[2009] QSC 266
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CIVIL JURISDICTION
P LYONS J
No 12405 of 2008
| MARINA WONG and GLOBAL CEMENT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD. | Plaintiff Plaintiff |
| and | |
| ANTHONY JOHN HUISMAN and GREGORY ALLAN ISON and LORRAINE ISON | Defendant Defendant Defendant |
BRISBANE
..DATE 22/07/2009
ORDER
HIS HONOUR: In this action the first and second plaintiffs have sued the defendants for an amount of $194,000 as a result of the defendants having called on a bank guarantee issued by the Bank of Queensland Limited, and the second plaintiff has claimed a further sum of $887,000.
The defendants now seek an order for security for costs.
It is necessary to say a little more about the action. The statement of claim alleges that the defendants were the registered proprietors of land at 120, Gosport Street, Hemmant. That was the subject of a lease in favour of the second plaintiff. It was a term of the lease that the tenant provide a guarantee by a bank for the due performance by the tenant of its obligations under the lease. There was a further term of the lease that the landlord might call up the bank guarantee to compensate the landlord for the loss suffered as a result of a failure by the tenant to perform its obligations under the lease.
The statement of claim alleges that on 1st of July, 2008, the defendants wrongfully purported to determine the lease and that on the 8th of July, the second plaintiff accepted the defendant's conduct as repudiating the lease, and it self-terminated the lease.
It also alleges that the second plaintiff was the owner of certain chattels of which the defendants took possession on re-entry, and which they caused to be destroyed.
The statement of claim also alleges that the defendants called up the amount payable under the bank guarantee of $194,000. The claim previously mentioned made by both plaintiffs for the sum of $194,000 relates to the calling up by the defendants of the bank guarantee, and the claim of the second plaintiff for $887,000 is in respect of the chattels.
The second plaintiff is a company. The title to the action states that a controller has been appointed to it. I am told that receivers were appointed on the 20th of February, 2008, pursuant to a fixed and floating charge held by National Australia Bank Limited. The action was commenced on the 2nd of December, 2008. On the 13th of February, 2009, the solicitors for the defendants wrote to the solicitors for the plaintiffs expressing concern about "Your client's financial position", and referring to the appointment of a receiver/manager, and the appointment of controllers.
A schedule in the letter identified estimated costs totalling $51,598.50 on the basis of a three day trial, and calling for payment of that amount into Court as security.
On the 27th of March, 2009, solicitors for the defendants again wrote to the solicitors for the plaintiffs. That letter referred to the letter of 13th of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wong & Global Cement Australia P/L v Huisman and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] QSC 266
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues revolved around whether the court should grant the defendants' application for security for costs, considering the financial position of the second plaintiff and the prospects of success of the claim. The court considered the report from the receivers of the second plaintiff, which revealed significant financial difficulties, and the arguments presented by both parties regarding the merits of the claim and the delay in bringing the application.
The court found that there was reason to believe that the second plaintiff would not be able to pay the defendants' costs if ordered to do so. The court also found that the presence of the first plaintiff as a co-plaintiff did not prevent the application for security for costs, as the main claim was brought by the second plaintiff. Additionally, the court deemed the delay in bringing the application and the amount sought as security to be insufficient grounds to refuse the application.
The court ordered the second plaintiff to provide security for costs in the amount of $51,598.50, which was considered reasonable given the estimated length of the trial and the amounts in issue.
Background
Background to the litigation
The action was commenced on 2nd December 2008. The defendants filed and served a notice of intention to defend and defence on 5th January 2009, to which the plaintiffs filed and served a reply on 19th January 2009. On 2nd February 2009, the plaintiffs applied for further and better particulars of the defence, which were provided on about 16 February 2009. On 13th February 2009, the solicitors for the defendants expressed concern about the plaintiffs' financial position and requested payment of estimated costs of $51,598.50 as security for costs. The plaintiffs responded on 27th March 2009, stating they were awaiting final instructions regarding security for costs and challenging the amount claimed. On the same day, the defendants notified the plaintiffs of their intention to proceed with a Court application. The current application was filed on 14th July 2009. On 28th April 2009, the defendants applied for the second plaintiff's claim to be struck out due to the second plaintiff being in receivership, but this application was dismissed on 5th June 2009. The plaintiffs and defendants made disclosure on 24th April 2009 and 1st May 2009, respectively.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the second plaintiff is a corporation and there is reason to believe the plaintiff will not be able to pay the defendant's costs if ordered to pay them.
2. Whether the prospects of success or the merits of the proceeding warrant the refusal of the application for security for costs.
3. Whether the delay in bringing the application for security for costs is significant enough to warrant the refusal of the application.
4. Whether the quantum of security sought is appropriate given the amounts in issue and the estimated length of the trial.
Held
1. The court concluded that the second plaintiff is a corporation and there is reason to believe the plaintiff will not be able to pay the defendant's costs if ordered to pay them.
2. The court concluded that the prospects of success or the merits of the proceeding do not warrant the refusal of the application for security for costs.
3. The court concluded that the delay in bringing the application for security for costs is not significant enough to warrant the refusal of the application.
4. The court concluded that the quantum of security sought is appropriate given the amounts in issue and the estimated length of the trial.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the application for security for costs under Rule 670 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The court was satisfied that the second plaintiff is a corporation and there is reason to believe it would not be able to pay the costs of the defendants if ordered to pay them based on the report from the receivers indicating a significant shortfall in the company's assets. The court found that the presence of the first plaintiff, who is a natural person, did not warrant the refusal of the application for security for costs as the substance of the action is the claim by the second plaintiff and not that of the first plaintiff. The court also found that the delay in bringing the application was not significant enough to warrant refusal, considering the circumstances and the fact that the application was brought shortly after the holiday period. Finally, the court determined that the quantum of security sought, which is over $51,000, is appropriate given the amounts in issue and the estimated length of the trial. The court did not consider the merits of the claim but focused on the ability of the plaintiffs to pay costs and the other discretionary factors under Rule 672 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.