Woolworths Limited v Maryborough City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Woolworths Limited v Maryborough City Council & Anor [2004] QPEC 086

PARTIES:

WOOLWORTHS LIMITED ACN 000 014 675     (Appellant)

AND

MARYBOROUGH CITY COUNCIL       (First Respondent)

AND

ROKAY PTY LTD ACN 098 337 690    (Second Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

1480 of 2004

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment

PROCEEDING:

Submitter Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning & Environment Court of Queensland, Maryborough

DELIVERED ON:

17 December 2004

DELIVERED AT:

Maroochydore

HEARING DATE:

15 – 18 November 2004

JUDGE:

Judge J.M. Robertson

ORDER:

   [1]      Appeal allowed.

   [2]      Negotiated Decision Notice 25 March 2004 is set aside.

CATCHWORDS:

Whether proposed change to impact assessable application “minor”; 3.5.14(2)(a) and (b) of the Integrated Planning Act 1997; whether proposal conflicts with DEO; whether proposal should be seen as part of integrated use of whole of premises; characterisation of present and proposed use; whether proposal conflicts with planning scheme; whether sufficient planning grounds to approve notwithstanding conflict.

Cases cited:

Carillion Development Ltd v Maroochy Shire Council [2000] QPELR 216
Ausbuild Pty Ltd v Redland Shire Council, Andiwork Pty Ltd v Redland Shire Council [2001] QPELR 409
Warehouse Group (Australia) Pty Ltd v Woolworths Ltd [2003] NSW CA 270
Koerner & Ors v Maroochy Shire Council & Baines [2004] QDELR 211
Shire of Perth v O’Keith (1965) 110 CLR 529
Westfield Management Ltd v Pine Rivers Shire Council & Anor (unreported, Planning and Environment Court, Britton SC DCJ, 14 November 2003, 1627/2003)
Woolworths Limited v Caboolture Shire Council and The Warehouse Group (Australia) Pty Ltd; Woolworths Limited v Caboolture Shire Council and Makro Warehouse Pty Ltd 2004 QPEC 015
Woolworths Limited v Caboolture Shire Council and The Warehouse Group (Australia) Pty Ltd; Woolworths Limited v Caboolture Shire Council and Makro Warehouse Pty Ltd 2004 QPEC 026
Foodbarn Pty Ltd v Solicitor General (1975) 32 LGERA 157
Skateway Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council & Ors [1980] QPLR 245
Cut Price Stores Retailers & Ors v Caboolture Shire Council [1984] QPLR 126
Roosterland Pty Ltd and its agents v Brisbane City Council [1986] QPLR 515
Luke v Maroochy Shire Council [2003] QPELR 5

Statutes cited:

Integrated Planning Act 1997

COUNSEL:

G.Gibson QC with J Houston (for the appellant)

R. Litster (for the first respondent)

C. Hughes SC with M Williamson (for the second respondent)

SOLICITORS:

Mallesons Stephen Jacques (for the appellant)

Corser, Sheldon & Gordon (for the first respondent)

P&E Law (for the second respondent)

Contents

Page

Introduction  .....................................................................................................................

4

The Preliminary Point.......................................................................................................

6

The Appeal........................................................................................................................

8

The Planning Scheme Extracts.........................................................................................

9

The 1990 Scheme..............................................................................................................

9

The City Plan ...................................................................................................................

11

The Characterisation Issue................................................................................................

13

Is TWG engaged in bulky goods retailing? .....................................................................

17

Can the use be characterised by reference to the City Plan?............................................

19

The Disputed Issues – discussion......................................................................................

