Yawari and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

Yawari and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) (Compensation) [2023] AATA 3208 (11 October 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2021/1960 & 2022/2644

Re:Ms Shaista Yawari

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Date:11 October 2023

Place:Melbourne

Under section 43(1)(c)(i) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that Ms Yawari is entitled to compensation under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 for her condition of adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood.

........................[SGD]........................

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

CATCHWORDS

WORKER’S COMPENSATION – postal worker – denial of liability – claims of bullying and harassment – adjustment disorder – employment contributed to the cause of her injury to a significant degree – new evidence of symptoms raised during the hearing process - decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

CASES

Australian Postal Corporation v Burch (1998) 85 FCR 264

Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535
Comcare v Mooi (1996) 69 FCR 439

Whisprun Pty Ltd v Dixon (2003) 234 CLR 492

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms A E Burke AO Member

11 October 2023

  1. The Applicant, Ms Shaista Yawari, applied for review of two decisions made by Australian Postal Corporation (Australia Post): to deny of liability for compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act).

  2. On 31 March 2021 Ms Yawari, sought review of that decision by the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal), stating that the decision was wrong in fact and law.

    INTRODUCTION

  3. Ms Yawari was employed by Australia Post from 29 April 2020 until 6 August 2020 as a mail officer. Ms Yawari is a 22-year-old Afghani national, who resides with her parents. She completed year 12 and commenced a nursing degree at Federation University. Whilst working at Australia Post Ms Yawari was studying and also working for Coles Supermarkets.

  4. On 19 July 2020 Ms Yawari submitted an incident report noting the date of incident as 4 May 2020 describing what happened as “I always got bullied, discriminated and harassed because of my religion, appearance and race. I was and is mentally injured because of what I have been going through at Auspost”.

  5. On 9 August 2020 Ms Yawari first sought medical treatment for the injury and submitted a claim for compensation under the SRC Act on 11 October 2020.

  6. On 21 January 2021 Australia Post concluded an internal investigation into Ms Yawari’s claim of bullying and harassment on grounds of Religion and Physical Characteristics against Ms Triantaflaros, Ms Jansz and Ms Barber. The report found the claims had not been substantiated and were therefore not considered to be breaches of the Australia Post Harassment Discrimination Bullying Policy or Ethics.

  7. On 25 January 2021 Australia Post rejected Ms Yawari’s claim for compensation under section 14 of the SRC Act for her claimed “depression, anxiety,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yawari and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) (Com... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3208
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Ms. Yawari against a decision by the Australian Postal Corporation to deny her claim for compensation. Ms. Yawari, a parcel sorter, alleged she suffered an adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood due to bullying, harassment, and discrimination by colleagues during her employment. The Australian Postal Corporation had rejected her claim, finding that her alleged condition did not arise out of, or in the course of, her employment. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the Australian Postal Corporation was liable to pay compensation to Ms. Yawari for her claimed workplace injury.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Ms. Yawari's adjustment disorder constituted a compensable "injury" under the relevant legislation, and if so, whether her employment had contributed to it to the requisite degree. The Tribunal had to distinguish between an "injury simpliciter," which requires the injury to arise out of or in the course of employment, and a "disease," which requires employment to have contributed to it to a significant degree. The Tribunal considered the evidence presented, including medical reports and Ms. Yawari's account of her experiences, to ascertain the nature of her condition and its causal link to her work.

The Tribunal reasoned that Ms. Yawari's claimed condition of adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood was not an "injury simpliciter" arising directly from specific incidents of bullying and harassment, as the allegations of such conduct were not substantiated. However, applying the principles established in cases such as *Australian Postal Corporation v Burch*, the Tribunal found that her condition was a "disease" to which her employment had contributed to a significant degree. The Tribunal was satisfied, based on the evidence, that Ms. Yawari's employment was a substantial contributing factor to her psychiatric condition, leading to her incapacity.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the Australian Postal Corporation's decision and substituted a new decision finding that Ms. Yawari was entitled to compensation under section 14 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* for her adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood. The matter was to be remitted to the Australian Postal Corporation for determination of liability under other relevant sections of the Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Yawari was a 20-year-old student employed as a casual parcel sorter with Australia Post, starting her employment on 29 April 2020. During her employment, she alleged that she was subjected to bullying and harassment by her work colleagues, specifically a worker named Carmel, who made comments about her religion and fasting during Ramadan, and physically pinched her. She also reported that another colleague, Mary, began treating her poorly after she reported the incidents to Mary, who had initially promised to address the issue. Ms Yawari claimed that Mary, who was the sole operator of a forklift, nearly hit her several times and then apologised. Despite these allegations, Australia Post found no substantiated evidence of bullying or harassment following an investigation.

