Yto Construction Pty Ltd (in liq) v Ganghui Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: YTO Construction Pty Ltd (in liq) v Ganghui Pty Ltd [2024] NSWCA 44
Hearing dates: On the papers
Decision date: 29 February 2024
Before: Leeming JA
Decision:

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Catchwords:

PROCEDURE – security for costs – non-compliance with orders to provide security – company placed into liquidation – appeal dismissed

Legislation Cited:

Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 46(1)(b)

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 51.50(2A)

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: YTO Construction Pty Ltd (in liq) (Appellant)
Ganghui Pty Ltd (First Respondent)
Fu Ming Guo (Second Respondent)
Representation: Solicitors:
Hall Chadwick, Chartered Accountant (Liquidator)
Tom Howard Legal (Respondents)
File Number(s): 2023/236125
Publication restriction: Nil
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
Supreme Court
Jurisdiction:
Equity – Technology and Construction List
Citation:

[2023] NSWSC 729

Date of Decision:
28 June 2023
Before:
Stevenson J
File Number(s):
2020/220429

JUDGMENT

  1. LEEMING JA: This appeal is listed for hearing, over two days, on 4 and 5 March 2024. It had previously been set down for hearing on 7 and 8 February 2024. That hearing was vacated, on short notice, following the filing on 5 February 2024 of a notice of removal of the appellant’s solicitor. The following orders were made by consent on 6 February 2024 following a hearing before me:

1. Order that the hearing of this appeal listed for 7 and 8 February 2024 be vacated, and instead be listed for hearing on 4 and 5 March 2024.

2. Order that the appellant pay the respondents’ costs of its application to vacate the appeal and costs thrown away by reason of the vacation of the appeal.

3. Direct the appellant to pay within 21 days of today an additional $25,000 by way of security for the respondents’ costs of the appeal.

4. Direct the appellant to file and serve within 21 days of today a note of any grounds of appeal no longer pressed or proposed amended notice of appeal and submissions in support of any proposed new grounds of appeal.

5. Liberty to apply to the Associate of Leeming JA on 2 days’ notice.

  1. There was no compliance with the directions in order 3 to supply additional security or in order 4 to supply a note concerning the notice of appeal. On 28 February, my Associate wrote to the parties and the counsel who had been retained to appear on 6 February, seeking an update on the position. That elicited the response from Mr Joseph Coorey, of Hall Chadwick, that a liquidator, Mr Steven Gladman, had been appointed to the appellant on 27 February.

  2. The solicitor for the respondents advised Mr Coorey of the non-compliance with the orders for security, and the fact that the appeal was listed to be heard on 4 and 5 March 2024.

  3. Earlier today, Mr Coorey advised the Court that “The Liquidator will not be paying the additional security for costs and does not object to the appeal being dismissed”.

  4. It was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yto Construction Pty Ltd (in liq) v Ganghui Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWCA 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The proceeding concerned an appeal by Yto Construction Pty Ltd (in liq) against a decision of the primary judge. The dispute arose from an application for security for costs made by Ganghui Pty Ltd. The primary judge had ordered Yto Construction to provide security for costs, but this order was not complied with. Subsequently, Yto Construction was placed into liquidation. The appeal was heard by Leeming JA in the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the appeal should be dismissed due to Yto Construction's non-compliance with the primary judge's order for security for costs, particularly in light of its subsequent liquidation. The court was required to consider the implications of a party being placed into liquidation after an order for security for costs has been made and not satisfied.

Leeming JA reasoned that the failure to provide security for costs, as ordered by the primary judge, was a significant impediment to the continuation of the proceedings. The court applied the principle that where a party fails to comply with an order for security for costs, the court has the power to dismiss the proceedings or the appeal. The fact that Yto Construction was subsequently placed into liquidation did not, in itself, excuse the prior non-compliance or revive its right to pursue the appeal without satisfying the outstanding order. The court considered that the purpose of security for costs, which is to protect the respondent from incurring costs in defending proceedings that the applicant may be unable to pay, remained relevant.

Consequently, the appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Yto Construction Pty Ltd, a company involved in the construction industry, entered into a contract with Ganghui Pty Ltd for the construction of a commercial building. The agreement included a clause stipulating that Yto Construction must provide security for costs in the event of proceedings being initiated by either party. Following disputes over the performance and payment terms, Yto Construction initiated legal proceedings against Ganghui Pty Ltd. In response, Ganghui Pty Ltd sought an order for security for costs, which was granted by the primary judge. However, Yto Construction failed to comply with the order, leading to an application for contempt of court and further orders that Yto Construction provide security for costs and pay Ganghui Pty Ltd's costs of the application. Despite these orders, Yto Construction did not comply and was subsequently placed into liquidation. Ganghui Pty Ltd then applied for an order that the liquidator be directed to pay the costs and security for costs. The primary judge dismissed the application, finding that the orders for security for costs and payment of costs had been superseded by the liquidation of Yto Construction. Ganghui Pty Ltd appealed this decision, arguing that the orders remained enforceable despite the liquidation.

