WKBF and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

Applicant:WKBF

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2023/6813

Tribunal:Senior Member A. Nikolic  

Place:Melbourne

Date:13 December 2024  

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.................[SGD].......................................................

Senior Member A. Nikolic

Catchwords
MIGRATION – mandatory visa cancellation – citizen of Ethiopia – where Applicant granted Class AY (Subclass 104) Preferential Family Visa – substantial criminal record – failure to pass good character test – mandatory visa cancellation – non-revocation decision – diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia – guardian appointed – reviewable decision affirmed by previously constituted Tribunal – application remitted by Federal Court of Australia – whether another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation of Applicant’s visa – Ministerial Direction no. 110 applied – reviewable decision affirmed

Legislation
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)
Mental Health and Wellbeing Act 2022 (Vic)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)
Migration Amendment (Clarifying International Obligations for Removal) Act 2021 (Cth)
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)
Social Security Act 1991 (Cth)
Social Security (Administration) Act 1999 (Cth) Sch 2 Cl 4

Cases
Ali v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 650
Andrew and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2024] AATA 3279
Assistant Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Splendido (2019) 271 FCR 595
Bettencourt v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2021) 287 FCR 294
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
BFMV v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 199
BOE21 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCAFC 99
CGX20 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2021) 284 FCR 416
CRNL v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCAFC 138
CTK17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCA 1211
DOB18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 1523
DLZZ and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] AATA 3922
EPL20 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2021) 288 FCR 158
Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2019) 266 CLR 250
FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs (2019) 272 FCR 454
FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs and Anor [2020] HCA Trans 056
Hughes v The Queen (2017) 263 CLR 338
Ibrahim v Minister for Home Affairs (2019) 270 FCR 12
Ismail v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 2
Jagroop v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2016) 241 FCR 461
Leota v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCA 1120
Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs v ERY19 (2021) 285 FCR 540
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Obele (2010) 119 ALD 358

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs v Thornton [2023] HCA 17
Murphy v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 1924
Nathanson v Minister for Home Affairs (2022) 276 CLR 80

NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship & Multicultural Affairs [2023]

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read WKBF and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ARTA 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Applicant, a citizen of Ethiopia with an extensive criminal history and diagnosed paranoid schizophrenia, sought a review of the Minister's decision to not revoke the mandatory cancellation of his visa. The Minister had cancelled the Applicant's visa due to his substantial criminal record, which included crimes of violence and drug-related offences. Despite his long residence in Australia, the Applicant's visa was cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) as he failed to pass the good character test. The Applicant's initial application for revocation of the visa cancellation was rejected by the Tribunal, but the Federal Court of Australia quashed this decision due to material jurisdictional error and remitted the matter for re-determination.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether there was another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant's visa. The Tribunal considered the Ministerial Direction no. 110 which outlines the criteria for considering the non-revocation of a mandatory visa cancellation. The Applicant's lawyer argued that the Applicant's mental health condition, specifically his paranoid schizophrenia and recent relapse, warranted revocation. The Tribunal had to assess the weight of this consideration against the expectations of the Australian community as outlined in the Direction.

