Wrightville Operations Pty Ltd (T/As Jarvis Ford) v Lisman

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

WRIGHTVILLE OPERATIONS PTY LTD (T/AS JARVIS FORD) v LISMAN

[2007] SASC 259

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Layton

12 July 2007

MAGISTRATES - APPEALS FROM AND CONTROL OVER MAGISTRATES - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - PRINCIPLES ON WHICH COURT ACTS - OTHER MATTERS

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE'S FINDINGS OF FACT - PROOF AND EVIDENCE - OTHER MATTERS

TORTS - NEGLIGENCE - ESSENTIALS OF ACTION FOR NEGLIGENCE - DAMAGE - CAUSATION - OTHER CASES

Appeal by third party (appellant) against a decision of a magistrate who found the defendant's (respondent) claim for loss and damage resulting from negligence and breach of contract proved against the appellant - the respondent purchased a motor vehicle from the appellant - following a car accident it was found that the appellant had installed an incorrect nut to the steering mechanism during repair work which was loose - whether the appellant's conduct was a causally relevant factor to the damage sustained in the car accident - whether the Magistrate failed to have sufficient regard to the body of evidence, in particular the expert evidence.

Held: the Magistrate erred in her approach to the evidence - in particular the expert evidence - decision substituted as evidence did not prove that the loose nut caused the accident - appeal allowed - Magistrate's judgment set aside and judgment entered for the appellant.

Magistrates Court Act 1991 s 40; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 Rule 292, referred to.
CSR Ltd v Della Maddalena (2006) 80 ALJR 458; Dearman v Dearman (1908) 7 CLR 549; Fox v Percy (2003) 241 CLR 118; Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531, applied.
Devries v Australian National Railways Commission (1993) 177 CLR 472, considered.

WRIGHTVILLE OPERATIONS PTY LTD (T/AS JARVIS FORD) v LISMAN
[2007] SASC 259

Magistrates Appeal:  Civil

LAYTON J:

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal against the decision of a magistrate pursuant to s 40 of the Magistrates Court Act 1991.  On 3 November 2006, following a two-day trial in July 2006, between the defendant and the third party, the Magistrate found the defendant’s claim for loss and damage resulting from negligence and breach of contract proved against the third party.  The third party now appeals against that decision.

    Background

  2. In May 2004, the defendant (“the respondent”) purchased a Holden Commodore from the third party Jarvis Ford (“the appellant”).  Following its purchase, the RAA carried out an inspection on the vehicle. Subsequently, the respondent returned the vehicle to the appellant, and repair work was undertaken.  This repair work included replacing the vehicle’s steering rack and conducting an associated front wheel alignment. 

  3. On 18 June 2004, the respondent was driving the vehicle along Cheltenham Parade, before turning right into Port Road, travelling west.  Shortly after turning onto Port Road, the respondent’s car collided with a building on the southern side of the road.  As a result of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wrightville Operations Pty Ltd (T/As Jarvis Ford) v Lisman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 259
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Wrightville Operations Pty Ltd (T/As Jarvis Ford) v Lisman concerned a claim for loss and damage resulting from negligence and breach of contract brought by the respondent against the appellant, a motor vehicle dealer. The respondent had purchased a motor vehicle from the appellant, which was subsequently involved in an accident. The respondent alleged that the appellant had installed an incorrect nut to the steering mechanism during repair work, which was loose, and that this was a causally relevant factor in the damage sustained in the car accident. The case was heard before a magistrate, who found in favour of the respondent and ordered the appellant to pay damages. The appellant appealed this decision to the Supreme Court.

The legal issues before the court were whether the appellant's conduct was a causally relevant factor to the damage sustained in the car accident, and whether the magistrate failed to have sufficient regard to the body of evidence, in particular the expert evidence. The court considered whether the magistrate had erred in her approach to the evidence, and whether the evidence proved that the loose nut caused the accident.

The court found that the magistrate had erred in her approach to the evidence, in particular the expert evidence. The court held that the evidence did not prove that the loose nut caused the accident, and that the magistrate had failed to appropriately address and analyse the expert evidence given by Messrs Aust, Hall and Richer. The court substituted its decision for that of the magistrate, and set aside the magistrate's judgment, entering judgment in favour of the appellant.

