Winterhalter (Australia) Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Winterhalter (Australia) Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2021] AATA 4407 (29 November 2021)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/6219; 2019/6221

Re:Winterhalter (Australia) Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndComptroller-General of Customs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:The Hon. Dennis Cowdroy AO QC, Deputy President

Date:29 November 2021

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal finds that the correct or preferable decision is that the warewashers do not satisfy the requirements of the TCO and that the decision under review should be affirmed.

...................................[SGD].....................................

The Hon. Dennis Cowdroy AO QC, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

CUSTOMS - tariff concession order – meaning of cycle – meaning of program - decision under review affirmed  

LEGISLATION

Acts Interpretation Act1901 (Cth) ss 15AA, 15AB

Customs Act 1901 (Cth) s 269F

Customs Tariff Act 1995 (Cth)

CASES

Becker Vale Pty Ltd v CEO of Customs [2015] FCA 525

Brand Developers Aust Pty Ltd and CEO of Customs [2015] AATA 215

Collector of Customs v Agfa-Gevaert Limited (1996) 186 CLR 389

Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic Enterprises Pty Ltd (1993) 43 FCR 280

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Media Holdings Ltd (2012) 87 ALJR 98

On Track Tyre Trust and Chief Officer of Customs [2009] AAT 877

Toro Australia Group Sales Pty Ltd and Chief Executive Officer of Customs [2014] AATA 187

SECONDARY MATERIALS

General Rules for the Interpretation of Schedule 3 to the Customs Tariff Act 1995

Second Reading Speech to the Customs Legislation (Tariff Concessions and Anti-Dumping) Amendment Bill 1992, Senate Hansard 28 May 1992

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. Dennis Cowdroy AO QC, Deputy President

29 November 2021

  1. By application for review filed on 30 September 2019, Winterhalter (Australia) Pty Ltd (the Applicant) seeks review of a decision made by a delegate of the Respondent. By such decision, the Respondent, by Internal Review of Tariff Advice Numbers 22242300 and 22242900, found that Tariff Concession Order 1612840 (“the TCO”) does not apply to the Applicant’s commercial dishwashers.

  2. The Applicant contends that the decision is incorrect and submits that a decision should be made that the TCO does apply to the Applicant’s commercial dishwashers.

    FACTS

  3. The Applicant is the Australian subsidiary of Winterhalter Gastronom GmbH in Germany. The Applicant imports warewashing systems for sale in the retail market, one of the imports being commercial warewashers (“the warewashers”). The warewashers are available in four models and configurations. The warewashers that are subject to these proceedings are known as the UC series; PT series; UF series; and Classeq Duo “undercounter” and “passthrough”.

  4. Each model has programs and cycles as part of its design. The standard wash programs available in the warewashers (“the Programs”) that are the subject of these proceedings are:

    (a) light;

    (b) normal; and

    (c) heavy.

  5. The Applicant asserts that two washing cycles (“cycles”) are available with the warewashers, namely:

    (a) wash (with water and detergent): this cycle is designed to wash the dishes and/or glasses bypassing hot water with detergent over the contents.

    (b) rinse (freshwater and hot water with rinse aid): upon completion of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Winterhalter (Australia) Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 4407
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Winterhalter (Australia) Pty Ltd (the Applicant) seeking to challenge a decision by the Comptroller-General of Customs (the Respondent) regarding the eligibility of the Applicant's commercial dishwashers for a Tariff Concession Order (TCO). The Applicant contended that its warewashers, specifically the UC series, PT series, UF series, and Classeq Duo models, should qualify for TCO 16/25, which applies to "Commercial Warewashing Machine" under tariff heading 8422.19.00. The core of the dispute centred on whether these machines met the TCO's requirement of having "one OR two OR four cycles."

The legal issue before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal was to determine the number of "cycles" available on the Applicant's warewashers, as defined within the context of the relevant TCO. The Applicant argued that their machines possessed two cycles: a wash cycle and a rinse cycle, each constituting a complete course of operations. Conversely, the Respondent's decision, which the Applicant sought to overturn, found that the machines had three standard wash programs, which were considered interchangeable with "cycles" in the context of dishwashers, and therefore did not meet the TCO's criteria of one, two, or four cycles.

