XHRC and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

XHRC and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2019] AATA 5396 (13 December 2019)

Division:                  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:2018/7204          

Re:XHRC  

APPLICANT

Child Support RegistrarAnd  

RESPONDENT

DZJRAnd  

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D Mitchell      

Date:13 December 2019

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and in substitution, the Tribunal decides that the percentages of care for the Children are 34 percent for the Applicant and 66 percent for the Other Party with effect from 5 April 2018.

.................................................................

Member D Mitchell

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – pattern of care of children during the relevant period – decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)

CASES

Confidential and Social Security Appeals Tribunal and Anor [2010] AATA 1

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 46 FLR 409

Parent A and Child Support Registrar [2013] AATA 562

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No. 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member D Mitchell

13 December 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, XHRC (the Father), and the Other Party, DZJR (the Mother), are the separated parents of two daughters born in 2004 and 2007 (the Children).

  2. From 25 November 2017, the child support assessment reflected the Father as having 39 percent care, and the Mother 61 percent care of the Children.[1]

    [1] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, page 22, Details of Objection Decision.

  3. On 10 April 2018, the Mother advised the Respondent of a change of care stating that from 6 April 2018, the Father had 30 percent care and she had 70 percent care of the Children.[2]

    [2] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T57, page 255-256, Child Support file notes for the period 30 September 2017 to 24 October 2018.

  4. On 23 June 2018, the Respondent decided not to revoke the existing care determination and as such there was no basis for a new determination of the parties’ percentages of care of the Children to be made.[3] The original determination remained in place.

    [3] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T8, pages 37-40, Child support file notes for the period 2 February 2018 – 3 October 2018, T23, pages 149-150, Child Support Letter: change in care arrangements, T46, pages 227-228, Child Support Letter: change in care arrangements.

  5. The Mother objected to this decision on 25 June 2018.[4]

    [4] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T57, pages 261-262, Child Support file notes for the period 30 September 2017 to 24 October 2018.

  6. On 25 August 2018, the Respondent allowed the objection in part and decided to:[5]

    a.revoke the existing determination of the percentages of care; and

    b.make a determination under section 50 of the Assessment Act, that the Father…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read XHRC and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 5396
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support care percentage determination, brought before the Tribunal by the Father against the Child Support Registrar. The dispute centred on the pattern of care of the Children during a specific period between 6 April 2018 and 28 August 2018, following a notified change in care arrangements. The parties presented conflicting accounts of the actual care provided by each parent during this "Relevant Care Period."

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the existing care percentage determination in place at 10 April 2018 should be revoked under section 54F(1) of the Assessment Act. If revocation was warranted, the Tribunal also needed to determine the correct percentage of care to be attributed to the Father and the Mother under section 50 of the Assessment Act, and specify the date of effect for any new determination. The core of the dispute involved assessing the actual care provided by each parent, which had deviated from the consent orders made in 2009 due to the Father's work commitments.

The Tribunal considered the evidence, including written submissions and care calendars provided by both parents. It found that the Father's work arrangements during the Relevant Care Period meant he was unable to adhere to the usual pattern of care or the existing court orders. Applying section 54F of the Assessment Act, the Tribunal was satisfied that a change in care had occurred. After analysing the care calendars, and noting a minor discrepancy which was resolved in favour of the Father's calendar, the Tribunal concluded that the Father had 34 percent care and the Mother had 66 percent care of the Children during the period in question.

