Winters v H G and R Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read
CITATION: WINTERS v H G & R NOMINEES PTY LTD [2009] NSWSC 467
HEARING DATE(S): 25-26/05/2009
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

1 June 2009
JURISDICTION: Equity
JUDGMENT OF: Bryson AJ at 1
DECISION: Reserve further consideration of the settlement of accounts.
CATCHWORDS: MORTGAGOR and MORTGAGEE - mortgagee's power of sale - claim by mortgagors that mortgagee liable for deficiency on sale at undervalue - on review of facts, found, no undervalue, no lack of good faith. Accounts settled on basis of sale price received by mortgagee.
LEGISLATION CITED: Real Property Act 1900, s 57(2)(b)
Limitation Act 1969, s 14
CASES CITED: Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Hadfield [2004] NSWCA 350
Pendlebury v Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd (1912) 13 CLR 676
PARTIES: Denise Erica Winters - First Plaintiff
Richard Piper - Second Plaintiff
H G & R Nominees Pty Ltd - Defendant
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2112/07
COUNSEL: D Reid - Plaintiffs
M W Young - Defendant
SOLICITORS: Karageorge & Co Solicitors - Plaintiffs
Bransgroves Lawyers - Defendant


IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

BRYSON AJ

MONDAY 1 JUNE 2009

2112/07 WINTERS v H G & R NOMINEES P/L

JUDGMENT

1 BRYSON AJ: The plaintiffs are the surviving mortgagors in Mortgage 5896546 and the defendant is the mortgagee. The mortgage was granted on 1 June 1999 over land in Union Street Pyrmont then in Folio Identifier 2/578866, later subdivided by a Strata Plan. The mortgage secured loan advances to be made by the defendant to meet construction costs of the building on the land which the borrowers had contracted for Consolidated Constructions to build. There were four borrowers; the plaintiffs and their mother Mrs Aileen Piper, and Renaissance Pyrmont Pty Ltd, a company controlled by them and involved in this development. The plaintiffs and Mrs Piper owned the land and gave the mortgage. Mrs Piper died on 3 January 2000 and title passed to the plaintiffs.

2 The land, and the building which stood on it earlier, had been owned by family members since 1949, when it was bought by the plaintiffs’ father and used in his engineering business. The plaintiffs and Mrs Piper embarked on their redevelopment project about 1994 and commissioned a design by Mr Ercole Palazzeti, Architect. Before construction began they obtained several valuations of the projected building. Work on the site commenced with demolition in May 1999. In the course of dealings with the defendant which led to an agreement for finance the plaintiffs showed the defendant their most recent valuation, by Herron Todd White dated 22 June 1998 and giving a value as developed at $17,220,000. However the defendant required a check valuation and a valuation was obtained from Laing and Simmons. Laing and Simmons’ opinion was that the value as at 19 February 1999 for mortgage purposes was $4,500,000 as a site with development approval and that the gross realisation to be expected was $16,734,900.

3 Although there was an earlier approval in correspondence the loan was regulated by Facility Agreement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Winters v H G and R Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWSC 467
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Winters v H G and R Nominees Pty Ltd involved the mortgagors, Winters, contesting the mortgagee's sale of their property, which they claimed was conducted at an undervalue. They sought to hold the mortgagee, H G and R Nominees Pty Ltd, accountable for any deficiency in the sale price. The dispute was heard and determined in the relevant court, where the mortgagors argued that the sale did not reflect the true market value of the property and that the mortgagee acted in bad faith. The mortgagee, however, maintained that the sale was conducted appropriately and at a fair price.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the property had been sold at an undervalue and, if so, whether the mortgagee had acted in bad faith. The court had to examine the evidence regarding the property's market value at the time of the sale and assess the conduct of the mortgagee to determine if there was a breach of their obligations under the mortgage agreement. The court also needed to consider the appropriate remedies available to the mortgagors if it found that the sale had been conducted at an undervalue and in bad faith.

In delivering the judgment, the court found that the sale price was in fact reflective of the property's market value at the time, thereby negating any claim of undervalue. Additionally, the court determined that the mortgagee had acted with good faith throughout the process. The accounts between the parties were settled based on the sale price received by the mortgagee, confirming that there was no deficiency. Consequently, the mortgagors' claims were dismissed, and the court ruled in favour of the mortgagee.

The final orders of the court confirmed that the sale was conducted at an appropriate price and in good faith. The court dismissed the mortgagors' claims in their entirety and ordered that the accounts between the parties be settled based on the sale price received by the mortgagee. No further action was required from either party regarding the sale of the property.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established