ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review by taxpayer pursuant to s 39B Judiciary Act 1903 of announced policy of Commissioner of Taxation as to assessment of those involved in an alleged scheme – whether review precluded by s 175, s 177 of Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 – standing of applicant – whether relief should be refused on discretionary grounds
TAXATION – whether a general policy announcement by the Commissioner of Taxation as to the assessment of a class of taxpayer is subject to judicial review
ALAN JAMES YOUNG v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION N 99 OF 2000
GYLES J SYDNEY 17 FEBRUARY 2000
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 99 OF 2000
BETWEEN:
ALAN JAMES YOUNG APPLICANT
AND:
COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION RESPONDENT
JUDGE:
GYLES J
DATE OF ORDER:
17 FEBRUARY 2000
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The application is dismissed.
2.The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs in these proceedings.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 99 OF 2000
BETWEEN:
ALAN JAMES YOUNG APPLICANT
AND:
COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION RESPONDENT
JUDGE:
GYLES J
DATE:
17 FEBRUARY 2000
PLACE:
SYDNEY
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
This is an application by Alan James Young (“the applicant”) for an order of review under s 39B(1) or, alternatively, s 39B(1A) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) of the actions of the Commissioner of Taxation (“the Commissioner”) in adopting and announcing a policy (“the Policy”) concerning the proposed treatment by the…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Young v Commissioner of Taxation and more:
The case of Young v Commissioner of Taxation concerned a dispute between the applicant and the Commissioner regarding the legality of a policy implemented by the Commissioner under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth). The applicant argued that the Commissioner was bound to implement a predetermined policy when exercising his powers, while the Commissioner maintained that the policy allowed for each case to be considered on its merits. The primary facts were undisputed, but there was a disagreement on the conclusion that should be drawn from them. The Commissioner's policy was outlined in two media releases, one dated 15 June 1999 and the other dated 30 November 1999, which addressed the disallowance of tax deductions for linked bonds and notes.
The legal issues in this case revolved around whether the Commissioner's policy was unlawful, and if so, whether the applicant had standing to challenge it. The Commissioner contended that even if the policy was unlawful, the applicant had no right to relief as the policy was not justiciable, the applicant had a right to a full merits review under the Act, and the relief sought was precluded by sections 175 and 177 of the Act. The court was required to determine whether the applicant had standing to challenge the policy and whether any relief should be granted.
The court found that assuming the policy was unlawful, the applicant did not have standing to challenge it. The most controversial aspect of the policy, the settlement offer, did not adversely affect the applicant. The remedy, if any, would lie at the suit of the Attorney-General for the Commonwealth. The alleged unlawfulness in relation to the other options was also deemed elusive, as the applicant had a full right of review on the merits, including the issue of penalty, when and if the Commissioner applied Part IVA of the Act to the transaction during the assessment process.
In conclusion, the application was dismissed, and the applicant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs in these proceedings. The court found that the applicant did not have standing to challenge the Commissioner's policy, and other remedies were available to address any concerns regarding the policy's legality.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application is dismissed.
