Wilson v Barker

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT  

OF QUEENSLAND  No. 666 of 1995

Brisbane

[Wilson v Barker]

BETWEEN:

ANITA RACHEL WILSON

Plaintiff

AND:

PETER JOSEPH MICHAEL BARKER

Defendant

AND:
BETWEEN:

PETER JOSEPH MICHAEL BARKER

Plaintiff
  by Counterclaim

AND:

ANITA RACHEL WILSON

First Defendant
  by Counterclaim

AND:

DANLISA PTY LTD

Second Defendant
  by Counterclaim

CATCHWORDS:     CASE APPRAISAL - Decision of a case appraiser - time at which case appraiser’s decision becomes binding upon parties - whether, in the absence of draft orders of the case appraiser, the Court is able to make orders to give effect to case appraiser’s decision - whether judicial discretion under Supreme Court of Queensland Act permits orders to be made.

Solicitors:Robbins Watson for the plaintiff/applicant

The defendant/respondent appeared on his own behalf

Hearing Date:              18 September 1998

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - ATKINSON J

Judgment delivered 1 October 1998

  1. This case arose from the breakdown of a de facto relationship between the parties.  During the course of their relationship there was some significant intermingling of their financial affairs, each of them having come to the relationship with some separate estate.  Each sought relief regarding the disposition of the property on the breakdown of their relationship.

  2. On 10 September 1997 the Court referred the matter to case appraisal pursuant to s. 102 of the Supreme Court of Queensland Act 1991 (“the Act”). The case appraisal was held on 6 May 1998. On 18 May 1998, the case appraiser’s certificate and the case appraiser’s decision were filed with the Registrar under s. 109 of the Act. Under O. 99 r. 26(1) a case appraiser’s decision must be in writing, but the case appraiser need not give reasons for the decision. On 11 June 1998, the case appraiser, at the request of the parties, dealt with the question of costs and clarified some aspects of the original decision.

  3. Subsection 97(2) of the Act provides that the case appraiser’s decision is not binding on the parties until -

    (a)the time prescribed under the rules for filing and election to go to trial has passed; and

    (b)the Supreme Court, by order, gives effect to the decision.

  4. Section 111 provides that a party may apply to the Supreme Court for an order giving effect to the case appraiser’s decision after the time prescribed under the rules for electing to go to trial has past.  In those circumstances the Court may make any order it considers appropriate in the circumstances.  Under O.99 r.30 a party who is dissatisfied with the case appraiser’s decision may elect to have the dispute go to trial in the ordinary way by filing an election in Form 522 with the Registrar.  Such election must be filed within twenty-eight days after the case appraiser’s certificate is filed in the Registry.  Unless such an election is made, under O.99 r.28 the case appraiser’s decision becomes final. 

  5. In this case, no election was made by either party to go to trial.  By notice of motion the plaintiff has applied for specific orders to give effect…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wilson v Barker and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] QSC 205
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a dispute between Anita Rachel Wilson and Peter Joseph Michael Barker regarding the division of their property following the breakdown of their de facto relationship. Both parties sought relief in relation to the disposition of their property, which included significant intermingling of their separate estates during the relationship. The matter was referred to case appraisal under s. 102 of the Supreme Court of Queensland Act 1991, and the case appraiser issued a decision on 18 May 1998. The legal issues in the case revolved around the binding nature of the case appraiser's decision and the Court's ability to make orders to give effect to the decision in the absence of draft orders from the case appraiser. The Court needed to determine whether the Supreme Court of Queensland Act permitted such orders under its judicial discretion.

The Court found that while the case appraiser's decision was not binding on the parties until specific conditions were met, the Court had the discretion to make orders to give effect to the decision under s. 111 of the Act. The Court noted that it would be preferable for the case appraiser to include draft orders in their decision to provide certainty for the parties and to assist the trial judge in determining the appropriate disposal of costs. However, the Court was still able to give effect to the case appraiser's decision in this instance, particularly due to the wide discretion provided under s. 111(3) of the Act. The Court made specific orders in relation to the sale of the parties' properties and the distribution of the proceeds, as outlined in the case appraiser's decision and the additional clarification provided on 11 June 1998.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established