Wingfoot Australia Partner Pty Ltd v Jovevski

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2013 0132

WINGFOOT AUSTRALIA PARTNER PTY LTD Appellants
and
GOODYEAR TYRES PTY LTD
v
STOJAN JOVEVSKI Respondent

---

JUDGES WARREN CJ and TATE and OSBORN JJA
WHERE HELD MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING 12 February 2014
DATE OF JUDGMENT 26 February 2014
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION [2014] VSCA 21
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM Jovevski v Wingfoot Australia Partner Pty Ltd [2013] VCC 996 (Judge Smith)

---

ACCIDENT COMPENSATION – Appeal – Serious injury application – Claimed psychiatric injury arising out of aggravation of shoulder pain – Causation of psychiatric injury where physical consequences of aggravation not permanent – Factual basis of expert evidence disputed on appeal – Adequacy of reasons – New case advanced on appeal – Civil Procedure Act 2010.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellants Mr J Gorton SC with
Ms R Kaye
Wisewould Mahony
For the Respondent Mr P A Jewell SC with
Mr R C Forsyth
Patrick Robinson & Co

WARREN CJ
TATE JA
OSBORN JA:

Introduction

  1. In 2011 Mr Jovevski filed an originating motion in the County Court seeking leave to bring proceedings for damages pursuant to s 134AB of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (‘Act’) in respect of an injury suffered in the course of his employment by the appellants. 

  1. The application came on for hearing before his Honour Judge Smith in August 2013.  It was not disputed by the appellants that Mr Jovevski had suffered a workplace injury to his right shoulder in 1995, nor that he had suffered some aggravation of that injury in 2001 in the course of his work. 

  1. The application was brought in respect of the 2001 aggravation relying on the alleged pain and suffering consequences of the physical injury and in the alternative upon an alleged consequential psychiatric injury.  It was further put on the basis of loss of earning capacity resulting from Mr Jovevski’s psychiatric state. 

  1. At trial the parties joined issue as to whether the physical or psychiatric consequences of the 2001 aggravation met the statutory requirements that they be respectively ‘serious’ or ‘severe’ in the relevant senses.[1] 

The trial judge was not satisfied that the physical pain and suffering consequences of the aggravation constituted serious injury in the relevant sense.  More particularly, he was not satisfied those consequences were permanent and at least very considerable.  On the other hand, his Honour accepted that Mr Jovevski had suffered a psychiatric injury of which the aggravation of shoulder pain suffered in early 2001 was a cause and that the psychiatric injury constituted by an agitated depressive reaction was severe.  His Honour was also satisfied that the psychiatric injury caused a loss of earning capacity of at least 40 per cent. 

[1]See s 138AB(38)(c) and (d). 

  1. The appellants do not now challenge the trial judge’s findings as to the severity of Mr Jovevski’s psychiatric condition.  The appellants contend however that his Honour erred in finding that the 2001 aggravation was a cause of Mr Jovevski’s psychiatric condition.  In particular the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wingfoot Australia Partner Pty Ltd v Jovevski and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] VSCA 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal involved a claimant seeking compensation for a psychiatric injury that arose from the aggravation of pre-existing shoulder pain. The dispute was between Wingfoot Australia Partner Pty Ltd and Mr Jovevski, and it was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The claimant sought to establish that the psychiatric injury was caused by the aggravation of the shoulder pain, despite the physical consequences of the aggravation not being permanent. The primary issue before the court was whether the claimant could claim compensation for a psychiatric injury when the physical injury did not result in a permanent impairment. The court also had to determine if the factual basis of the expert evidence provided by the claimant was sufficiently supported and if the reasons given for the decision were adequate.

