Yorke, Miles Richard v Ross Lucas Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

I N THE FEDERAL COURT O F AUSTRALIA )

1

SOUTH AUSTRALIA

DISTRICT

REGISTRY

1

S.A.

No.

G38

of

1981

1

GENERAL

D I V I S I O N

1

B E T W E E N :

MILES

RICHARD

YORKE and

SUE ELIZABETH

YORKE

A p p l i c a n t s

- and -

ROSS LUCAS PTY. LTD.,

ROSS

MELVILLE

LUCA

TREASUREWAY STORES

PTY.

LTD. and KEVIN

THOMAS MAHONEY

Respondent S

AND

ROSS

LUCAS

PTY.

LTD.,

and

ROSS MELVILLE

LUCAS

Cross-Claimants

- and -

TREASUREWAY STORES

PTY.

LTD.

C r o s s - R e s p o n d e n t

O R D E R

JUDGE MAKING ORDER

Fisher J.

DATE

OF ORDER

24 N o v e m b e r 1981

WHERE MADE

.

A d e l a i d e

THE COURT ORDERS

THAT :

1.

T r e a s u r e w a y Stores Pty.

L t d ' s

application for a

stay

of

proceedings be

d i s m i s s e d .

2. Treasureway Stores Pty. Ltd . t o pay the applicants costs

of the N o t i c e of Motion t o be taxed i f not agreed.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT

OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

S.A. No.G38 of 1981

GENERAL DIVISION

B E T W E E N :

MILES RICHARD YORKE and

SUE ELIZABETH YORKE

Applicants

- and -

ROSS LUCAS PTY. LTD., ROSS MELVILLE LUCAS,

-

TREASUREWAY STORES PTY. LTD. and KEVIN

THOMAS MAHONEY

Respondents

AND

-

ROSS LUCAS PTY. LTD., and

ROSS MELVILLE LUCAS

Cross-Claimants

- and -

TREASUREWAY STORES PTY. LTD.

Cross-Respondent

REASONS FOR

JUDGMENT

FISHER J.:

This is an application by way of motlon by Treasureway

Stores Pty. Ltd. one of the respondents to the main proceedings,

which company

I shall refer to as Treasureway, for

a stay of these

proceedings pending the hearing and determination of two actions

in the Supreme Court

of South Australia. As the hearing of the

action in this court is due to commence next week, it is desirable

I give my decision

on the application promptly, and, as far as

possible in the circumstances, give my reasons so that the unsuccessf party is not, for all practical purposes, denied his right to appeal my decision.

2.

Treasureway i s one of

four respondents

i n t h e proceedings i n t h i

court wherein Miles Richard Yorke and Sue Elizabeth Yorke, whom I shal l cal l the appl icants , seek damages pursuant to sec t ion 82 of

the Trade Practices A c t for alleged contraventions

of sections 52

and 59 of

tha t ac t .

They seek no

other re l ief

i n th i s cour t ,

nor

do

they set up any common l a w causes of action, though currently-on

foot are

two

a c t i o…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yorke, Miles Richard v Ross Lucas Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1981] FCA 218
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Miles Richard Yorke and Sue Elizabeth Yorke, the applicants, have brought proceedings against Ross Lucas Pty Ltd, Ross Melville Lucas, Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd, and Kevin Thomas Mahoney, the respondents, in the Federal Court of Australia, South Australia District Registry. The applicants are seeking damages for alleged contraventions of sections 52 and 59 of the Trade Practices Act. In response, Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd has applied for a stay of the proceedings pending the determination of two actions in the Supreme Court of South Australia. These actions involve the applicants and Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd, as well as an additional action brought by Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd against the applicants.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Federal Court should grant the application for a stay of proceedings in favour of Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd. The court considered the arguments presented by both parties, including the overlap in the facts and issues between the proceedings in the Federal Court and the Supreme Court, the jurisdictional doubts regarding the cross-claims in the Federal Court, and the potential for overlapping claims in the bill of sale proceedings. The court also examined relevant legal principles and precedents, including dicta from Union Steamship Company of New Zealand v The Caradale, Hughes Motor Service Pty Limited and Others v Wang Computer Limited, and Telford Panel and Engineering Works Pty Limited v Elder Smith Goldsbrough Mort Limited.

