Wissmann v Nugent

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:  Wissmann v Nugent [2022] QIRC 058
PARTIES:  Wissmann, Annika
(Complainant)
v
Nugent, Frederick
(Respondent)
CASE NO.:  AD/2020/108
PROCEEDING:  Application in existing proceedings
DELIVERED ON:  25 February 2022
HEARING DATE:  11 January 2022
MEMBER:  Power IC
HEARD AT:  Brisbane
ORDERS: 
1.  The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed

on 8 October 2021 issued to Dr Salesh Dheda be varied and Dr Salesh Dheda is directed to disclose any documents and electronic records, including notes and dates, relating to the Complainant's back injury within 14 days of this order.

2.       The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed on 25 October 2021 issued to David Anderson be varied and David Anderson is directed to disclose any documents and electronic records, including notes and dates, relating to the Complainant's back injury within 14 days of this order.

3.       The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed on 8 October 2021 issued to Dr Paul Jip be varied and Dr Paul Jip is directed to disclose any documents and electronic records, including medical notes and dates, relating to the Complainant's back injury or psychological injury within 14 days of this order.

4.       The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed on 26 October 2021 issued to Virginia Corpus-McDermott be varied and Virginia Corpus-McDermott is directed to disclose any documents and electronic records confirming the dates of the

Complainant's membership of

Movement Vitality within 14 days of this order.

5.       The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed on 28 October 2021 issued to Yan Bo Li be varied and Yan Bo Li is directed to disclose any documents and electronic records relating to the treatment of the Complainant's back injury, including dates of treatment, within 14 days of this order.

CATCHWORDS: 

INDUSTRIAL LAW – QUEENSLAND – OTHER MATTERS – Application in Existing Proceedings – where there is an objection to notice of non-party disclosures – direct relevance

LEGISLATION:  Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld), ss 118 and
119
Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011
(Qld), rr 64B, 64E, 64F and 64G
CASES:  DP World Brisbane Pty Ltd v Rogers & Anor
[2014] ICQ 10
Harman v Secretary of State for Home
Department [1983] 1 AC 280

Mullins v Workers' Compensation Regulator; Ex parte Drake International Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2020] QIRC 003

Weston and Parer v State of Queensland (Department of Justice and Attorney General) (No 4) [2016] QIRC 75

APPEARANCES:  Ms A. Wissmann, the Complainant in person
Mr F. Nugent, the Respondent in person

Reasons for Decision

Background

  1. Mr Frederick Nugent ('the Respondent') filed five Form 29 Notice of Non-Party Disclosures ('NNPD') on the following parties:

(a) Dr Salesh Dheda;
(b) Mr David Anderson – Recoverwise;
(c) Dr Paul Jip;
(d) Ms Virginia Corpus-McDermott; and
(e) Mr Yan Bo Li.
  1. Ms Annika Wissmann ('the Complainant') has objected to the five NNPDs as an affected party and submits that the documents sought lacks particularity, contains privileged and confidential information and are not relevant to matters at issue in the substantive proceedings before the Commission.

  2. The Respondent subsequently filed separate Form 4…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wissmann v Nugent and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QIRC 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Wissmann v Nugent, the parties are contesting the validity and scope of notices for non-party disclosures in a dispute concerning compensation claims. The matter was heard in the Queensland Industrial Court, where the judge was tasked with addressing the objections to the notices and determining the appropriate scope of the disclosure orders.

The court was required to decide whether the notices for non-party disclosures were valid and sufficiently specific. The objections raised by the respondents centred on the ambiguity of the notices, arguing that they were overly broad and did not clearly specify the documents required. Additionally, the court had to consider the applicability of the Harman undertaking, which ensures that documents obtained through compulsory processes are only used for the intended purpose.

The court found that the notices for non-party disclosures were indeed ambiguous and thus ordered that they be varied to ensure clarity. The court emphasised the importance of specifying the exact nature of the documents required, particularly concerning the treatment of the complainant's injuries, including dates of treatment. Furthermore, the court reiterated the necessity of the Harman undertaking to prevent the misuse of disclosed documents. Consequently, the court issued varied notices directing the non-parties to disclose specific documents and records within a stipulated timeframe.

The final orders mandated the respondents to disclose any relevant documents and records within 14 days of the order, specifying the precise nature of the information required. This included documents relating to the complainant's back injury, psychological injury, and membership details, as well as treatment records. The court's decision ensured that the disclosure process was clear, precise, and aligned with the legal requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I consider that any documents in the possession of this practitioner to be relevant to the claim for compensation and so order that the NNPD be varied, given the ambiguity of the wording on the form, to order the disclosure of any documents in Mr Li's possession relating to the treatment of the Complainant including dates of treatment. Conclusion The parties are not legally represented in this matter and as such it is appropriate to make clear the undertaking that applies in these circumstances. The Harman[6] undertaking is an implied undertaking that documents obtained as a result of a compulsory process such as this will only be used for the purposes for which they were disclosed and will not be used for a collateral or ulterior purpose. [6] Harman v Secretary of State for Home Department [1983] 1 AC 280. Orders I make the following orders: 1. The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed on 8 October 2021 issued to Dr Salesh Dheda be varied and Dr Salesh Dheda is directed to disclose any documents and electronic records, including notes and dates, relating to the Complainant's back injury within 14 days of this order. 2. The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed on 25 October 2021 issued to David Anderson be varied and David Anderson is directed to disclose any documents and electronic records, including notes and dates, relating to the Complainant's back injury within 14 days of this order. 3. The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed on 8 October 2021 issued to Dr Paul Jip be varied and Dr Paul Jip is directed to disclose any documents and electronic records, including medical notes and dates, relating to the Complainant's back injury or psychological injury within 14 days of this order. 4. The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed on 26 October 2021 issued to Virginia Corpus-McDermott be varied and Virginia Corpus- McDermott is directed to disclose any documents and electronic records confirming the dates of the Complainant's membership of Movement Vitality within 14 days of this order. 5. The Notice of Non-Party Disclosure filed on 28 October 2021 issued to Yan Bo Li be varied and Yan Bo Li is directed to disclose any documents and electronic records relating to the treatment of the Complainant's back injury, including dates of treatment, within 14 days of this order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.