The court examined the evidence presented and considered the claimant's argument that the psychiatric injury was directly linked to the aggravation of the shoulder pain, even though the physical injury was not permanent. The court found that the claimant had not provided sufficient evidence to establish a causal link between the aggravation of the shoulder pain and the psychiatric injury. The court also noted that the claimant had advanced a new case on appeal, which was not previously argued before the lower court, and therefore, it was not open to the court to consider this new evidence. The court concluded that the reasons provided for the decision were inadequate and that the claimant had not met the burden of proof required to establish causation.

The reasoning and outcome of the case were grounded in the statutory provisions of the Civil Procedure Act 2010, which required the claimant to demonstrate a causal link between the aggravation of the shoulder pain and the psychiatric injury. The court found that the claimant had failed to meet this burden of proof and therefore dismissed the appeal. The claimant was not entitled to compensation for the psychiatric injury as there was insufficient evidence to establish a causal link with the aggravation of the shoulder pain. The court's decision was based on the inadequacy of the reasons provided and the failure to establish the necessary causal link between the physical and psychiatric injuries.

Background

Background to the litigation

Wingfoot Australia Partner Pty Ltd v Jovevski involved a claim by the plaintiff for psychiatric injury arising from the aggravation of shoulder pain. The plaintiff, who was a forklift driver, experienced shoulder pain from an earlier workplace accident. The aggravation of this pain was alleged to have caused a psychiatric injury. The case centred on whether the aggravation of the shoulder pain led to a permanent physical consequence, and if so, whether this aggravation caused the psychiatric injury claimed. The defendant disputed the factual basis of the expert evidence provided by the plaintiff and questioned the adequacy of the reasons given by the lower court in determining the psychiatric injury.

The matter was initially heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland, where the trial judge found in favour of the plaintiff. The defendant appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal. The appeal was heard by a three-judge panel. Key issues in the appeal included the factual basis of the expert evidence and the adequacy of the reasons provided by the trial judge. The plaintiff advanced a new case on appeal, which was not raised at the trial, regarding the permanent physical consequences of the aggravation of shoulder pain.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the factual basis of the expert evidence regarding the psychiatric injury adequately supported by the evidence?
2. Did the trial judge provide adequate reasons for determining that the aggravation of the shoulder pain caused the psychiatric injury?
3. Is the new case advanced by the defendant on appeal, which was not raised at the trial, to be considered by the Court of Appeal under the Civil Procedure Act 2010?

Held
1. The court held that the factual basis of the expert evidence regarding the psychiatric injury was inadequately supported by the evidence provided.
2. The court found that the trial judge did not provide adequate reasons for determining that the aggravation of the shoulder pain caused the psychiatric injury.
3. The court ruled that the new case advanced by the defendant on appeal, which was not raised at the trial, is not to be considered by the Court of Appeal under the Civil Procedure Act 2010.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the factual basis of the expert evidence regarding the psychiatric injury. The evidence was contested on appeal as it was argued that the expert's opinion did not have a sufficient factual foundation. The court held that the evidence provided was insufficient to support the expert's conclusion, leading to the conclusion that the factual basis was inadequate. Consequently, the appeal regarding the psychiatric injury was dismissed due to the lack of a solid factual foundation for the expert's opinion.

Next, the court assessed whether the trial judge provided adequate reasons for determining that the aggravation of the shoulder pain caused the psychiatric injury. The court found that the trial judge's reasons were insufficient, as they did not clearly outline the basis for connecting the aggravation of the shoulder pain to the psychiatric injury. This inadequacy in the trial judge's reasoning led to the court's conclusion that the reasons provided were not adequate, resulting in the need for further clarification on this causal link.

Finally, the court considered the new case advanced by the defendant on appeal, which was not raised at the trial. Under the Civil Procedure Act 2010, the court examined whether this new case should be considered. The court held that the new case should not be entertained as it was not presented during the trial. The reasoning behind this decision was that allowing new cases to be introduced on appeal could undermine the finality and integrity of trial proceedings, thereby the new case was not considered by the Court of Appeal. This decision reflects the court's adherence to the principles of finality in litigation proceedings and the importance of maintaining the integrity of the trial process.