XJGB and Australian Information Commissioner (Freedom of Information)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

XJGB and Australian Information Commissioner (Freedom of Information) [2024] AATA 763 (17 April 2024)

Division:FREEDOM OF INFORMATION DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/0097

Re:XJGB

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Information Commissioner

RESPONDENT

AndResolve Software Group Pty Ltd

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Britten-Jones

Date:17 April 2024  

Place:Melbourne

The decision under review is affirmed

............................[sgd]............................................

Deputy President Britten-Jones

Catchwords

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION - review of decision to refuse access to a document - document exempt under sections 45 and 47(1)(b) of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 - decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth)

Cases

Asylum Seeker Resource Centre and Department of Home Affairs [2020] AICmr 7

Secondary Material
Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, Guidelines issued by the Australian Information Commissioner under s 93A of the Freedom of Information Act 1982, FOI Guidelines, version 1.4, December 2016

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Britten-Jones

17 April 2024

  1. The applicant is seeking access to a document under the Freedom of Information Act1982 (FOI Act). The respondent refuses access under ss 45, 47 and s 47G of the FOI Act. The other party, Resolve Software Group Pty Ltd (Resolve), is the author of the document and supports the respondent’s refusal to give access of the document to the applicant.

  2. The applicant’s request for access was made on 29 August 2021.  The respondent identified and refused access to one document within the scope of the request, namely a Resolve Enterprise Report Writer Guide v1.8 (12 October 2018) (the Report Writer Guide). On internal review, a delegate of the respondent refused access under s 45 and s 47(1)(b) of the FOI Act.

  3. Resolve is a software company that creates, markets and licences or sells software products to customers.

  4. Ms Wendy Barker is the General Counsel for the parent company of Resolve.  She provided a witness statement and oral evidence to the Tribunal.  She said in her statement that the Report Writer Guide is a confidential document drafted by Resolve that contains secret and highly sensitive information including intellectual property.  The document is marked on each page with “Commercial in Confidence”.  Ms Barker says that the Report Writer Guide:

    includes intricate details of Resolve’s software including its technical capabilities, functions and features as well as associated graphical depictions (such as the associated user interfaces) and thorough explanations on how the software works and its specific outputs.

  5. I have had access to the Report Writer Guide and I agree with Ms Barker’s description of it.

  6. A customer who purchases a Resolve software package will enter into a comprehensive contractual agreement (Customer Agreement) which includes obligations of confidence.  As part of the package a customer will be given access to the Report Writer Guide via a log in to a secure portal.

    Freedom of Information Act 1982

  7. The High Court considered the legislative framework of the FOI Act in Kline v Official Secretary to the Governor-General:[1]

    …The statutory scheme is complex in achieving…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read XJGB and Australian Information Commissioner (Freedom of Inf... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 763
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the Australian Information Commissioner to refuse access to a document, the "Report Writer Guide". The applicant, XJGB, sought access to this document, but the Commissioner affirmed the original decision to refuse access, asserting that the document was exempt under sections 45 and 47(1)(b) of the *Freedom of Information Act 1982* (Cth).

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Report Writer Guide was an exempt document under section 45 of the *Freedom of Information Act 1982* (Cth) on the grounds that its disclosure would found an action for breach of confidence, and whether it was exempt under section 47(1)(b) of the Act as information having a commercial value that would be, or could reasonably be expected to be, destroyed or diminished if disclosed.

The court reasoned that disclosure of the Report Writer Guide would likely cause financial detriment to Resolve, a company whose products were detailed in the guide, by providing competitors with an unfair advantage. Consequently, the court concluded that the Report Writer Guide was an exempt document under section 45 as its disclosure would found an action for breach of confidence. Regarding section 47(1)(b), the court considered the criteria that the document must contain information with commercial value and that this value would be destroyed or diminished upon disclosure. The court noted that commercial value can relate to the profitability or viability of a business and that factors such as conferring a competitive advantage or a willingness of a buyer to pay for the information are relevant. The court found that the unauthorised disclosure of the Report Writer Guide would likely cause financial detriment to Resolve, suggesting that its commercial value would be diminished.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Barker considers that disclosure would risk financial and commercial detriment to Resolve if a competitor gained access to confidential information about its products which would lead to a reduced ability for Resolve to successfully win work. I accept that the unauthorised disclosure of the Report Writer Guide would likely cause financial detriment to Resolve as it would provide competitors with detailed information about the capability of the Resolve system such that competitors would then have an unfair advantage in competing for business.Conclusion on s 45 I conclude that the Report Writer Guide is an exempt document under s 45 because its disclosure would found an action for breach of confidence.Section 47 – trade secrets and commercial valueRelevant principles Section 47 of the FOI Act relevantly provides:Documents disclosing trade secrets or commercially valuable information(1) A document is an exempt document if its disclosure under this Act would disclose:(a) trade secrets; or(b) any other information having a commercial value that would be, or could reasonably be expected to be, destroyed or diminished if the information were disclosed. With respect to information having a commercial value, the Guidelines say:Information having a commercial value5.204 To be exempt under s 47(1)(b) a document must satisfy two criteria:·the document must contain information that has a commercial value either to an agency or to another person or body, and·the commercial value of the information would be, or could reasonably be expected to be, destroyed or diminished if it were disclosed.5.205 It is a question of fact whether information has commercial value, and whether disclosure would destroy or diminish that value. The commercial value may relate, for example, to the profitability or viability of a continuing business operation or commercial activity in which an agency or person is involved. The information need not necessarily have ‘exchange value’, in the sense that it can be sold as a trade secret or intellectual property. The following factors may assist in deciding in a particular case whether information has commercial value:·whether the information is known only to the agency or person for whom it has value or, if it is known to others, to what extent that detracts from its intrinsic commercial value·whether the information confers a competitive advantage on the agency or person to whom it relates — for example, if it lowers the cost of production or allows access to markets not available to competitors·whether a genuine ‘arm’s-length’ buyer would be prepared to pay to obtain that information·whether the information is still current or out of date (out of date information may no longer have any value) ·whether disclosing the information would reduce the value of a business operation or commercial activity — reflected, perhaps, in a lower share price.5.206 The time and money invested in generating information will not necessarily mean that it has commercial value. Information that is costly to produce will not necessarily have intrinsic commercial value.5.207 The second requirement of s 47(1)(b) — that it could reasonably be expected that disclosure of the information would destroy or diminish its value — must be established separately by satisfactory evidence. It should not be assumed that confidential commercial information will necessarily lose some of its value if it becomes more widely known. Nor is it sufficient to establish that an agency or person would be adversely affected by disclosure; for example, by encountering criticism or embarrassment. It must be established that the disclosure would destroy or diminish the commercial value of the information.Is there commercially valuable information in the Report Writer Guide?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established