Winston and Anor and Medland

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WINSTON & ANOR & MEDLAND [2013] FCCA 1903

Catchwords:

FAMILY LAW – Parenting – dispute about future parenting arrangements for a child aged 9 – where the child’s mother died suddenly in 2012 – where prior to her mother’s death the child was living with the mother and spending time with the father – where the child has lived with the maternal grandparents since the mother’s death – maternal grandparents proposing that this continue – father seeking an order that the child live with him – child conflicted and not expressing a preference – whether the fact of parenthood tips the balance in favour of the child living with the father.

Legislation:
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), ss.60CC, 60K, 61DA, 65DAA, 64C, 65C
Aldridge & Keaton (2009) FLC93-421
D & F [2001] FamCA 382
Dennett & Norman [2007] FamCA57
Mazorski & Albright (2008) 37 FamLR 518
Rice & Miller (1993) FLC92-415
Applicants: MS WINSTON & MR WINSTON
Respondent: MR MEDLAND
File Number: NCC 234 of 2009
Judgment of: Judge Terry
Hearing dates: 11, 12 & 13 November 2013
Date of Last Submission: 13 November 2013
Delivered at: Tamworth
Delivered on: 21 November 2013

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Rugendyke
Solicitors for the Applicant: Braye Cragge Solicitors
Counsel for the Respondent:  Ms Shearman
Solicitors for the Respondent: Bridge Street Lawyers
Counsel for the Independent Children’s Lawyer: Ms Carty
Solicitor for the Independent Children’s Lawyer: Jennifer Blundell & Associates

ORDERS

  1. All previous parenting orders concerning [X] born [omitted] 2004 are discharged.

  2. The father, the maternal grandmother Ms Winston and the maternal grandfather Mr Winston shall have equal shared parental responsibility for the child.

  3. The child shall live with the maternal grandparents.

  4. The child shall spend time with the father:

    (a)each alternate weekend during school terms from 6.00pm on Friday until 3.30pm on Sunday;

    (b)for a period of 9 days during the Term 1, 2 and 3 school holidays as agreed between the parties and failing agreement commencing at 3.30pm on the first non-school day of the holiday period and concluding at 3.30pm 9 days later;

    (c)for one half of the Christmas school holidays as agreed and failing agreement for the first half when the holidays commence in an even numbered year and the second half when the holidays commence in an odd numbered year; and

    (d)at such additional or alternate times as may be agreed between the father and the maternal grandparents.

  5. Unless otherwise agreed changeover between the parties shall take place at McDonalds Family Restaurant at [S].

  6. Notwithstanding any other order:

    (a)if Father’s Day falls on a weekend when the child would otherwise be with the maternal grandparents the maternal grandparents time with the child shall be suspended on that weekend and the child shall spend that weekend with the father;

    (b)if Mother’s Day falls on a weekend when the child would otherwise be with the father the child’s time with the father shall be suspended on that weekend and the child shall spend that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Winston and Anor and Medland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCCA 1903
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned a dispute over the future parenting arrangements for a nine-year-old child, [X]. The child's mother died suddenly in 2012, after which [X] had been living with her maternal grandparents. Prior to her mother's death, [X] had lived with her mother and spent time with her father. The maternal grandparents sought orders for [X] to continue living with them, while the father sought an order for [X] to live with him. The child was conflicted and did not express a clear preference. The matter was heard by Judge Terry.

The court was required to determine whether the fact of parenthood tipped the balance in favour of the child living with the father, and to make orders for the future parenting arrangements for [X]. In doing so, the court considered various factors including the child's maturity, sex, and background, the attitude to parenthood demonstrated by each party, the nature of the child's relationships with her father and maternal grandparents, and any other relevant facts or circumstances. The court also considered the potential for future proceedings and the need for the child to settle peaceably into a new regime.

In its reasoning, the court noted that the child did not express a clear preference for living with either party, and that any comments she made about her stepmother were given little weight due to the risk of her saying what she thought the maternal grandparents wanted to hear. The court expressed concern about the father's past decision to withhold [X] and the potential for ongoing animosity between the parties, despite recent improvements in their interactions. The court found that while the child had a close and loving relationship with both her father and maternal grandparents, her comments to a psychologist suggested a less positive relationship with her stepmother and her stepmother's children. The court ultimately found that it was preferable for the child to live with the maternal grandparents, while also ensuring significant time with the father.

