Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd v Bordex Wineracks Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

WINE ACC SUPPLIES PTY LTD v BORDEX WINERACKS PTY LTD

[2014] SASCFC 49

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice Sulan and The Honourable Justice Blue)

27 May 2014

EQUITY - EQUITABLE REMEDIES - INJUNCTIONS - INTERLOCUTORY INJUNCTIONS - GENERALLY

EQUITY - EQUITABLE REMEDIES - INJUNCTIONS - INTERLOCUTORY INJUNCTIONS - INJUNCTIONS TO PRESERVE STATUS QUO AND PROPERTY PENDING DETERMINATION OF RIGHTS - MAREVA INJUNCTIONS

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - DISCHARGE, BREACH AND DEFENCES TO ACTION FOR BREACH - REPUDIATION AND NON-PERFORMANCE - ELECTION AND RESCISSION - EFFECT OF RESCISSION

Appeal against interlocutory injunction and freezing order.

In 2011, the plaintiff, Bordex Wineracks Pty Ltd, brought an action against Bordex Manufacturing Pty Ltd and its two directors for breach of restraint of trade clauses in an agreement and associated directors’ deed under which Bordex Wineracks had purchased the business of Bordex Manufacturing.  Bordex Wineracks pleaded that, by their conduct, the defendants had repudiated the agreement and directors’ deed and Bordex Wineracks accepted the repudiation.  Bordex Wineracks claimed return of the purchase price of the business.  In the alternative, it claimed damages for breach of the agreement and deed.

In 2014, Bordex Wineracks sought permission to join Wine ACC Supplies as an additional defendant, claiming that the third defendant was using it as a vehicle to carry on business in breach of the restraint of trade provision contained in the deed.  A Judge granted an interlocutory injunction and freezing order restraining Wine ACC Supplies from manufacturing or selling wine racks or disposing of its assets except in limited circumstances.

Wine ACC Supplies appeals against the interlocutory injunction and freezing order.  It contends that the agreement and deed were terminated by Bordex Wineracks in 2011 and Bordex Wineracks cannot now claim relief against it on the basis that the agreement and deed are still on foot.  It contends in the alternative that the Judge erred in the exercise of the discretion to grant an interlocutory injunction and freezing order.

Held (per the Court) allowing the appeal:

1.      The Judge erred in the exercise of his discretion in granting the injunction and freezing order.  The Judge did not address Wine ACC Supplies’ contention concerning termination of the agreement and deed.  The Judge did not give adequate weight to the unexplained delay by Bordex Wineracks in seeking any interlocutory relief against any defendant.  The balance of convenience did not favour the broad interlocutory injunction and freezing order granted (at [20]-[25]).

2.      By its statement of claim, Bordex Wineracks unequivocally terminated the agreement and deed and cannot now obtain relief against Wine ACC Supplies on the basis that the agreement and deed are still on foot (at [33]-[34]).

3.      Action against Wine ACC Supplies dismissed (at [35]).

N E Perry Pty Ltd v Judge (2002) 84 SASR 86; Heyman v Darwins Limited [1942] AC 356; Holland v Wiltshire (1954) 90 CLR 409; Ogle v Comboyuro Investments Pty Ltd (1976) 136…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd v Bordex Wineracks Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASCFC 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Victoria heard an appeal concerning an interlocutory injunction and freezing order. The plaintiff, Bordex Wineracks Pty Ltd, had brought an action against Bordex Manufacturing Pty Ltd, Duyen Minh Pham, and Dang Minh Pham, alleging breaches of a business sale agreement and a restraint of trade clause. Bordex Wineracks later sought to join Monterey Wine Accessories Pty Ltd as a fourth defendant, claiming it was operating a competing business under the control of the individual defendants. The court had previously discharged an injunction and freezing order against Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd, substituting it with new terms that restricted Wine ACC's ability to deal with its assets, except for specific business expenses and legal costs, and required monthly accounting.

The central legal issues before the court were whether Bordex Wineracks had validly accepted a repudiation of the business sale agreement, and consequently, whether its action against Bordex Manufacturing and the other defendants should be dismissed. The court also considered the implications of alternative pleas within Bordex Wineracks' pleadings regarding the termination of the contract.

