwise recover it.d.No proceeding in any court against the Defendant, or in relation to any of its property, may be begun or proceeded with.e.No enforcement process in relation to property of the Defendant may be begun or proceeded with.7.In accordance with Rule 15A.7(1)(c)-(d) of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000, the Plaintiff is directed to:a.Publish a notice of the making of this order in accordance with Form 21 in a daily newspaper circulating generally in Australia; andb.Send a notice of the making of this order in accordance with Form 21 to each Australian creditor of the Defendant known to the Plaintiff by registered post to the registered office of each creditor, or by facsimile, or by email;c.Send a notice of the making of this order in accordance with Form 21 to Sea Trader International Limited by way of facsimile transmission to the firm of solicitors Wellners Lawyers, 1566 Wynnum Road, and Tingalpa QLD 4173.8.Liberty to any person to apply to the Court in respect of Order 6 on 2 days’ notice.The evidence So far as proceedings and potential interests in Australia are concerned, the affidavit of Chun Il Yu set out the following matters:Other foreign proceedings involving the Defendant…22.I am not aware of any proceedings in Australia which involve the Defendant, in relation to the following:(a) proceedings under the Bankruptcy Act 1966;(b)the appointment of a receiver (within the meaning of section 416 of the Corporations Act 2001), or a controller or a managing controller (both within the meaning of section 9 of that Act), in relation to the property of STX Pan Ocean Co. Ltd; and (c)proceedings under Chapter 5, or section 601CL, of the Corporations Act 2001 in respect of the Defendant.Nature of the Defendant’s business and presence of assets in Australia23.The Defendant does not have any assets permanently situated in Australia.24.However, vessels owned and operated by the Defendant regularly call into Australian ports to pick up and deliver cargo for shipments to Korea as well as other countries. I address this further at paragraphs 32 to 40 below.Known creditors of the Defendant in the Australian jurisdiction25.I am aware that the entities appearing in the list of creditors annexed and marked CIY-8 are creditors of the Defendant with registered offices located in Australia. I am not aware of any other creditors of the Defendant with registered offices located in Australia, other than those listed in CIY-8.Grounds for provisional reliefGround 1 – arrest of other ships in Australian waters26.The Defendant operates 371 vessels and owns 94 vessels, including 71 dry bulk cargo vessels. The vessels travel around the world delivering cargo.27.As at 24 June 2013, 20 vessels have been arrested worldwide.28.The Defendant’s vessels regularly call into Australian ports to deliver or pick up cargo.29.Annexed and marked CIY-9 is a copy of a docking schedule for vessels owned or operated by the Defendant in Australia ports for the period May 2012-July 2013. The third column of the docking schedule shows the dates on which vessels are scheduled to dock in Australia [sic] ports.30.The schedule indicates [sic] following vessels owned by the Defendant are presently docked in Australian ports or due to dock at the dates indicated below:(a)On 20 June 2013, the ship STX ACE2 was scheduled to dock at Botany Bay port. It is scheduled to depart Botany Bay port on 26 June 2013;(b)On 28 June 2013, the ship STX ACE2 is scheduled to dock at Brisbane port;(c)On 5 July 2013 the ship STX ACE2 it is scheduled to dock at Torres Strait port;(d)On 6 July 2013, the ship STX Amber is scheduled to dock at Gladstone port;(e)On 13 July 2013, the ship STX Jasmine is scheduled to dock at Geraldton port;(f)On 7 July 2013, the ship New Emerald is scheduled to dock at Torres Strait port;(g)On 12 July 2013, the ship Seastar Empress is scheduled to dock at Kwinana port. The Seastar Empress is subsequently scheduled to dock at Albany port on 17 July 2013 and Esperance port of [sic] 20 July 2013.31.There is a risk that creditors of the Defendant located in Australia (listed in CIY-8) may take steps to arrest ships owned and operated by the Defendant when they call into Australian ports. I am informed by Mr Jin Joo Kim, manager of the legal department of the Defendant, and believe that vessels owned by the Defendant, that is, (vessels with “STX” included in the name), that are due to enter Australian waters have been drifting in nearby waters for fear being subject to arrest or attachment. Numerous vessels owned by the Defendant which were scheduled to call into Australian ports have been not been able to enter into Australia.32.The arrest and delay of ships in Australia will cause a chain reaction of delays as the vessels are scheduled to depart Australia to other destinations around the world. The arrest and delay of ships may lead to severe liquidation damage payments and termination of contract of affreightments with the Defendant’s major customers, one of the main sources of the Defendant’s revenues.33.If the vessels owned by the Defendant are subject to arrest or attachment in Australia there will be little possibility for the Defendant to achieve a successful reorganisation that will see it continue in business. The Defendant’s ships regularly circle the globe and often call into Australian ports to load cargo and deliver such cargo throughout the world. As Australia is a leading producer of natural resources, Australia is one of the countries most frequently visited by its vessels. If the Defendant was unable to call into Australian ports, voyages to other countries would be meaningless since there would be no cargo to deliver. This business is the main source of revenue for the Defendant.34.Moreover, if the Defendant was required to pay security deposits for the release of arrested vessels it would not have any working capital to operate its business.Ground 2 – the New Joy Proceeding35.On 12 June 2008, Sea Trader International Ltd (Sea Trader), a creditor of the Defendant with its registered office located in Hong Kong, commenced action against a ship owned by the Defendant, MV “New Joy” in the Supreme Court of Queensland (“the New Joy Proceedings”). An arrest warrant was issued by the Court on that day. A copy of the documents relating to the proceedings is annexed and marked CIY-10.36.Shortly thereafter, the warrant executed on the MV “New Joy”. The ship is presently held in Gladstone, Queensland. Annexed and marked CIY-11 is a document summarising the details of the arrest, prepared by Ms Jin Joo Kim, manager of the legal department of the Defendant.37.The following relief is sought in the New Joy Proceedings:(a) Sale of the New Joy;(b) Judgment in the amount of USD $1,389,000 plus interest, or an order for the sale of the ship MV “New Joy”. The judgment sum is said to represent unpaid fees for bunkers supplied to the vessel on 13 May 2013.38.As to the sale of the ship, I do not presently know whether that sale is imminent. However, if it were, the consequences for the Defendant and the rehabilitation proceedings would be considerable as it would constitute a dissipation of a very valuable asset.39.As to the payment of the judgment sum sought, the Defendant is presently prohibited from paying Sea Traders claim due to restrictions imposed in the Korean proceedings, unless approval of the Court is sought. I am concerned that if the Defendant is ultimately ordered to pay Sea Trader the amount of US$1,389,000 plus interest, the rehabilitation proceedings will not be successful.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the administration and realisation of all of the Defendant's assets located in Australia should be entrusted to the foreign representative.
2. Whether the court should prohibit the enforcement of charges on the property of the Defendant and prevent the sale or enforcement of liens or pledges on the Defendant's property in Australia.
3. Whether the court should restrain the owner or lessor of property used or occupied by the Defendant from taking possession of the property.
4. Whether the court should restrain proceedings against the Defendant or in relation to any of its property in Australia.
5. Whether the court should restrain the enforcement of any processes in relation to the property of the Defendant in Australia.
6. Whether the Plaintiff should be directed to publish and send notices of the court's orders to relevant parties in Australia.

