Woodstock Central Dairy Company Ltd v Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read
15 CLR 241

WOODSTOCK CENTRAL DAIRY COM-

PANY LTD.

THE COMMONWEALTH AND THE COMP-

DEFENDANTS.

TROLLER GENERAL OF CUSTOMS Commerce (Trade Descriptions) Act 1905 (No. 16 of 1905), secs. 3, 11 (1), 14, 17 -

Application of trade description to goods intended for export-Regulations requiring goods to be graded and marked-Validity of Regulations.

The Commerce (Trade Descriptions) Act 1905 does not authorize the making of regulations requiring goods intended for export to be graded by a Common- wealth officer, or to be marked by him in such a manner as to indicate the grade so fixed, or prohibiting the exportation of such goods unless they have been so graded and marked.

CASE Stated for the opinion of the Full Court.

In an action brought by the Woodstock Central Dairy Co. Ltd. against the Commonwealth and Nicholas Colston Lockyer, the Comptroller General of Customs, the parties concurred in stating the questions of law arising in the action in the form of a special case for the opinion of the Full Court as follows: :-

" 1. The plaintiff is a company duly incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act of New South Wales and carries on the business of manufacturing and exporting butter.

"2. The defendant Nicholas Colston Lockyer is the Comptroller General of Customs and as such is the permanent head of the Customs and has the chief control of the Customs throughout the Commonwealth of Australia.

3. The plaintiff has recently duly notified the defendants through their proper officer of its intention to export and has

15 CLR 242

duly submitted for examination a certain five parcels of pure

creamery butter to which have been applied by the plaintiff the words " Pure Creamery Butter, weight 56 lbs. nett, N.S.W., Aus- tralia," being a trade description of the character, and relating to the matters and applied in the manner prescribed by the Com- merce (Trade Descriptions) Act 1905, which said description is not in any particular a false trade description within the meaning of the said Act, and the plaintiff desires to continue to manufacture and to export large quantities of butter with the same or a similar trade description.

"4. The defendants have claimed and still claim to be entitled, and intend, notwithstanding the objections of the plaintiff, and unless restrained by the order of this Honourable Court, to grade and place marks upon the said boxes of butter indicating such grade, and to grade and place marks indicating such grade upon other boxes of butter submitted for examination for export.

"5. The plaintiff believes and charges it as a fact that such grading and marking will have a prejudicial effect on the sale of the said butter, and that it will lose the profits it would otherwise obtain.

"6. The plaintiff submits that both such grading and such marking are illegal, and that the Regulations attached as an Exhibit hereto, and purporting to be made under the Commerce (Trade Descriptions) Act, SO far as they purport…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Woodstock Central Dairy Company Ltd v Commonwealth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1912] HCA 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Woodstock Central Dairy Company Ltd. brought an action against the Commonwealth and the Comptroller General of Customs concerning the validity of regulations made under the Commerce (Trade Descriptions) Act 1905. The parties agreed to state the legal questions in a special case for the opinion of the Full Court. The company intended to export butter with a trade description applied by them, but the defendants claimed the right to grade and mark the butter according to Commonwealth regulations, which the company argued would prejudice their sales and were ultra vires the Act.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the Commerce (Trade Descriptions) Act 1905 authorised the making of regulations that required goods intended for export to be graded by a Commonwealth officer, marked with that grade, and prohibited from export unless so graded and marked. The Court was asked to determine if the regulations purporting to grant this power were valid or invalid as being beyond the scope of the Act.

The Court reasoned that the Act defined "trade description" to include descriptions of the "grade" of goods, but this word, in the context of the Act and its ordinary meaning at the time of enactment, referred to a pre-existing quality or classification of the goods. The Act did not contain language that clearly indicated an intention to empower the executive to create an entirely new, artificial grading system and impose it as a condition of export. The judges emphasised that any abridgement of individual liberty or interference with state powers must be clearly expressed in the legislation. Therefore, the regulations that purported to establish a system for grading butter by Commonwealth officers and making such grading a prerequisite for export were held to be ultra vires the Act.

The Court ordered that the defendants be restrained from grading and marking the plaintiff's butter under the Act and regulations in question, and that the defendants pay the plaintiff's taxed costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established