The court ordered that all previous parenting orders be discharged. It was ordered that the father, maternal grandmother, and maternal grandfather have equal shared parental responsibility for the child. The child was ordered to live with the maternal grandparents, and to spend time with the father on alternate weekends during school terms, for a period of nine days during school holidays, and for one half of the Christmas school holidays, with provisions for agreed or default arrangements. The orders also included provisions for communication, notification of medical conditions and travel, and attendance at school events, with specific clauses regarding Father's Day and Mother's Day. The court also directed that the maternal grandparents arrange for the child to see a professional to explain the orders to her.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

All previous parenting orders concerning [X] born [omitted] 2004 are discharged.

2.

The father, the maternal grandmother Ms Winston and the maternal grandfather Mr Winston shall have equal shared parental responsibility for the child.

3.

The child shall live with the maternal grandparents.

4.

The child shall spend time with the father:

(a) each alternate weekend during school terms from 6.00pm on Friday until 3.30pm on Sunday;

(b) for a period of 9 days during the Term 1, 2 and 3 school holidays as agreed between the parties and failing agreement commencing at 3.30pm on the first non-school day of the holiday period and concluding at 3.30pm 9 days later;

(c) for one half of the Christmas school holidays as agreed and failing agreement for the first half when the holidays commence in an even numbered year and the second half when the holidays commence in an odd numbered year; and

(d) at such additional or alternate times as may be agreed between the father and the maternal grandparents.

5.

Unless otherwise agreed changeover between the parties shall take place at McDonalds Family Restaurant at [S].

6.

Notwithstanding any other order:

(a) if Father’s Day falls on a weekend when the child would otherwise be with the maternal grandparents the maternal grandparents time with the child shall be suspended on that weekend and the child shall spend that weekend with the father;

(b) if Mother’s Day falls on a weekend when the child would otherwise be with the father the child’s time with the father shall be suspended on that weekend and the child shall spend that weekend with the maternal grandparents.

7.

The party or parties who do not have the child in their care shall have telephone or Skype communication with her as agreed between the parties and failing agreement each Tuesday and Thursday between 4.00pm and 6.00pm and the adults shall afford the child reasonable privacy during that time.

8.

Each party shall promptly notify the other(s) should the child while in their care be diagnosed as suffering from a serious medical condition, be involved in an accident requiring attendance at hospital or be the subject of a medical emergency requiring attendance at hospital and each party may visit the child in hospital and obtain from the hospital or treating medical practitioner any relevant medical information concerning or reports prepared about the child.

9.

Each party may obtain from the child’s schools newsletters, notices, school reports, school photograph order forms and any other information or documents normally provided to parents.

10.

Each party is entitled to attend all events involving the child including:

(a) sporting fixtures;

(b) extra curricula activities that allow for parental attendance;

(c) school functions and events that allow for adult attendance including but not limited to concerts, school assemblies, sports days, parent teacher interviews, canteen duties and social functions.

11.

Each party is to keep the other informed of their current residential address, postal address, and landline (if they have one) and mobile telephone number and shall advise the other party or parties within 24 hours of any changes to any of these details.

12.

If a party intends to take or send the child away from their usual residential address for more than 4 days during their period of holiday time with the child they shall notify the other party or parties in writing (by email, text message or otherwise) no later than 48 hours prior to departure of their dates of departure and return and the address at which the child will be staying while away from the usual residential address.

13.

During the time the child is with each party or parties each party shall:

(a) not physically chastise the child or allow any person to do so;

(b) speak respectfully of the other party or parties or the father’s partner as the case may be;

(c) not denigrate, insult or threaten the other parties or the father’s partner and use their best endeavours to ensure that others do not do so in the presence or hearing of the child;

(d) not seek to elicit from the child any views about where the child should live.

14.

The maternal grandparents shall promptly make an appointment for the child to see Ms C for the purposes of Ms C explaining to the child the orders which have been made.

