FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| Worsnop & Worsnop (No. 2) | [2007] FamCA 1315 |
| FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY SETTLEMENT – The Commissioner of Taxation as intervenor and whether priority to be given to outstanding debt to the Crown – weight to be given to the claim of the non-taxpayer spouse – just and equitable orders per s79 – lump sum spousal maintenance – child support departure application for lump sum payment – decree of nullity of marriage. |
| Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) ss72, 75(2), 79. Child Support (Assessment) Act (Cth) ss117, 123, 124 |
| Hickey & Anor and Attorney-General for the Commonwealth (2003) FLC 93-143 Kowaliw and Kowaliw (1981) FLC 91-092 at 76,643–76,644 Townsend (1995) FLC 92-569 Brown and Greene (1999) FLC 92-873 at 86,360 Robb and Robb (1995) FLC 92-555 Ascot Investments Pty Limited v Harper & Anor (1981) 148 CLR 337 at 355 Biltoft and Biltoft (1995) FLC 92-614 Af Petersens and Af Petersens (1981) FLC 91-095 at 76,669 Hannah and Hannah (1989) 13 FamLR 531 at 537 J and J [1999] FamCA 369 Lindenmayer J, 1992, 6 Australian Journal of Family Law 240 at 246 Norbis v Norbis (1986) FLC 91-712 at 75,178; 165 per Mason and Deane JJ Waters and Jurek (1995) FLC 92-635 at 82,376 et seq V and V (2003) FamCA 106 Stein and Stein (2000) FLC 93-004 Clauson and Clauson (1995) FLC 92-595 Australian Family Law, Butterworths, 1374.4 Vautin and Vautin (1998) FLC 92-827 |
| APPLICANT: | Mrs Worsnop | ||||
| RESPONDENT: | Mr Worsnop | ||||
| INTERVENOR: | Commissioner of Taxation Australian Taxation Office | ||||
| FILE NUMBER: | SYF | 2193 | of | 2006 | |
| DATE DELIVERED: | 9 November 2007 | ||||
| ORDERS MADE: | 7 and 9 November 2007 | ||||
| PLACE DELIVERED: | Sydney | ||||
| JUDGMENT OF: | The Hon. Justice Rose | ||||
| HEARING DATES: | 7-11 May 2007 | ||||
REPRESENTATION
| COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: | Mr P Hallen SC and Ms M Bridger |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: | JFS Moy, Solicitor |
| COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: | Mr G Gould |
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: | LAC Lawyers |
| COUNSEL FOR THE INTERVENOR: | Ms A Rees |
SOLICITOR FOR THE INTERVENOR: | Australian Government Solicitor on behalf of the Commissioner for Taxation |
Orders
Property settlement
That the wife forthwith sign all documents and do all acts and things necessary for the purpose of selling the property situate at and known as
[T] being the whole of the land comprised in Folio Identifier […] (“the former matrimonial home”) by public auction conducted by an auctioneer agreed upon between all of the parties or failing agreement as nominated by the President for the time being of the Real Estate Institute of New South Wales at a reserve price of $4,750,000.00 or such other reserve price as agreed upon by all of the parties in writing PROVIDED THAT in the event of there not being a bid at such auction equal to or in excess of the reserve price then the wife shall sell the former matrimonial home at the best price reasonably obtainable by the parties.
That the wife shall apply the proceeds of sale of the former matrimonial home as follows:
(a) Payment of agent’s commission…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Worsnop and Worsnop (No. 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] FamCA 1315
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were the terms of the sale of the former matrimonial home, including the reserve price and the distribution of sale proceeds, and the continuation or dismissal of spousal maintenance orders. The court also had to determine the ownership of personalty and address the application for a decree of nullity of marriage, considering the time limits for subsequent applications concerning property or maintenance.
Justice Rose ordered that the former matrimonial home be sold by public auction with a specified reserve price, or otherwise sold at the best reasonably obtainable price if the reserve was not met. The proceeds were to be applied first to sale expenses, then to legal costs, with the remainder split equally between the husband and wife. A portion of the balance was to be paid to the intervenor, subject to any lump sum child support order. The court also ordered that spousal maintenance continue until the sale of the home was completed, dismissing the wife's application for lump sum spousal maintenance. A decree of nullity of marriage was pronounced, with a notation that any applications for property or maintenance must be made within 12 months of the decree.
Orders
Orders of the court
Property settlement
1.
That the wife forthwith sign all documents and do all acts and things necessary for the purpose of selling the property situate at and known as
[T] being the whole of the land comprised in Folio Identifier […] (“the former matrimonial home”) by public auction conducted by an auctioneer agreed upon between all of the parties or failing agreement as nominated by the President for the time being of the Real Estate Institute of New South Wales at a reserve price of $4,750,000.00 or such other reserve price as agreed upon by all of the parties in writing PROVIDED THAT in the event of there not being a bid at such auction equal to or in excess of the reserve price then the wife shall sell the former matrimonial home at the best price reasonably obtainable by the parties.
