WYBM and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

WYBM and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2023] AATA 1263 (17 May 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):     2022/8807          

Re:WYBM

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndGSLR

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member W Frost

Date:17 May 2023

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

..................[SGD]..........................................

Member W Frost

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – Administrative Appeals Tribunal Tier 1 review – where the Mother applied for review outside the 28 day period – ‘special circumstances’ – whether there were circumstances that prevented lodgement – do full-time work and care duties constitute ‘special circumstances’ – Tribunal not satisfied – decision under review affirmed 

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 37, 43

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 ss 16, 95N, 96A

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989, cited.

Cases

P v Child Support Registrar [2012] FCA 1398

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Secondary Materials

Guides to Social Policy: Child Support Guide

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)-16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member W Frost

17 May 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, ‘WYBM’ (the Mother), and the Other Party, ‘GSLR’ (the Father), are the separated parents of two children (the Children). In October 2022, the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT1) set aside a decision of a delegate of the Respondent, the Child Support Registrar (Registrar), and in substitution decided that the Mother had 100% care of the Children and the Father had 0% care of the Children from 22 December 2021.[1] The determination of the percentage of care is one of the requisite steps in assessing the rate of any child support payable by one parent to the other under the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989.

    [1] Exhibit 1, pages 6-11.

  2. The AAT1 also refused the make a determination that ‘special circumstances’ prevented the Mother from applying to the AAT1 within the required 28-day period. The date of effect, therefore, of the AAT1 decision was the date the Mother applied to the AAT1, being 25 August 2022, rather than the date determined by the AAT1 to be when the percentage of care for the Children changed, being 22 December 2021. The Mother applied to the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) for review of this second element of the AAT1 decision, regarding special circumstances for her late application to the AAT1. The issue of the percentage of care provided to the Children by the Mother and the Father was not in dispute before the Tribunal.

    ISSUE

  3. The issue for the Tribunal to determine in this proceeding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read WYBM and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 1263
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review by the Tribunal concerning child support. The parties were WYBM (the Mother) and the Child Support Registrar. The dispute centred on whether the Mother had established "special circumstances" that prevented her from lodging an application for review with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT1) within the prescribed 28-day period following a decision made on 9 June 2022. The AAT1 had previously affirmed a decision that no such special circumstances existed, meaning the effective date of a revised care percentage determination was the date the Mother lodged her late application, rather than an earlier date when the change in care was found to have occurred.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Mother's circumstances constituted "special circumstances" as contemplated by subsection 95N(2) of the Collection Act, which would permit an extension of time for her application to the AAT1. Specifically, the Tribunal had to determine if the Mother's full-time employment, operation of a small business, and her responsibilities in caring for her two children and her mother, who suffered from chronic pain, brain aneurysms, and diabetes, were sufficient to prevent her from lodging her appeal within the required 28-day timeframe.

The Tribunal considered the Mother's evidence detailing her extensive care duties for her mother, which involved daily assistance with personal hygiene, meals, and medical appointments, particularly during June, July, and August 2022. She also highlighted her full-time employment and efforts to generate additional income through a small business, alongside her responsibilities as a parent to two teenage children. The Tribunal noted that the definition of "special circumstances" typically requires the applicant to demonstrate that their particular situation prevented them from lodging within the timeframe, with examples including serious illness, accidents, or personal trauma, none of which were directly present. The Tribunal also considered evidence from the Father, who pointed to the Mother's mother's statement indicating she regularly assisted with childcare during the relevant period, and that payroll and care calendars submitted by the Mother were not from the period in question.

Ultimately, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the Mother's circumstances met the threshold for "special circumstances" that prevented her from lodging her application within the required 28-day period. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the AAT1's decision, meaning the effective date of the revised care percentage determination remained 25 August 2022, the date the Mother lodged her application with the AAT1.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around the Mother's application for a review of a child support decision made by the Child Support Registrar, which was lodged outside the stipulated 28-day period. The Mother, who is responsible for the care of her two children, sought to establish 'special circumstances' that would excuse her failure to lodge the application within the specified timeframe. The Mother claimed that she was preoccupied with her full-time employment, her own small business, and the care of her ailing mother, who suffers from chronic pain injury, brain aneurysms, and diabetes, all of which contributed to her missing the deadline for the appeal. In June, July, and August 2022, the Mother was heavily involved in assisting her mother, which, combined with her work and business commitments, left her too busy to lodge the application on time.