The court ordered that the time within which the appellant be entitled to appeal be extended to 7 December 2006, that the appeal be allowed, that the order of the magistrate entering judgment in favour of the respondent be set aside, and that the third party claim be dismissed and judgment be entered in favour of the appellant.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal against the decision of a magistrate pursuant to s 40 of the Magistrates Court Act 1991. On 3 November 2006, following a two-day trial in July 2006, between the defendant and the third party, the Magistrate found the defendant’s claim for loss and damage resulting from negligence and breach of contract proved against the third party. The third party now appeals against that decision. Background In May 2004, the defendant (“the respondent”) purchased a Holden Commodore from the third party Jarvis Ford (“the appellant”). Following its purchase, the RAA carried out an inspection on the vehicle. Subsequently, the respondent returned the vehicle to the appellant, and repair work was undertaken. This repair work included replacing the vehicle’s steering rack and conducting an associated front wheel alignment. On 18 June 2004, the respondent was driving the vehicle along Cheltenham Parade, before turning right into Port Road, travelling west. Shortly after turning onto Port Road, the respondent’s car collided with a building on the southern side of the road. As a result of the accident, damage was caused to both the building and to the respondent’s vehicle. The owner of the building brought a claim against the respondent for damage caused by the accident. Subsequently, the respondent brought a third party claim against the appellant seeking indemnity “for all loss determined arising from the negligence and/or breach of contract by the Third Party in failing to properly repair the motor vehicle”. It was common ground that the nut at the end of the bolt forming part of the connection between the vehicle’s steering column and steering rack, was of the wrong type and was not tight on the bolt following the accident. The manufacturer’s specifications state that the nut used to secure the bolt should be a self-locking nut, which this nut was not. The nut was fitted at the time of the repairs carried out by the appellant. The issue at trial was whether this loose nut caused the accident.The steering mechanism The steering mechanism consists of a U-shaped rod, which cups around the cylinder on the steering rack. This rod is called the coupling (referred to in submissions as the “female part”), and the cylinder is called the steering pinion (referred to in submissions as the “male part”). The steering pinion is planed flat on each side, so that when connected, the two sides of the coupling fit flat against the two planed sides of the steering pinion. A single bolt (the cam bolt) clamps the coupling and the steering pinion together. The cam bolt passes through both sides of the coupling, but does not pass through the steering pinion. A rigid connection is formed between the coupling and the steering pinion. The coupling in turn is connected by a universal joint to the steering column, which connects to the steering wheel. As the steering wheel is turned, the coupling turns the steering pinion which in turn moves the steering rack from side to side, which then causes the road wheels to turn. As indicated, it was the nut at the end of the cam bolt which was an incorrect nut, and was not tightly fitted, which was alleged to have caused the accident.Extension of time to appeal

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This appeal therefore requires careful consideration of both the Magistrate’s reasons, and the evidence given before her. Evidence at Trial At trial, evidence was given by the respondent, Angela Lisman, and by an RAA examiner, Mr Richer. The appellant called two mechanical engineers, Mr Aust and Mr Hall. The respondent gave evidence that as she approached the traffic lights at the intersection of Port Road and Cheltenham Parade, she slowed and almost came to a complete stop, before the lights turned green, and she turned onto Port Road into the middle lane. She said that when she was in the middle lane her car “didn’t feel right”, so she moved into the right-hand lane. Then she felt “okay”, so she changed back into the middle lane. She said she turned the steering wheel to move into the middle lane, and the car started going that way, but that thereafter she couldn’t straighten the car up. She said that she didn’t have any control over the steering, and that the car kept moving left even though her hands were straight on the steering wheel. Mr Richer On 21 June 2004, Mr Richer, a qualified mechanic employed by the RAA, examined the respondent’s car at her home. Mr Richer’s report was admitted as Exhibit P6. That report stated that: 4.Inspection of the steering lower coupling revealed the coupling was loose on the steering gear pinion shaft. 5.Inspection of the lower cam bolt and nut revealed the nut fitted to the clamp bolt was not a crimp-locking nut and could be moved by hand. Note: Holden workshop manual states that a new crimp nut should be installed when the steering rack is replaced. 6.When tested by turning the steering wheel, the lower steering coupling jumped approximately two splines (engine not running). The report concluded: …it would appear the steering failure was due to the incorrect nut fitted to the clamp bolt when the steering rack was replaced. The nut has worked loose allowing the steering coupling to jump splines on the pinion shaft. The steering coupling could also have cocked on the shaft and dislodged the joint. Mr Richer gave evidence of two theories regarding the cause of the accident. First, Mr Richer said that if in the circumstances where the nut was not fitted correctly there was excess load on the steering wheel or front wheels, the coupling may have “opened up” to allow the pinion to rotate inside the coupling, or the coupling to rotate around the pinion. This would result in looseness in the steering, so that the steering wheel could move without moving the wheels. Mr Richer’s second theory was that if the bolt was loose, the coupling could ride up or down the pinion, and if it rode up it could ‘cock on the top’ of the pinion. According to Mr Richer, this would mean that the universal joint would be at an incorrect angle, and could jam, making the steering tight. Mr Richer gave evidence that, at his inspection on 21 June 2004, he was able to turn the steering wheel approximately six or seven millimetres, but that it felt like there was movement in the lower joint, and “it felt like it jumped on the lower coupling”. In his report Mr Richer referred to the lower coupling jumping “approximately two splines”. He conceded in evidence that he had been incorrect in referring to “splines” in his written report, as there were no splines on this coupling. Mr Richer also took a photograph (Exhibit P6) which showed that the cam bolt was in place at the time of inspection.Mr Aust