2. The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs in these proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
When the matter came before me on 10 February 2000 for interlocutory relief, the parties, very sensibly, agreed that it would be more appropriate to hear the matter on a final basis and the hearing commenced on that day. With interruptions, it was possible to complete the hearing on 11 February. For any relief which may be granted to be of utility, it is necessary that a decision be made promptly. I will therefore express my reasons more briefly and with less citation of authority than may have been the case if more time were available. I shall not reproduce the various statutory provisions to which I shall refer.Facts There is no dispute as to the primary facts, which are reflected solely in documents, but there is an issue as to the conclusion which should be drawn from them. It is submitted on behalf of the applicant that the Commissioner has bound himself to implement a pre-determined policy when exercising his powers under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (“the Act”), whereas it is submitted on behalf of the Commissioner that the Policy is not inconsistent with each case being considered on its merits. I was taken through the chronology of documents by each counsel. I need not set this chronology out in these reasons. The important thing is the announced position of the Commissioner at the time the proceedings were commenced. In my opinion, the operative statements constituting the Policy are:1. The Commissioner’s media release 99/21 dated 15 June 1999, which is in the following terms:“TAX OFFICE TO DISALLOW LINKED BONDS TAX DEDUCTIONSTax deductions claimed by taxpayers participating in linked bond, or note, arrangements will be disallowed, Tax Commissioner Michael Carmody said today.These bonds, currently marketed by a number of banks, combine the features of a bond paying fixed interest on maturity with potential for a bonus return. This bonus return is linked to the performance of either a pre-selected equity (single share, basket of shares, equity index), interest rate or exchange rate.The usual features of these bonds are:·the investor borrows 100 per cent of the face value of the bond and pre-pays the interest, of which a significant portion (in some cases up to 90 per cent) is borrowed from the issuer in the first year of the arrangement;·the investor returns the fixed interest on maturity of the bond in the second year of the arrangement; and·the bond offers potential for a bonus return linked to the movement of a share price, exchange rate or other contingent event.“In the cases we are concerned about, the arrangements are structured so that, putting aside the claimed tax benefits, there is little if any prospect of commercial gain. In a typical product, a movement of up to 30 per cent in the linked shares or index is required before the investor recoups his or her actual outlay.” Mr Carmody said.“Loans to buy bonds are provided to investors who, in some instances, have inadequate underlying security. One taxpayer had assets of $500,000 and was loaned an amount exceeding $20 million. Banks are providing these loans without security because the loan is returned to them through the purchase price of the bond.“In what appears to be a typical example, one taxpayer purchased securities with a face value in excess of $20 million for an outlay of less than $200,000 and claimed a tax deduction of approximately $2.5 million.“The Tax Office is aware of some cases where investors have acquired bonds with contrary positions. For example, in one case, a taxpayer purchased $10 million in bonds linked to a rise in the All Ordinaries Index along with $10 million in bonds linked to a fall in the same Index. In this case a movement of 56 per cent in the Index was required in order for the taxpayer to recoup their outlay” Mr Carmody said.“By further reducing the prospect of commercial gain, this example reinforces the dominant tax purpose of these products.“Another group purchased bonds with a face value in excess of $800 million, claiming a tax deduction of $80 million which was equivalent to the profit made on a takeover.“Given the features and typical use of these bonds we have concluded that their dominant purpose is to obtain a tax benefit and the general anti-avoidance provisions could apply.“In such circumstances substantial penalties may apply. However, we are offering participants in these arrangements the opportunity to come forward before 31 July 1999 and receive reduced penalties in accordance with our normal policy,” Mr Carmody said.The ATO position under the law and the options available are accessible on our website under What’s New. People wishing to come forward to take advantage of the offer can contact us on 1300 650 135, or write to the Linked Bond Unit at P.O. Box 9003, Penrith, NSW, 2740.CANBERRA15 June 1999”2. The Commissioner’s media release 99/84 dated 30 November 1999, which is in the following terms: “TAX OFFICE SETTLES ON EQUITY LINKED BONDSTax Commissioner Michael Carmody announced today that the terms of a settlement have been agreed with representatives of the International Banks and Securities Association of Australia (IBSA) in relation to equity linked bonds and notes.Mr Carmody said that the effect of the settlement is that the self-cancelling parts of the note arrangement will not be recognised for income tax purposes.“This negates the claimed timing advantage built into the arrangement, but still recognises an investor’s actual cash outlay and receipts from participating in the facility,” Mr Carmody said.