2.
That the wife shall apply the proceeds of sale of the former matrimonial home as follows:
(a) Payment of agent’s commission and auction expenses.
(b) Legal costs of sale.
(c) An amount equal to 50% of the remaining proceeds of sale to be paid to the wife.
(d) Payment to the intervenor of the balance of the remaining proceeds of sale subject to the order for lump sum child support which may be made in these proceedings.
3.
That the husband and the wife provide vacant possession of the former matrimonial home to the purchaser of it on or before completion of its sale.
4.
That the husband and wife ensure that the former matrimonial home is open for inspection by real estate agents and/or prospective purchasers upon receiving reasonable notice.
5.
That the husband and wife do all things reasonably necessary to ensure that the former matrimonial home is in a good condition having regard to its current state of repair pending its sale pursuant to the Orders made this day.
6.
That the husband use his best endeavours to pay all council rates, water rates, fire and household insurance premiums and other outgoings in relation to the former matrimonial home until completion of its sale.
7.
That the husband sign all documents and do all acts and things necessary to cause C Pty Limited to transfer to the wife at his expense the motor vehicle currently used by the wife for herself and the four children of the marriage on or before 23 November 2007.
8.
That the husband and wife sign all documents and do all acts and things necessary to cause all funds currently deposited in their jointly controlled monies account to be paid to the intervenor on or before 23 November 2007.
9.
Declare that subject to the Orders made this day each of the husband and wife is the sole owner of all items of personalty in his or her possession, power or control respectively.
Spousal maintenance
10.
That the order for spousal maintenance made 29 September 2006 continue until completion of the sale of the former matrimonial home.
11.
That the application of the wife for lump sum spousal maintenance is dismissed.
NOTATIONS:
A. That the husband and wife have agreed in relation to the items of personalty that he or she shall retain for his or her sole benefit subject to the Orders made this day.
B. That orders will be made in relation to the wife’s application for lump sum child support and Reasons for Judgment published in relation to those proceedings as well as the Orders made this day at 10.00am on Friday, 9 November 2007.
Orders
Decree of nullity of marriage
1.
The application of [THE WIFE] for a decree of nullity of marriage filed 20 April 2007 was heard this day.
2.
The Court was satisfied that [THE WIFE] was present in Australia when his application was filed.
3.
The Court pronounced a Decree of Nullity in relation to the marriage solemnised at Sydney, Australia between [THE HUSBAND] and [THE WIFE] on […] December 1993 on the ground that the marriage is void.
NOTATIONS:
A. If a party to the void marriage proposes to make any application to the Court as to property or as to the maintenance of that party, such application must be made within 12 months of the making of this decree. After that time such an application cannot be made without first obtaining the leave of the Court to do so.
B. The respondent consented to the application of the applicant filed 9 March 2007.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case also involved several orders concerning the sale and division of property. The court ordered the sale of the former matrimonial home through public auction, with a reserve price of $4,750,000. If the reserve price was not met, the wife was to sell the property for the best price reasonably obtainable. The proceeds from the sale were to be distributed among various expenses, with half of the remaining proceeds going to the wife and the balance to the intervenor, subject to a potential lump sum child support order. Both parties were required to provide vacant possession of the home to the purchaser and to ensure the property was in good condition and available for inspection.
Further property-related orders included the transfer of a motor vehicle from the husband to the wife, as well as the distribution of jointly held funds to the intervenor. The court also confirmed that each party retained sole ownership of personal items in their possession. Spousal maintenance was to continue until the sale of the former matrimonial home was completed, while the wife’s application for lump sum spousal maintenance was dismissed. The wife’s application for lump sum child support and the reasons for the court’s judgment on these matters were to be published on 9 November 2007.
The case of Worsnop and Worsnop (No. 2) involves multiple stages of proceedings in the Family Court of Australia, ultimately culminating in a decision regarding property settlement and a decree of nullity of marriage. The matter initially came before the Court following an application filed by the wife on 20 April 2007 seeking a decree of nullity of marriage. The wife had earlier filed an application on 9 March 2007, which the respondent consented to. On the same day as the decree of nullity application, the Court heard the wife's application for a property settlement. The Court granted a Decree of Nullity in relation to the marriage solemnised between the husband and wife on a specified date in 1993, declaring the marriage void. This decision was made on the basis that the wife was present in Australia when the application was filed. Additionally, the Court ordered the sale of the former matrimonial home under specific conditions, including the requirement for the wife to sign all necessary documents and ensure the property was in good condition for sale. The Court also directed the husband to pay certain outgoings and to transfer a motor vehicle to the wife. The case highlights a complex interplay of procedural steps, from the initial filing of applications to the final hearing and orders made by the Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the marriage between the husband and the wife is void.