The Tribunal considered the Applicant's submission that the terms "cycle" and "program" could be used interchangeably, but noted that the manufacturer's own documentation and website indicated three distinct standard wash programs (light, normal, and heavy). These programs, while operating within a single wash and rinse sequence, adjusted parameters such as water pressure, time, detergent, and temperature based on the user's selection. The Tribunal found that the TCO's requirement for "one OR two OR four cycles" was not met because the warewashers offered three distinct programs, which were considered to be the operative "cycles" for the purpose of the TCO.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the Respondent's decision, finding that the Applicant's warewashers did not meet the specified criteria of the TCO. The goods were therefore not eligible for the Tariff Concession Order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant contends that the decision is incorrect and submits that a decision should be made that the TCO does apply to the Applicant’s commercial dishwashers.FACTS The Applicant is the Australian subsidiary of Winterhalter Gastronom GmbH in Germany. The Applicant imports warewashing systems for sale in the retail market, one of the imports being commercial warewashers (“the warewashers”). The warewashers are available in four models and configurations. The warewashers that are subject to these proceedings are known as the UC series; PT series; UF series; and Classeq Duo “undercounter” and “passthrough”. Each model has programs and cycles as part of its design. The standard wash programs available in the warewashers (“the Programs”) that are the subject of these proceedings are:(a) light;(b) normal; and (c) heavy. The Applicant asserts that two washing cycles (“cycles”) are available with the warewashers, namely:(a) wash (with water and detergent): this cycle is designed to wash the dishes and/or glasses bypassing hot water with detergent over the contents. (b) rinse (freshwater and hot water with rinse aid): upon completion of the wash cycle, the rinse cycle rinses the contents to ensure no soap or other residue is left on the articles being washed. The intensity of the cycles varies according to the Program selected by the user. The programs do not change the central function of the wash and rinse cycles.OPERATION OF TCO The relevant TCO is entitled Commercial Warewashing Machine. The TCO was lodged under section 269F of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth), and was published on 6 July 2016 in the Commonwealth of Australia Gazette TC 16/25 under the heading “TCOs Made”. The TCO is keyed to 8422.19.00. Its specifications are relevant for present purposes in respect of the requirement contained in the keyed wording as follows:KITCHENWARE AND OR TABLEWARE WASHING MACHINES, under counter OR pass through OR front loading OR rack conveying, one OR two OR four cycle, having ALL of the following:…DECISION UNDER REVIEW The Respondent’s decision entitled Internal Review of Tariff Advice Number 22242300 is dated 8 May 2019 and is identified as follows:Issue: TCO EligibilityGoods: Winterhalter Commercial Dishwashers – UC series Relevantly, the decision contained the following:The term ‘cycle’ as described in the heading of TCO 162840 has acquired a specific trade meaning in the context of dishwashers. The term ‘cycle’ is used to define the dish washing programs. It is agreed with the applicant that the terms ‘cycle’ and ‘program’ can be used interchangeably. The applicant contends that the machines “all run a single cycle per operation which is made up of two sub-cycle processes being a wash cycle and a rinse cycle.”However my research on the manufacturer’s website shows that there are 3 standard wash cycle [sic]: light, medium or heavy. Depending on the cycle chosen the machine automatically adjusts the components responsible for the dishwashing process such as water pressure, time, detergent and temperature. Whilst the machine runs a single was [sic] cycle per operation there are three available wash cycles to select. The UC product brochure (refer figure 3) explicitly states that “every machine has 3 programmes which adapt to the shape and size of the wash items and the level of soiling.” The Operation instructions confirm that there are three defined standard programs that can be selected using the symbols on the touchscreen of the washer (refer to figure 4 and 5).