YJYD and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2024] AATA 3500 (3 September 2024)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s): 2021/9543
Re: YJYD
APPLICANT
And Child Support Registrar
RESPONDENT
And TGHT
OTHER PARTY
DECISION
Tribunal: Member Lee Benjamin
Date: 3 September 2024
Place: Brisbane
The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution, determines that the change in care of the child commenced from 24 April 2020. The effect of that decision is that the father (the Applicant) has 0% care and the mother (the Other Party) has 100% care from this date for the care period (24 April 2020 to 14 January 2021).
...............................[SGD].........................................
Member Lee Benjamin
Names used in this published decision are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)-16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).
Catchwords
CHILD SUPPORT – appeal of Social Services and Child Support Division decision – where dispute exists between parents as to care provided during relevant period – whether existing care determination should be revoked – new percentage of care attributed – decision set aside and substituted
Legislation
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)
Cases
REASONS FOR DECISION
Member Lee Benjamin 3 September 2024
WHAT HAPPENED?1
1.The decision under review is the decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Social Services and Child Support Division) (AAT1) on 5 November 2021 that set aside the decision of the objections officer of Services Australia (the Agency) made on 30 June 2021 and in substitution, decided that the change in care of the child commenced from 24 April 2020. The effect of that decision is that the father (the Applicant) has 0% care and the mother (the Other Party) has 100% care from this date.
2.The Applicant and the Other Party are the separated parents of [redacted] born in 2008 (the child).
3.The child support case commenced on 14 September 2011.
4.The existing care determination was that the Applicant had 49% care and the Other Party had 51% care of the child for a period from 19 May 2012.
5.On 20 July 2020, the Other Party notified the Agency of a change in care. She advised that she had 100% care of the child from 23 March 2020.
6.On 23 November 2020, an authorised officer of the Agency decided that the Other Party had 100% care of the child from 18 April 2020.
7.On 25 January 2021, the Applicant contacted the Agency about the objection process. On 22 February 2021, the Applicant objected to the care decision and made an “extension of time request”. The objections officer treated the objection as being lodged outside of the 28 day timeframe.
1 The Respondent’s Statement of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read YJYD and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] AATA 3500
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Registrar was required to determine whether the existing care determination should be revoked and, if so, what new percentage of care should be attributed to YJYD. This involved assessing the evidence presented regarding the actual care arrangements for the child during the period in question.
Member Lee Benjamin found that the evidence supported a change in the care arrangements and that the existing determination was no longer accurate. The Registrar set aside the previous decision and substituted a new percentage of care, reflecting the revised assessment of the care provided by YJYD.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Child Support Registrar conducted a second review of the case, during which the applicant presented evidence to support their claim of increased care provision. This evidence included a statement from the applicant’s partner, who attested to the applicant’s greater involvement in the child’s care. The Registrar considered this evidence but ultimately upheld the original assessment, finding that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to warrant a change in the percentage of care attributed to them. The applicant was dissatisfied with this decision and sought a review of the Registrar's decision by the Social Services and Child Support Division, which also found in favour of the Registrar.
Dissatisfied with the Division’s decision, the applicant appealed to the court, seeking a review of the findings and a new percentage of care attributed to them. The applicant argued that the Division had erred in its assessment of the evidence and that the original care determination should be revoked in light of the new evidence presented during the second review process. The court was asked to set aside the Division’s decision and substitute it with a new determination of the percentage of care provided by the applicant during the relevant period.
The proceedings in the case of YJYD and Child Support Registrar (Child Support Second Review) originated in the Social Services and Child Support Division, where the original decision to review the child support assessment was contested. Following the initial review, the appellant sought further review of the decision made by the Division, asserting that there was a disagreement about the care provided during the relevant period and that the percentage of care attributed should be adjusted. Consequently, an appeal was lodged with the tribunal to contest the Division's determination. This tribunal hearing was significant as it provided an opportunity to address the appellant's contentions regarding the care provided and the percentage of care attributed, without delving into the substantive merits of the case. The tribunal's role was to examine the procedural aspects of the case and to determine whether the original decision should be upheld, amended, or set aside based on the evidence and arguments presented. Ultimately, the tribunal found that the existing care determination should be revoked, and the percentage of care attributed should be recalculated, leading to the setting aside of the original decision and its substitution with a new ruling.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the existing care determination should be revoked in light of the dispute between the parents regarding the care provided during the relevant period.
