Yas and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

Yas and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 629 (3 April 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2018/4622

Re:Ali Yas

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member C Edwardes

Date:3 April 2019

Place:Perth

The decision under review is affirmed.

.....[Sgd]...............................................................

Member C Edwardes

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – whether Applicant of good character – meaning of good character – conviction for operating business illegally – enduring moral qualities – Australian values –

Applicant found not to be of good character at time that the Minister made decision – decision under review is affirmed

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) - ss 21(1) – 21(2) – 21(2)(h) – 24(1) – 24(1A) – 52(1)(b)

CASES

Assafiri v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) AATA 35

Fenn and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 931
Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 68 FCR 422
Kakar v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] AATA 132

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Immigration and Border Protection, Australian Citizenship Policy, at 1 June 2016 – Chapter 11

Australian Citizenship Instructions – 2014

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member C Edwardes

3 April 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for the review of a decision of a delegate of the Respondent (the Minister). This decision, made on 30 July 2018 (T1, 5-6) refused the Applicant’s application for Australian citizenship by conferral under s 24(1) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Citizenship Act). The application was refused on the basis that the Applicant did not satisfy the character requirements under s 21(2)(h) of the Citizenship Act at the time of the Minister’s decision.

  2. Citizenship by conferral (that is, where citizenship is granted to a person who does not have an automatic or statutory entitlement to citizenship) may be granted where an applicant satisfies certain requirements of the Citizenship Act.

    BACKGROUND

  3. The Applicant is a 35 year old citizen of Iraq who arrived in Australia on 1 May 2013 as the holder of an XB 200 Refugee and Humanitarian visa (T1, 8).

  4. He applied for conferral of Australian citizenship on 28 May 2017 (T7, 97-126). This application was refused on 30 July 2018 as Applicant failed the character test as required by s 21(2)(h) of the Citizenship Act.

  5. The Minister’s delegate stated (T1, 11):

    Your Australian Police Check Results Report indicates that you have been convicted of the following offence:

    25/05/2018

    Perth Magistrates Court     Carried On Business Without Being Holder Of Valid     Dealers  License Result: (Counts 1) Fine $12500.

    Crimes of this nature are considered serious in the context of Citizenship Policy.  I give your criminal conviction, and the nature of your recent offence, considerable weight.

    On 2 July 2018 the Department wrote to you and provided you with the opportunity to comment on this adverse information held by the Department and to provide any further information you wished to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yas and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 629
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for Australian citizenship by conferral by Ali Mohammed Yas, an Iraqi national who arrived in Australia in 2013. His application was refused by the Minister for Home Affairs on 30 July 2018, as he failed to meet the character test under section 21(2)(h) of the *Citizenship Act 1948* (Cth). The refusal was based on a conviction for carrying on business without a valid dealer's licence, for which he was fined $12,500. Mr Yas applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) for a review of this decision.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Mr Yas was a person of good character at the time the Minister made the decision to refuse his citizenship application. This required the Tribunal to consider the nature of his criminal conviction, the time elapsed since the offence, and any evidence of rehabilitation or remorse. The Tribunal also had to assess the weight to be given to character references provided by Mr Yas, in light of the relevant Citizenship Policy.

The Tribunal reasoned that Mr Yas's conviction for operating a motor vehicle dealership without a licence was a serious offence, reflecting a disregard for Australian laws designed to protect consumers and legitimate businesses. The offence involved 106 vehicle transactions over 19 months, and the Magistrate's comments highlighted the detrimental impact on consumers and the industry. Despite Mr Yas's submission that he did not understand the licensing requirements and his subsequent guilty plea, the Tribunal found that his personal statement to the Tribunal did not acknowledge his offending or express remorse. Furthermore, many of the character references provided were from family members or friends and did not adequately address the offence, thus attracting less weight according to the Citizenship Policy.