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Therefore, the sole issue for determination is whether the warewashers have “one Or two OR four cycles”.THE EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALApplicant’s Principal Contention It is the Applicant’s contention that the warewashers comply with the definition of the TCO because they have two cycles. The Applicant refers to the definition of “cycle” as contained in the Macquarie dictionary, that which relevantly defines this term as:“[a]ny round of operations or events; a series which returns upon itself; any complete course or series”. Accordingly, the Applicant states that the warewashers have two “cycles”: namely the wash and rinse cycles, each of which is a complete course or series in which the wash functions and the rinse functions are carried out. The Applicant maintains that the wash and rinse cycles can also be considered to be rounds of operations, including maintenance of water temperature and release of detergent and rinse aid. In support of its contention, the Applicant relies upon a witness statement of Mark Hutchinson signed on 1 September 2021 (first statement). Mr Hutchinson is the National Service Manager at Winterhalter (Australia) Pty Ltd, and is a qualified electrical and mechanical technician with 22 years’ experience and holding the following qualifications:1.6 I am a qualified electrical and mechanical technician, with 22 years’ experience and the following qualifications:(a) NVQ Level 2 in Electrical and mechanical engineering;(b) Australian trade recognition in appliance servicing;(c) Supervisor Certificate 87135s; and(d) White Card (General Construction Induction Course). Relevantly, Mr Hutchinson’s statement includes the following:The Warewashers 3.4 Each model has programs and cycles built into its design. As discussed further below programs and cycles are different functions of the Warewashers.3.5 The standard wash programs available with the Warewashers the subject of this application are:(a) light;(b) normal; and(c) heavy,(together, the Programs)3.6 The Programs are tailored to address the needs of the user based on the level of soiling of the dishes and glasses to be cleaned. For example, dishes with heavily baked on or burnt food residue may require a heavy program while wine glasses may require a light program.3.7 There are two cycles available with the Warewashers being:(a) wash (with water and detergent); and(b) rinse (fresh water and hot water with rinse aid), (together, Cycles)Annexed to this Statement and marked “MH-1” is a copy [of] a letter from Winterhalter’s parent company confirming the wash programs and wash cycles.3.8 The Cycles are designed to wash the dishes and/or glasses by passing hot water with detergent over the contents. Once the wash cycle has removed the food or beverage residue the rinse cycle rinses the contents to ensure no soap or other residue is left on the contents.3.9 The Cycles vary their intensity based on the Program selected by the user. The Warewashers are also designed with particular functionalities which ensure the water remains clean during the wash and rinse cycles including filtering out large food particulates. The functions of the Warewashers are described in detail in the product specifications and manuals discussed below and annexed to this Statement.3.10 Cycles represent the basic functionality of the Warewashers. The Programs are designed to control the intensity of the wash and rinse Cycles however, do not change the central function of the wash and rinse Cycles.3.11 The Warewashers are able to be adapted to the needs of the user including by taking into account the level of soiling of the dishes or glasses to be washed. The Warewashers are also designed to be economical in power and water usage with Programs and Cycles specifically tailored to achieve the required results while maintaining efficiency.3.12 The Warewashers also include the ability to self-clean and “de-scale” (as a result of heavy water in certain areas) and are equipped with diagnostic capabilities for the purpose of servicing the machine and responding to errors.3.13 The Warewashers the subject of this application are standard models. Winterhalter is able to customise warewashers, as indicated in the promotional material annexed to this statement. This is done at the request of the customers. However, the Warewashers the subject of this application were imported in their standard form.Industry Use of the Terms Cycle And Program

