Wood v Adelaide Resource Recovery Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

WOOD v ADELAIDE RESOURCE RECOVERY PTY LTD

[2017] SASCFC 13

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Blue, The Honourable Justice Lovell and The Honourable Justice Hinton)

20 February 2017

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - POLLUTION - WASTE DISPOSAL - REGULATION - LICENSING - CONDITIONS

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - POLLUTION - WASTE DISPOSAL - OFFENCES - PARTICULAR OFFENCES

Appeal against acquittal.

The respondent was acquitted by a Judge of the Environment Resources and Development Court of two counts of contravening a condition of an environmental authorisation.

The respondent operated a waste or recycling depot at Wingfield pursuant to a 2013 environmental authorisation subject to conditions. Conditions required that it only receive, process or store waste in the categories Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed) and Commercial and Industrial Waste (General) within the undercover picking station or storage shed. The respondent stored material in stockpiles outside those buildings.

The prosecution’s case at trial was that the material stored in the stockpiles was waste and the material the subject of count 1 was Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed) and the material the subject of count 2 was Commercial and Industrial Waste (General).

The Judge concluded that the material had ceased to be waste because it had been subject to processing and was now a product being refuse derived fuel. The Judge concluded that in any event the meaning of the terms “Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed)” and “Commercial and Industrial Waste (General)” in the authorisation was uncertain such that it could not be concluded that the material comprised either category of waste.

The complainant appeals against the acquittals, contending that the Judge erred on both issues.

Held by Blue J (Lovell and Hinton JJ agreeing):

1.  Under the first limb of the definition of “waste” in the Act, waste is a purposive and relative concept. Material that was formerly waste may be converted from waste into a product. In many cases, it will be a question of fact and degree to determine the point at which waste has changed its character and become a product (at [44]-[46]).

2.  On the evidence adduced at trial, the material in the stockpiles had not been converted into a product and remained waste (at [52]).

3.  Clause 4 of the Environment Protection (Waste to Resources) Policy 2010 made by the Authority does not extend the meaning of waste for the purposes of the Act generally as opposed to the substantive provisions of the Policy itself (at [61] per Blue J and [103] per Hinton J).

4.  If Clause 4 of the Policy had validly extended the definition of waste for the purposes of the Act, the material in question would not have fallen within the extended definition (at [62]-[64]).

5.  The authorisation incorporated the Authority’s September 2009 Waste Guidelines (at [75]).

6.  On the evidence adduced at trial, it was proved beyond reasonable doubt that the material in the stockpiles predominantly comprised C & D Waste. Count 1 was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wood v Adelaide Resource Recovery Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASCFC 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The complainant appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia against the acquittal of Adelaide Resource Recovery Pty Ltd (ARR) in the Environment Court. The dispute concerned whether ARR had breached conditions of its environmental licence by receiving and storing waste materials that were not permitted under its licence. Specifically, the complainant alleged that ARR had received and stockpiled waste that did not fall within the categories of "Commercial and Industrial Waste (General)" or "Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed)" as defined in the licence and associated guidelines.

The legal issues before the Full Court were whether the Environment Court had erred in its findings regarding the nature of the waste received by ARR and whether the waste fell within the permitted categories under the licence. This involved interpreting the definitions of "waste," "Commercial and Industrial Waste (General)," and "Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed)" as set out in the licence and the incorporated EPA Waste Guidelines September 2009. The court also considered the definition of "waste" under section 3(1) of the *Environment Protection Act 1993* (SA) and the potential for an environment protection policy to expand this definition.

The Full Court, in allowing the appeal, reasoned that the material in the stockpile constituted "waste" within the meaning of the Act. The court found that the Environment Court had erred in its interpretation of the licence conditions and the definitions of the permitted waste streams. Specifically, the court clarified the distinction between "Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed)" and "Commercial and Industrial Waste (General)," noting that the former could contain a certain percentage of foreign material, including plastics and timber, provided it did not predominantly consist of such materials or municipal solid waste. The court concluded that the material in question, based on its composition, should have been classified as "Commercial and Industrial Waste (General)" and therefore was permitted under the licence.

