Young t/as LK & HM Young v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Young t/as LK & HM Young v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2021] QCAT 8

PARTIES: LEE KELVIN YOUNG t/as LK & HM YOUNG

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR051-18

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

8 January 2021

HEARING DATE:

19 October 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member McLean Williams

ORDERS:

The decision under review is set aside and is returned to the original decision-maker for further consideration, in light of these reasons.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – where direction to rectify issued – circumstance of fresh evidence showing responsibility of another building contractor for performance of defective building work the subject of the direction – consideration of Tribunal’s review jurisdiction generally – meaning of ‘building work’ and ‘defective building work’.

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 20, s 24.

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) s 71l, s 72, s 72A, s 86, s 87

Chew v QBSA [2010] QCAT 501.
Imperial Homes (Queensland) Pty Ltd v QBCC [2014] QCAT 42
Jensen v QBCC [2017] QCAT 232

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicants:

Self-represented, by Mr Lee Kelvin Young

Respondent:

Queensland Building & Construction Commission

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. By means of an Application to review a decision filed in the Tribunal on 16 February 2018, the applicant seeks to review a decision (‘the decision’) of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (‘the QBCC’), made on 24 January 2018, to issue him with a direction to rectify (‘DTR’), in respect of certain defective building works within unit 9, of a 12-unit complex at Maroochydore (‘the subject property’).

  2. The 12-unit complex at Maroochydore had been constructed by the applicant. Practical completion of that project was achieved on 5 December 2012. In February 2015, the applicant fell into financial difficulty and entered bankruptcy, thereafter ceasing to be a QBCC licence holder in the category of builder.

  3. The DTR relates to a leaking shower in the main bathroom of the subject property.  This problem did not reveal itself until 22 November 2017, yet other units in the same complex had experienced similar problems.  It is to be noted that the DTR relates only to unit 9, the subject property.

  4. The applicant contends that an unfairness arises in circumstances wherein the DTR has been directed solely unto himself, in specific circumstances where the actual building work that has been the cause of the problem was undertaken by another licence holder, as sub-contractor.  The applicant now seeks a review of the decision before the Tribunal.

Powers and Jurisdiction of this Tribunal

  1. The ability for the applicant to seek review of this decision by the Tribunal is a matter that is available by reason of s 86(1)(e) and s 87 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) (‘the QBCC Act’).

  2. Section 86(1)(e) provides that a decision of the QBCC to give (or not give) a direction…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Young t/as LK & HM Young v Queensland Building and Construct... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCAT 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Young trading as LK & HM Young v Queensland Building and Construction Commission involves a dispute regarding the rectification of defective building work. The matter was heard and determined by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The primary issue before the Tribunal was whether the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) had correctly identified the respondent as the person responsible for the defective building work, and consequently, whether the QBCC was entitled to issue a Direction to Rectify (DTR) to the respondent.

The legal issues that the Tribunal needed to decide included whether the respondent was indeed the person who carried out the defective building work, and whether the respondent was, therefore, subject to the power under section 72(2)(a) of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1999 (QBCC Act) to direct the rectification of the building work. Another issue was whether the invoices presented by the respondent constituted fresh evidence that could be considered by the Tribunal in its review of the QBCC's decision.

The Tribunal found that the respondent, while being the building contractor, had indirectly caused the defective building work to be carried out by a subcontractor, Scott Harris Prestige Tiling Pty Ltd. The Tribunal accepted the uncontentious evidence that the respondent had supervised the work carried out by the subcontractor, and was thus responsible for the defective work. As a result, the Tribunal concluded that the QBCC had correctly identified the respondent as the person responsible for the defective building work, and the QBCC was entitled to issue the DTR. The Tribunal also found that the invoices presented by the respondent constituted fresh evidence and could be considered in the review of the QBCC's decision.

The final orders of the Tribunal were that the review application be dismissed, and the DTR issued by the QBCC be affirmed. The respondent was ordered to pay the QBCC's costs of the review proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The position of the QBCC may be summarised, as follows:(i)Because there is ‘defective building work’, a power arises under s.72(2)(a) of the QBCC Act for the QBCC to direct the rectification of that building work, by “the person who carried out the building work”;(ii)Pursuant to s.71l(1) & 71l(2)(a)(ii), the applicant is “a person who carried out the (defective) building work”, by reason that the applicant was the building contractor who indirectly caused the work to be carried out (by subcontractor Scott Harris Prestige Tiling Pty Ltd) and, per s.72l(2)(b), supervised that work.Applicant’s evidence before the Tribunal During the hearing, the applicant relied on both affidavit and oral evidence from his brother, Mr Ross Young; as well as on some documentary evidence, in order to make the case that had previously been raised by him with the QBCC, in the Power & Cartwright correspondence dated 13 December 2017, even prior to the QBCC issuing the DTR. Mr Ross Young’s evidence (which was entirely uncontentious and not disputed by the QBCC), was to the effect that he had been employed by the applicant during the construction of the subject property and that ‘Scott Harris trading as Prestige Tiling’ had approached him looking for work, and that the tiling and sub-tile waterproofing had been sub-contracted to Scott Harris. Mr Ross Young also informed the Tribunal that, after that had happened, Scott Harris had again approached him and had inquired whether it would be acceptable, in turn, for Scott Harris to sub-contract the waterproofing work to his own son, a Mr Dean Harris, on the basis that Dean Harris was very short of work at the time. This was allowed by the applicant. Thereafter, the tiling and waterproofing were performed by other QBCC licence holders, on a subcontract/sub-subcontract basis, and this work was supervised by Mr Ross Young, on behalf of the applicant. The Tribunal accepts the testimonial evidence of Mr Ross Young. The documentary evidence relied upon by the applicant is in the form of two tax invoices (numbered 136 and 139), from Scott Harris Prestige Tiling Pty Ltd (QBCC Licence Number 728355). Invoice 136, dated 11 July 2012 and in the total amount of $2,354.00, relates to work performed by Scott Harris Prestige Tiling Pty Ltd on 6 July 2012, described as:Tile wet areas @ primary school units as requested by Lee Young as follows: Wet area tiling and water proofing to wet areas 30m2. 2 x bedded basses [sic]. Silicone 50l/mSupply and fit 1x door way angle standard.Thanking you. Scott Harris. Invoice 139, dated 13 August 2012 in the total amount of $10,367.28, relates to work performed by Scott Harris Prestige Tiling Pty Ltd on 10 August 2012 and described as: Primary school crt units, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 as follows:Main floor 42m2 x 6 units = 252m2Kitchen splash backs to same units 2.88m2 x 6 = 17.28m2Thanking you. Before proceeding further with these reasons for decision, it is important to record that neither invoice 136 nor invoice 139 were available for consideration by the QBCC decision-maker, at the time when making the original DTR decision, now under review. These invoices constitute “fresh evidence”, of a type that may now be considered by the Tribunal, given that these review proceedings are conducted de novo.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established