The Tribunal found that the Applicant's mental health condition did not provide a compelling reason to revoke the visa cancellation. While the Applicant's schizophrenia and recent relapse were significant, the Tribunal determined that they did not outweigh the strong community expectation that individuals with serious criminal records should not be allowed to remain in Australia. The Tribunal also noted that the Applicant's ongoing involvement with illicit drugs and potential non-compliance with medication further supported the community's expectation for visa cancellation. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the Minister's decision not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant's visa.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons the Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision. BACKGROUND The Applicant is a 44-year-old citizen of Ethiopia. He arrived in Australia on 13 December 1997 when 17 years of age and has not departed since.[1] [1] Exhibit R1, 388. The Applicant has an extensive criminal history since 2004 resulting in multiple sentences of imprisonment.[2] He has committed crimes of violence or involving the threat of violence. This includes intentionally and recklessly causing injury, recklessly threatening to inflict grievous bodily harm, and aggravated burglary while a person was present. He has also possessed weapons, trafficked illicit drugs, resisted police and emergency workers, breached conditional liberty orders, contravened intervention orders, and committed other dishonesty, property damage, and public nuisance offences.[2] Ibid 54-9. The Applicant has a persistent history of polydrug abuse including intravenous use of heroin and methamphetamine.[3] He has been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia[4] and amphetamine use disorder.[5] The Applicant also has a history of mental health relapses in the context of non-compliance with antipsychotic medication and/or misuse of illicit drugs.[6] He has previously been placed on an inpatient treatment order.[7] The Public Advocate has been his legal guardian since 17 February 2023.[8][3] Ibid 103-4 [44]-[45], 106.[4] Ibid 667 [135], 1105 [8 (a)].[5] Ibid 724 [36]; 773 [19].[6] Ibid 116 [28], 707.[7] Ibid 708-11.[8] Ibid 330-1.Procedural history This application has an extensive procedural history as follows:(a)On 3 May 2012, the Applicant was notified of an intention to consider cancelling his visa because of a substantial criminal record.[9][9] Ibid 380-5.(b)On 19 June 2012, the Respondent decided not to cancel the visa and instead issued the following formal warning:‘After taking into account all relevant considerations, a delegate of the Minister has made a decision not to cancel your visa on character grounds on this occasion. Your current Class AY Subclass 104 Preferential Family visa will continue to provide you with permission to remain in Australia. However the delegate decided that you are to be given the following formal warning.Please note that visa cancellation may be reconsidered if you commit further offences or otherwise breach the character test in future. Disregard of this warning will weigh heavily against you if your case is reconsidered’.[10][10] Ibid 386-7.(Emphasis in original).(c)The Applicant continued to reoffend. (d)On 18 September 2018, while he was serving a term of imprisonment, the Respondent cancelled his visa on character grounds as required under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”).[11] The Applicant was invited to make representations to have the cancellation decision revoked but failed to do so within the permissible 28-day period. A revocation request sent by Refugee Legal on 8 January 2019 was refused.[12][11] Ibid 81-5.[12] Ibid 74.(e)Between January and November 2020, Refugee Legal wrote to the Respondent alleging the Applicant was invalidly notified of the cancellation decision. The Applicant’s ‘capacity and personal circumstances’ were invoked[13] and an intention conveyed to file proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.[14][13] Ibid 89.[14] Ibid 94.(f)On 3 March 2022, the Applicant was renotified of the mandatory cancellation decision.[15] Refugee Legal made representations on his behalf during 2022 and 2023 seeking revocation.