Young and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Young and National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 407 (31 March 2017)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2016/4223

Re:Margaret Young

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Senior Member J F Toohey
Member D Connolly

Date:31 March 2017

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

..............................[sgd]..........................................

Senior Member J F Toohey

Catchwords

National Disability Insurance Scheme – reasonable and necessary supports – vehicle modification – whether applicant’s plan should include funding for swivel seat – whether value for money – whether likely to be effective and beneficial – economic participation –what is reasonable to expect family to provide – Tribunal not satisfied of all criteria in s 34(1) – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013, ss 3, 4, 33, 34, 100

Cases

Project Blue Sky v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; (1998) 194 CLR 355; (1998) 153 ALR 490

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634 

Secondary Materials

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

Operational Guideline Including specific types of supports in plans, September 2016

Productivity Commission Inquiry Report, Disability Care and Support, No. 54, July 2011, vol 2

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member J F Toohey

31 March 2017

Introduction

  1. Margaret Young is a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) which is governed by the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act2013 (the Act).  She has Limb Girdle Muscular Dystrophy, a degenerative condition which causes muscle weakness and soreness, and difficulty with mobility.  Her husband, Brendon Young, has made a number of modifications to their home to make it more accessible for her including lowering the steps between the garage and the main house and adding hand rails, and modifying the step from the front porch into the house. 

  2. As a participant in the NDIS, Mrs Young has a participant’s plan which comprises a statement of her goals and aspirations, and a statement of participant supports approved by the CEO of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA): s 33 of the Act.  A statement of participant’s supports includes the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded under the NDIS: s 33(b).

  3. Mrs Young’s plan includes funding for transport, house cleaning, a personal alarm system, exercise physiology and occupational therapy.  She seeks review of a decision by the NDIA not to include in her plan funding of $12,056 for a Turny swivel seat to enable her to get in and out of her husband’s LandCruiser.  The LandCruiser is higher from the ground than a standard vehicle. 

    Mrs Young’s participant’s plan

  4. Mrs Young became a participant in the NDIS in April 2014.  Her first plan commenced on 14 May 2014 and, in accordance with s 33(2)(c) of the Act, provided that it would be reviewed  by 15 April 2015.  On 26 November 2014, a second plan was approved.  A third plan commenced on 14 May 2015 and was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Young and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 407
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mrs Young for funding from the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) for a "Turny" swivel seat to assist her in accessing a LandCruiser vehicle. The dispute arose because the NDIA declined to fund the swivel seat, and Mrs Young sought review of this decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the provision of a Turny swivel seat constituted a "reasonable and necessary support" under the National Disability Insurance Scheme. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether the support would assist Mrs Young in pursuing her stated goals, facilitate her social and economic participation, represent value for money, and be effective and beneficial, taking into account the cost of alternative supports and what might reasonably be expected of family members.

The Tribunal applied the criteria set out in section 34(1) of the relevant legislation. While acknowledging that the Turny seat would assist Mrs Young in achieving her goals of travel and exercise, and that it was appropriately funded through the NDIS rather than another system, the Tribunal was not satisfied that all the criteria were met. The primary reason for this was the lack of satisfaction regarding value for money. The Tribunal found that the cost of the Turny seat was not reasonable relative to the benefits achieved, particularly when compared to the potential cost-effectiveness of alternative supports proposed by TAD (Technical Aid to the Disabled). The Tribunal also noted that funding was available for an occupational therapist to explore these alternative options.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision not to fund the Turny swivel seat.