Decision

Reasons for decision

The relevant TCO is entitled Commercial Warewashing Machine. The TCO was lodged under section 269F of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth), and was published on 6 July 2016 in the Commonwealth of Australia Gazette TC 16/25 under the heading “TCOs Made”. The TCO is keyed to 8422.19.00. Its specifications are relevant for present purposes in respect of the requirement contained in the keyed wording as follows:KITCHENWARE AND OR TABLEWARE WASHING MACHINES, under counter OR pass through OR front loading OR rack conveying, one OR two OR four cycle, having ALL of the following:…DECISION UNDER REVIEW The Respondent’s decision entitled Internal Review of Tariff Advice Number 22242300 is dated 8 May 2019 and is identified as follows:Issue: TCO EligibilityGoods: Winterhalter Commercial Dishwashers – UC series Relevantly, the decision contained the following:The term ‘cycle’ as described in the heading of TCO 162840 has acquired a specific trade meaning in the context of dishwashers. The term ‘cycle’ is used to define the dish washing programs. It is agreed with the applicant that the terms ‘cycle’ and ‘program’ can be used interchangeably. The applicant contends that the machines “all run a single cycle per operation which is made up of two sub-cycle processes being a wash cycle and a rinse cycle.”However my research on the manufacturer’s website shows that there are 3 standard wash cycle [sic]: light, medium or heavy. Depending on the cycle chosen the machine automatically adjusts the components responsible for the dishwashing process such as water pressure, time, detergent and temperature. Whilst the machine runs a single was [sic] cycle per operation there are three available wash cycles to select. The UC product brochure (refer figure 3) explicitly states that “every machine has 3 programmes which adapt to the shape and size of the wash items and the level of soiling.” The Operation instructions confirm that there are three defined standard programs that can be selected using the symbols on the touchscreen of the washer (refer to figure 4 and 5). The decision made the following determination:Based on all the above product information the goods have 3 standard programs or wash cycles. Therefore the goods do not meet the TCO criteria which requires they have one or two or four cycles. The goods are not eligible for TCO 1612840.ISSUE FOR DETERMINATION The only issue for determination identified by the Applicant is whether TCO 1612840 applies to a set of Winterhalter warewashers in four models (UC series, PT series, UF series and Classeq Duo “undercounter” and “passthrough”) (together, warewashers). There is no dispute as to the applicable tariff classification under tariff heading 8422.19.00, as TCO 1612840 applies to the following:TCO 1612840 applies to the following (emphasis added):8422.19.00 KITCHENWARE AND/OR TABLEWARE WASHING MACHINES, under counter OR pass through OR front loading OR rack conveying, one OR two OR four cycles, having ALL of the following:(a) rack chamber height NOT less than 205mm and NOT greater than 800 mm;(b) rack sizes NOT less than 400 mm x 400 mm and NOT greater than 1 320 mm x 700 mm;(c) width NOT less than 460 mm and NOT greater than 1 750 mm;(d) depth NOT less than 520 mm and NOT greater than 1 600 mm;(e) height NOT less than 700 mm and NOT greater than 1 930 mm.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The intensity of the cycles varies according to the Program selected by the user. The programs do not change the central function of the wash and rinse cycles.OPERATION OF TCO The relevant TCO is entitled Commercial Warewashing Machine. The TCO was lodged under section 269F of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth), and was published on 6 July 2016 in the Commonwealth of Australia Gazette TC 16/25 under the heading “TCOs Made”. The TCO is keyed to 8422.19.00. Its specifications are relevant for present purposes in respect of the requirement contained in the keyed wording as follows:KITCHENWARE AND OR TABLEWARE WASHING MACHINES, under counter OR pass through OR front loading OR rack conveying, one OR two OR four cycle, having ALL of the following:…DECISION UNDER REVIEW The Respondent’s decision entitled Internal Review of Tariff Advice Number 22242300 is dated 8 May 2019 and is identified as follows:Issue: TCO EligibilityGoods: Winterhalter Commercial Dishwashers – UC series Relevantly, the decision contained the following:The term ‘cycle’ as described in the heading of TCO 162840 has acquired a specific trade meaning in the context of dishwashers. The term ‘cycle’ is used to define the dish washing programs. It is agreed with the applicant that the terms ‘cycle’ and ‘program’ can be used interchangeably. The applicant contends that the machines “all run a single cycle per operation which is made up of two sub-cycle processes being a wash cycle and a rinse cycle.”However my research on the manufacturer’s website shows that there are 3 standard wash cycle [sic]: light, medium or heavy. Depending on the cycle chosen the machine automatically adjusts the components responsible for the dishwashing process such as water pressure, time, detergent and temperature. Whilst the machine runs a single was [sic] cycle per operation there are three available wash cycles to select. The UC product brochure (refer figure 3) explicitly states that “every machine has 3 programmes which adapt to the shape and size of the wash items and the level of soiling.” The Operation instructions confirm that there are three defined standard programs that can be selected using the symbols on the touchscreen of the washer (refer to figure 4 and 5). The decision made the following determination:Based on all the above product information the goods have 3 standard programs or wash cycles. Therefore the goods do not meet the TCO criteria which requires they have one or two or four cycles. The goods are not eligible for TCO 1612840.ISSUE FOR DETERMINATION The only issue for determination identified by the Applicant is whether TCO 1612840 applies to a set of Winterhalter warewashers in four models (UC series, PT series, UF series and Classeq Duo “undercounter” and “passthrough”) (together, warewashers). There is no dispute as to the applicable tariff classification under tariff heading 8422.19.00, as TCO 1612840 applies to the following:TCO 1612840 applies to the following (emphasis added):8422.19.00 KITCHENWARE AND/OR TABLEWARE WASHING MACHINES, under counter OR pass through OR front loading OR rack conveying, one OR two OR four cycles, having ALL of the following:(a) rack chamber height NOT less than 205mm and NOT greater than 800 mm;(b) rack sizes NOT less than 400 mm x 400 mm and NOT greater than 1 320 mm x 700 mm;(c) width NOT less than 460 mm and NOT greater than 1 750 mm;(d) depth NOT less than 520 mm and NOT greater than 1 600 mm;(e) height NOT less than 700 mm and NOT greater than 1 930 mm.