22

INTRODUCTION

  1. In late 1999 the then owner of Lot 7 SP 107050, a vacant block of land comprising approximately 1.3 hectares in Ferry Street, Maryborough applied to the Maryborough City Council (Council) for a material change of use of the premises for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Woolworths Limited v Maryborough City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] QPEC 86
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Woolworths Limited filed an appeal against the Maryborough City Council's decision to reject a proposed change of use for a portion of the premises from a showroom to a supermarket. The case was heard in the Queensland Planning and Environment Court. The central issue was whether the proposed change of use could be considered "minor" and thus exempt from certain requirements under section 3.5.14(2) of the Integrated Planning Act 1997. The court also had to determine whether the proposed use conflicted with the Development and Environment Order (DEO) and whether the proposal should be viewed as part of an integrated use of the entire premises. Additionally, the court examined whether the proposal conflicted with the planning scheme and if sufficient planning grounds existed to approve the change despite the conflict.

The court considered whether the proposed change of use was minor, taking into account the existing and proposed uses of the premises. It found that the proposal did not constitute a minor change and thus was not exempt from the requirements of section 3.5.14(2). The court also evaluated whether the proposed use conflicted with the DEO and whether it should be seen as part of an integrated use of the entire premises. The court concluded that the proposed use did conflict with the DEO and was not part of an integrated use of the premises. Furthermore, the court assessed whether the proposal conflicted with the planning scheme and if there were sufficient planning grounds to justify the approval despite the conflict. The court found that the evidence did not establish a community need for the proposed use, and thus the planning grounds were insufficient to approve the change of use.

In light of the above findings, the court allowed the appeal and set aside the Negotiated Decision Notice dated 25 March 2004. The decision underscores the importance of considering the nature of the proposed use, its conflict with existing planning instruments, and the adequacy of the planning grounds in assessing applications for changes of use.

Orders

Orders of the court

[1] Appeal allowed.

[2] Negotiated Decision Notice 25 March 2004 is set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I agree with Mr Gibson QC that in one significant respect the approach of Rokay to this issue has been misguided. The appeal has never been about the future of TWG’s operation in Maryborough. To a significant extent I think Rokay has attempted to portray the impression that the continuation of the present use of some quite small part of TWG to sell food and groceries is essential to the continuation of the business as a whole. The decision of this Court, on the evidence before it, will have no effect on the existence of TWG business. Mr Hughes asked many questions of witnessed called by the appellant along these lines. At page 230, line 20 he asked Mr Buckley: Mr Gibson QC objected on the grounds of relevancy and the objection was upheld. The main planning ground relied upon related to community need. There is no dispute that need is a relevant town planning ground in relation to the decision under appeal. Mr Hughes SC and Mr Williamson helpfully summarised the correct approach in their written submission and I adopt their summary: In that submission, Rokay has to a significant effect concentrated on the town planning need for TWG in Maryborough. Paragraph 7 of their written submission states: At paragraph 61 they state: The appellant took no issue that on the evidence, there is clearly a “need” for TWG in the City. Mr Clark’s evidence establishes that on average 5000 people have visited the premises since it opened in June 2003. The submission of the appellant is that the evidence does not establish any need for 150 square metres of floor space for the sale of food and groceries, which is the subject of the material change in use decision under appeal. Mr Walkley’s survey established that when residents were asked unprompted “where would you mostly shop for food and groceries”, TWG did not rate a mention by name. Similarly, other questions established that shopping for food and groceries is not what attracts people to shop at TWG. It is obvious, in my view, that the “decision” referred to in s. 3.5.14(2)(b) is the decision to permit TWG to trade in food and groceries, and is not in any way referable to the original decision to approve the use on the premises as a showroom. It follows that where there is conflict with the Planning Scheme, the second respondent must point to sufficient planning grounds to justify that decision, if it is to succeed. In my view, the evidence simply does not establish any community need for a small portion of the premises to be devoted to the sale of food and groceries. In this sense, the comments of his Honour Judge Wilson SC in Luke v Maroochy Shire Council [2003] QPELR 5 to which Mr Hughes SC referred in his submission are distinguishable. I agree with Mr Hughes that the decision of Council to approve the use is a relevant factor in this determination, but there is simply no evidence that the Council regarded need for the sale of food and groceries as opposed to need for the whole TWG DDS as an important and persuasive planning ground in support of approval.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established