Held
1. The court held that the administration and realisation of all of the Defendant's assets located in Australia should be entrusted to the foreign representative.
2. The court held that it should prohibit the enforcement of charges on the property of the Defendant and prevent the sale or enforcement of liens or pledges on the Defendant's property in Australia, except with leave or the foreign representative's written consent.
3. The court held that it should restrain the owner or lessor of property used or occupied by the Defendant from taking possession of the property.
4. The court held that it should restrain proceedings against the Defendant or in relation to any of its property in Australia, except with leave.
5. The court held that it should restrain the enforcement of any processes in relation to the property of the Defendant in Australia, except with leave.
6. The court held that the Plaintiff should be directed to publish and send notices of the court's orders to relevant parties in Australia.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the evidence presented by the Plaintiff, Chun Il Yu, and found that there were sufficient grounds to grant the provisional relief sought under Article 21 of the Model Law. The court was particularly concerned about the potential for Australian creditors to arrest the Defendant's vessels in Australian ports, which would cause significant delays and financial harm to the Defendant's business. The court also noted that the Defendant's vessels regularly called into Australian ports to pick up and deliver cargo, making it essential for the Defendant to maintain its ability to operate in Australia.

The court found that the foreign representative, as the central point of coordination in the cross-border insolvency proceedings, was best suited to manage the Defendant's assets in Australia. The court recognised the importance of preventing Australian creditors from taking unilateral action that could interfere with the rehabilitation proceedings and the Defendant's ability to continue its business.

In granting the relief sought, the court emphasised the need to balance the interests of the foreign representative, the Defendant, and the Australian creditors. The court was satisfied that the orders would achieve this balance by protecting the Defendant's assets in Australia while still allowing for the enforcement of certain charges, liens, and pledges under specific conditions. The court also noted that the Plaintiff was directed to publish and send notices of the court's orders to relevant parties in Australia, ensuring that all interested parties were aware of the court's decision.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cross-border insolvency proceedings, Australian courts have the jurisdiction and authority to grant provisional relief under Article 21 of the Model Law to protect the assets and interests of the insolvent entity in Australia. The court's decision to grant such relief is based on the need to balance the interests of the foreign representative, the insolvent entity, and the Australian creditors, while also ensuring that the rehabilitation proceedings are not unduly prejudiced by unilateral actions taken by Australian creditors.