Orders

Orders of the court

at para 68

Background

Background to the litigation

Mrs Young’s goals and aspirations, and the funding to be provided, are broadly similar in each of her plans. Her goals include “to be able to spend more time walking and exercising and to travel” and to “continue to exercise regularly and stay mobile”. To help meet these goals, her first plan included funding for an assessment by an occupational therapist to investigate options for safe transfer in and out of her home and the LandCruiser “with a view to travelling with a caravan in the future”. Her current plan includes funding for “occupational therapy to conduct a further review and investigation of options around [her] mobility”. Background Mrs Young has a Honda sedan which she can get in and out of independently. She drives herself each day to her full time job as a medical recruiter. Mr Young is a taxi driver and drives his LandCruiser when not working. Mrs Young cannot get in or out of the LandCruiser by herself. For a number of years she has used a foldable step that Mr Young made for her when she needed a means of getting in and out of a tour coach during a trip to Europe. When that became too low, he made a second, larger foldable step to go with the smaller step so she can get into and out of the LandCruiser. They took the steps on a trip to central Australia in the LandCruiser in 2015. The steps are different heights and have no handrail. The NDIA does not dispute, and we accept, that the foldable steps are no longer suitable. Mr Young uses the LandCruiser for trips to the hardware store and landscape suppliers, and to transport equipment and gardening supplies for work on their large garden. Mrs Young would like to be able to join him but cannot do so without a suitable means of getting into and out of the LandCruiser. They both enjoy bushwalking, and the exercise helps Mrs Young keep mobile. They like to take the LandCruiser to bushwalks that are not easily accessible in her sedan. Mrs Young plans to start cutting back her work later this year and eventually retiring altogether. She has long service and other leave available this year and would like to travel in Australia with Mr Young. They have a number of friends who enjoy caravanning. On their trip to central Australia in 2015 they drove the LandCruiser and stayed in on-site caravans. They would like to travel more when Mrs Young has leave, and in their retirement. They plan to buy a caravan with an internal bathroom so she does not have to rely on communal facilities. In order to accompany her husband on local trips in the LandCruiser, to bushwalking sites that are not accessible in her car, and on caravanning trips, Mrs Young needs a safe means of getting into and out of the LandCruiser. The question is whether the NDIS should provide funding for a Turny seat. We have seen YouTube footage of various models of the Turny swivel seat in use. All act on the same principle. The seat is installed in place of a driver’s or passenger’s seat and is operated electronically. It swivels and extends outside the vehicle, lowering or lifting the person to or from the ground. It can be transferred to another vehicle with the assistance of a professional installer.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The NDIA acknowledges, and we are satisfied, that a support that enables Mrs Young to get into and out of the LandCruiser (and other mobility and access supports) is most appropriately provided through the NDIS and is not more appropriately funded through another general system of service delivery, such as the health system.Conclusion We are not satisfied of all of the matters in s 34(1) in relation to the funding of a Turny seat. In particular, we are not satisfied that it represents value for money in that the costs are reasonable, relative to the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support. We are not persuaded that the steps proposed by TAD cannot achieve the same benefit, at a fraction of the cost. We note that Mrs Young’s current plan includes funding for an occupational therapist to explore options and that funding appears still to be available for this purpose. For these reasons, we affirm the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The CEO of the NDIA has made Operational Guidelines (Guidelines) to assist decision-makers in decisions about matters including reasonable and necessary supports. The Guidelines represent government policy and should be applied by the Tribunal unless there is good reason not to do so: Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2)[1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634. Relevant to this matter is the Guideline Including specific types of supports in plans issued in September 2016, in particular as it concerns Vehicle Modifications. ConsiderationSection 34(1)(a) We are satisfied that the Turny seat would assist Mrs Young to pursue her goal to travel and, insofar as it assists her to go bushwalking, that it would assist her to pursue her goal of spending more time walking and exercising, and staying mobile. We are therefore satisfied of s 34(1)(a).Section 34(1)(b) The objects of the Act include supporting the independence and social and economic participation of people with disability: s 3(1). The general principles guiding actions under the Act include that people with disability should be supported to participate in and contribute to social and economic life to the extent of their ability: s 4(2). Section 34(1)(b) requires us to be satisfied that funding of a Turny seat will assist Mrs Young “to undertake activities so as to facilitate her social and economic participation”. We accept that there are social aspects of travel and bushwalking and, insofar as the Turny seat would allow Mrs Young to travel in the LandCruiser, we are satisfied that it would assist in her to undertake activities so as to facilitate her social participation. That said, according to her evidence, Mrs Young’s social participation is not lacking. She describes her existing social life as “strong”. She works full time. She and Mr Young have a close and supportive family and see their adult children and their partners, and their grandchild, weekly. They also spend time with their extended family and with a network of friends in their local area and through their work, and they often have friends to dinner (rather than going to restaurants that might present difficulties of access). They travel. It might be said that the Turny seat would further enhance her social participation but is not “necessary” to it. Section 34(1)(b) requires that a support will assist the participant to undertake activities so as to facilitate his or her social and economic participation. (In contrast to the disability requirement in s 24(1)(d) that an impairment affect a person’s capacity for social or economic participation). Economic participation in this context is not defined. We accept the submissions made by both parties that social and economic participation should be given a broad meaning in light of the general purpose and policy underlying the NDIS as reflected in the Act: Project Blue Sky v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; (1998) 194 CLR 355; (1998) 153 ALR 490.