The Full Court set aside the acquittal of ARR on count 1 and substituted a conviction. The matter was remitted to the Environment Court for sentencing and to deal with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The complainant appeals against the acquittals, contending that the Judge erred on all issues.Background In the early part of the 2000 decade, Adelaide Brighton Cement Limited commenced using in its calciner an alternative fuel termed “refuse derived fuel”. Adelaide Brighton Cement and Resource Co (a competitor of ARR) formed a joint venture company called the Alternative Fuels Company (AFF). AFF processed high calorific waste containing a high proportion of timber and a lower proportion of plastic by finely shredding it into pieces with a diameter of less than 15 millimetres and sold it to Adelaide Brighton Cement as refuse derived fuel. AFF was the exclusive supplier of refuse derived fuel to Adelaide Brighton Cement until at least October 2013. In 2004, ARR commenced operating a waste or recycling depot (the Depot) at 412-440 Hanson Road, Dry Creek (the Premises). Section 36 of the Environment Protection Act 1993 (SA) (the Act) prohibits the undertaking of “prescribed activities of environmental significance” except as authorised by an environmental authorisation in the form of a licence under Part 6. Schedule 1 defines “prescribed activities of environmental significance” to include as item 3(3) the conduct of a waste or recycling depot, namely a depot for the reception, storage, treatment or disposal of waste (subject to prescribed exceptions) (a waste depot).[2] Section 40 empowers the Environment Protection Authority (the Authority) to grant an environmental authorisation (licence) and section 45 empowers the Authority to impose conditions of a licence.[2] A “waste or recycling depot” referred to in item 3(3) is a phrase referring to a single, composite concept. Recycling falls within the expression “reception, storage, treatment or disposal of waste”: City of Adelaide v Environment Protection Authority [2005] SASC 221, (2005) 139 LGERA 211 at [22] per Debelle J (with whom Vanstone and Anderson JJ agreed). For economy of expression, I refer to the composite concept simply as a “waste depot”. ARR initially operated the Depot under a licence authorising the Adelaide City Council to conduct a waste depot. Since 2007, ARR has held a series of licences (number 18944) in its own name to operate a waste depot. In 2010, the Authority published a “Standard for the production and use of Refuse Derived Fuel” (the RDF Standard). The summary states that all proposals for production and use of refuse derived fuel need to be approved by the Authority and that the RDF Standard will be used to assess proposals. Clause 1.1 states that the RDF Standard applies to the production and use of refuse derived fuel to produce energy for an industrial process within a known market and applications need to identify the producer or supplier and the user. The RDF Standard does not contain any specifications but rather sets out a general methodology for applications and assessment. In June 2013, the Authority issued to ARR the Licence to conduct a waste depot at the Premises up to 31 October 2017 subject to conditions. Condition 3 provides that ARR must “ONLY RECEIVE and/or DISPOSE of waste materials at the Premises that are identified on the ‘Schedule – Permitted Wastes’” attached to the Licence (the Schedule). The Schedule permits ARR to receive, but not to dispose of, the following types of waste:1. Commercial and Industrial Waste (General) (C & I Waste);2. Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed) (C & D Waste);3. Construction and Demolition Waste (Inert);4. Inert Waste;5. Intermediate Soil;6. Waste Fill;7. Low Level Contaminated Soil;8. Low Level Contaminated Waste;9. Green Waste;10. Scrap Metal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The complainant failed to prove count 2 beyond reasonable doubt.Conclusion I would allow the appeal. I would set aside the acquittal of ARR on count 1 and substitute a conviction on count 1. I would remit the matter to the Environment Court for sentencing (including dealing with costs). LOVELL J: I agree with Blue J. HINTON J: I have had the benefit of reading the judgment of Blue J for which I am grateful. I agree with Blue J for the reasons he gives that the material in the stockpile was waste within the meaning of the first limb of the definition of waste contained in s 3(1) of the Environment Protection Act 1993 (SA) (EPA). I turn to the question of whether the definition of waste as contained in s 3(1) EPA is expanded by the Environment Protection (Waste to Resources) Policy 2010 (SA) (the Policy). The definition of waste in s 3(1) EPA is as follows:(1) In this Act, unless the contrary intention appears –…waste means –(a)any discarded, rejected, abandoned, unwanted or surplus matter, whether or not intended for sale or for recycling, reprocessing, recovery or purification by a separate operation from that which produced the matter; or(b)anything declared by regulation (after consultation under section 5A) or by an environment protection policy to be waste, whether of value or not. On a literal reading of the definition matter will be waste for the purposes of the EPA if it answers the description contained in paragraph (a), or, is declared by regulation (after consultation under section 5A) to be waste, or, is declared by an environment protection policy to be waste. If paragraph (b) were construed as conferring a power limited only by the scope and purpose