The Mother's mother provided statements to the Tribunal, corroborating the Mother's claims that she was frequently unwell and required daily assistance with personal care, medical appointments, and household tasks. The Mother's mother also noted that she regularly helped with the care of the children, but during periods of her own illness, the Mother took on additional responsibilities. Despite submitting some documentation to the Agency during the relevant period, the Mother argued that her circumstances were such that she could not lodge the application to the AAT1 within 28 days of receiving the Registrar's decision on 9 June 2022. The Mother lodged her application for review with the AAT1 on 25 August 2022, well beyond the 28-day period, and subsequently applied to the Tribunal for a review of the AAT1's decision that there were no special circumstances preventing timely lodgement.

This matter came before the Tribunal for review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT1). The Mother, who had earlier objected to a decision by a delegate of the Registrar regarding care percentages for her children, sought to appeal the Registrar's decision to the AAT1. However, she did not lodge the application for review within the statutory 28-day period. Consequently, the AAT1 reviewed the objection decision but determined that the date of effect of its decision was the day the Mother lodged her application for review to the AAT1, rather than the date the original decision was made. The Mother subsequently applied to the Tribunal for review of the AAT1 decision that there were no special circumstances which prevented her from lodging the application for review to the AAT1 within the required 28 days. The Tribunal's task was to determine whether there were special circumstances under subsection 95N(2) of the Collection Act that would permit the Tribunal to extend the period within which the Mother could lodge the application to the AAT1.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For completeness, the Tribunal notes that, pursuant to subsection 96A(c) of the Collection Act, an application may be made to the General Division of the Tribunal for review of a decision under subsection 95N(2) to make, or not to make, a determination. The Tribunal therefore has jurisdiction in relation to the Mother’s application for review of the AAT1 decision that there were no special circumstances that prevented her from applying to the AAT1 within the required 28 day period from 9 June 2022. EVIDENCEThe Mother The Mother provided a written statement in this proceeding dated 1 February 2023.[25] She noted that her mother suffers from ‘chronic pain injury’, ‘brain aneurysms’ and ‘diabetes’ and relevantly stated that:[26]At times these conditions cause her to become debilitated and require assistance in caring for herself properly. During these times, I need to assist her up to twice daily with things such as attending doctors [sic] appointments, food shopping, making meals, cleaning and personal hygiene.In June, July and August, I assisted my Mother on an almost daily basis.During June, July and August, I was employed full-time, had 75% of my children…and was also working on my own small business in an attempt to generate extra income.…The extra time and pressure of caring for my Mother on top of my full-time work, caring for children and small business caused me to miss the deadline for lodging an appeal. [25] Exhibit 2. [26] Ibid. The Mother told the Tribunal at the hearing that she relied on the material provided by her in this proceeding and that the reason for her late lodgement of the application to the AAT1 was due to being ‘extremely busy’, ‘focused on a full-time job’, ‘running a small business’, and ‘caring for two teenage children’ and her ‘sick mother’. The Mother contended that, even though she was able to submit some documentation to the Agency during the relevant period, on 19 July 2022, this ‘does not mean’ she ‘wasn’t unable’ to lodge an application to the AAT1.[27] She maintained that, despite there only being an income statement from mid-2020, her full-time employment with the same employer continued from that time and through the relevant period between June and August 2022. [27] Exhibit 1, pages 113-121. On 19 July 2022, the Mother’s mother made a written statement which relevantly noted that:[28]I regularly help [the Mother] with care of the children by taking them to and from school, training, sporting events and their casual café jobs when [the Mother] is not able to take them.I see the children at least 3-5 times per week.[28] Ibid., page 113. On 4 November 2022, for the purpose of this proceeding, the Mother’s mother made a Statutory Declaration.[29] This document relevantly stated that:[30]When I am feeling well, I am able to assist [the Mother] with caring for the children, including driving them to sport training, games, school and making them dinner while she is working.There are times when my disabilities flair up and prevent me from assisting [the Mother].During the times of my flair ups, [the Mother] assists me on a daily basis with my needs including shopping, cooking, cleaning, showering and dressing.During June, July and August 2022, I had a flair up of my chronic pain injury.On most days during those months [the Mother] visited me at my home to assist with the above tasks or took me to doctors [sic] appointments.[29] Exhibit 3. [30] Ibid.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 9 June 2022, another delegate of the Registrar disallowed the Mother’s objection and the existing care percentage determination continued.[9] Relevantly for this proceeding, by letter dated 9 June 2022, the Agency notified the Mother of the Registrar’s decision, enclosed the reasons and informed her that any application for review of the decision to the AAT1 must be made within 28 days from the date she received the decision.[10] The letter from the Agency relevantly stated that:[11][9] Ibid., pages 41-52 and 104-108.