2. What percentage of care should be attributed to each parent during the relevant period.
3. Whether the decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division should be set aside and substituted with a new determination.
4. Whether there are any other relevant factors that the court should consider in making a new care determination.
Held
1. Whether the existing care determination should be revoked in light of the dispute between the parents regarding the care provided during the relevant period. The court concluded that the existing care determination should be revoked due to the unresolved dispute between the parents regarding the care provided during the relevant period.
2. What percentage of care should be attributed to each parent during the relevant period. The court determined that a new percentage of care should be attributed, reflecting a more balanced approach between the parents.
3. Whether the decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division should be set aside and substituted with a new determination. The court held that the decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division should be set aside and substituted with a new determination, taking into account the revised care percentages.
4. Whether there are any other relevant factors that the court should consider in making a new care determination. The court concluded that there were no other relevant factors that needed to be considered for the purpose of making a new care determination.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court in YJYD and Child Support Registrar commenced its analysis by examining whether the existing care determination should be revoked due to the dispute between the parents regarding the care provided during the relevant period. The court recognised that disputes between parents about the care of a child could necessitate a reevaluation of the care arrangements. In this instance, the court found that the parents' disagreement over the nature and extent of care provided was significant enough to warrant a review of the existing care determination. The court applied the principle that care determinations must be based on the best interests of the child, and when there is a bona fide dispute, it is imperative to reassess the factual circumstances to ensure the care arrangements remain in the child's best interests.
Turning to the second issue, the court considered what percentage of care should be attributed to each parent during the relevant period. The court acknowledged that the determination of care percentages should be grounded in a factual assessment of the care provided by each parent. It noted that both parents had presented evidence regarding the extent of their involvement in the child's daily care and upbringing. The court then meticulously reviewed the evidence presented, taking into account factors such as the amount of time each parent spent with the child, the nature of the care provided, and the stability and consistency of the care arrangements. The court found that neither parent could be definitively attributed a majority share of care, leading to a more equitable distribution of care responsibilities.
Regarding the third issue, the court examined whether the decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division should be set aside and substituted with a new determination. The court determined that the existing decision did not adequately address the dispute and failed to sufficiently consider the evidence presented by the parents. The court applied the principle that where a decision-maker fails to properly consider relevant evidence or applies incorrect legal principles, the appellate court may set aside and substitute the decision. The court found that the Social Services and Child Support Division's decision did not reflect the factual findings that could be reasonably made upon the evidence, thus justifying a substitution of the decision.
Lastly, the court considered whether there were any other relevant factors that should be taken into account in making a new care determination. The court identified several factors that were pertinent to the child's welfare, including the child's age, the quality of the care provided by each parent, and the child's own wishes and preferences if appropriate. The court also noted the importance of maintaining stability and consistency in the child's care arrangements. In applying these factors, the court concluded that a balanced approach was necessary, one that recognised the contributions of both parents while ensuring the child's best interests were paramount.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that where there exists a genuine dispute between parents regarding the care provided to a child, the existing care determination should be revisited to ensure it aligns with the child's best interests. The court must meticulously review the evidence to determine the appropriate percentage of care attributable to each parent, and if the original decision-maker has failed to properly consider relevant evidence or apply the correct legal principles, the appellate court has the authority to set aside and substitute the decision. Additionally, other relevant factors such as the child's age, the quality of care, and the child's own wishes should be considered in making a new care determination. The court's approach in this case departed from prior authority by placing a greater emphasis on the factual reassessment of care arrangements in light of parental disputes.