“We have agreed that noteholders who wish to come within the terms of the settlement will be allowed an income tax deduction for the amount of their cash outlay for interest changed on the notes.“Money borrowed from the note issuer to ‘prepay’ the balance of interest charged will not be deductible. As a result only the ‘bonus’ interest received in the next year will be assessed.“We recognise that there still is a genuine difference of view on linked notes. The terms of this settlement will allow noteholders to clear the air in respect of their own tax affairs. As usual, assessments for participants in a settlement of a tax dispute will be finalised for each year in respect of the particular matter.“The Tax Office will contact all noteholders shortly to set out the terms of the settlement proposal for them to consider.“Noteholders who participate in the settlement will be subject to a 10 per cent tax shortfall penalty on the amount of interest claimed that will be excluded under the settlement. Noteholders will be entitled to offset their interest on overpayment entitlement in the second year against the interest chargeable on the underpayment in the first year.“Noteholders who decline to participate in the settlement will face the uncertainty of future Court action. However, we will proceed as quickly as possible to have the matter decided.“We have also received submissions regarding a small group of investors who have a history of returning profits from securities trading activities on revenue account. It was claimed that their trading activities set them apart from the majority of noteholders.“Whilst the taxation drivers strongly embedded within the linked note product work against that conclusion, we are prepared to look at individual trader’s circumstances.“The discussions with IBSA have been valuable in clarifying the competing views about the note arrangements. We have also agreed with IBSA on a framework for future discussions on new financial services products as they are developed in the marketplace,” Mr Carmody.Investors and tax practitioners with inquiries on equity linked bonds and notes should contact the Tax Office on 1300 650 135 and further details will be available on the Tax Office’s Internet site, ATOassist, at November 1999”
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
GYLES J
It was contended for the Commissioner that even if the Policy was unlawful in the sense submitted by the applicant:1.The Policy as such was not properly justiciable between the applicant and the Commissioner;2.The applicant will have a right to a full merits review pursuant to the Act in relation to any steps taken to implement the Policy;3.In any event, the relief sought by the applicant is precluded by s 175 and s 177 of the Act.Decision Assuming that the Policy is unlawful, as submitted on behalf of the applicant, although it is doubtful whether any of the points argued on behalf of the Commissioner preclude the relief sought, in my opinion, the combined effect of them is such that in the exercise of my discretion I should grant no relief. The applicant can only be concerned with the Policy insofar as it affects him. The most controversial aspect of the Policy, in my opinion, is the settlement offer reflected in option 2. It raises questions of law and administration when proposed as part of this package of options. I can, however, see no adverse affect upon the applicant as a result. Indeed, it gives him an opportunity he would not otherwise have. The fact that he has to make a decision is not, in any relevant sense, adverse to him. In those circumstances, in my opinion, he has no standing to complain about any breach of the law that might be involved. The remedy, if any, would lie at the suit of the Attorney-General for the Commonwealth (Bateman’s Bay Local Aboriginal Land Council v Aboriginal Community Benefit Fund Pty Ltd (1998) 194 CLR 247 at 260-264). The alleged unlawfulness in relation to options 1 and 3 is somewhat elusive. It is certainly correct that application of an inflexible policy without regard to the merits of individual cases is a standard ground of attack upon administrative decisions, although there is often a thin line between that situation and a decision-maker properly taking into account a general policy which is consistent with the Act (Corlette v MacKenzie (1995) 62 FCR 584 at 595 E-G). Here, Mr Gageler submits that options 1 and 3 are merely the result of applying Pt IVA to the transactions in question and reflect the statutory level of penalty, depending upon disclosure or otherwise. These options do indicate a fixed view about the question of remission of penalty and may also involve an unwillingness to consider the circumstances of individual taxpayers in entering into the transactions. It is not necessary to come to any final view as to whether this is unlawful. What is clear is that the critical step which actually affects the taxpayer is the ultimate application of Pt IVA of the Act to the transaction by the Commissioner when the process of assessment takes place. When and if that takes place, the applicant has a full right of review on the merits, including the issue of penalty, and including an appeal on questions of law to the Court. That process results in the correct substantive decision. The existence of other remedies has always been a powerful factor against the grant of relief of the kind envisaged by s 39B of the Judiciary Act, including the alternate remedy of declaration.