Following these incidents, Ms Yawari reported feeling stressed and having disturbed sleep, weight loss, and concentration difficulties. She ceased working and consulted her general practitioner on 9 August 2020. She began seeing psychologist Dr Andrew Plewa under a Mental Health Care Plan and was prescribed medication for her symptoms. Despite the treatment, her symptoms persisted, leading to a diagnosis of adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood by Associate Professor Abdul Khalid, a Consultant Psychiatrist. Ms Yawari’s symptoms included tearfulness, feelings of helplessness, passive death wishes, loss of appetite, weight loss, and a lack of motivation, which significantly affected her daily life and studies.

The Australian Postal Corporation initially denied Ms Yawari's claim for compensation, stating that her claimed condition did not arise out of or in the course of her employment. However, the Tribunal found that Ms Yawari's employment with Australia Post had significantly contributed to her condition. The Tribunal set aside the initial decision and determined that Ms Yawari was entitled to compensation for her condition of adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood. The Tribunal’s decision hinged on the evidence that Ms Yawari's employment had substantially contributed to her psychiatric condition, meeting the criteria for a compensable claim under the applicable legislation.

The matter before the court pertains to a claim for workers' compensation brought by Ms Yawari against the Australian Postal Corporation. Ms Yawari alleged that her employment with Australia Post contributed to her psychological condition, specifically an adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood. The claim originated from a decision by the reconsideration officers to reject her application for compensation. This rejection was based on the officers' determination that her condition did not arise out of or in the course of her employment. Ms Yawari subsequently sought judicial review of this decision, arguing that her employment was a significant contributing factor to her condition. The case proceeded to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which was tasked with determining whether Australia Post was liable to compensate Ms Yawari for her workplace injury under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act). The Tribunal held a hearing where it was agreed that its role was limited to this determination. Following the hearing, the Tribunal found that Ms Yawari's claims of bullying and harassment were not substantiated, but it was satisfied that her employment had significantly contributed to her condition. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the reconsideration officers' decision and substituted its own, finding that Ms Yawari was entitled to compensation.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 17 March 2021 the Reconsideration Officers in their reasons for affirmation of rejection stated:Reasons for decision In a claim for compensation dated 11 October 2020, you advised that your claimed psychological condition of “depression, anxiety, mental health injuries, and psychological injuries” occurred ‘during the course of your employment up until you ceased work on 14 August 2020’. You claimed that you were harassed, bullied and discriminated everyday by three work colleagues. You reported that you first sought medical treatment on 9 August 2020.You stated: “We sorted parcel every day. Worked close to each other. I always got bullied, discriminated & harassed because of my religion, appearance & race. I was and is mentally injured because of what I have been going through at AusPost.”On 27 August 2020, Dr Martin Hill diagnosed “alleged bullying and harassment by work colleagues both verbal and physical beginning 14/05/2020. Anxiety, depression with insomnia”, and retrospectively certified you totally incapacitated for work from 4 August 2020 to 18 August 2020.You continued to attend consultations with Dr Hill, who maintained his diagnosis, and continued to certify you totally incapacitated for work.Information made available indicates that you did submit a Harassment, Discrimination and Bullying complaint to my HR for investigation. In correspondence dated 23 November 2020, Ms Maree Lotstra, Employee Relations Case Manager, advised that all allegations made by you against your work colleagues were not proven.You were provided with correspondence dated 21 January 2021, which detailed that your complaint of Bullying and Harassment on Grounds of Religion and Physical Characteristics against three work colleagues were not substantiated, and therefore not considered to be breaches of the Australia Post Harassment Discrimination Bullying Policy or Our Ethics.The determination dated 25 January 2021 denied liability for compensation for your claim as the claims manager was not satisfied that your claimed condition arose out of, or in the course of, your employment with Australia Post.Medical evidence Associate Professor Abdul Khalid (A/P Khalid), Consultant Psychiatrist, in a medico-legal report of 22 July 2021 opined:DIAGNOSTIC ASSESSMENTMs Yawari is a 20-year-old female who started as a casual parcel sorter with Australia Post on 29 April 2020. Ms Yawari alleged being bullied and harassed by a worker named Carmel. She said that Carmel used to make comments about her religion and fasting during the month of Ramadan. She alleged that Carmel used to pinch her. She said that she reported these matters to her line manager Mary, who told her that she would talk to the Facility Manager. She said that she did not hear anything back and then Mary also started treating her the same way. She said that Mary was the only one who drove the forklift and she almost hit her a few times, and then apologised. She said that she kept quiet and tolerated everything because she needed money to pay her fees. She said that on 3 August 2020 she had gone to the carpark to get a cutter and when she came back, Mary yelled at her in front of everyone. She said that the next day she had a meeting with the manager who told her that it was not fair what had happened to her, but he said that he needed all the workers during COVID-19. She said that she stopped working and saw her GP on 9 August 2020.Ms Yawari said that she felt stressed and had disturbed sleep. She said that