Winra v Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Winra v Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 1447

Citation: Winra v Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 1447
Parties: BETHANY HELENA WINRA v SKYCITY ADELAIDE PTY LTD and KELMAN DAVID
File number: SAD 285 of 2011
Judge: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 18 December 2012
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – discovery – application for non-standard and more extensive discovery under Rules 20.13 and 20.14 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (“the Rules”) – alternative application for particular discovery under Rule 20.21 of the Rules.

PRIVILEGE – legal professional privilege – implied waiver – whether privileged legal advice put in issue by pleading – whether implied waiver on basis of partial disclosure.

Held: The first respondent has not waived legal professional privilege. Other orders for discovery made.  

Legislation:  Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), Rules 20.13, 20.14
Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth)
Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth), ss 28A, 28B, 105, 106
Cases cited:

Ampolex Ltd v Perpetual Trustee Co (Canberra) Ltd (1996) 40 NSWLR 12, cited
Bennett v Chief Executive Officer of the Australian Customs Service (2004) 140 FCR 101, cited
DSE (Holdings) Pty Ltd v Intertan Inc (2003) 127 FCR 499, cited
Mann v Carnell (1999) 201 CLR 1, cited

Nine Films & Television Pty Ltd v Ninox Television Ltd (2005) 65 IPR 442, cited
Pratt Holdings Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2004) 136 FCR 357
Thomason v Campbelltown Municipal Council (1939) 39 SR (NSW) 347, cited

Date of hearing: 14 November 2012
Place: Adelaide
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 21
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S Mitchell
Solicitor for the Applicant: Hamdan Lawyers
Counsel for the First Respondent: Ms A Manos
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Sparke Helmore

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 285 of 2011

BETWEEN:

BETHANY HELENA WINRA
Applicant

AND:

SKYCITY ADELAIDE PTY LTD
First Respondent

KELMAN DAVID
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

BESANKO J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 DECEMBER 2012

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1. The first respondent be required to make discovery of the documents which fall within the description in the Schedule below, where the documents:

(a)are relevant to the issues raised by the pleadings or in the affidavits ;

(b)       are within the categories set out in the Schedule; and

(c)       are, or have been, in the party’s control.

2.The first respondent is to make discovery in terms of Order 1 as follows:

(a)the criteria mentioned in Rule 20.14(1) and (2) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) do not apply;

(b)the first respondent is to use categories in the List of Documents and that each document in a category also be separately described;

(c)the discovery is not to be made in electronic form; and

(d)the discovery is not to be given in accordance with a discovery plan.

3.The first respondent is to produce for inspection by the applicant the aforesaid discovered documents within 21 days.

Schedule

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Winra v Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 1447
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Winra v Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd was a legal dispute heard by the Federal Court of Australia. The primary issue in the case was whether the first respondent, Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd, should be compelled to disclose certain documents to the applicant, Winra. The dispute centred around the discovery of documents in three categories: Category 1, Category 2, and Category 3. While there was agreement that the applicant was entitled to orders with respect to Category 3, the main contention involved Categories 1 and 2. The first respondent admitted it had failed to include these documents in its initial list of documents, but claimed legal professional privilege over them. The central legal issues the court had to address were whether the first respondent had waived legal professional privilege and whether the applicant had demonstrated sufficient grounds for the discovery of the disputed documents.

The court assessed the arguments presented by both parties. The applicant argued that the extent of the investigation into the sexual harassment complaint and the documents it produced became evident only after reviewing certain discovered documents. The applicant contended that the first respondent's claim of legal professional privilege was not valid given the circumstances. The first respondent, on the other hand, maintained that it had conducted the investigation solely to obtain further legal advice, thus warranting the privilege claim. The court needed to determine whether the privilege was appropriately claimed and if the applicant had provided adequate justification to compel the disclosure of these documents. After considering the evidence and arguments, the court concluded that the applicant had not successfully demonstrated that the first respondent had waived the privilege, and therefore, the orders for the discovery of documents in Category 1 (excluding paragraph 1.1) and Category 2 should be denied.

In conclusion, the court ordered the first respondent to produce specific documents within 21 days. These documents were to be related to previous complaints, instances, or alleged instances of sexual harassment or inappropriate conduct by a named individual. The order specified that the documents should be relevant to the issues in the case, be within the outlined categories, and be in the party’s control. The court also specified that the discovery should not be made electronically and was not to be governed by a discovery plan. The parties were directed to discuss whether an order concerning paragraph 1.1 of the applicant's application was necessary and, if so, the specific terms of such an order. The court also indicated that the parties would be heard on the matter of costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute regarding the discovery of certain documents in relation to a sexual harassment complaint made by the applicant against an employee of the first respondent, Kelman David. The applicant, represented by Ms Abby Hamdan, seeks the discovery of documents related to the complaint, including those concerning the investigation into the complaint and previous complaints against Kelman David. The first respondent, Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd, accepts that it should have included certain documents in its initial List of Documents served on 8 October 2012 and has since served an Amended List of Documents, which now includes documents in Category 1 and Category 2. The primary issue raised is whether the first respondent waived legal professional privilege in relation to the documents in Category 1 and Category 2.

