SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Full Court: Civil)
WOOD v ADELAIDE RESOURCE RECOVERY PTY LTD
[2017] SASCFC 13
Judgment of The Full Court
(The Honourable Justice Blue, The Honourable Justice Lovell and The Honourable Justice Hinton)
20 February 2017
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - POLLUTION - WASTE DISPOSAL - REGULATION - LICENSING - CONDITIONS
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - POLLUTION - WASTE DISPOSAL - OFFENCES - PARTICULAR OFFENCES
Appeal against acquittal.
The respondent was acquitted by a Judge of the Environment Resources and Development Court of two counts of contravening a condition of an environmental authorisation.
The respondent operated a waste or recycling depot at Wingfield pursuant to a 2013 environmental authorisation subject to conditions. Conditions required that it only receive, process or store waste in the categories Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed) and Commercial and Industrial Waste (General) within the undercover picking station or storage shed. The respondent stored material in stockpiles outside those buildings.
The prosecution’s case at trial was that the material stored in the stockpiles was waste and the material the subject of count 1 was Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed) and the material the subject of count 2 was Commercial and Industrial Waste (General).
The Judge concluded that the material had ceased to be waste because it had been subject to processing and was now a product being refuse derived fuel. The Judge concluded that in any event the meaning of the terms “Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed)” and “Commercial and Industrial Waste (General)” in the authorisation was uncertain such that it could not be concluded that the material comprised either category of waste.
The complainant appeals against the acquittals, contending that the Judge erred on both issues.
Held by Blue J (Lovell and Hinton JJ agreeing):
1. Under the first limb of the definition of “waste” in the Act, waste is a purposive and relative concept. Material that was formerly waste may be converted from waste into a product. In many cases, it will be a question of fact and degree to determine the point at which waste has changed its character and become a product (at [44]-[46]).
2. On the evidence adduced at trial, the material in the stockpiles had not been converted into a product and remained waste (at [52]).
3. Clause 4 of the Environment Protection (Waste to Resources) Policy 2010 made by the Authority does not extend the meaning of waste for the purposes of the Act generally as opposed to the substantive provisions of the Policy itself (at [61] per Blue J and [103] per Hinton J).
4. If Clause 4 of the Policy had validly extended the definition of waste for the purposes of the Act, the material in question would not have fallen within the extended definition (at [62]-[64]).
5. The authorisation incorporated the Authority’s September 2009 Waste Guidelines (at [75]).
6. On the evidence adduced at trial, it was proved beyond reasonable doubt that the material in the stockpiles predominantly comprised C & D Waste. Count 1 was…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wood v Adelaide Resource Recovery Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] SASCFC 13
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Full Court were whether the Environment Court had erred in its findings regarding the nature of the waste received by ARR and whether the waste fell within the permitted categories under the licence. This involved interpreting the definitions of "waste," "Commercial and Industrial Waste (General)," and "Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed)" as set out in the licence and the incorporated EPA Waste Guidelines September 2009. The court also considered the definition of "waste" under section 3(1) of the *Environment Protection Act 1993* (SA) and the potential for an environment protection policy to expand this definition.
The Full Court, in allowing the appeal, reasoned that the material in the stockpile constituted "waste" within the meaning of the Act. The court found that the Environment Court had erred in its interpretation of the licence conditions and the definitions of the permitted waste streams. Specifically, the court clarified the distinction between "Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed)" and "Commercial and Industrial Waste (General)," noting that the former could contain a certain percentage of foreign material, including plastics and timber, provided it did not predominantly consist of such materials or municipal solid waste. The court concluded that the material in question, based on its composition, should have been classified as "Commercial and Industrial Waste (General)" and therefore was permitted under the licence.
The Full Court set aside the acquittal of ARR on count 1 and substituted a conviction. The matter was remitted to the Environment Court for sentencing and to deal with costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
On appeal, the complainant challenges each of these conclusions.Incorporation of Guidelines into Licence Condition 3 of the Licence provides:PERMITTED WASTES – RECEIPT AND/OR DISPOSALThe Licensee must:1.ONLY RECEIVE and/or DISPOSE of waste materials at the Premises that are identified on the ‘Schedule – Permitted Wastes’ attachment to this Licence;2.submit written application to the EPA to amend waste materials listed on the ‘Schedule’. The Schedule contains two tables. The first table is entitled:TABLE 1 – Permitted Waste Streams – EPA Waste Guidelines September 2009 Table 1 then lists 28 waste streams in alphabetical order, each of which is defined in the Guidelines. It shows that ARR is permitted to receive six of those waste streams, including C & D Waste and C & I Waste. These waste streams are generally not defined in the definition section at the beginning of the Licence. The second table is entitled:TABLE 2 – Permitted Waste Streams – Falling outside of EPA Waste Guidelines September 2009 Table 2 then lists 11 waste streams, of which ARR is permitted to receive four. These waste streams are generally defined (with the exception of scrap metal which has its ordinary English meaning) in the definition section at the beginning of the Licence. The Guidelines are explicitly incorporated into table 1 of the Schedule to the Licence.C & D Waste The Guidelines define Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed) as follows:Construction and Demolition Waste (Mixed) The solid component of waste stream arising from the construction, demolition or refurbishment of buildings or infrastructure which contains some foreign material (as set out below), but does not contain Municipal Solid Waste, Commercial and Industrial Waste (General), Listed Waste, Hazardous Waste or Radioactive Waste.Notes:C&D Waste is considered C&D Waste (Mixed) if it contains significant foreign materials from construction and demolition activities that would render the load of waste no longer inert (as a guide, 5−25% maximum by volume per load). Foreign material includes green waste, plastics, electrical wiring, timber, paper, insulation, tins, packaging and other waste associated with construction or demolition of a building or other infrastructure. Foreign material must not be Municipal Solid Waste, Liquid, Listed, Hazardous or Radioactive Waste. Where waste from construction and demolition sites contains predominantly foreign materials or domestic waste, such as waste from household clean-ups collected by commercial skip bins, this is defined as Commercial and Industrial Waste (General). C & D Waste is differentiated from Construction and Demolition Waste (Inert), which is defined as follows:Construction and Demolition Waste (Inert) The solid component of waste stream arising from the construction, demolition or refurbishment of buildings or infrastructure but does not contain Municipal Solid Waste, Commercial and Industrial Waste (General), Listed Waste, Hazardous Waste or Radioactive Waste.Notes:C&D waste (Inert) should be such that the entire composition of the C&D materials is Inert Waste with no contamination by foreign material. As such it is acknowledged that – with the owner of no contamination – there may be some negligible components of foreign material contained in the waste (as a guide, 0−5% maximum by volume per load). C&D waste (Inert) includes bricks, concrete, tiles and ceramics, steel and inert soils.Foreign material includes green waste, plastics, electrical wiring, timber, paper, insulation, tins, packaging and other waste associated with construction or demolition of a building or other infrastructure. Foreign material must not be Municipal Solid Waste, Liquid, Listed, Hazardous or Radioactive Waste.