Young & Ors v Harris & Ors No. Scciv-99-1484

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

YOUNG AND OTHERS  v  HARRIS AND OTHERS
[2001] SASC 282

Civil

Bleby J

  1. The plaintiffs in this action are two individuals and one company, Leandre Nominees Pty Ltd (“Leandre”).  They are former shareholders in a company previously known as Warlan Pty Ltd (“Warlan”).  They commenced this action in the Federal Court of Australia, and the proceedings were subsequently transferred to this Court.

  2. In essence, the plaintiffs sue the defendants, a firm of chartered accountants, for damages arising out of three transactions involving or consequent upon the sale of their shares in Warlan.  It is not necessary to recite all the details contained in the Statement of Claim.  It is sufficient to say that the plaintiffs allege that the defendants aided abetted counselled and procured or were directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in a breach by the directors of Warlan of s 129 of the Companies Code or s 205 of the Corporations Law as the case may be, as a result of which the plaintiffs, as shareholders, suffered loss and damage.  They further allege breach of a duty of care and of their retainer as accountants and advisers to the plaintiffs in respect of the transactions concerned, breach of fiduciary duty, aiding and abetting a breach of the directors’ duties under s 229 of the Companies Code and damages for misrepresentation.  They further allege a breach of duty of care and of a fiduciary duty in respect of the entry by the plaintiffs into a deed of variation extending a loan granted in respect of the original sale of their shares in Warlan.  They allege that the deed of variation had the effect of negating the security given by Warlan for a loan by them to the purchasers of the shares in Warlan because Warlan itself was not a party to the deed.

  3. The defendants have joined a firm of solicitors as third party to the proceedings claiming indemnity or contribution in respect of the plaintiffs’ claim.

  4. A separate action by Warlan, now in liquidation, against the defendants was also commenced, and has also been transferred to this Court.  Similar allegations are made in that action, although the deed of variation extending the loan is not in issue in that action.  Save in one respect to be mentioned, I am not concerned with those proceedings in relation to the determination of this present application.

  5. The plaintiffs have sued individuals said to be the partners of the firm, including the executrix of a deceased partner.  They have also sued BPM Pty Ltd as proprietor of the business and Birdanco Nominees Pty Ltd, said to have “taken over” the obligation, including the liabilities, of BPM Pty Ltd.  The defendants plead that the only relevant services provided to the parties were provided by BPM Pty Ltd.  It seems tolerably clear that the action cannot succeed against all defendants, even if it succeeds against one.

  6. At all material times the defendants were insured by HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd (HIH), and their defence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Young & Ors v Harris & Ors No. Scciv-99-1484 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Young & Ors v Harris & Ors, the plaintiffs, including Leandre Nominees Pty Ltd, former shareholders of Warlan Pty Ltd, initiated legal action against the defendants, a firm of chartered accountants, and others. They sought damages arising from transactions involving the sale of their shares in Warlan, alleging breaches of fiduciary duty, negligence, and misrepresentation, among other claims. The defendants, who were insured by HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd, subsequently sought an order for security for costs against Leandre and disclosure of its financial position, following HIH’s liquidation.

The court was tasked with determining whether an order for security for costs should be made under Rule 100.01 of the Supreme Court Rules and s 1335(1) of the Corporations Law. The key issues were whether Leandre, as a nominal plaintiff and in a condition of poverty, qualified for the discretionary remedy of security for costs, and whether the defendants’ delay in bringing the application should be considered fatal.

The court found that Leandre, as a trustee of the Ward Family Trust, was a nominal plaintiff and in a condition of poverty for the purposes of Rule 100.01. While Leandre had no assets in its own right, it had a right of indemnity against the Trust assets, which was its only potential asset. The court also found that under s 1335(1) of the Corporations Law, there was reason to believe that Leandre would be unable to pay the defendants' costs if successful in their defence. The court considered the defendants' argument that the beneficiaries of the Ward Family Trust should provide security, but ultimately found that Leandre’s claim of impecuniosity and the potential stultification of its action were sufficient grounds for granting security.

The court dismissed the application for disclosure of Leandre’s financial position, as it found that the information already provided was sufficient. The court also rejected the plaintiffs’ argument that the defendants’ actions had caused Leandre’s financial demise, noting that Leandre had never had significant assets and that causation was still a matter in dispute.

The court ordered Leandre Nominees Pty Ltd to provide security for the defendants’ costs in the sum of $40,000 by way of a guarantee under seal from Philip John Ward, a person said to have control of Leandre. The proceedings at the instance of Leandre would be stayed until the security was furnished.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.