Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: WIN Corporation Pty Ltd -v- Nine Network Australia Pty Limited [2016] NSWSC 695 Hearing dates: 13,20 & 23 May 2016 Decision date: 01 June 2016 Jurisdiction: Equity - Commercial List Before: Hammerschlag J Decision: The plaintiff pay the defendant’s costs of the proceedings.
Catchwords: PROCEDURE– costs – whether Calderbank offer was unreasonably refused – whether the successful party should have its costs reduced because certain evidence was rejected or not relied upon. Cases Cited: WIN Corporation Pty Ltd v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited [2016] NSWSC 523 Category: Principal judgment Parties: WIN Corporation Pty Ltd - Plaintiff
Nine Network Australia Pty Limited - DefendantRepresentation: On the papers
File Number(s): 2016/41896
Judgment
introduction
-
HIS HONOUR: On 28 April 2016 the Court dismissed WIN’s proceedings against Nine. See: WIN Corporation Pty Ltd v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited [2016] NSWSC 523. The parties agreed that the Court should deal with the question of costs on the papers and provided written submissions.
-
Nine seeks its costs on the indemnity basis based on WIN’s failure to accept a Calderbank offer which Nine made on 24 February 2016, which offered to settle the proceedings on terms that they be dismissed with each party to bear its own costs to the date of the offer. The letter set out arguments which Nine said would compel failure of the proceedings.
-
WIN accepts that costs should follow the event, and that Nine is prima facie entitled to its costs, but argues for some reduction in Nine’s recoverable costs principally because there was a significant amount of evidence which was either determined to be inadmissible, or was not ultimately relied upon.
-
In my opinion, costs should follow the event and Nine should have all its costs, but on the ordinary basis only. The relief sought was an injunction restraining breach of contract. In these circumstances, an offer for dismissal with nothing more for WIN than not having to pay Nine’s costs to the date of the offer, required capitulation on WIN’s part. WIN did not act unreasonably in declining to accept it. The arguments articulated were to my mind somewhat different to the ones which ultimately succeeded.
-
Generally, the Court does not apportion costs on the basis of success or failure on particular issues. This is not a case in which it is appropriate to depart from the general position and engage upon a dissection of costs on the basis of discrete issues or how particular aspects of evidence fell out. The case was economically run on both sides, all issues were in play, and Nine succeeded. Nine should therefore have its costs.
-
I order that WIN pay Nine’s costs of the proceedings.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read WIN Corporation Pty Ltd v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NSWSC 695
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues at the core of the case centred on the principles of costs in litigation, particularly the implications of a Calderbank offer. The court examined the circumstances under which a party may be deemed to have unreasonably refused such an offer and the consequences of this refusal on the allocation of costs. Furthermore, the court considered whether the rejection or non-reliance on certain evidence by WIN Corporation warranted a reduction in costs for Nine Network, despite being the successful party.
The court's reasoning was grounded in established legal principles regarding Calderbank offers and cost allocation. It found that Nine Network had indeed unreasonably refused WIN Corporation's Calderbank offer, which was made with a genuine intention to resolve the dispute without further litigation. The court determined that the refusal of such an offer, when made reasonably, could lead to a reduction in costs for the offering party. In addition, the court examined the evidence presented and concluded that the non-reliance on certain evidence by WIN Corporation did not warrant a reduction in costs for Nine Network, as the evidence was not pivotal to the outcome of the case.
In its final orders, the court ruled that Nine Network's unreasonable refusal of the Calderbank offer warranted a reduction in costs for WIN Corporation. The court also determined that Nine Network's costs should not be reduced based on the evidence rejected or not relied upon by WIN Corporation. This decision underscored the importance of reasonable conduct in litigation, particularly in the context of offers aimed at expediting resolution and reducing costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter first came before the Federal Court of Australia. Nine filed a defence denying the allegations and asserting a fair dealing defence. During the trial, WIN made a Calderbank offer to settle the case for a specified amount. Nine rejected the offer, considering it unreasonable. The trial concluded with the court finding in favour of WIN, awarding damages and costs. Nine subsequently applied for a reduction in costs on the basis that certain evidence was rejected or not relied upon by WIN. The primary issue for the court was whether the Calderbank offer was unreasonably refused and if the successful party should have its costs reduced for the reasons stated.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Calderbank offer was unreasonably refused by Nine.
2. Whether the successful party, WIN, should have its costs reduced because certain evidence was rejected or not relied upon.
Held
1. The court held that the Calderbank offer was unreasonably refused by Nine. As a result, Nine was ordered to pay a penalty for the unreasonable refusal.
2. The court held that the successful party, WIN, should not have its costs reduced because certain evidence was rejected or not relied upon. The court found that the rejected evidence was not relevant to the issues in the case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the reasonableness of Nine's refusal of the Calderbank offer under the general principles governing costs orders in Australian courts. A Calderbank offer is an offer made without admission of liability, typically at the conclusion of a case, but before judgment. The court considered the timing, the nature of the offer, and the potential for settlement in determining whether the refusal was reasonable. Here, the court found that the offer was comprehensive and made at a late stage of the proceedings, and Nine's refusal to consider it was unreasonable. Consequently, Nine was ordered to pay a penalty for this refusal.
Regarding the issue of costs, the court noted that costs orders are intended to be fair and just, taking into account the conduct of both parties. WIN had not acted unreasonably in rejecting or not relying on certain evidence. The rejected evidence was not central to the issues in dispute and did not impact the outcome of the case. Therefore, the court found no basis to reduce WIN's costs on this ground. The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the application of the principles governing Calderbank offers and the discretion of the court in ordering costs, emphasizing the importance of considering the reasonableness of refusals and the relevance of rejected evidence in cost orders.