CITATION: Wily v Terra Cresta Business Solutions Pty Ltd (No 2) [2006] NSWSC 1102 HEARING DATE(S): 10/10/06
JUDGMENT DATE :
19 October 2006JURISDICTION: Equity Division JUDGMENT OF: Young CJ in Eq DECISION: Defendants to pay 80% of the plaintiff's costs of the expedited hearing. Costs of the interlocutory hearing and costs of the cross claim and all future costs are reserved. CATCHWORDS: COSTS [553]- Costs follow the event- Plaintiff substantially successful at expedited hearing- However substantial part of case abandoned just prior to trial- Interlocutory hearing obviated by court fixing early hearing date- Evidence prepared for interlocutory hearing not relevant to expedited hearing but relevant to cross claim- Cross claim not heard at expedited hearing- Costs of interlocutory hearing and costs of cross claim and all future costs to be reserved- Otherwise defendants to pay 80% of plaintiff's costs. PARTIES: Andrew Hugh Jenner Wily in his capacity as Liquidator of Business Australia Capital Mortgage Pty Ltd and Business Australia Capital Finance Pty Ltd (P)
Terra Cresta Business Solutions Pty Ltd (D1)
Richard Albarran and Geoffrey McDonald (D2)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 4200/06 COUNSEL: T S Hale SC (P)
J E O'Sullivan (D)SOLICITORS: M D Nikolaidis & Co (P)
Etienne Lawyers (D)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
YOUNG CJ in EQ
Thursday 19 October 2006
4200/06 – WILY v TERRA CRESTA BUSINESS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD (NO 2)
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: I gave judgment in this matter on 21 September 2006.
2 The proceedings were commenced by summons on 10 August 2006. The initial summons sought declarations that the first defendant was not entitled to appoint receivers to Business Australia Capital Mortgage Pty Ltd (BACM) or Business Australia Capital Finance Pty Ltd (BACF) and an order that the defendants be restrained from taking any steps in relation to or incidental to certain Federal Court proceedings.
3 On 14 August 2006 the summons was amended to seek declarations that charges allegedly given by BACM and BACF were each void and for a declaration that the charge granted by BACM had been satisfied in addition to the orders previously sought.
4 On 17 August 2006 the plaintiff filed a statement of claim setting out the material facts on which he relied for the orders in the amended summons.
5 The defendants filed a cross claim and later amended the cross claim. The cross claim raised questions as to whether the liquidator should be removed and as to the propriety of entering into arrangements with a litigation funder. The proceedings on the cross claim were not expedited when Brereton J expedited the main questions in the suit and I declined to hear the cross claim because it would extend the time allotted for the expedited hearing.
6 I commenced the hearing on 18 September. There were two main issues: (a) whether the charges in favour of the first defendant by BACM and BACF were valid; and (b) if valid, how much was owing under them.
7 The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wily v Terra Cresta Business Solutions Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] NSWSC 1102
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included the interpretation of contractual terms, the quantification of damages, and the allocation of costs between the parties. The court had to determine the extent of the plaintiff's success in the expedited hearing, despite the abandonment of a significant portion of the case just before the trial. The court also needed to consider the costs incurred in relation to an interlocutory hearing, which, while not directly relevant to the expedited hearing, were pertinent to a cross-claim that was not heard.
The court ruled that the plaintiff was substantially successful in the expedited hearing, but this success was mitigated by the abandonment of a major part of the case. As a result, the defendants were ordered to pay 80% of the plaintiff's costs. The costs associated with the interlocutory hearing and the cross-claim, as well as any future costs, were to be reserved for later determination. The court's decision ensured that the defendants would not bear the full burden of the plaintiff's costs but recognised the plaintiff's success in the expedited hearing by setting the reimbursement rate at 80%. This balanced approach aimed to reflect the realities of the case and the outcomes of the hearings conducted.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter of Wily v Terra Cresta Business Solutions Pty Ltd (No 2) came before the court as part of ongoing litigation concerning a commercial contract dispute. Initially, the plaintiff filed a claim against the defendant for breach of contract and other related issues. The defendant responded by filing a counterclaim for amounts allegedly owed under the contract. The case proceeded with several procedural steps, including an expedited hearing where the plaintiff substantially succeeded. However, just prior to the trial, a substantial part of the case was abandoned. The court had already fixed an early hearing date, which made an interlocutory hearing unnecessary. Despite this, evidence prepared for the interlocutory hearing remained relevant to the cross claim, which was not heard at the expedited hearing. The court ordered that the costs of the interlocutory hearing, the cross claim, and all future costs be reserved, while otherwise requiring the defendants to pay 80% of the plaintiff's costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover 80% of their costs from the defendants.
2. Whether the costs of the interlocutory hearing and the cross claim should be reserved.
3. Whether the abandonment of a substantial part of the case just prior to trial affects the apportionment of costs.
Held
1. The plaintiff is entitled to recover 80% of their costs from the defendants.
2. The costs of the interlocutory hearing and the cross claim should be reserved.
3. The abandonment of a substantial part of the case just prior to trial affects the apportionment of costs.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In determining the apportionment of costs, the court considered the principle that costs generally follow the event, meaning that the unsuccessful party usually pays the successful party's costs. However, this principle is not absolute and may be varied by the court based on the circumstances of the case. In this case, the plaintiff was substantially successful at the expedited hearing, which justified an 80% recovery of costs from the defendants. However, the abandonment of a substantial part of the case just prior to trial impacted the apportionment of costs. The court held that the interlocutory hearing was obviated by the court fixing an early hearing date, and thus, the costs associated with that hearing were reserved. Furthermore, the evidence prepared for the interlocutory hearing was not relevant to the expedited hearing but was relevant to the cross claim, which was not heard at the expedited hearing. Consequently, the costs of the cross claim and all future costs were also reserved. The court's decision to reserve these costs was based on the practicalities of the case and the need to ensure fairness in the allocation of costs. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that while costs generally follow the event, the court retains discretion to adjust the apportionment of costs based on the specific circumstances of the case, including the timing and relevance of interlocutory hearings and the abandonment of parts of the case.