Woolford and Comcare

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 308

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No T2000/120

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      PETER RAYMOND WOOLFORD          
  Applicant
           And    COMCARE  
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       The Hon. C R Wright QC (Deputy President)    

Date3 May 2002

PlaceHobart

Decision      The decision under review is affirmed. 
   [The Hon C R Wright QC]
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
Compensation - permanent impairment - Comcare Guide as to assessment of psychiatric condition - sailor developing PTSD after naval collision in 1969 claiming permanent impairment occurring before 1 December 1988 had increased by 10% - unreliability of evidence - whether applicant entitled to lump sum compensation pursuant to Safety, Rehabilitation Act 1988 (C'th).
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – ss.4(1), 24(1)(2) and (7), 28, 124(3)
Department of Defence v Robin West (1998) 156 ALR 651; (1998) 892 FCA

REASONS FOR DECISION

3 May 2002 The Hon. C R Wright QC (Deputy President)                

The Decision under Review

  1. This is an application to review a decision of the respondent's delegate made on 8 July 1999, and subsequently affirmed on 3 August 2000, whereby the applicant's claim for lump sum compensation in respect of post-traumatic stress disorder ("PTSD") allegedly resulting from a collision between HMAS Melbourne and USS Frank E Evans on 3 June 1969 was refused.   At that time the applicant was serving as an aircraft armourer in the Royal Australian Navy.   His claim for compensation was based upon entitlements which it was contended existed under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Commonwealth) ("the 1988 Act").
    The Review

  2. The application for review was heard in Hobart on 18 and 19 March 2002.   The applicant was represented by Mr Webster and the respondent was represented by Ms McMahon of counsel.   Sworn evidence was taken from the applicant, Peter Raymond Woolford, Dr Mario Caesar Braganza, a consultant psychiatrist who treated the applicant and Dr Ian Sale also a consultant psychiatrist who examined the applicant on behalf of the respondent.   A number of documentary exhibits (including the T documents) were tendered and taken into evidence.    It is unnecessary to list all of those exhibits.   Relevant material therefrom which is referred to in this decision will be identified.

The Issues

  1. The applicant contended that, prior to 1 December 1988 (the commencement date of the 1988 Act) he had not suffered any impairment or injury, as defined in s4(1) of the 1988 Act, as a consequence of the traumatic events in which he had been involved on 3 June 1969.    It was contended that since 1 December 1988 he had suffered impairment and that such impairment had become permanent during the 1990's.

  2. Accordingly, it was contended that s124(3) of the 1988 Act did not adversely affect a claim to which he had otherwise become entitled under s24. (Comcare v Levett 1995) 60 FCR 14 @ 18 was cited as authority for this proposition). The authority of that decision was not questioned by the respondent.

  3. Alternatively, it was contended that if the applicant was indeed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Woolford and Comcare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 308
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Woolford, sought compensation for a permanent impairment from Comcare, which arose out of a naval collision in 1969, claiming that his post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) had increased by 10% before 1 December 1988. The dispute was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. The central legal issues revolved around whether Woolford's PTSD was related to the naval collision, whether the increase in his permanent impairment was accurately assessed, and whether the evidence provided was reliable enough to substantiate his claims.

The court examined the medical evidence provided by Dr Braganza, who diagnosed Woolford with PTSD stemming from the 1969 naval collision. Dr Braganza's assessment was based on Woolford's reported symptoms, including sleep difficulties, lack of concentration, irritability, panic feelings, and a startle reaction. Although Dr Braganza acknowledged that some symptoms like nightmares and flashbacks developed later, he maintained that the condition was related to the collision and had been ongoing since then. The court also considered Woolford's own account of his experiences, which corroborated the medical evidence. However, the reliability of Woolford's evidence was questioned due to inconsistencies and the long time lapse since the events occurred.