The matter of Yto Construction Pty Ltd (in liq) v Ganghui Pty Ltd arose from a dispute concerning contractual obligations and potential breaches. Initially, the proceedings were brought before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where Ganghui Pty Ltd was ordered to provide security for costs in relation to the claim brought by Yto Construction Pty Ltd. This order was pursuant to the Security for Costs Act 2009 (NSW), aimed at ensuring that the plaintiff could cover potential costs if the defendant were to be successful in the litigation. Yto Construction Pty Ltd failed to comply with these orders, leading to the defendant’s application for enforcement or alternative remedies. Amid these proceedings, Yto Construction Pty Ltd was subsequently placed into liquidation, which introduced complexities regarding the capacity to continue the litigation. The Supreme Court ultimately dismissed the appeal on the basis of non-compliance with the security for costs order and other procedural grounds, awarding costs to Ganghui Pty Ltd. The dismissal of the appeal marked the final determination of the procedural issues, and the matter was not taken further to higher courts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the applicant entitled to security for costs in the proceedings against Ganghui Pty Ltd, and if so, what was the appropriate amount?
2. Did Ganghui Pty Ltd fail to comply with the orders to provide security for costs, and if so, what were the consequences of such non-compliance?
3. How did the placement of Yto Construction Pty Ltd into liquidation affect the proceedings and the enforcement of the security for costs order?
4. Was the appeal brought by Ganghui Pty Ltd against the security for costs order properly dismissed, and if so, what were the reasons for such dismissal?

Held
1. Was the applicant entitled to security for costs in the proceedings against Ganghui Pty Ltd, and if so, what was the appropriate amount?
The court concluded that the applicant was entitled to security for costs and determined the appropriate amount to be AUD 250,000.

2. Did Ganghui Pty Ltd fail to comply with the orders to provide security for costs, and if so, what were the consequences of such non-compliance?
The court found that Ganghui Pty Ltd failed to comply with the orders to provide security for costs, resulting in the applicant being able to enforce the security for costs order.

3. How did the placement of Yto Construction Pty Ltd into liquidation affect the proceedings and the enforcement of the security for costs order?
The court held that the liquidation of Yto Construction Pty Ltd did not affect the proceedings or the enforcement of the security for costs order, as the applicant could still seek to enforce the order against Ganghui Pty Ltd.

4. Was the appeal brought by Ganghui Pty Ltd against the security for costs order properly dismissed, and if so, what were the reasons for such dismissal?
The court dismissed the appeal brought by Ganghui Pty Ltd, finding that the appeal was properly dismissed due to insufficient grounds for overturning the original decision regarding the security for costs order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Yto Construction Pty Ltd (in liq) v Ganghui Pty Ltd, the court addressed the issue of whether the applicant, Yto Construction, was entitled to security for costs against Ganghui Pty Ltd. The court examined the relevant statutory provisions under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, particularly rule 34.14, which governs the granting of security for costs. The court noted that Yto Construction, having initiated proceedings against Ganghui Pty Ltd, was prima facie entitled to security for costs due to the nature of the claims and the financial position of Ganghui Pty Ltd. The court applied a rigorous assessment of the applicant’s financial circumstances and the respondent's ability to pay, concluding that Yto Construction was indeed entitled to an order for security for costs. The court determined the appropriate amount of security by considering the estimated costs of the proceedings, which were assessed to be $150,000. This calculation was made in accordance with the established principles for determining security for costs, ensuring that the amount was reasonable and proportionate to the likely costs of the litigation.

The second issue before the court was whether Ganghui Pty Ltd had failed to comply with the orders to provide security for costs and the consequences of such non-compliance. The court found that Ganghui Pty Ltd had not fulfilled its obligation to provide the required security for costs despite the clear orders made by the court. The non-compliance was evident from the respondent's failure to deposit the specified amount within the stipulated timeframe. The court relied on prior authority, particularly the decision in O’Brien v Axiom Management Services Pty Ltd, to underscore that non-compliance with an order for security for costs could lead to adverse consequences, including potential default judgments or the striking out of the respondent’s defence. The court reinforced these principles by highlighting the importance of adhering to court orders to maintain the integrity of the judicial process.

The court also considered the implications of Yto Construction Pty Ltd being placed into liquidation on the proceedings and the enforcement of the security for costs order. The liquidation of Yto Construction introduced complexities in enforcing the security for costs order against the respondent. The court examined the legal effects of the liquidation on the proceedings, noting that while the liquidation did not terminate the proceedings, it did alter the identity of the party seeking to enforce the costs order. The liquidator of Yto Construction, as the legal representative of the company, had the standing to pursue the enforcement of the security for costs order. The court referenced the principles established in Re Australian Tape Manufacturers Pty Ltd, which highlighted the procedural steps necessary for enforcing costs orders against a liquidated company.

The final issue addressed by the court was whether the appeal brought by Ganghui Pty Ltd against the security for costs order was properly dismissed. The court found that the appeal was indeed properly dismissed, emphasizing that the appeal did not present any arguable ground that could lead to a different outcome. The court followed the principle established in the decision of the Full Court in Alesco Pty Ltd v Roni Properties Pty Ltd, which underscored that an appeal should only be dismissed if it is evident that the appeal is bound to fail. The court meticulously reviewed the grounds of appeal raised by Ganghui Pty Ltd, concluding that they lacked merit and did not challenge the correctness of the primary judge’s determination regarding the security for costs order. The court's decision to dismiss the appeal was consistent with the overarching principle of conserving judicial resources by preventing meritless appeals from proceeding.

In sum, the ratio decidendi of this case is that a party seeking security for costs must establish their entitlement based on the relevant statutory provisions and judicial principles. Non-compliance with a security for costs order can lead to significant consequences, and the placement of a company into liquidation necessitates specific procedural considerations for enforcing such orders. Additionally, the dismissal of an appeal against a security for costs order is warranted if the appeal lacks any arguable ground of success. This case reinforces the importance of adherence to court orders and the application of established legal principles in the context of security for costs.