[16] This was complicated by a concurrent guardianship process with multiple extensions of time granted for submissions.[15] Ibid 477-84. Pursuant to EPL20 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2021) 288 FCR 158; and Sillars v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2021) 288 FCR 180.[16] Exhibit R1, 489, 503, 507.(g)On 17 February 2023, the Office of the Public Advocate was appointed as the Applicant’s litigation guardian.[17][17] Ibid 330, 681.(h)On 8 September 2023, the Applicant and his lawyer were advised that a delegate of the Respondent had decided not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the visa (“non-revocation decision”).[18][18] Ibid 25-8.(i)On 15 September 2023, the Applicant asked the Tribunal to review the non-revocation decision.[19][19] Ibid 18-24.(j)On 1 December 2023, the Tribunal, differently constituted, affirmed the reviewable decision (“2023 hearing”).[20] [20] WKBF and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023](k)The Applicant appealed. On 6 May 2024, the Federal Court of Australia quashed the Tribunal’s decision by consent of the parties because of material jurisdictional error. Justice Hespe accepted that the Tribunal had regard to three offences where convictions were not recorded, which were irrelevant considerations pursuant to Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs v Thornton [2023] HCA 17.[21] Her Honour remitted the matter to the Tribunal for re-determination according to law, thereby enlivening the current proceeding.[21] Exhibit R1, 1989.(l)It is noteworthy that parallel to the reviewable decision currently before the Tribunal, the Applicant applied for a Protection Visa on 7 February 2019.[22] The procedural history of that separate application is now summarised:[22] Ibid 798 [7].(i)On 8 July 2019, the Applicant’s Protection Visa application was refused by a delegate of the Minister, which was in turn affirmed by the Migration and Review Division (“MRD”) of this Tribunal on 16 September 2019.[23][23] Ibid 801 [26].(ii)On 3 March 2020, the Federal Circuit Court, ordered by consent that the MRD decision should be quashed because it was affected by jurisdictional error. The matter was remitted for reconsideration according to law.[24][24] Ibid.(iii)On 21 December 2020, the Tribunal, differently constituted, decided the Applicant is a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under 36(2)(a) of the Act. The application was remitted to the Respondent for reconsideration.[25](iv)On 5 January 2023, a delegate of the Respondent refused to grant the Protection Visa under s 65 of the Act because the Applicant failed to satisfy the criterion at s 36(1C)(b) of the Act (danger to the Australia community).(v)The Applicant asked the Tribunal to review this decision, and, on 13 November 2023, the Tribunal set aside the delegate’s decision and remitted the matter to the Respondent for reconsideration with a direction that the Applicant satisfies s 36(1)(b) of the Act and is not ineligible for the grant of a Protection Visa.[26] (vi)On 16 August 2024 the Minister issued the Applicant with a notice of intention to consider refusal of the Protection Visa under s 501(1) of the Act.[27](m)On the second hearing day of the current proceeding (29 October 2024), just prior to closing submissions, Mr Hughan advised the Tribunal that correspondence was received from the Respondent’s Department a few minutes earlier that changed the Applicant’s circumstances. Leave was sought and granted for a 30-minute adjournment to enable further enquiries. The following then occurred:(i)Upon resumption, Mr Hughan advised that the Applicant’s Protection Visa application was refused, and he would likely be released on a Bridging (Class WR) Visa R (“BVR”).(ii)Another adjournment was granted until 2:00 pm to enable further enquiries. Upon resumption, Mr Hughan advised that the Applicant had been granted a BVR, the details of which were currently being conveyed to his public guardian. Mr Hill confirmed receipt of instructions about the grant of a BVR. He also informed the Tribunal that IHMS[28] had undertaken a Special Needs Health Assessment and formed the view that the Applicant ‘didn’t currently meet the criteria for treatment under the Mental Health Act’. Reference was made to supports available to the Applicant through the Status Resolution Support Services (“SRSS”).