Decision

Reasons for decision

As this matter was not used as a basis for the Magistrate’s reasons, I simply note that her observation would not necessarily be supportive of the conclusion that she draws. In my view the photographs do not support the conclusion that there was a steering failure.Conclusion as to appeal grounds For the reasons set out above, I consider that the Magistrate erred in her approach to the case. Her Honour failed to ask the correct question and disclosed errors of understanding of the evidence. In particular, she failed to appropriately address and analyse the expert evidence given by Messrs Aust, Hall and Richer. Accordingly, I would allow the appeal. I must now consider what is the proper course to follow, whether to order a retrial or whether I should substitute the decision of the Magistrate. In this case, having reviewed all of the evidence for the purposes of the appeal, and by reason of the conclusions I have reached as set out above, I consider that the evidence, particularly that of the experts, overwhelmingly indicates that it cannot be proved on the balance of probabilities that the cause of the accident was the loose nut on the cam bolt. Accepting the respondent’s description of her driving on the night, all the evidence given by the experts, when properly analysed, does not satisfy me on the balance of probabilities that the incorrect and loose nut caused her accident and resultant damages. Therefore, the appellant is not liable for damages, either in negligence or under contract. Whilst it is not necessary to find an alternative cause for the accident, I note that the respondent had only had the car a short period of time, a matter of days. During that period of time the vehicle had been taken away for repairs and returned. It was evening and the conditions were wet. She had only just rounded a 90 degree corner, she was travelling at 50 kilometres per hour. The accident occurred only a short distance away from the intersection after the respondent had changed lanes twice. A number of these features were raised by Mr Aust in his report. The combination of these events may well have been causative of the accident. However, this is not a matter that the appellant is required to prove. In deciding to substitute the Magistrate’s decision, I note that the Magistrate’s findings largely concerned her treatment of the experts’ opinion evidence rather than matters which concerned findings of credit. This Court is therefore not subject to the restraints in discharging its appellate functions as articulated in Devries[4] Further, in my view, it is unlikely that in a second trial, the parties would significantly alter their evidence. The objective evidence is so strong that a retrial would be futile. For all these reasons, I consider that this Court is in a good position to substitute its decision for that of the Magistrate. Accordingly, I find that I am not satisfied that the claim for damages has been proved and I make the following orders:[4] Devries v Australian National Railways Commission (1993) 177 CLR 472, 479, per Brennan, Gaudron and McHugh JJ. Discussed in Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118.1.The time within which the appellant be entitled to appeal be extended to 7 December 2006.2.That the appeal be allowed.3.The order of the Magistrate entering judgment in favour of the respondent is set aside.4.That the third party claim be dismissed and judgment be entered in favour of the appellant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Wrightville Operations Pty Ltd (T/As Jarvis Ford) v Lisman examined the approach of the Magistrate to the evidence, particularly the expert evidence, in determining whether the appellant's conduct was a causally relevant factor in the damage sustained in the car accident. The court found that the Magistrate erred in her approach to the evidence, particularly the expert evidence, and that she failed to ask the correct questions or appropriately analyse the expert evidence given by Messrs Aust, Hall, and Richer. The court noted that the Magistrate's findings largely concerned her treatment of the experts' opinion evidence rather than matters which concerned findings of credit, which meant that the Court was not subject to the restraints in discharging its appellate functions.

In considering whether the Magistrate failed to have sufficient regard to the body of evidence, particularly the expert evidence, the court found that the evidence, particularly that of the experts, overwhelmingly indicates that it cannot be proved on the balance of probabilities that the cause of the accident was the loose nut on the cam bolt. The court noted that the combination of factors, such as the respondent having only had the car for a short period of time, the vehicle having been taken away for repairs and returned, and the wet conditions on the night of the accident, may well have been causative of the accident. However, the court found that the appellant was not required to prove an alternative cause for the accident.

The court also noted that the objective evidence was so strong that a retrial would be futile, and that the parties were unlikely to significantly alter their evidence. The court found that it was in a good position to substitute its decision for that of the Magistrate and set aside the Magistrate's judgment, entering judgment in favour of the appellant.

In reaching its decision, the court applied the principle that it is not subject to the restraints in discharging its appellate functions when the findings largely concern the treatment of expert opinion evidence rather than matters which concern findings of credit. The court also applied the principle that a retrial would be futile when the objective evidence is so strong that it is unlikely that the parties would significantly alter their evidence. The court departed from the Magistrate's approach to the evidence, particularly the expert evidence, and found that the evidence did not prove on the balance of probabilities that the loose nut on the cam bolt caused the accident.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that when a court is reviewing a decision made by a Magistrate, it must consider whether the Magistrate erred in her approach to the evidence, particularly the expert evidence, and whether she failed to have sufficient regard to the body of evidence. The court must also consider whether the evidence, particularly that of the experts, overwhelmingly indicates that it cannot be proved on the balance of probabilities that the cause of the accident was the factor in question. If the court finds that the Magistrate erred in her approach to the evidence or failed to have sufficient regard to the body of evidence, it may substitute its decision for that of the Magistrate and set aside the Magistrate's judgment.