Consequently, the Tribunal revoked the care percentage determination in place on 10 April 2018. In substitution, it determined that for the period between 6 April 2018 and 28 August 2018, the Father had 34 percent care and the Mother had 66 percent care of the Children. The date of effect for this new determination was established as 5 April 2018, as the change of care had been notified to the Respondent within the prescribed 28-day period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issues for the Tribunal to consider are:(a)Whether the care percentage determination in place at 10 April 2018 should be revoked under section 54F(1) of the Assessment Act; and(b)If the existing care percentage determination should be revoked, what percentage of care should be attributed to the Father and the Mother under section 50 of the Assessment Act; and(c)The date of effect of the new determination.EVIDENCE All of the evidence before the Tribunal has been taken into account including the submissions made by the Father and the Mother. It is clear that the Mother and Father, as is not uncommon in these kinds of matters, have a fractured relationship. It was agreed that this application relates to a closed period (the Relevant Care Period) being between 6 April 2018 (the date of notified change of care)[11] and 28 August 2018 when a new care determination was made that the Father provides 39 percent care and the Mother 61 percent care of the Children.[12][11] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T57, pages 255-256, Child Support file notes for the period 30 September 2017 to 24 October 2018.[12] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T14, pages 85-87, Child Support Assessments for the period 6 April 2018 to 30 November 2018. The Father provided a number of different written submissions throughout the review process, all of which consistently outlined that his working arrangements led to the change in arrangements for the Children during the period and accepted that he missed days of care.[13] [13] Exhibit 5, Applicant’s submission dated 30 September 2019 with annexures and Exhibit 7, Applicant’s submissions with calendar received by the Tribunal on 24 February 2019. The Father at Hearing told the Tribunal that:·He did not agree with the 30/70 split in care.·He had the Children for extra nights in March and that in April he missed 4 nights and that he missed 2 nights in May.·On 12 March 2018, he started a new job and initially had to work a “five-on/two-off” roster.·He contends that there was not a change of pattern of care.· During the April school holidays, he was working a five day on two days off roster and he organised a week off however it was not his week and the Mother would not allow him to swap days.·From 14 May, his roster went back to normal – seven days on seven days off.·From June, he changed the days he had the Children from Friday to Tuesday to Thursday to Monday.·He missed two days in the June school holidays. The Mother provided a written submission on 21 February 2019 providing a 2018 calendar of care for the Children and provided:[14]7 April 2018 to 24 August 2018 – the percentage of care was 68% care for me which equates to 94 nights out of 139 and 32% for the father which equates to 45 nights out of 139.[14] Exhibit 8, Other Party’s submission with calendar dated 21 February 2019. The Mother at Hearing told the Tribunal that:·The Father had not met the court orders during the period. The Father did not have care of the Children in the April school holidays or as expected in the July school holidays.·She feels like she is expected to subsidise the Father going to work.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Based on the evidence from the Mother and analysis of the care calendars, the Tribunal finds that the date of the change of care necessitating the revocation of the existing determination was 6 April 2018. Pursuant to section 54F(2)(a)(ii) of the Assessment Act, as the change of care was notified to the Respondent within 28 days of the change, the date of effect of the change in care is 5 April 2018, being the day before the day the change commenced.DECISION The Tribunal finds that in accordance with section 54F of the Assessment Act the care percentage determination in place on 10 April 2018 should be revoked. Pursuant to section 50 of the Assessment Act, for the period between 6 April 2018 and 28 August 2018 the Father had 34 percent care and the Mother had 66 percent care of the Children. Accordingly, the decision under review is set aside and in substitution it is decided that the percentages of care for the Children are 34 percent for the Father and 66 percent for the Mother with the date of effect being 5 April 2018.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The consent orders relating to the care of the Children were made in 2009 and provide the Children are with the Father:[17]·From 4 pm on Friday to 4 pm on Wednesday.·Mother’s Day and Father’s Day weekends will be swapped between the Father and the Mother as required.·Time for the Children’s, Father’s and Mother’s birthdays which does not affect the night care arrangements.·Half of the school holidays.·Alternate Christmas eve or Christmas day.·Half of the 4 days of Easter (which alternate).[17] Supplementary T Documents, ST2, pages 285-290, Consent order. CONSIDERATION The question before the Tribunal is what were the care arrangements for the Children during the Relevant Care Period. It is plain on the evidence that the Father was unable to provide his usual pattern of care of the Children during the Relevant Care Period due to work commitments. During the Relevant Period the Father’s care of the Children did not adhere to the court orders or usual care pattern. The Tribunal is required pursuant to section 54F of the Assessment Act to consider the actual care of the Children during the Relevant Care Period and, if satisfied of a relevant change, revoke the care determination. In the present circumstances as the Relevant Care Period has long passed and is closed by the nature of a later care determination the Tribunal is limited to considering the actual care provided. There is a one day discrepancy between the care calendars and on this occasion the Tribunal accepts the calendar provided by the Father. Based on the care calendars provided by the Father and Mother, the Tribunal is satisfied that a change in care occurred with the relevant care for the Relevant Care Period being 34 percent for the Father and 66 percent for the Mother. Based on the evidence from the Mother and analysis of the care calendars, the Tribunal finds that the date of the change of care necessitating the revocation of the existing determination was 6 April 2018. Pursuant to section 54F(2)(a)(ii) of the Assessment Act, as the change of care was notified to the Respondent within 28 days of the change, the date of effect of the change in care is 5 April 2018, being the day before the day the change commenced.DECISION The Tribunal finds that in accordance with section 54F of the Assessment Act the care percentage determination in place on 10 April 2018 should be revoked. Pursuant to section 50 of the Assessment Act, for the period between 6 April 2018 and 28 August 2018 the Father had 34 percent care and the Mother had 66 percent care of the Children. Accordingly, the decision under review is set aside and in substitution it is decided that the percentages of care for the Children are 34 percent for the Father and 66 percent for the Mother with the date of effect being 5 April 2018.