Wilson v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCR 2016 0148

CHERYL ANNE-MARIE WILSON
V
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

---

JUDGES: REDLICH, KAYE JJA and CAVANOUGH AJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 17 August 2016
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 22 August 2016
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2016] VSCA 204
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2016] VSC 426 (Emerton J)

---

CRIMINAL LAW – Bail – Show cause situation – Attempted murder – Appellant pleaded not guilty by reason of mental impairment – Appellant having established diagnosis of schizophrenia – Regular methamphetamine use and non-compliance with medication in period preceding alleged offending – Whether proposed bail condition that Health Clinic report non-compliance with medical regime desirable – Previous convictions and prior incidents involving dangerous conduct during psychotic episodes – Judge not satisfied cause shown – Judge satisfied appellant unacceptable risk of harm to others – Whether judge’s conclusions open – Whether judge erred in considering a non-custodial supervision order not likely if appellant found not guilty due to mental impairment.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellant Mr L Richter Stary Norton Halphen
For the Respondent Mr G Silbert SC with Ms D Mandie Office of Public Prosecutions

REDLICH JA

KAYE JA
CAVANOUGH AJA:

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of a judge of the Trial Division on 26 July 2016 refusing the appellant’s application for bail pending the trial of charges against her in the Supreme Court.[1]

    [1]In the Matter of an Application for Bail by Cheryl Wilson [2016] VSC 426 (‘Reasons’).

  1. On 11 February 2016, the appellant was arrested and charged with four offences, including a charge of the attempted murder of her mother. Because of the nature of the charges against her, the appellant was required, pursuant to s 4(4)(c) of the Bail Act 1977, to show cause why her detention in custody was not justified. 

  1. The appellant, who is 48 years old, has suffered from long standing psychiatric illness.  Approximately ten years ago, she was diagnosed with schizophrenia.  During that period of time, she has had approximately seven admissions to public mental health facilities, the most recent of which was in 2008.  Until her arrest, the appellant had been in receipt of case management from her local area mental health service, the Harvester Clinic of the Midwest Area Mental Health Service, as a voluntary patient.  From 2013, her medication had consisted of an injectable depot anti-psychotic and an oral anti-psychotic drug.  During the latter half of 2015, the appellant’s mother, and others, became concerned about her behaviour.  She became non-compliant with her medication, and she was using methamphetamine on a regular basis.  Before the alleged offending, she last received her fortnightly anti-psychotic injection on 15 January 2016, and she had not taken her oral medication since November 2015. 

  1. For some time, the appellant had been residing in a unit leased to her by the Women’s Housing Limited Division of the Ministry of Housing in Melton South.  It appears that two days before the alleged offence, the appellant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wilson v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] VSCA 204
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Wilson v Director of Public Prosecutions, the appellant, Wilson, applied for bail pending the determination of a charge of attempted murder. The appellant had pleaded not guilty by reason of mental impairment, having been diagnosed with schizophrenia and exhibiting a history of non-compliance with medication. The nature of the dispute centred on whether the proposed bail conditions, which included a requirement to report non-compliance with medical treatment, were sufficient to ensure the safety of the community. The case was heard by the court which had to decide whether the appellant had shown cause for being released on bail and whether the risk of harm to others was unacceptable.

The court examined the legal issues regarding the criteria for granting bail in a show cause situation and the weight to be given to the appellant's mental health history, including their regular methamphetamine use and non-compliance with medication prior to the alleged offence. It was crucial to assess whether the judge's conclusions about the risk to others were open and whether the consideration of a non-custodial supervision order in the event of an acquittal due to mental impairment was appropriate. The court needed to determine if the judge had erred in their assessment of the risk posed by the appellant.

The court concluded that the judge's decision to deny bail was open, as it was based on a comprehensive assessment of the appellant's history of dangerous conduct during psychotic episodes, coupled with their non-compliance with medical treatment and substance abuse. The court found that the judge was not persuaded that the proposed bail conditions, including the requirement to report non-compliance with medical treatment, would adequately mitigate the risk of harm to others. The court further found that the judge had not erred in considering that a non-custodial supervision order was not likely if the appellant were found not guilty due to mental impairment. The appellant's application for bail was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, Wilson, has been charged with attempted murder. He has pleaded not guilty by reason of mental impairment, having established a diagnosis of schizophrenia. Wilson has a history of non-compliance with his prescribed medication and has used methamphetamine regularly. During the period before the alleged offending, his non-compliance with his medical regime was noted. Wilson has previous convictions and incidents of dangerous conduct during psychotic episodes. Despite his plea of not guilty by reason of mental impairment, he remains in custody awaiting trial.

The matter came before the court as an application for bail in a show cause situation. Wilson's legal team argued for his release on bail, proposing specific conditions to ensure his compliance with medical treatment and supervision. The prosecution opposed the bail application, citing the seriousness of the charge and Wilson's history of dangerous conduct. The court heard arguments from both parties and considered the evidence presented, including expert psychiatric opinions and details of Wilson's criminal history. Ultimately, the judge denied the bail application, finding that Wilson posed an unacceptable risk of harm to others if released.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed bail condition that a Health Clinic report on non-compliance with the medical regime was desirable.
2. Whether the judge's conclusions that Wilson posed an unacceptable risk of harm to others were open to the court.
3. Whether the judge erred in considering that a non-custodial supervision order was not likely if Wilson were found not guilty due to mental impairment.

Held
1. The court found that the proposed bail condition for a Health Clinic report on non-compliance with the medical regime was desirable to ensure the appellant's compliance with his treatment, particularly given his history of non-compliance with medication and diagnosis of schizophrenia.
2. The court held that the judge's conclusions regarding the appellant posing an unacceptable risk of harm to others were open to the court. The findings were based on the appellant's previous convictions, prior incidents of dangerous conduct during psychotic episodes, and his regular methamphetamine use.
3. The court determined that the judge did not err in considering that a non-custodial supervision order was not likely if the appellant were found not guilty due to mental impairment. The judge's conclusion was supported by the appellant's history and the nature of his offending.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the desirability of the proposed bail condition that required the Health Clinic to report on non-compliance with the appellant's medical regime. Given the appellant's diagnosis of schizophrenia and history of non-compliance with medication, the court found this condition necessary to ensure his compliance with treatment. This condition was deemed a reasonable measure to address the appellant's health issues that could impact his risk to the community.

Regarding the risk posed by the appellant, the court reviewed the appellant's previous convictions and incidents of dangerous conduct during psychotic episodes. The court found that these factors provided a sufficient basis for the judge's conclusion that the appellant posed an unacceptable risk of harm to others. The court upheld the judge's assessment, acknowledging the appellant's history of methamphetamine use, which further compounded the risk.

Lastly, the court addressed the judge's consideration of a non-custodial supervision order in the event of an acquittal due to mental impairment. The court held that the judge's view that such an order was unlikely was reasonable, considering the appellant's history and the nature of his offending. The court did not find error in the judge's reasoning, affirming that a non-custodial supervision order was not a suitable alternative given the appellant's past behaviour and health issues.