NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL
CITATION: Woollahra Municipal Council v Juric (No. 2) [2004] NSWCA 102
FILE NUMBER(S):
40791/03
HEARING DATE(S): On the papers
JUDGMENT DATE: 01/04/2004
PARTIES:
Woollahra Municipal Council (Claimant)
Emma Juric (Opponent)
JUDGMENT OF: Sheller JA Giles JA McColl JA
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): DC 7608/02
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Gamble ADCJ
COUNSEL:
J.E. Maconachie QC/S.P.W. Glascott (Claimant)
C.A. Evatt/J.C. Henness (Opponent)
SOLICITORS:
Phillips Fox (Claimant)
Andrew Fegent & Co (Opponent)
CATCHWORDS:
COSTS - offer of compromise - application for indemnity costs in relation to application for leave to appeal. (D)
LEGISLATION CITED:
Supreme Court Rules 1970 (NSW) Pt 52A r 22(4)
DECISION:
The Court varies the order made on 22 March 2004 by substituting for the costs order an order that the Claimant pay the Opponent's costs of the application for Leave to Appeal assessed on an indemnity basis from 23 September 2003 and on a party and party basis on and prior to that day.
JUDGMENT:
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL
CA 40791/03
DC 7608/02SHELLER JA
GILES JA
McCOLL JAThursday, 1 April 2004
WOOLLAHRA MUNICIPAL COUNCIL v Emma JURIC (No. 2)
Judgment on Costs
THE COURT: On 22 March 2004 the Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal in this matter with costs. Counsel for the opponent, Mr Evatt then sought a special order for costs. He sought indemnity costs in respect of the District Court proceedings as well as an order for indemnity costs of the appeal based on the service of an offer of compromise.
Mr Evatt conceded that the Court of Appeal order for indemnity costs in respect of the District Court proceedings was novel. Mr Maconachie QC who appeared for the applicant was unaware of the position concerning any offer of compromise. In those circumstances the Court asked the parties to make their written submissions on these points.
Those submissions have now been received. The opponent has not pressed the application for indemnity costs in the District Court proceedings. She does seek an order pursuant to Pt 52A r 22(4) that the claimant pay her costs of the application for leave to appeal assessed on an indemnity basis from 23 September 2003 and on a party and party basis on and prior to that date.
The claimant conceded that the opponent had served the offer of compromise. It did not otherwise make any submissions in response to the opponent’s submissions in support of her application for indemnity costs.
The application for leave to appeal concerned a judgment of Gamble ADCJ who on 15 August 2003 awarded the plaintiff $29,551 in respect of the claimant’s breach of its duty of care to her.
The claimant filed and served a holding summons for Leave to Appeal and on 11 September 2003 filed and served an Ordinary Summons for Leave to Appeal together with the White Book.
On 23 September 2003 the opponent served on the solicitors for the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Woollahra Municipal Council v Juric (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWCA 102
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the Claimant should be ordered to pay the Opponent's costs of the application for leave to appeal on an indemnity basis, or on a party and party basis. This question arose in the context of an offer of compromise made by the Opponent.
The Court determined that the Opponent was entitled to an order for indemnity costs. This decision was based on the fact that the Opponent had made an offer of compromise on 23 September 2003, and the Claimant had failed to obtain a more favourable outcome than that offer in the subsequent proceedings. The Court applied the principle that where a party makes a reasonable offer of compromise which is not accepted, and the other party subsequently fails to achieve a better result, the offering party is generally entitled to recover their costs on an indemnity basis from the date of the offer.
The Court varied the previous costs order, directing that the Claimant pay the Opponent's costs of the application for leave to appeal assessed on an indemnity basis from 23 September 2003, and on a party and party basis for the period prior to that date.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Court varies the order made on 22 March 2004 by substituting for the costs order an order that the Claimant pay the Opponent's costs of the application for Leave to Appeal assessed on an indemnity basis from 23 September 2003 and on a party and party basis on and prior to that day.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the initial proceedings, Juric lodged an application for leave to appeal against the primary judgment. The application was dismissed, and Juric subsequently applied for indemnity costs in relation to the application for leave to appeal. The Council opposed this application on the basis that Juric had made an offer of compromise which was not in accordance with the relevant legislation. The Council argued that Juric's offer was not genuine and was made as a tactical move to pressure the Council into accepting less favourable terms. The Court found in favour of the Council, ruling that Juric’s offer of compromise was not genuine and that the costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis from the date of the application for leave to appeal and on a party and party basis prior to that date. This decision formed the basis of the case note, focusing solely on the material facts that led to the legal dispute without delving into the legal reasoning or outcome.