The Tribunal affirmed the Minister's decision, finding that Mr Yas had not demonstrated that he was a person of good character at the time of the refusal. The seriousness of the offence, its recency, and the lack of sufficient evidence of rehabilitation or remorse, when weighed against the character references, led the Tribunal to conclude that Mr Yas had failed the character test.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Citizenship by conferral (that is, where citizenship is granted to a person who does not have an automatic or statutory entitlement to citizenship) may be granted where an applicant satisfies certain requirements of the Citizenship Act.BACKGROUND The Applicant is a 35 year old citizen of Iraq who arrived in Australia on 1 May 2013 as the holder of an XB 200 Refugee and Humanitarian visa (T1, 8). He applied for conferral of Australian citizenship on 28 May 2017 (T7, 97-126). This application was refused on 30 July 2018 as Applicant failed the character test as required by s 21(2)(h) of the Citizenship Act. The Minister’s delegate stated (T1, 11):Your Australian Police Check Results Report indicates that you have been convicted of the following offence:25/05/2018Perth Magistrates Court Carried On Business Without Being Holder Of Valid Dealers License Result: (Counts 1) Fine $12500.Crimes of this nature are considered serious in the context of Citizenship Policy. I give your criminal conviction, and the nature of your recent offence, considerable weight.On 2 July 2018 the Department wrote to you and provided you with the opportunity to comment on this adverse information held by the Department and to provide any further information you wished to have considered in relation to your application. ……As you have not provided a personal statement addressing your criminal offence I am unable to give weight to any possible mitigating or exceptional circumstances that may exist.I do not believe sufficient time has elapsed for you to demonstrate that you are of reformed character.While it is possible for a person who was not of good character to be considered to have become a person of good character I have not come to this conclusion in your case. The Tribunal notes that the Applicant has provided various character references (T11, 152-155). While the Tribunal ascribes some weight to these character references as the referees did indicate awareness of the Applicant’s previous offence, the Tribunal is mindful that two of the references are from family members. The Tribunal notes the delegate’s findings (T2, 22):In response, on 22 July 2018 your migration agent Rebus Legal provided three character statements by email; which were from two family members and one friend. These character referee's vouch for your good character and indicate an awareness of your previous conviction, and as such I give these statements some weight. The Applicant applied to the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) on 16 August 2018 for a review of the delegate’s decision (T1, 1-4).JURISDICTION This application for review is made in accordance with s 52(1)(b) of the Citizenship Act, which allows applications to be made to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of a decision made under s 24 of the Citizenship Act.RELEVANT LEGISLATION AND POLICY Section 21(1) of the Citizenship Act provides that a person may make an application to the Minister to become an Australian citizen. Section 24(1) of the Citizenship Act provides that if a person makes an application under s 21, the Minister must, by writing, approve or refuse to approve the person becoming an Australian citizen.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issue for determination by this Tribunal is whether the Applicant was, as at 30 July 2018, a person of good character for the purpose of satisfying s 21(2)(h) of the Citizenship Act.EVIDENCE The application for review was initially heard in Perth on 26 February 2019. The Applicant appeared in person and was assisted by Mr Alherz as the interpreter. The Respondent was represented by Ms Ladhams of the Australian Government Solicitor. The matter was adjourned to a later date as the Tribunal was not satisfied that the Applicant had been served with requisite documentation and had time to understand the content. The application was resumed on 27 March 2019. The Applicant appeared in person and was assisted by Ms Tawbi as interpreter, while the Respondent was again represented by Ms Ladhams of the Australian Government Solicitor. The Tribunal received the following evidence:·Exhibit A1 – Statement by Ali Mohammed Yas dated 29 October 2018.·Exhibit A2 – Statement by Dr Al Salihee dated 25 October 2018.·Exhibit A3 – Statement by Adnan Aljibari dated 14 October 2018.·Exhibit A4 – Statement by Sam Alla (undated).·Exhibit A5 – Statement by Menshad Alsudani (undated).·Exhibit A6 – Petition in support of Applicant.·Exhibit R1 – T documents (T1-11 pp1-159).·Exhibit R2 – Statement of facts, Issues and Contentions (SOFIC) dated 25 January 2019.·Exhibit R3 – Applicant’s Prosecution Notice.·Exhibit R4 – Sentencing Transcript dated 25 May 2018.·Exhibit R5 – Hearing Certificate.