[29](iii)The Tribunal adjourned the hearing until 12 November 2024, the next available date for parties, for updated closing submissions.[25] Ibid 158-93.[26] WKBF and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023]AATA 3728.[27] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues, and Contentions dated 1 October 2024, 5 [25] (‘RSFIC’); Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues, and Contentions dated 27 August 2024, 3 [16] (‘ASFIC’).[28] International Health and Medical Services (IHMS), which provides primary and mental health care services within the Australian immigration detention network.[29] Exhibit R6.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Over 2000 pages of documents were tendered into evidence as follows:(a)Remittal bundle numbering 1999 pages;[43][43] Exhibit R1.(b)Additional remittal bundle numbering 127 pages;[44][44] Exhibit R2.(c)Copy of Migration Amendment (Bridging Visa Conditions) Regulations 2024 (Cth) dated 7 November 2024, covering an amended copy of Sch 2, item 070 incorporating amendments from those Regulations;[45][45] Exhibit R3.(d)Notice of Visa Refusal dated 29 October 2024 relating to the refusal of the Applicant’s Protection Visa application;[46][46] Exhibit R4.(e)Notice dated 29 October 2024 relating to the grant of a BVR to the Applicant;[47][47] Exhibit R5.(f)IHMS Health Discharge Summary dated 29 October 2024 with IHMS Special Needs Assessment dated 18 October 2024;[48][48] Exhibit R6.(g)Two-page email summary from Status Resolution Support Programs dated 29 October 2024 relating to the Applicant’s support entitlements under his BVR;[49][49] Exhibit R7.(h)Notice dated 7 November 2024 relating to the grant of a BVR to the Applicant;[50](i)Temporary Treatment Order from Monash Health dated 5 November 2024 enabling an inpatient assessment of the Applicant;[51](j)VCAT Order dated 1 November 2024 regarding the appointment of an administrator;[52](k)Statutory Declaration of Rosemary Therese Barker, Office of the Public Advocate, dated 21 October 2024;[53](l)Psychiatric report of forensic psychiatrist Dr Nina Zimmerman dated 16 October 2024, covering letter of instruction dated 8 October 2024 from Refugee Legal;[54](m)VCAT Notice of Hearing dated 6 August 2024;[55](n)Notice dated 16 August 2024 regarding the Respondent’s intention to consider refusal of the Applicant’s Protection (Class XA) visa application;[56](o)Online documents titled ‘Do you meet the residence requirements – NDIS’ and ‘Residence descriptions’ from Services Australia regarding entitlement to a Centrelink payment or concession card;[57](p)Statutory Declaration of Rosemary Therese Barker, Office of the Public Advocate, dated 7 November 2024;[58] and(q)Listing notice from the Tribunal dated 7 November 2024 relating to merits review of the decision to refuse the Applicant’s Protection Visa application.[59][50] Exhibit R8.[51] Exhibit R9.[52] Exhibit R10.[53] Exhibit A1.[54] Exhibit A2.[55] Exhibit A3.[56] Exhibit A4.[57] Exhibit A5.[58] Exhibit A6.[59] Exhibit A7.Oral evidence The Applicant did not give oral testimony at either the 2023 hearing or the current proceeding based on expert evidence that his psychosis renders him incapable of giving legal instructions or making legal decisions.[60] He remains under a Guardianship Order. [60] ASFIC, 1 [3]; 2 [7]; Exhibit R1, 668 [152]. The Applicant relied on a Statement of Facts, Issues, and Contentions (“SFIC”)[61] dated 27 August 2024, and reply submissions dated 21 October 2024 to the Respondent’s SFIC dated 1 October 2024. It was initially submitted he continues to rely on the SFIC lodged for the first hearing in late 2023 ‘to the extent that anything contained therein is referred to or developed’ in the latest SFIC.[62] Upon resumption of the hearing on 12 November 2024, both parties verbally amended their SFIC to incorporate the events of the previous fortnight.Expert evidence – documentary[61] A SFIC is akin to a pleadings document in a judicial proceeding.[62] ASFIC, 1 [3].Documentary evidence: Dr Zimmerman and Associate Professor Sullivan