of the EPA it could not be doubted that such power could be exercised to expand or contract the meaning of waste contained in paragraph (a). That could have far reaching consequences for the application of the EPA. It would be unusual for the Parliament to delegate such power save in express terms. For the reasons that follow I do not think that paragraph (b) confers such power. The first of the two methods of declaring anything to be waste as contained in paragraph (b) requires the making of a regulation. Paragraph (b), however, does not identify who may make such regulation nor purport to confer power on any office or person. Section 140 EPA confers power on the Governor to “make such regulations as are contemplated by, or as are necessary or expedient for the purposes of” the EPA. In my view the power to make the declaration contemplated by the first method referred to in paragraph (b) is to be found in s 140 EPA. Paragraph (b) conditions the exercise of that power on compliance with s 5A EPA. Section 5A EPA, like the first method subject of paragraph (b) assumes the existence of a regulation making power provided for somewhere else. If this analysis is correct, the ambit of a declaration made by regulation for the purposes of paragraph (b) is constrained by the limits on the power to make regulations and the purpose of regulations. Further, it takes its character from the nature of the power to make regulations. By that I mean it is intended to supplement the operation of the Act. That suggests that the first method contained in paragraph (b) is not intended to function as an alternative to the definition contained in paragraph (a) but as permitting an expansion of the definition by declaring a thing to be waste for the purposes of the regulation made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On appeal, the complainant challenges each of these conclusions.Incorporation of Guidelines into Licence Condition 3 of the Licence provides:PERMITTED WASTES – RECEIPT AND/OR DISPOSALThe Licensee must:1.ONLY RECEIVE and/or DISPOSE of waste materials at the Premises that are identified on the ‘Schedule – Permitted Wastes’ attachment to this Licence;2.submit written application to the EPA to amend waste materials listed on the ‘Schedule’. The Schedule contains two tables. The first table is entitled:TABLE 1 – Permitted Waste Streams – EPA Waste Guidelines September 2009 Table 1 then lists 28 waste streams in alphabetical order, each of which is defined in the Guidelines. It shows that ARR is permitted to receive six of those waste streams, including C & D Waste and C & I Waste. These waste streams are generally not defined in the definition section at the beginning of the Licence. The second table is entitled:TABLE 2 – Permitted Waste Streams – Falling outside of EPA Waste Guidelines September 2009 Table 2 then lists 11 waste streams, of which ARR is permitted to receive four. These waste streams are generally defined (with the exception of scrap metal which has its ordinary English meaning) in the definition section at the beginning of the Licence. The Guidelines are explicitly incorporated into table 1 of the Schedule to the Licence.C & D Waste The Guidelines define Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed) as follows:Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed) The solid component of waste stream arising from the construction, demolition or refurbishment of buildings or infrastructure which contains some foreign material (as set out below), but does not contain Municipal Solid Waste, Commercial and Industrial Waste (General), Listed Waste, Hazardous Waste or Radioactive Waste.Notes:C&D Waste is considered C&D Waste (Mixed) if it contains significant foreign materials from construction and demolition activities that would render the load of waste no longer inert (as a guide, 5−25% maximum by volume per load). Foreign material includes green waste, plastics, electrical wiring, timber, paper, insulation, tins, packaging and other waste associated with construction or demolition of a building or other infrastructure. Foreign material must not be Municipal Solid Waste, Liquid, Listed, Hazardous or Radioactive Waste. Where waste from construction and demolition sites contains predominantly foreign materials or domestic waste, such as waste from household clean-ups collected by commercial skip bins, this is defined as Commercial and Industrial Waste (General). C & D Waste is differentiated from Construction and Demolition Waste (Inert), which is defined as follows:Construction and Demolition Waste (Inert) The solid component of waste stream arising from the construction, demolition or refurbishment of buildings or infrastructure but does not contain Municipal Solid Waste, Commercial and Industrial Waste (General), Listed Waste, Hazardous Waste or Radioactive Waste.Notes:C&D waste (Inert) should be such that the entire composition of the C&D materials is Inert Waste with no contamination by foreign material. As such it is acknowledged that – with the owner of no contamination – there may be some negligible components of foreign material contained in the waste (as a guide, 0−5% maximum by volume per load). C&D waste (Inert) includes bricks, concrete, tiles and ceramics, steel and inert soils.Foreign material includes green waste, plastics, electrical wiring, timber, paper, insulation, tins, packaging and other waste associated with construction or demolition of a building or other infrastructure. Foreign material must not be Municipal Solid Waste, Liquid, Listed, Hazardous or Radioactive Waste.