·Exhibit R6 – Media Statement dated 28 May 2018. The Tribunal has reviewed all of the material before it. The Tribunal is satisfied that all relevant evidence was before it and that both parties were provided an opportunity to address the evidence, either orally or in writing. Relevant aspects of the evidence and material before the Tribunal will be analysed and referred to below. The Respondent’s contentions concerning the character of the Applicant were presented in its SOFIC (R2):Whether the applicant meets the good character requirement in s 21(2)(h)20.In assessing whether the applicant meets the good character requirement in s 21(2)(h), it will be appropriate for the Tribunal to take into account, amongst other things, the applicant’s criminal convictions, and character references provided on his behalf. As Davies J said in Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 68 FCR 422 at 425:… But criminal convictions or the absence of them and character references are likely to be an important source of primary information. If there is a criminal conviction, the decision-maker will have regard to the nature of the crime to determine whether or not it reflected adversely upon the character of the applicant. If the conviction was in the past, the decision-maker will turn his attention to whether or not the applicant has shown that he has reformed. If persons speak well of the applicant, the decision-maker will take that into account.21.These considerations are addressed in turn below.Applicant’s offending22.As the Tribunal (Deputy President Wright) said in Kakar and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] AATA 132 at [14]:When criminal offences have been committed by an applicant they will obviously be taken into account. The extent to which the existence of criminal conduct will weight in the scales against a finding of good character will depend upon many things including the seriousness of the crime, the length of time since its commission and the degree of rehabilitation of the offender.23.In the present case, the applicant has a conviction for a single offence. The conviction was recorded in May 2018 and appears to relate to conduct engaged in over a period of approximately 19 months.24.In sentencing the applicant, the Magistrate said to him:…we have a system of laws here to protect consumers and the relevant legislation is the Motor Vehicle Dealer’s Act. Those dealers pay a fee to be registered motor vehicle dealers. They have overheads. They can be – consumers can go to the courts and get a result if there’s a bad motor vehicle dealer. You operated completely outside all of that. You took part in 83 separate transactions.That is a cost to the motor vehicle industry, because they are buying and selling those cars; you are. Being motor vehicle dealers, they’re entitled to the protection of the law from people, with respect, like yourself that just go and do it in your backyard.25.Although the applicant’s offence is not at the more serious end of the range of offences, it raises significant concerns about his character for the purposes of a citizenship application because:25.1.it suggests that the applicant does not respect and abide by the laws of Australia;25.2.as the comments of the sentencing Magistrate suggest, conduct such as the applicant’s can operate to disadvantage business operators in a regulated industry, who comply with the regulations and incur cost in doing so; and25.3.conduct such as the applicant’s can also deny consumers their rights. This can be demonstrated by the following comments in a press release issued by the Department of Mines, Industry Regulation and Safety following the conviction of the applicant and his brothers:Commissioner for Consumer Protection David Hillyard said this case is the biggest unlicensed dealing matter the Department has investigated and prosecuted.“With a total of 284 vehicles being traded by the three brothers over 20 months, it is by far the most extensive illegal motor vehicle dealing investigation in the history of Consumer Protection,” Mr Hillyard said."The three Yas brothers flouted the licensing laws to make a profit that robbed legitimate licensed dealers of valuable business and buyers of the vehicles were denied their consumer rights.“Our investigation into the operation continues and further action may be pending.“Closing down this major unlicensed dealing operation means that the integrity of the motor vehicle industry is upheld and the warranty rights of consumers are protected.26.The nature of the applicant’s offending also raises further questions which may be relevant to the assessment of his character, but which are not yet addressed in the evidence. These include:26.1.Did the applicant comply with his taxation obligations in the running of his business?26.2.Has the applicant demonstrated a disregard for public safety by failing to comply with relevant legislation regarding buying and selling used cars, including rules relating to road worthiness of vehicles, vehicle repairs and disclosure of known issues?27.The applicant provided a statement by his lawyer to the Department regarding his offending. The same lawyer appeared for the applicant before the Magistrates Court in relation to his offence. The paragraphs in the statement explaining the offending read (T11, p144-145):10.The Applicant and his brother began buying and