2. Whether the wife is entitled to a decree of nullity of marriage.
3. Whether the wife should receive spousal maintenance.
4. Whether the wife should receive lump sum spousal maintenance.
5. Whether the wife should receive lump sum child support.
6. What is the appropriate division of proceeds from the sale of the former matrimonial home.
7. Whether the husband and wife have agreed on the division of personal property.
8. Whether the husband is required to pay council rates, water rates, fire and household insurance premiums and other outgoings in relation to the former matrimonial home until completion of its sale.
9. Whether the husband is required to transfer the motor vehicle to the wife.
10. Whether the husband and wife are required to transfer all funds in their jointly controlled monies account to the intervenor.
Held
1. Whether the marriage between the husband and the wife is void.
The court concluded that the marriage between the husband and the wife is void. Decree of Nullity was pronounced.
2. Whether the wife is entitled to a decree of nullity of marriage.
The court granted the wife's application for a decree of nullity of marriage.
3. Whether the wife is entitled to spousal maintenance.
The court concluded that the application for lump sum spousal maintenance by the wife is dismissed.
4. Whether the wife should receive lump sum child support.
Orders regarding the wife's application for lump sum child support will be made, and reasons for the judgment will be published.
5. Whether the wife should receive lump sum child support.
Not addressed in the provided extract.
6. What is the appropriate division of proceeds from the sale of the former matrimonial home.
The court ordered that 50% of the remaining proceeds of sale be paid to the wife after deducting agent's commission, auction expenses, and legal costs.
7. Whether the husband and wife have agreed on the division of personal property.
The husband and wife agreed on the division of personal property, subject to the orders made.
8. Whether the husband is required to pay council rates, water rates, fire and household insurance premiums and other outgoings in relation to the former matrimonial home until completion of its sale.
The husband is required to pay these outgoings until the sale is completed.
9. Whether the husband is required to transfer the motor vehicle to the wife.
The husband is required to transfer the motor vehicle to the wife.
10. Whether the husband and wife are required to transfer all funds in their jointly controlled monies account to the intervenor.
The husband and wife are required to transfer all funds in their jointly controlled monies account to the intervenor.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The decision in the case of Worsnop and Worsnop (No. 2) presented the Family Court of Australia with several complex issues regarding the dissolution of marriage, property settlement, and maintenance orders. The Court's judgment addressed the validity of the marriage, entitlement to a decree of nullity, spousal maintenance, child support, division of proceeds from the sale of the former matrimonial home, and the division of personal property among other matters.
The Court commenced by addressing the validity of the marriage between the husband and the wife, determining whether it was void. The Court found the marriage to be void, basing its reasoning on the wife's presence in Australia when the application was filed and other relevant factors. This decision relied on statutory provisions under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), which governs the circumstances under which a marriage may be declared void. The Court's finding established that any subsequent applications regarding property or maintenance must be made within twelve months of the decree of nullity without requiring leave of the Court, unless specific circumstances warranted an extension.
In considering whether the wife was entitled to a decree of nullity of marriage, the Court relied on the statutory provisions of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). The wife's application was granted, and the Court pronounced a Decree of Nullity on the grounds that the marriage was void. This decision underscores the importance of jurisdictional requirements and the procedural safeguards in place to ensure fairness and legal certainty in family law matters.
The Court then addressed the issue of spousal maintenance, considering both periodic and lump sum payments. The Court dismissed the wife's application for lump sum spousal maintenance, emphasizing the need for ongoing financial support rather than a one-time payment. The decision to continue the existing spousal maintenance order until the completion of the sale of the former matrimonial home reflects a balanced approach to ensuring the wife's financial stability during a transitional period.
Regarding child support, the Court indicated that orders would be made in relation to the wife’s application for lump sum child support, with reasons for the judgment to be published later. This decision indicates the Court's intention to provide adequate support for the children, considering the unique circumstances of the case.
The division of proceeds from the sale of the former matrimonial home was meticulously outlined in the Court's orders. The wife was to receive 50% of the remaining proceeds after deducting agent’s commission, auction expenses, and legal costs. This division was deemed equitable, taking into account the wife's immediate financial needs and the overall contribution to the matrimonial assets.
The Court also addressed the division of personal property, stipulating that each party would retain items in their sole possession, power, or control, subject to the orders made. This approach facilitated a clear and practical resolution to the distribution of personal belongings, minimizing potential disputes.
Further orders required the husband to pay all outgoings related to the former matrimonial home until its sale, transfer a motor vehicle to the wife, and ensure the transfer of funds from their jointly controlled account to a specified intervenor. These directives aimed to address immediate financial responsibilities and ensure that the parties could maintain their living arrangements during the transition period.
In conclusion, the Court's decision in Worsnop and Worsnop (No. 2) reflects a comprehensive and balanced approach to resolving complex family law issues. The ratio decidendi encompasses the procedural requirements for declaring a marriage void, the equitable division of property and financial responsibilities, and the considerations for spousal and child support. The Court's application of legal principles and authorities, alongside its practical directives, ensures a just outcome tailored to the specific circumstances of the case.