Background

Background to the litigation

I must consider the child’s maturity sex and background. This is not relevant as a separate consideration. I must consider the attitude to the child and the responsibilities of parenthood demonstrated by each of the child’s parents. Insofar as he has been a keen and active part of his daughter’s life the father has demonstrated a good attitude to the child and the responsibilities of parenthood in the past. I must consider any issues of family violence and the existence of any family violence orders but family violence is not an issue in this case and there are no family violence orders. I must consider whether it is preferable to make the order least likely to lead to further proceedings. I wish that I could be sure, after all [X] as gone through, that any order I made would last for the remainder of her childhood and adolescence but of course I cannot. Unexpected health issues or accidents could intervene for any of the parties and no orders I make can prevent this. I can only hope that each of the parties allows [X] to settle peaceably into the regime which is place following this decision regardless of their own disappointment about the outcome. It concerns me that the father chose to withhold [X] in August 2013 because of scabs on her head caused by head lice. Unless the father learns a different style of dealing with issues which concern him not only might [X] be made anxious and distressed but the matter might end up back in court again sooner rather than later. I must consider any other relevant fact or circumstance. The relationship between the maternal grandparents and the father and Ms M has been poor for much of the period since March 2010. The maternal grandmother said that she and the maternal grandfather and the father had been getting on better in the last 12 months, and certainly the changeovers which they have all attended have been uneventful and none of them displayed any overt animosity to the others in the witness box. The maternal grandmother said that she had been rebuffed in her attempts to talk to Ms M. Ms M denied this and it is impossible for to make a finding about where the truth lies, because this does not come down to issues of credit but to the fact that there can be genuine differences of perception in situations such as this. However while during the last fifteen months the parties have been able to get along well enough most of the time I have concerns about the future and consider that the possibility of trouble erupting between them may be just under the surface rather than buried deep. The father decision to withhold [X] on 18 August 2013 rather than adopting a course involving meaningful and respectful communication with the maternal grandparents causes me concern, and while Ms M fell in readily enough with the suggestion by Counsel for the Independent Children’s Lawyer that she was willing to start communicating with the maternal grandparents in paragraph 43 of the affidavit she swore only a month ago she said the exact opposite.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The first of the additional considerations in s.60CC (3) is any views expressed by the child and any factors (such as the child's maturity or level of understanding) that the court thinks are relevant to the weight it should give to the child's views. None of the parties claimed that [X] was expressing a wish about where she should live, and Dr R said as follows:Discussing the time she spends with her father, [X] reported it occurred for a “little bit” every second weekend. She stated that Nan had told her to say where she wanted to live when she is older and then declared she “want(s) to stay with Daddy forever, wants to stay with (MGPs) forever” and she does not know what to do.[7][7] Dr R’s report page 3 The next additional consideration is the nature of the relationship of the child with each of her parents and any other persons including any grandparents or other relative of the child. [X] has a close and loving relationship with her father and with her maternal grandparents. [X] also has a very good relationship with her best friend [Z], who she mentioned to Dr R, and a reasonable although perhaps not especially close (it is difficult to tell from the limited evidence) relationship with her aunt Ms T and cousin [A] who is in the year above her at school. [X] has made negative comments about Ms M to the maternal grandparents in the past fifteen months. However the relationship between the two sides of the family while functional has not been cordial for much of the period since the father retained [X] in March 2010, something [X] must inevitably have picked up on, and the maternal grandparents readily agreed during cross-examination that little if any weight could be given to comments [X] made to them from time to time about her step-mother because of the risk that [X] was saying things which she thought might please them. The maternal grandfather very fairly said as follows in his affidavit:I still don’t know if [X] is saying things to us about Ms M because she thinks they are things that I want to hear, or if she is simply having trouble fitting into a blended household with four adults and four children.[8][8] Paragraph 66 affidavit of Mr Winston filed 31 October 2013 Of greater concern is that [X] said a number of things to Dr R which suggested that she did not have a good relationship with Ms M or Ms M’s children. Dr R reported as follows:In 3 houses, in which she could decide who lived where, [X] decided – 1.With her – [Y] and [Z]2.Next door, to see whenever she wanted – Nan, Pop, [A], Aunt [Ms T], Daddy, Mum3.Far away, never to see again – [B], [C], Ms M.[9] [9] Dr R’s report page 4 Dr R also reported that:When asked if she likes Ms M, [X] replied “kind of”. To an enquiry if Dad and Ms M fight, she stated “yes, not much”, at which times Dad goes into his room and shuts the door and Ms M could take a drive or go to poker. Questioned if they “yell and scream and swear” during their fights, she said “only yelling”. [10][10] Dr R’s report page 3