Decision

Reasons for decision

The duration of the Applicant’s residence in Australia is long but has not been accompanied by the development of strong family or other prosocial ties. On the best reading of the evidence, only slight weight is placed on this primary consideration in favour of revocation.Best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision No submissions were advanced by either party regarding this primary consideration. The evidence does not disclose that the interests of any minor children are enlivened within the meaning of the Direction. It follows that this primary consideration carries neutral weight.Expectations of the Australian community Clause 8.5(1) of the Direction identifies the expectations of the Australian community: (1) The Australian community expects non-citizens to obey Australian laws while in Australia. Where a non-citizen has engaged in serious conduct in breach of this expectation, or where there is an unacceptable risk that they may do so, the Australian community, as a norm, expects the Government to not allow such a non-citizen to enter or remain in Australia. Clause 8.5(2) of the Direction states:In addition, visa cancellation or refusal, or non-revocation of the mandatory cancellation of a visa, may be appropriate simply because the nature of the character concerns or offences is such that the Australian community would expect that the person should not be granted or continue to hold a visa. In particular, the Australian community expects that the Australian Government can and should refuse entry to non-citizens, or cancel their visas, if they raise serious character concerns through conduct, in Australia or elsewhere, of the following kind:a)acts of family violence; orb)causing a person to enter into, or being party to (other than being a victim of), a forced marriage;c)commission of serious crimes against women, children or other vulnerable members of the community such as the elderly or disabled; in this context, 'serious crimes' include crimes of a violent or sexual nature, as well as other serious crimes against the elderly or other vulnerable persons in the form of fraud, extortion, financial abuse/material exploitation or neglect;d)commission of crimes against government representatives or officials due to the position they hold, or in the performance of their duties; ore)involvement or reasonably suspected involvement in human trafficking or people smuggling, or in crimes that are of serious international concern including, but not limited to, war crimes, crimes against humanity and slavery; orf)worker exploitation. Clause 8.5(3) of the Direction provides that the above expectations apply regardless of whether the non-citizen poses a measurable risk of causing physical harm to the Australian community. Clause 8.5(4) of the Direction provides that this consideration is ‘about the expectations of the Australian community as a whole’, and decision-makers are to proceed based on the Government’s views as articulated in the Direction, without independently assessing the community’s expectations in a particular case. This correlates with the reasoning in FYBR[156] where the plurality held that this primary consideration is a deeming provision with normative principles, ascribing to the community an expectation aligning with that of the executive government. The reasoning in FYBR establishes that the ‘deemed community expectation’ will in most cases call for cancellation, but ‘the question of whether it is appropriate to act in accordance with the deemed community expectation is in all cases left for the decision-maker to determine’.[157] The High Court then refused an application for special leave to appeal from the orders in FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs and Anor.[158] [156] FYBRv Minister for Home Affairs (2019) 272 FCR 454, 471–2 [66] (Charlesworth J), 476 [91] (Stewart J) (‘FYBR’).[157] Ibid 473 [75]–[76] (Charlesworth J).[158] FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs and Anor [2020] HCA Trans 56.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Upon the resumption of the hearing on 12 November 2024, a further four-page Statutory Declaration was tendered from Ms Barker dealing with events since the Applicant’s release from immigration detention on 29 October 2024.[98] Ms Barker also gave oral evidence, key aspects of which are summarised as follows:(a)Ms Barker said she has been the Applicant’s guardian since April 2023 and the VCAT guardianship order remains in place until reassessed. When asked how long she expects the order to remain, Ms Barker said this depends on how quickly the Applicant’s mental health is stabilised. She believes ‘he will need a guardian for longer’ to assist with things such as accommodation, access to services and in relation to his legal proceedings.(b)Ms Barker said she has spoken to the Applicant four times since his release on 29 October 2024, but he ‘always hung up’. She attempted to inform him during these calls of a VCAT hearing and to discuss other guardianship issues. The Applicant has not responded to her text messages.(c)Ms Barker said she applied for an administration order to VCAT on 31 October 2024 and the State Trustee had since been appointed as the Applicant’s financial administrator. She has taken this step because the Applicant is receiving a Special Benefit from Centrelink since release. Ms Barker said the Applicant is also entitled to 12 weeks of accommodation paid for under the SRSS.(d)When referred to IHMS documents at Exhibit R6, Ms Barker said she advocated for the Applicant to have a mental health assessment with a ‘clinician’ on the day of his release from immigration detention, but this did not occur.(e)Ms Barker said that as of 7 November 2024 the Applicant remained admitted to an acute bed at a ‘High Dependency Unit’ under a Temporary Treatment Order issued on 5 November 2024,[99] which remains in effect for 28 days. The Applicant will be assessed as to ‘what order should follow’ and Ms Barker was informed by a nurse that testing is being undertaken about the most efficacious medication for his needs. She said this has consisted of oral medication to date rather than depot injections.(f)Ms Barker said there ‘may be a hearing’ before the MHT to decide next steps. She intends preparing a report and advocating for a new Treatment Order when the current order expires. Ms Barker also intends advocating to the Chief Psychiatrist in Victoria regarding a SECU bed to advance the treatment plan proposed by Dr Zimmerman. Ms Barker is concerned if the Applicant is ‘released too early [from an acute setting] he may not comply with his medication regime’. (g)Ms Barker said she is unaware if the Applicant has used illicit drugs or alcohol since release. Although compliant with his prescribed dose of methadone in immigration detention, Ms Barker said he has since refused to take it.(h)Ms Barker said she is unaware if the Applicant has been involved in any offending or violent acts since release but stated she has received reports from a nurse that the Applicant ‘is stable and reasonably quiet on the unit’.[98] Exhibit A6.[99] Exhibit R9.PRIMARY AND OTHER CONSIDERATIONS