selling cars as a business. However, they did not at the time understand that we needed a specific licence in order to do so.11.Indeed, when the Applicant went to the licensing centre in order to transfer ownership, the licensing centre did not provide information regarding a valid dealer’s licence.12.The Applicant has only completed a Certificate II in English language studies. Unfortunately, due to his imperfect grasp of English, he did not realise the sophisticated rules meant to protect Australian consumers and the community associated with buying and selling used vehicles.13.Soon after the Applicant received the infringement notice informing us of the offence. The Applicant immediately stopped all activities related to the business.14.On 25 May 2018, the Applicant pleaded guilty at the first instance to the charges and was fined $12,500. The Applicant trusts the Australian justice systems and was prepared to plead guilty to the crime, as he is fully aware that he was in the wrong.28.The Minister submits that the statement by the applicant’s lawyer should be given little weight, because it is not direct evidence from the applicant, and does not contain any expressions of remorse or explanation of the offending in the applicant’s own words.29.In his statement provided to the Tribunal dated 29 October 2018, the applicant has said nothing about his offence or any remorse that he now feels. It is concerning that the applicant has not, either personally or via his lawyer, disclosed the extent of the offending, including the number of vehicles involved and the duration of the offending. This suggests that the applicant may not be fully facing up to his past conduct.30.The Minister also notes that it is less than 1 year since the applicant’s conviction. In the circumstances of the present case, the Minister submits that the applicant’s offending raises significant concerns about his character, and insufficient time has passed since the offending for the Tribunal to now be satisfied that the applicant is of good character.Evidence provided by applicant to demonstrate good character31.The applicant has provided information about his good character in order to try and satisfy the good character requirement.32.As noted above, in his statement to the Tribunal dated 29 October 2018, the applicant does not acknowledge his offending at all, nor does he express any remorse for his offending. Rather, the applicant states that he has ‘always obeyed the Australian law’ which, in the light of his conviction, is clearly not true. The applicant also says in his letter that:32.1.he has been helpful in the community32.2.he is a very calm and kind person who has never had a problem with anyone and is willing to help people32.3.he is a carer for his father and is willing to volunteer in this field to help the community32.4.he has a good relationship with his neighbours and all people around him32.5.he promises to be a good Australian citizen and will do his best to support Australia and its people.33.The applicant has also provided character statements from family, friends and community members. These include:33.1.A letter from Yashar Khaleel Sameen dated 20 July 2018 (T11, p152) – This letter states that the author is the applicant’s cousin. He acknowledges the offence and says that it was out of character. He says that the applicant informed him that he did not know the law regarding buying and selling cars, and once he was notified that what he had done was illegal, he immediately stopped buying and selling cars and pleaded guilty to the charge at the first instance. Mr Sameen further says that the applicant has always been a good friend, husband and father and has always acted with honesty and integrity to everyone in the community and is of good repute.33.2.A letter from Kamalaldeen Yashar Khaleel dated 18 July 2018 (T11, p153) – The applicant is said to be the uncle of the author of this letter. The letter states that the applicant has always been helpful over the years, acknowledges the offence and says it is out of character and that the applicant did not intend to break any laws.33.3.A letter from Jabbar Alhussainy dated 18 July 2018 (T11, p154-155) – The author is a friend of the applicant. The author acknowledges the offence and states that it is not in keeping with the applicant’s general good character. The author indicates that the applicant has always acted with respect towards everyone he meets, and is deeply committed to his family and life in Australia, and has always worked hard to be a good role model to his son. The author was surprised at the offence, given the ethics the applicant showed at work, and the offence weighs greatly on the applicant and he is remorseful.33.4.A letter from Adnan Aljibari of the Fadeck Cultural Centre Inc dated 14 October 2018 – The author states that the applicant has been known to the association since 2013 as a person of good character and has regularly volunteered to conduct humanitarian and charity works. The author says that, to the best of his knowledge, the applicant is a well-behaved, trustworthy man who would appreciate moral values. The offence is not acknowledged in the letter.33.5.A letter from Dr Nisreen Al Salihee dated 25 October 2018. Dr Al Salihee states that