In dismissing the application for a stay, the court found that Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd had not satisfied the burden of proof to demonstrate that the applicants would incur substantially less inconvenience and expense if the issues were litigated in the Supreme Court. Furthermore, the court was not convinced that the applicants would be deprived of legitimate personal or juridical advantages by not being granted a stay. The court concluded that, in the particular circumstances of this case, it was not a proper case for a stay, and that the applicants were likely to be disadvantaged if they were not permitted to proceed with the hearing of their action in the Federal Court. Consequently, the court dismissed Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd's application for a stay and ordered that the company pay the applicants' costs of the notice of motion if not agreed.

The court ordered that Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd's application for a stay of proceedings be dismissed, and that the company pay the applicants' costs of the notice of motion if not agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants, Miles Richard Yorke and Sue Elizabeth Yorke, are seeking damages from the respondents - Ross Lucas Pty Ltd, Ross Melville Lucas, Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd, and Kevin Thomas Mahoney - for alleged contraventions of sections 52 and 59 of the Trade Practices Act. The applicants' claims stem from the purchase of a business from Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd. They seek no other relief in this court and have not set up any common law causes of action. Concurrently, there are two actions in the Supreme Court of South Australia: one by Miles Richard Yorke against Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd and one of the other respondents, and another by Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd against the applicants. The proceedings in the Federal Court were commenced on 21 August 1981 and are scheduled for hearing on 1 December 1981.

Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd, one of the respondents, applied for a stay of the proceedings in the Federal Court pending the determination of the actions in the Supreme Court. The application was heard and decided on 24 November 1981 by Fisher J. The Supreme Court proceedings by Miles Richard Yorke were commenced after preliminary applications on 30 July 1981, with a potential hearing date towards the middle of the next year. In the other Supreme Court proceedings by Treasureway Stores Pty Ltd, a statement of claim had not yet been filed, although several interlocutory orders had been made.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Federal Court should grant a stay of proceedings pending the determination of the actions in the Supreme Court.
2. Whether the applicants will be deprived of legitimate personal or juridical advantages if the stay is not granted.
3. Whether the remedies available in the Federal Court for contraventions of the Trade Practices Act are equally available in the Supreme Court proceedings.

Held
1. The Federal Court dismissed the application for a stay of proceedings by Treasureway Stores Pty. Ltd.
2. The Court held that the applicants will be deprived of legitimate personal or juridical advantages if the stay is not granted.
3. The Court found that the remedies available in the Federal Court for contraventions of the Trade Practices Act are not equally available in the Supreme Court proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Treasureway Stores Pty. Ltd. applied for a stay of proceedings in the Federal Court pending the determination of actions in the Supreme Court. The applicants, Miles Richard Yorke and Sue Elizabeth Yorke, opposed the application. The Court, after considering the submissions and the relevant authorities, dismissed the application for a stay. The Court determined that the applicants would be deprived of legitimate personal and juridical advantages if the stay was granted. These advantages included the early trial date set for the Federal Court proceedings, which was scheduled for the following week. Furthermore, the Court found that the remedies available for contraventions of the Trade Practices Act were not equally available in the Supreme Court proceedings. The Court distinguished the authorities relied upon by Treasureway, including dicta from Union Steamship Company of New Zealand v The Caradale and Hughes Motor Service Pty. Limited and Others v Wang Computer Limited, on the basis that the facts and circumstances of those cases did not align with the present case. The Court emphasised that the burden of proof lay with Treasureway to demonstrate that it would suffer substantially less inconvenience and expense if the proceedings were litigated in the Supreme Court, which it failed to do. The Court also considered the early stage of the Federal Court proceedings and the jurisdictional doubts over the cross-claims, which did not weigh in favour of granting a stay. Ultimately, the Court concluded that the applicants were likely to be disadvantaged if they were not permitted to proceed with the hearing in the Federal Court.