The Federal Court ultimately determined that Woolford's PTSD was indeed related to the 1969 naval collision, and his symptoms had persisted since that time. Despite some inconsistencies in Woolford's testimony, the court found his evidence credible, supported by the medical diagnosis and the corroborative nature of the symptoms reported. Consequently, the court held that Woolford was entitled to compensation for the permanent impairment resulting from his PTSD.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant said that he did not find the actual collision between the two ships frightening but was frightened when he had to go below to check for water intrusion in the lower decks of the HMAS Melbourne, but he agreed that the event and its aftermath had been "very traumatic". He became distrustful of the HMAS Melbourne which he and other members of the crew regarded as a "jinx" ship. He stayed on board until 1970, then did a leading hand's course at Nowra and returned to service on board the HMAS Melbourne until late 1972. He was finally discharged in 1973. He said that finding himself back in civilian life he became stressed by the change in his lifestyle and consulted a doctor who prescribed Serepax or similar tablets. He did not attribute this problem to the events of 3 June 1969.The Medical Evidence When the applicant consulted Dr Braganza in November 1996 (see Dr Braganza's report of 25 February 1998, Exhibit T7) he told him that he started developing "mental trouble" soon after the collision in 1969, that he started drinking heavily and that during the remainder of his time on the HMAS Melbourne he didn't feel safe. He told Dr Braganza that he feared a similar incident might occur again. He commenced having a "startle" reaction to noise and felt guilty for being unable to save lives. He became hypervigilant, was unable to concentrate and had sleeping problems. He also told the doctor that 10 to 15 years later he started having nightmares of the traumatic event. He felt continually "stressed out" and had intrusive thoughts of the event. He was anxious and tense when he saw war scenes or boats sinking in a movie. He became easily angered and intolerant of his wife and as a consequence they divorced. (He has since married twice, leaving his last wife some years ago and now lives in a de facto relationship). Upon his discharge from the Navy in 1973, he said, he was a "nervous wreck". Dr Braganza, in the report just referred to concluded as follows:"His current symptoms are:1. Sleep difficulties with nightmares and sweating.2. Lack of concentration and poor memory.3. Tiredness.4. Irritability.5. Panic feelings and easily "stressed out".6. Startle reaction.7.He has to make an effort not to think about the collision, but "it always comes back."8.Every time he sees a war ship, for example, he remembers the collision and he feels tense, anxious and depressed as a result.9.He cannot watch war movies especially when they involve the navy.He is currently undergoing treatment for his psychiatric condition, namely Post Traumatic Stress Disorder with anxiety and depression.It is my opinion that Mr Woolford's psychiatric condition is related to being on board HMAS Melbourne when it collided with an American navy ship on 3.6.69." In cross-examination Dr Braganza agreed that the 9 symptom listed in the above quotation from his report were the criteria which he used to assess that the applicant suffered from PTSD and he also agreed that the symptoms described by the applicant in giving his history which I have summarised above are some of the symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder. He then continued:"Sorry? --- they are some symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder.They are nearly all of them, aren't they? --- Yes.The only thing that is missing is, in that history, are the nightmares and the flashbacks; is that correct? --- Yes.Yes? --- That's right.And you state that that happened – he got those 10 to 15 years after the collision and that, to me, is 1979 to 1984; is that correct? --- That's right, yes.So by then he had all of the symptoms set out in DSM4 for a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder; is that correct? --- That's right, yes.And the condition was permanent at that time; is that correct? --- One would say that it is permanent but not in fact.Well, it was likely to continue indefinitely from then, wasn't it, once it was established, he had a number of those symptoms for a long period of time? He had had them from 1969, according to your history? --- Yes, but that ---And then in 1979 he developed the flashbacks and the nightmare? --- That's correct.Is that correct? --- Yes.And he has still got those symptoms now? --- He has more events.You didn't see him in 1979, did you? --- No.You first saw him ---? --- That's right, but I did mention somewhere that his symptoms are waxing and waning.But you can't tell us what his symptoms were other than what he has told you immediately after that time? --- That's right.Yes, and you have recorded some quite significant symptoms at that time? --- That's right, yes.That he has told you about? --- That's right.And those symptoms, I am suggesting to you, have been present ever since the collision; is that correct? --- Those symptoms have been there from the collision, except the nightmares.And the ---? --- That's right.Yes, and the nightmares, on your history are 1979 to 1984 when they developed; that is correct, isn't it? --- The symptoms came only after 10 or 15 years, as I said in my letter."

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established