[10] Ibid., pages 35 and 41. [11] Ibid., page 41. If you do not agree with this decisionIf you think this decision is wrong, you can ask the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to review it. You must do this within 28 days from the date you receive this letter. You can contact the AAT by going to their website aat.gov.au or calling them on 1800 228 333. [emphasis in original] On 24 August 2022, the Mother telephoned the Agency seeking to apply for review of the objection decision from 9 June 2022.[12] She was advised that any such application for review should be lodged with the AAT1.[13][12] Ibid., page 137. [13] Ibid. On 25 August 2022, the Mother applied to the AAT1 for review of the objection decision made on 9 June 2022.[14] In her application to the AAT1, the Mother stated that the date she received the decision from the Agency was 9 June 2022.[15] [14] Ibid., pages 34-40.[15] Ibid., page 35. On 21 October 2022, the AAT1 decided to set aside the objection decision made by a delegate of the Registrar and substituted it with a decision that, from 22 December 2021, the Mother had 100% care of the Children and the Father therefore had 0% care of the Children.[16] Relevantly for this proceeding, the AAT1 also decided that, because the Mother’s application to the AAT1 was not made within the required 28 day period and there were no special circumstances which prevented lodgement within that time, the date of effect of its decision was 25 August 2022.[17] That is, the date of effect of the change in the percentage of care for the Children commenced on the day the Mother lodged her application for review to the AAT1 and not from 22 December 2021 when the change in care was found to have occurred.[18] [16] Ibid., pages 6-11. [17] Ibid. [18] Ibid. On 25 October 2022, the Mother applied to the Tribunal for review of the AAT1 decision that there were no special circumstances that prevented lodgement of the application for review to the AAT1 within the required 28 days from receiving the objection decision on 9 June 2022.[19] [19] Ibid., pages 1-5. For completeness, the Tribunal notes that on 31 August 2022, the Agency determined new percentages of care for the Children to reflect changes it found occurred from 8 April 2022, with the Mother from that time recorded as providing 66% care to one of the Children and 50% to the second of the Children and the Father recorded as providing 34% and 50% care respectively in relation to the Children.[20] These care percentage determinations are not before the Tribunal in this proceeding.[20] Ibid., pages 145-148.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Father gave evidence at the Tribunal hearing and noted that the payroll statement from the Mother’s employer was from a period in 2020, not during the relevant period from June to August 2022. Additionally, the Father stated that the care calendar submitted by the Mother was from August 2022, which was after the required 28-day period for the lodgement of an appeal with the AAT1.[34] The Father also again referred to the statement made by the Mother’s mother on 19 July 2022, being during the relevant period, that she was regularly caring for the Children.[35][34] Exhibit 4. [35] Exhibit 3. CONSIDERATION There was no dispute that the Mother made her application to the AAT1 outside the required 28-day period from the date she received the decision made by a delegate of the Registrar on 9 June 2022. The Mother also did not dispute that she received that decision on 9 June 2022. For the avoidance of doubt, the Tribunal is satisfied that the Mother did not lodge her application to the AAT1 until after the end of the 28-day period from 9 June 2022 and that this was not done until 25 August 2022, being some 42 days after the end of the relevant period in which to do so. The task of the Tribunal in this proceeding is therefore to determine whether, pursuant to subsection 95N(2) of the Collection Act, there are ‘special circumstances’ that prevented the Mother from making her application to the AAT1 within the required 28-day period. As set out above in these reasons, subsection 95N(1) of the Collection Act relevantly provides that, if the AAT1 varies or substitutes a decision on an objection to a care percentage decision and the application to the AAT1 was made ‘more than 28 days’ after notice of the decision was given, the AAT1 decision ‘has or is taken to have had effect on and from the day the application for AAT first review was made’. Here, that is 25 August 2022.[36][36] Exhibit 1, pages 34-40. However, subsection 95N(2) of the Collection Act relevantly provides that if the Tribunal is ‘satisfied that there are special circumstances that prevented’ the application to the AAT1 being made within the 28-day period, the Tribunal ‘may’ determine that the reference to 28 days is a reference to such longer period as it determines to be appropriate. This would mean that the Mother’s application to the AAT1 would be taken to have been made in time and therefore the date of effect of the AAT1 decision regarding the percentages of care for the Children would be 22 December 2021, being the date the AAT1 determined there was a change, and not 25 August 2022, being the actual date of the Mother’s application to the AAT1. While the term ‘special circumstances’ is not defined in the Collection Act, the Guide states that the ‘applicant must show that their particular circumstances prevented them from lodging an objection within the required timeframe’.[37] The Guide also provides what are referred to as ‘examples’ of special circumstances, which include the relevant parent being seriously ill, having an accident or suffering a personal trauma such as a death in the family.[38] None of the examples set out in the Guide exist in this proceeding. The Mother’s contention was that the special circumstances that prevented her from lodging the AAT1 application in time were that she was employed on a full-time basis, she was also working on her own small business, provided caring assistance to her mother on an almost daily basis and also cared for the Children.[37] Ibid., page 29. [38] Ibid.