the applicant has been his patient for 4 years and has ‘good personality, friendly and character’. The offence is not acknowledged in the letter.33.6.A letter from Sam Alla (undated) – The author has known the applicant for 6 years. The applicant has been an active member in the community and has offered endless services to the needy. The applicant is a peaceful man with high regard to all individuals.33.7.A letter from Menshad Alsudani (undated) – The author states that he has known the applicant since 2014 and describes the applicant as a reverential man with an outgoing and optimistic attitude towards everyone. The applicant is said to have a strong relationship with most of the Middle Eastern communities, is benevolent and trustworthy, and used to attend religious events and offer support. The author also said that the applicant is continuously helping and supporting all multicultural communities to settle and adjust themselves to Australian society. The applicant was said to have a helpful, kind and friendly nature and a positive attitude toward everyone.33.8.A document signed by 6 people which says:I the undersigned below do hereby acknowledge that Mr Ali Mohammed Yas is a very kind, hardworking man and of good character, he is a very cooperative member of the community. He is very keen to help others and looking to produce his best to everyone34.The Citizenship Policy provides the following guidance for considering character references:Referee reports can shed light upon an applicant’s character and should acknowledge, where applicable, any offence or other incident and explain why the applicant is nonetheless considered to be of good character. Decision makers should give very little weight to references which do not acknowledge the offence or incident. However, decision makers should note the inherent bias in any reference which is submitted by an applicant in support of their citizenship application.More weight should be given to references made as statutory declarations than those which are not. References should come from members of the community who have observed the applicant at work or in other contexts, and who are willing to provide contact details. Referees should also explain how long they have known the applicant for, and the context of their relationship…It is preferable that references are not submitted from family members. However, if they are, less weight should be given to them because of the societal expectation that family members would tend to support one another and play down unacceptable conduct.35.Each of the character references clearly speaks to good moral qualities of the applicant. However, taking into account the character references and the policy considerations, the Minister submits that the character references provided by the applicant, and the applicant’s personal letter, do not outweigh the concerns that arise as a result of the applicant’s offending. In relation to the character references, the Minister notes that:35.1.None of the character references are in the form of a statutory declaration.35.2.Those that acknowledge the applicant’s offending are from family members or friends. While it may, in many circumstances, be appropriate to give character references greater weight where the applicant’s offending is acknowledged, care should be taken when assessing character references from family members.35.3.Most of the character statements contain general statements of good character and moral qualities, without providing specific examples of when and how the applicant has demonstrated those qualities, or what the qualities referred to mean to each author.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In determining whether the Applicant was of good character at the time that the Minister made his decision, the Tribunal must take into account a number of considerations. These are outlined below. Was the Applicant of good character at the time of the Minister making the decision? The Tribunal notes the Magistrate’s sentencing comments from 25 May 2018 (R4):HIS HONOUR: Mr Yas, please stand up. I explained to your brother, we have a system of laws here to protect consumers and the relevant legislation is the Motor Vehicle Dealer’s Act. Those dealers pay a fee to be registered motor vehicle dealers. They have overheads. They can be – consumers can go to the courts and get a result if there’s a bad motor vehicle dealer. You operated completely outside all of that. You took part in 83 separate transactions.That is a cost to the motor vehicle dealing industry, because they aren’t buying and selling those cars; you are. Being motor vehicle dealers, they’re entitled to the protection of the law from people, with respect, like yourself that just go and do it in your backyard. You will be fined the same amount as your brother, $12,500, and if there was going to be a spent conviction application, it’s refused for the same reasons.