CATCHWORDS
Copyright and Designs - whether injunctive relief under s 116 and s 135AG of the Copyright Act 1968 should be granted to the applicants restraining the first respondents access to and/or dealings with goods seized by Customs under subs 135(7) following notice given on behalf of applicants under subs 135(2) - whether injunctive relief should be granted to the applicants restraining the first respondent from importing into Australia goods the subject of the applicants copyright claim - whether there is a serious question to be tried - whether detachable labels have no substantive value so that any infringement of copyright is de minimis - whether attached labels come with the meaning of “designs” in s 4(1) of the Designs Act 1906 and therefore attract no copyright protection - whether attached labels are “corresponding designs” within the meaning of s 74 of the Copyright Act - whether attached labels are unregistrable under the Designs Act pursuant to Designs Regulation 11(1)(a) - whether dressmaking patterns are designs within the meaning of s 4(1) Designs Act 1906 - whether patterns are literary works or compilations for purposes of the Copyright Act - whether patterns are unregisterable under the Designs Act because they do not indicate features of shape or configuration which, in the finished article, can be judged by the eye - whether on balance of convenience injunctive relief should be granted - effect of parallel importing on business of exclusive distributors - likely effect of injunctive relief on first respondent - first respondent’s prior knowledge of possibility of its infringement of copyright.
Copyright Act (1968) - subs 135(7), s 116, s 1135AG, subs 218(2), s 74, s 77, s 37, s 38
Designs Act (1906) - s 4(1)
Designs Regulations (1982) - reg 11(1)(a)
R & A Bailey & Co Ltd v Boccaccio Pty Ltd (1986) 4 NSWLR 701
W H Brine Co v Whitton (1981) 37 ALR 190
Dorling v Honnor Marine Ltd [1965] Ch1.
Slick Brands (Clothing) Ltd v Jollybird Ltd [1975] FSR 470
McAfee Associates Inc v Nestor Pty Ltd 24 July 1996 unreported:
Bullock v The Federated Furnishing Trades Society of Australasia (1985) 5 FCR 464
Re Littlewoods Pools Ltd’s Application (1949) 66 RPC 309
Re Wolanski’s Registered Design (1953) 88 CLR 278
WRANGLER APPAREL CORP & ANOR v CLASSIC BOOTS AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
No. NG 263 of 1997
CORAM: Lehane J
PLACE: Sydney
DATE: 2 June 1997
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY ) No. NG 263 of 1997
GENERAL DIVISION )
BETWEEN: WRANGLER APPAREL CORP
First Applicant
WRANGLER INC
Second Applicant
AND:CLASSIC BOOTS AUSTRALIA PTY
LIMITED
(A.C.N. 063 309 348)
First RespondentCHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF THE
AUSTRALIAN CUSTOMS SERVICE
Second Respondent
CORAM: Lehane J
PLACE: Sydney
DATE: 2 June 1997
MINUTE OF ORDERS
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
The applicants file and serve, not later than Friday, 6 June 1997, minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons.
NOTE:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wrangler Apparel Corp v Classic Boots Australia Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1997] FCA 457
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The questions to be decided by the court were whether there was a serious question to be tried and, if so, whether the balance of convenience favoured the granting of interlocutory relief to the applicants. The court found that there was a serious question to be tried and that, taking into account the balance of convenience, interlocutory relief should be granted to the applicants.
The court found that there was a serious question to be tried in relation to the labels and the dressmaking patterns, and that the applicants had established a prima facie case of infringement. The court found that the applicants had demonstrated that they had a legitimate interest in protecting their copyright and that the balance of convenience favoured the granting of interlocutory relief to the applicants. The court also took into account the applicants’ offer to purchase the seized jeans, subject to verification of the amount paid for them by Classic Boots, as a condition of interlocutory relief.
The court ordered that the applicants file and serve, not later than Friday, 6 June 1997, minutes of orders appropriate to give effect to these reasons. The court also ordered that the applicants purchase the seized jeans, subject to verification of the amount paid for them by Classic Boots, the purchase price being payable in two instalments: half immediately, and the balance as the seized jeans are sold. The court further ordered that the seized jeans be delivered up to Classic Boots or its solicitors, subject to a restraint on dealings except by way of sale as contemplated by the applicants’ offer. The court also ordered that Classic Boots be restrained, until the determination of the proceedings or further order, from importing for sale, etc. (without the licence of the applicants) jeans bearing the label which the court had discussed in these reasons, or made in accordance with a pattern according to which any of the seized jeans were made.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case is an application for interlocutory relief in the Federal Court of Australia, General Division, before Lehane J. The applicants seek orders for delivery up of the seized jeans to them or their solicitors, or alternatively that the jeans not be released to Classic Boots but continue to be held by Customs, or that they be delivered to Classic Boots on condition that Classic Boots not sell or distribute them for trade. Additionally, the applicants seek an order restraining Classic Boots from importing into Australia articles incorporating or constituting copies of the labels or dressmaking patterns without their licence. The case was heard on 16 May 1997 and 23 May 1997.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether there is a serious question to be tried regarding the infringement of copyright in the labels and dressmaking patterns.
2. Whether the balance of convenience favours granting interlocutory relief to the applicants.
Held
1. There is a serious question to be tried regarding the infringement of copyright in the labels and dressmaking patterns.
2. The balance of convenience favours granting interlocutory relief to the applicants.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court found that there was a serious question to be tried regarding the infringement of copyright in both the labels and dressmaking patterns. This was based on the evidence presented by the applicants that they owned the copyright in the labels and dressmaking patterns, and that Classic Boots had no license to import or sell the labels or jeans. The court considered that the labels attached to the jeans performed an important function of identifying the jeans, attracting custom and providing information, and thus had substantial value. The court also found that the dressmaking patterns were not necessarily registrable designs under the Designs Act, and thus copyright subsisted in them. The court rejected Classic Boots' argument that the labels and dressmaking patterns were de minimis infringements.
Regarding the balance of convenience, the court found that the balance favoured the applicants. The court considered the evidence presented by the applicants that the appointment of an exclusive distributor in Australia was the best means of marketing and selling their products, and that parallel importing threatened this arrangement. The court also considered the evidence that the release of the seized jeans to the market would cause substantial difficulties to the applicants' chosen means of distribution. Although the court acknowledged that Classic Boots would suffer some financial impact from being denied access to the seized jeans, the court found that the prejudice to the applicants would be greater if interlocutory relief was not granted. The court also considered the offer made by the applicants to buy the seized jeans, subject to certain conditions, as a significant factor in favour of granting interlocutory relief.
The court thus granted interlocutory relief to the applicants, subject to certain conditions. The seized jeans were to be delivered up to Classic Boots or its solicitors, subject to a restraint on dealings except by way of sale as contemplated by the applicants' offer. The court also granted an order restraining further importation of jeans bearing the labels or made in accordance with the dressmaking patterns.