The matter came before the court on an application for orders regarding the discovery of documents. The applicant relied on an affidavit of her solicitor, Ms Abby Hamdan, and the first respondent relied on an affidavit of Mr Holland. The court heard arguments from both parties and considered the evidence provided. The decision focused on whether the first respondent had waived legal professional privilege in relation to the documents in Category 1 and Category 2.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the hearing of this application there was also substantial agreement between the parties that the applicant was entitled to orders with respect to Category 3. The dispute relates to Category 1 and Category 2. As I understand it, the documents in these categories were not discovered by the first respondent in its List of Documents served on 8 October 2012. The first respondent accepts that it should have done that and it has now served an Amended List of Documents wherein the documents in Category 1 and Category 2 have been included in Schedule 1 Part 2. The issue raised therefore in relation to Category 1 and Category 2 is one of legal professional privilege.THE EVIDENCE ON THE APPLICATION The applicant relies on an affidavit of her solicitor, Ms Abby Hamdan, sworn on 7 November 2012. With respect to the documents in Category 1, Ms Hamdan deposes that the extent of the first respondent’s investigation into the applicant’s sexual harassment complaint, and the kinds of documents such an investigation was likely to produce, only became apparent upon inspection of certain documents already discovered by the first respondent, namely a report of Ms Elizabeth Kerr dated 21 September 2012 and a statement of Mr Tannock dated 27 October 2012. With respect to the documents in Category 3, Ms Hamdan deposes to her belief that documents detailing previous complaints made to the first respondent with respect to the second respondent’s conduct exist, on the basis of information provided by the applicant directly to her solicitors. Ms Hamdan states that this same information was provided by the applicant to Ms Kerr and that it appears in the transcript of the latter’s interview with the applicant which is annexed to Ms Kerr’s report. The first respondent relies on Mr Holland’s affidavit previously referred to. Mr Holland states that while the first respondent does not oppose an order with respect to the documents relating to the termination of the second respondent’s employment (Category 3, paragraph 3.5 of Annexure A), there are no documents concerning this matter that have not already been discovered. Mr Holland also states that the first respondent opposes any order for discovery with respect to the balance of the documents in Category 1 (that is, other than paragraph 1.1) and the entirety of the documents in Category 2 on the ground of legal professional privilege. He deposes to the fact that on 9 December 2010, he received a phone call from Mr Tannock, who sought legal advice with respect to the applicant’s harassment complaint. He deposes to the fact that immediately following this conversation, Mr Tannock commenced the investigation into this complaint “for the sole purpose of obtaining further legal advice”. He states that it was on the basis of the documents “including notes, emails and statements”, prepared as a result of that investigation, that on around 16 December 2010 he provided further legal advice to the first respondent. ISSUES ON THE APPLICATION

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant has not established that the first respondent has waived legal professional privilege, and orders for the discovery of documents in Category 1 (with the exception of paragraph 1.1) and Category 2 should be refused.CONCLUSION By the end of oral submissions neither the terms of Category 3 or the orders to be made in respect of that category were in serious dispute. Orders in the following terms should be made.1.The first respondent be required to make discovery of the documents which fall within the description in the Schedule below, where the documents:(a)are relevant to the issues raised by the pleadings or in the affidavits ;(b) are within the categories set out in the Schedule; and(c) are, or have been, in the party’s control;2.The first respondent is to make discovery in terms of Order 1 as follows:(a)the criteria mentioned in Rule 20.14(1) and (2) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) do not apply;(b)the first respondent is to use categories in the List of Documents and that each document in a category also be separately described;(c)the discovery is not to be made in electronic form; and(d)the discovery is not to be given in accordance with a discovery plan.3.The first respondent is to produce for inspection by the applicant the aforesaid discovered documents within 21 days.ScheduleAll documents recording information relevant to any previous complaint, instances, or alleged instances, of sexual harassment or inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature by Kelman David, including:(a)any documents recording any information regarding any complaints or regarding any instance or alleged instance of sexual harassment or inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature by Kelman David while an employee of the first respondent;(b)any documents recording any information regarding any complaints or regarding any instance or alleged instance of sexual harassment or inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature by Kelman David while an employee of Skycity Entertainment Group in New Zealand.(c)any document recording any information regarding the action taken by the first respondent or the Skycity Entertainment Group in consequence of complaint, or incident or alleged incident of any sexual harassment or inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature by Kelman David.(d)any documents recording any information regarding the reason for the commencement of the employment of Kelman David by the first respondent including any documents recording information relating to the reason for the transfer within the Skycity Entertainment Group from New Zealand to Adelaide.(e)Any documents recording any information regarding the circumstances of, or reasons for, the termination of the employment by the first respondent of Kelman David. I will hear the parties as to whether an order in terms of paragraph 1.1 of the applicant’s interlocutory application is necessary and, if so, the terms of any such order. I will also hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence provided by the applicant's solicitor, Ms Abby Hamdan, who stated that the extent of the first respondent's investigation into the applicant's sexual harassment complaint became apparent upon inspection of certain documents already discovered. However, the first respondent's counsel, Mr Holland, deposed that the investigation was commenced for the sole purpose of obtaining further legal advice. Mr Holland also stated that the first respondent opposed any order for discovery with respect to the balance of the documents in Category 1 and the entirety of the documents in Category 2 on the ground of legal professional privilege.

In determining whether the first respondent had waived legal professional privilege, the court considered the legal principles governing legal professional privilege and the authorities it relied on. The court applied the principles to the facts and concluded that the first respondent had not waived legal professional privilege in relation to the documents in Category 1 and Category 2. Therefore, orders for the discovery of these documents should be refused.

The binding legal principle established or applied by the decision is that legal professional privilege has not been waived when an investigation is commenced for the sole purpose of obtaining further legal advice, and the documents prepared as a result of that investigation are not discoverable. This decision followed prior authority on the protection of legal professional privilege in relation to documents prepared for the purpose of obtaining legal advice.