Yu Feng Pty Ltd v Ipswich City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

[2007] QPEC 125

DISTRICT COURT
CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE ROBIN QC

No 1587 of 2007

YU FENG PTY LTD Appellant
and
IPSWICH CITY COUNCIL Respondent
and
FKP COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD Co-Respondent
and
BUNNINGS GROUP LTD Co-Respondent by
Election
and
P & E Application No 2020 of 2007
BUNNINGS GROUP LTD Applicant
and
IPSWICH CITY COUNCIL Respondent
and
YU FENG PTY LTD Second Co-Respondent
and
FKP COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD Third Co-Respondent
BRISBANE
..DATE 29/08/2007
ORDER

CATCHWORDS: Integrated Planning Act 1997: ss 3.5.15(3),
4.1.28(2), 4.1.55 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules: s 69(1)(b)
commercial competitor's submitter appeal against council
approval for business use of bulky goods sales, garden centre
and café - whether appeal late - whether Council properly gave
copy of decision notice to set appeal period running - copy
given to submitter's agent with no mention of submitter's name

(as advised to it), or the identified author of the submission 10

or allusion to any submission - agent's personnel failed to appreciate relevance of copy to them and returned it to the council - circumstances in which, if needed, a longer time

would have been allowed for filing the appeal - parties to
appeal - successful application to be joined in submitter's
appeal by company asserting (against challenge by the
prospective lessor) a continuing entitlement to become lessee
on completion of the approved development.
20

HIS HONOUR: These applications can be disposed of now. The more unusual one is that of Bunnings Group Limited to be joined in appeal 1587 of 2007 which was commenced on the 5th

30
of June 2007 by Yu Feng Limited. It complains of the
respondent Council's decision to approve a development
application which authorises commercial development of the
premises at 383-391 and 393-415 Redbank Plains Road, Redbank
Plains for a business use of Bulky Goods Sales Garden Centre
40

and Café. The proposal of the co-respondent, FKP Commercial was to lease premises at the indicated address to Bunnings, presumably for a Bunnings Warehouse outlet there after a suitable building had been constructed.

50

Differences have arisen between FKP and Bunnings, centring on the former having claimed to exercise a right to terminate the commercial arrangements indicated in a general way above. 29082007 D.1 T(1)07/CAS(BNE) M/T BRIS17 (Robin DCJ)

2

ORDER

60

Bunnings dispute FKP's entitlement to terminate arrangements, 1
asserting that FKP's failure to pursue an application in
relation to signage constitutes a breach of contractual
obligations, and precludes reliance on the want of a signage
approval to bring arrangements to an end. It's accepted that

10

the Supreme Court is the appropriate venue for forcing FKP to
do what Bunnings contends is the right thing. Mr Cooke QC,
for Bunnings, encountered less opposition than he'd
anticipated to his client's application, or to his desire to

be heard on the other applications which are before the Court

20

within the appeal.

30

40

50

3   60

29082007 D.1 T(1)07/CAS(BNE) M/T BRIS17 (Robin DCJ)

Those are FKP's application to have the appeal struck out as 1
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yu Feng Pty Ltd v Ipswich City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] QPEC 125
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Yu Feng Pty Ltd, a competitor of Bunnings Warehouse, challenged the Ipswich City Council's decision to approve a development application for a commercial venture at Redbank Plains. Bunnings Warehouse, which had a contractual arrangement with the applicant, FKP Commercial Developments Pty Ltd, sought to be joined in the appeal as it feared its interests might not be adequately pursued. The central issues were whether Yu Feng's appeal was timely, and whether Bunnings could be joined as a party.

The court first addressed the timing of Yu Feng's appeal, noting that it was lodged within the required 20 business days after the decision notice was received. Despite the delay in the Council's notice reaching Yu Feng, the court found that the notice did not comply with statutory requirements as it did not clearly identify Yu Feng as the submitter. Consequently, the appeal was deemed timely. The court also considered whether Bunnings could be joined as a party in the appeal, citing the precedent in Leda Holdings Pty Ltd v Caboolture Shire Council, which allowed for the purchaser of a site to join an appeal. Given Bunnings' interest in the outcome, the court allowed its participation.

The court ultimately ruled that Yu Feng's appeal was timely and dismissed FKP's application to strike it out. It also permitted Bunnings to join the appeal, ensuring that its interests would be considered in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established