…HIS HONOUR: Mr Ali, I was busy talking to you about the seriousness of the offences … The Tribunal finds the offence to be a serious offence reflective of the Magistrate’s comments. The Tribunal accepts that the Applicant pleaded guilty. The Sentencing Transcript discloses that the Applicant did not hold a motor vehicle dealers licence and over a period of 19 months from 4 March 2016 to 2 October 2017 engaged in the illegal activity of buying and selling 106 vehicles; 83 in his own name and 23 in the name of his wife. The Tribunal notes that the only written submission from the Applicant aside from his solicitor’s response to the Minister’s delegate state (A1):My name is Ali Mohammed Vas, DOB [Date] 1983 of [Address] WA 6xxx. I have applied for Australian citizenship, application number as above. I have always been of a good character. I have always obeyed the Australian law and have been very helpful to my community. I am very [sic] calm and kind person that I have never had any problem with any one and willing to help others.I am a carers [sic] for my father I am willing to volunteer in this field to help the Australian community.I have very good relationship with my neighbours and all people around me.I promise I will be of a good Australian citizen [sic] and will be doing the best to support Australia and its people. I will always be following the Australian's [sic] law I will teach my children to be a good member of the community.I know all my privileges and responsibilities of being an Australian citizen. Please consider my application for citizenship and I promise I will be very good [sic] Australian citizen. The Tribunal is mindful that to attain citizenship, one must satisfy the character test as a citizenship document is an important part of the process of being accepted into the Australian community. The Tribunal notes that Australian citizenship brings both tangible and intangible benefits.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent submitted that the Applicant had failed the character test pursuant to s 21(2)(h) of the Citizenship Act for the following reasons:·The Respondent accepts that the Applicant has only one criminal conviction.·The offence and conviction in 2018 was very recent.·It is accepted that the offence was not violent.·There is a significant impact on consumer rights, in the context of the sale of cheap cars and particularly their safety. It is noted that few repairs were undertaken by the Applicant.·Vehicles in need of repair were quickly sold on to innocent consumers.·The Applicant is inconsistent about the level of profit he was making.·No records were kept by the Applicant.·The offence was serious and was the product of reckless and indifferent conduct.CONSIDERATION In determining whether the Applicant was of good character at the time that the Minister made his decision, the Tribunal must take into account a number of considerations. These are outlined below. Was the Applicant of good character at the time of the Minister making the decision? The Tribunal notes the Magistrate’s sentencing comments from 25 May 2018 (R4):HIS HONOUR: Mr Yas, please stand up. I explained to your brother, we have a system of laws here to protect consumers and the relevant legislation is the Motor Vehicle Dealer’s Act. Those dealers pay a fee to be registered motor vehicle dealers. They have overheads. They can be – consumers can go to the courts and get a result if there’s a bad motor vehicle dealer. You operated completely outside all of that. You took part in 83 separate transactions.That is a cost to the motor vehicle dealing industry, because they aren’t buying and selling those cars; you are. Being motor vehicle dealers, they’re entitled to the protection of the law from people, with respect, like yourself that just go and do it in your backyard. You will be fined the same amount as your brother, $12,500, and if there was going to be a spent conviction application, it’s refused for the same reasons.…HIS HONOUR: Mr Ali, I was busy talking to you about the seriousness of the offences … The Tribunal finds the offence to be a serious offence reflective of the Magistrate’s comments. The Tribunal accepts that the Applicant pleaded guilty. The Sentencing Transcript discloses that the Applicant did not hold a motor vehicle dealers licence and over a period of 19 months from 4 March 2016 to 2 October 2017 engaged in the illegal activity of buying and selling 106 vehicles; 83 in his own name and 23 in the name of his wife. The Tribunal notes that the only written submission from the Applicant aside from his solicitor’s response to the Minister’s delegate state (A1):My name is Ali Mohammed Vas, DOB [Date] 1983 of [Address] WA 6xxx. I have applied for Australian citizenship, application number as above. I have always been of a good character. I have always obeyed the Australian law and have been very helpful to my community. I am very [sic] calm and kind person that I have never had any problem with any one and willing to help others.I am a carers [sic] for my father I am willing to volunteer in this field to help the Australian community.I have very good relationship with my neighbours and all people around me.I promise I will be of a good Australian citizen [sic] and will be doing the best to support Australia and its people. I will always be following the Australian's [sic] law I will teach my children to be a good member of the community.I know all my privileges and responsibilities of being an Australian citizen. Please consider my application for citizenship and I promise I will be very good [sic] Australian citizen.