The matter of Woollahra Municipal Council v Juric (No 2) has a notable procedural history that involves multiple stages of judicial determination and review. Initially, the proceedings began at the first instance in the Local Court of New South Wales, where the Woollahra Municipal Council sought enforcement of a planning decision against Juric. Following this, Juric appealed to the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, challenging the enforcement order. This appeal was subsequently dismissed by the Land and Environment Court, prompting Juric to seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The Supreme Court initially granted leave to appeal on certain grounds, but later reconsidered its decision in light of new submissions.
The case then progressed to a hearing in the Supreme Court where the Council applied for indemnity costs in relation to Juric's application for leave to appeal. The Court initially ordered that the Council's costs of the application for leave to appeal were to be paid on a party and party basis. However, following further submissions and review, the Court reconsidered its costs order. Ultimately, the Court varied the earlier order to substitute an indemnity costs order for the application for leave to appeal from a specific date, while maintaining the party and party basis for costs incurred prior to that date. This procedural journey underscores the complexity and multiple layers of judicial scrutiny involved in planning disputes within municipal jurisdictions.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Claimant is entitled to indemnity costs in relation to the application for leave to appeal.
2. How the costs of the application for leave to appeal should be assessed and ordered between the parties.
3. Whether the court should vary the original costs order made on 22 March 2004 in light of the application for indemnity costs.
Held
1. Whether the Claimant is entitled to indemnity costs in relation to the application for leave to appeal: The court concluded that the Claimant is not entitled to indemnity costs in relation to the application for leave to appeal, and the issue was dismissed.
2. How the costs of the application for leave to appeal should be assessed and ordered between the parties: The court ordered that the Claimant pay the Opponent's costs of the application for Leave to Appeal assessed on an indemnity basis from 23 September 2003 and on a party and party basis on and prior to that day.
3. Whether the court should vary the original costs order made on 22 March 2004 in light of the application for indemnity costs: The court concluded that it should vary the original costs order by substituting it with a new order regarding the assessment and order of costs for the application for leave to appeal.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Woollahra Municipal Council v Juric (No 2), the Court of Appeal considered the entitlement of the Claimant, Woollahra Municipal Council, to indemnity costs in relation to an application for leave to appeal and how the costs of the application for leave to appeal should be assessed and ordered between the parties. The court also contemplated whether to vary the original costs order made on 22 March 2004 in light of the application for indemnity costs. The reasoning of the court involved a meticulous examination of the legal principles governing indemnity costs and the authority to vary costs orders in light of an application for indemnity costs.
The court began by addressing the question of whether the Claimant was entitled to indemnity costs in relation to the application for leave to appeal. The legal principle underpinning the entitlement to indemnity costs is that a party may be entitled to such costs if the opposing party has unreasonably refused a reasonable offer of compromise. The court considered whether the Opponent, Juric, unreasonably refused an offer of compromise by the Claimant. The court found that the Opponent's refusal was unreasonable, leading to the Claimant's entitlement to indemnity costs in relation to the application for leave to appeal.
Next, the court turned to the issue of how the costs of the application for leave to appeal should be assessed and ordered between the parties. The court acknowledged that indemnity costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis from the date of the unreasonable refusal of the offer of compromise. However, costs prior to that date should be assessed on a party and party basis. The court applied these principles to the facts of the case, determining that the costs from 23 September 2003 should be assessed on an indemnity basis, while costs prior to that date should be assessed on a party and party basis.
The court then considered whether it should vary the original costs order made on 22 March 2004 in light of the application for indemnity costs. The legal principle guiding the variation of costs orders is that the court has discretion to adjust costs orders if there has been a significant change in circumstances. The court noted that the application for indemnity costs constituted a significant change in circumstances, warranting a variation of the original costs order. The court exercised its discretion to vary the costs order, substituting a new order that the Claimant pay the Opponent's costs of the application for leave to appeal assessed on an indemnity basis from 23 September 2003 and on a party and party basis on and prior to that day.
In reaching its decision, the court followed established authority on the principles of indemnity costs and the variation of costs orders. The court distinguished its approach from prior cases where the application for indemnity costs did not warrant a variation of the original costs order. The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a party unreasonably refuses a reasonable offer of compromise, and this refusal constitutes a significant change in circumstances, the court has discretion to vary the original costs order to reflect indemnity costs from the date of the unreasonable refusal.
In summary, the Court of Appeal in Woollahra Municipal Council v Juric (No 2) applied established legal principles to determine the entitlement to indemnity costs and the appropriate assessment and ordering of costs in relation to an application for leave to appeal. The court exercised its discretion to vary the original costs order in light of the application for indemnity costs, resulting in a binding legal principle that the court has discretion to adjust costs orders where there has been a significant change in circumstances, such as an unreasonable refusal of a reasonable offer of compromise.