The court reasoned that Bordex Wineracks' assertion of repudiation by Bordex Manufacturing, and its subsequent acceptance of that repudiation through the commencement of legal action, was a clear and unequivocal stance. The court found that an alternative plea later in the pleading, suggesting a potential wrongful termination by Bordex Wineracks, did not qualify or undermine the initial acceptance of repudiation. The court concluded that the action against Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd should be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 15 April 2014, we discharged the injunction and freezing order and in lieu substituted the following:Until further order [Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd] shall not dispose of, deal with or diminish the value of any of its assets except for the purpose of:(a) paying its reasonable legal expenses;(b) paying or receiving all income received by [Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd] into account No. […]with the Commonwealth Bank of Australia;(c) expending the money held in [Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd’s] account No. […] with the Commonwealth Bank of Australia to meet the business expenses of [Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd] bona fide and properly incurred for materials (timber, steel and packaging), office consumables, telephone, electricity, water, rent, shipping, website correction, bank fees, accounting fees and wages (wages fixed at $500 per week).Until further order [Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd] shall keep proper accounts of all income received and expenditure paid by it and file copies of the accounts with the Court as an exhibit to an affidavit of its solicitor each calendar month, the first such account to be filed on 15 May 2014.We reserved consideration of the submission that the action against Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd should be dismissed. We have now reached the conclusion that the action against Wine ACC should be dismissed. Reasons for our conclusions on all issues follow. Background In these proceedings, on 1 April 2011, the plaintiff and respondent, Bordex Wineracks Pty Ltd, brought an action against Bordex Manufacturing Pty Ltd, Duyen Minh Pham and Dang Minh Pham. In the statement of claim filed on the same day, Bordex Wineracks pleaded that it entered into an agreement with Bordex Manufacturing on 17 September 2010 whereby Bordex Wineracks purchased the business of Bordex Manufacturing for $120,000.00. The agreement included a restraint of trade clause. Duyen Pham and Dang Pham signed a directors’ deed agreeing to equivalent restraints. It was further pleaded that Bordex Wineracks, Duyen Pham and Dang Pham acted in breach of the agreement and the directors’ deed and continued in breach of the restraint to engage in a like business. Under the heading “Repudiation – Business Sale Agreement”, Bordex Wineracks pleaded:[24]By reason of the matters pleaded in paragraphs 20, 21, 22 and 23 above, [Bordex Manufacturing] has evinced an intention not to be bound by the Business Sale Agreement and repudiated the same.[25][Bordex Wineracks Pty Ltd] accepted the said repudiation by the issue and service of the Summons in this Action.[26][Bordex Wineracks Pty Ltd] has suffered loss and damage by reason of [Bordex Manufacturing’s] repudiation of the Business Sale Agreement, namely the loss of the sum of $120,000. On 6 March 2012, Bordex Wineracks applied to join Monterey Wine Accessories Pty Ltd as a defendant. It was claimed that Monterey was acting under the control of Duyen Pham and Dang Pham, and had been engaging in business in breach of the restraint provisions from a date shortly after 27 September 2010. An order was made joining Monterey as the fourth defendant. A second statement of claim was filed. The pleadings, as extracted above, remained in the same terms in the second statement of claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Earlier in these reasons, we referred to the submissions of Bordex Wineracks that asserted that the acceptance of the termination was no more than a plea in the alternative. We do not consider that the alternative plea appearing later in the pleading has the effect of qualifying the acceptance of the repudiation. Presumably, that plea was advanced against the possibility that the Court may find that Bordex Wineracks had wrongfully terminated the contract. Conclusion We dismiss the action against Wine ACC. We will hear the parties as to any consequential orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's reasoning in Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd v Bordex Wineracks Pty Ltd begins with the issue of whether Bordex Wineracks Pty Ltd effectively accepted the repudiation of the Business Sale Agreement by Bordex Manufacturing Pty Ltd. The court examined the relevant legal principles and authorities regarding acceptance of repudiation, finding that Bordex Wineracks' acceptance was unequivocal. The court concluded that Bordex Wineracks' acceptance of the repudiation was not merely a plea in the alternative, as the alternative plea was not advanced until later in the proceedings and did not qualify the acceptance of the repudiation. The court relied on the principle that acceptance of a repudiation terminates the contract and precludes a party from claiming damages for non-performance.

The court then addressed whether the acceptance of the repudiation was merely a plea in the alternative, as submitted by Bordex Wineracks. The court found that the alternative plea did not qualify the acceptance of the repudiation and that Bordex Wineracks' acceptance was unequivocal. The court distinguished the present case from prior authority, which held that an alternative plea may qualify an acceptance of repudiation, as the alternative plea in this case was advanced at a later stage in the proceedings and did not qualify the acceptance of the repudiation.

The court next considered whether it should dismiss the action against Wine ACC Supplies Pty Ltd. The court found that the action against Wine ACC should be dismissed, as there was no evidence to support the claim that Wine ACC was acting under the control of Duyen Pham and Dang Pham and engaging in business in breach of the restraint provisions. The court relied on the principle that a party must establish a prima facie case for relief before the court will grant it.

The court then addressed whether the equitable remedies granted should be varied or discharged, and if so, what alternative measures should be put in place. The court found that the remedies granted were appropriate and did not need to be varied or discharged. The court relied on the principle that equitable remedies are discretionary and should be tailored to the circumstances of each case.

Finally, the court considered whether Bordex Wineracks Pty Ltd and the other defendants breached the restraint of trade clauses and engaged in business in breach of the agreement. The court found that Bordex Wineracks and the other defendants had breached the restraint of trade clauses and engaged in business in breach of the agreement. The court relied on the principle that parties to a contract are bound by its terms and that a breach of a restraint of trade clause may entitle the other party to seek relief.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a party's unequivocal acceptance of a repudiation terminates the contract and precludes the party from claiming damages for non-performance, even if the party later advances an alternative plea. The court also found that the equitable remedies granted were appropriate and did not need to be varied or discharged, and that the defendants breached the restraint of trade clauses and engaged in business in breach of the agreement.