she was losing weight. She used to work nightshift at Coles, which she has stopped. She started seeing psychologist Dr Andrew Plewa under a Mental Health Care Plan. She was prescribed Seremind to help with her sleep, but it did not work, and then she was prescribed Mirtazapine and currently she is taking 45mg daily, along with antianxiety medication Quetiapine 25mg night-time.Ms Yawari said that she was studying nursing at Federation University, and she struggled with her studies and changed to part-time this year but still did not perform well in her assessment in the semester. She said that she was struggling with her concentration.Ms Yawari said that she still has difficulty going to sleep and has bad dreams. She said that she feels sedated during the day due to the medications. She reported loss of appetite and weight. She had loss of energy and motivation. She stopped talking to her family and just sits in her bedroom. She does not do any household chores or cooking. She did not report any past history of any psychiatric illness.On mental state examination, Ms Yawari was tearful during the interview. She reported her mood as more depressed than anxious. She said she cries when sits alone. She said that she keeps thinking about what happened at work. She said that she feels helpless and expressed some passive death wishes with no suicidal plan or intent.Based on the history, mental state examination and the documents provided to me, in my opinion Ms Yawari's diagnosis is an adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood according to the DSM-5 diagnostic criteria.Diagnosis.I consider that Ms Yawari's diagnosis is an adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood according to the DSM-5 diagnostic criteria.Prognosis.Ms Yawari's prognosis is guarded because her symptoms have not improved despite treatment with antidepressant medication and sessions with her psychologist.The relationship between our client's injury and employment, if any. In particular, whether you believe that our client's employment has caused, aggravated or accelerated any underlying condition.I consider that Ms Yawari's adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood has arisen as a result of Ms Yawari's employment with Australia Post as she felt bullied, harassed and discriminated due to her religion. She did not report any pre-existing psychiatric condition.Whether you believe that our client’s employment has significantly contributed to her condition.Based on the information provided by Ms Yawari, I consider that her employment is the significant contributing factor for her psychiatric condition.In relation to our client’s condition, what is her capacity to work in the pre-injury role.I do not consider that Ms Yawari has any capacity to return in her pre-injury role.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, the Tribunal is satisfied that as a result Ms Yawari did suffer incapacity and that her injury was caused by or contributed to, to a significant degree, by her employment. That is to say, as regards to the degree of contribution, the Tribunal was satisfied on the evidence that it was substantially more than material.DECISION Under section 43(1)(c)(i) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that Ms Yawari is entitled to compensation under section 14 of the SRC Act for her condition of adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Counsel submitted that Ms Yawari’s numerous claims of bullying and harassment had simply not been made out and there was no link between her claimed condition, which was not conceded, and her work at Australia Post. CONSIDERATION At the commencement of the hearing, it was agreed by the parties the Tribunal’s role would be limited to a determination of section 14 of the SRC Act: was Australia Post liable to pay compensation to Ms Yawari for her claimed workplace injury. The parties agreed should the Tribunal find Ms Yawari had a compensable claim under section 14 the determination would need to be remitted to Australia Post to make a determination in respect of liability under sections 16, 19, 24 and 27 of the SRC Act. The Tribunal notes (like numerous Tribunal Members before) the following observations of the High Court in Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535 at 540 about the concept of an "injury":…First, the Act does not oblige Comcare to pay compensation in respect of an employee's impairment; it is liable to pay compensation in respect of 'the injury'. Secondly, the term 'injury' is not used in the Act in the sense of 'workplace accident'. The definition of 'injury' is expressed in terms of the resultant effect of an incident or ailment upon the employee's body. Thirdly, the term 'injury' is not used in a global sense to describe the general condition of the employee following an incident. The Act refers disjunctively to 'disease' or 'physical or mental' injuries and, at least to that extent, it assumes that an employee may sustain more than one 'injury'. The use in s 24(1) of the indefinite article in the expression 'an injury' reinforces that conclusion The distinction between sections 5A(1)(a) and 5A(1)(b) of the SRC Act is an important one, given that the classification of a condition as either a disease or an injury (other than a disease) will determine the applicable test for determining the contribution of work to an injury. Specifically, for there to be an injury (other than a disease) (often referred to as an ‘injury simpliciter’), the injury must arise out of, or in the course of, employment (section 5A(1)(b)). An injury simpliciter (within the meaning of section 5A(1)(b)) can be contrasted with a "disease" which, according to section 5B(1), must be contributed to, to a significant degree, by the employee's employment. Thus, a "disease" requires a stronger causal connection between the employment and the ailment (Australian Postal Corporation v Burch (1998) 85 FCR 264 at 268) than that required for an injury simpliciter. The Tribunal, based on all the evidence before it did not find that Ms Yawari’s allegations of bullying and harassment could be considered an injury simpliciter. The Tribunal, based on the evidence in Ms Yawari’s specific circumstances, and the preponderance of case law found that Ms Yawari’s claimed condition of adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood was an ailment being a disease.