Wilson and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

Wilson and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy [2022] AATA 730 (16 February 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION  

File Number(s):      2021/1586; 2021/4561

Re:Anton Wilson

APPLICANT

AndInspector-General in Bankruptcy

RESPONDENT

REASONS FOR DECISION

Tribunal:  The Hon. Matthew Groom, Senior Member

Date of decision  16 February 2022

Date of written reasons:         12 April 2022

Place:Melbourne

The applications for reinstatement are dismissed.

...............................[SDG]...............................

The Hon. Matthew Groom, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS - application for reinstatement – applicant failed to comply with directions – applicant failed to appear at directions hearing – whether reinstatement is appropriate – application dismissed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)

CASES

Jones and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy [2018] AATA 3260.
Re Manoli and Secretary, Department of Social Security [1994] AATA 130; (1994) 35 ALD
133. 
Re Oates and Department of Social Security (1994) 37 ALD 241.

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. Matthew Groom, Senior Member

INTRODUCTION

  1. These applications were dismissed by the Tribunal on 17 December 2021 pursuant to section 42A(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (the AAT Act).

  2. By email dated 11 January 2022, the applicant sought reinstatement of the applications. The Tribunal has treated that email as an application for reinstatement pursuant to section 42A(8A) of the AAT Act. Although the applicant’s email referred to only one of the matters, application number 2021/4561, the Tribunal has proceeded on the basis that the reinstatement sought by the applicant was in respect of both matters.

  3. On 16 February 2022, the Tribunal dismissed the applications for reinstatement.

  4. Set out below are the reasons for that decision.

    BACKGROUND

  5. It is appropriate to set out the procedural background to the substantive applications in some detail.

  6. The substantive applications brought by the applicant relate to two separate but connected matters arising out of the applicant’s bankruptcy. The applicant was made bankrupt on


    6 September 2017.

  7. Application number 2021/1586 is an application for review of a decision made by the respondent on 18 February 2021 under section 149K of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (the Bankruptcy Act), whereby the respondent confirmed a notice of objection to the discharge of the applicant’s bankruptcy.

  8. Application number 2021/4561 is an application for review of a decision made by the respondent on 8 June 2021 under section 139ZA of the Bankruptcy Act, whereby the respondent refused to conduct a review of certain income contribution assessments.

  9. The procedural history of each of the applications leading up to the hearing on 17 December 2021 is as follows:

    Application number 2021/1586

    (a)The applicant was initially represented by solicitors, Hunt & Hunt, and a case conference was held on 16 June 2021. Consent orders were made requiring the applicant to serve further evidence by 16 August 2021, and the conference adjourned to 24 August 2021.

    (b)On 19 August 2021, the applicant’s legal representatives sought an extension of time for the provision of the further evidence to 29 September 2021 and a corresponding adjournment of the conference to a later date. The extension of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wilson and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 730
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Senior Member of the Tribunal considered applications for reinstatement brought by the applicant, Anton Wilson, in relation to two separate but connected matters arising from his bankruptcy. The first application concerned a review of the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy's decision to confirm a notice of objection to the discharge of the applicant's bankruptcy. The second application related to a review of the Inspector-General's refusal to conduct a review of certain income contribution assessments. The applicant had failed to comply with numerous directions issued by the Tribunal, including providing evidence and attending hearings, and had also failed to appear at a non-compliance hearing on 17 December 2021.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it was appropriate to reinstate the applicant's applications, given his persistent non-compliance with procedural directions and his failure to appear at the final non-compliance hearing. This required the Tribunal to consider all relevant circumstances, including whether the applicant had provided a reasonable excuse for his non-appearance, the prospects of success in the substantive applications if reinstated, and issues of fairness and prejudice to the parties. The Tribunal also had to assess the applicant's explanations for his non-compliance, which included claims of personal health issues, stress, anxiety, and family illness, and his assertion that he had not previously understood the requirement to provide medical certificates.

The Tribunal reasoned that while it was required to consider all circumstances, including the applicant's stated personal difficulties and his eventual engagement with professional help, the applicant had a history of failing to comply with directions and provide necessary documentation, despite repeated opportunities and clear warnings. The Tribunal noted that the applicant had been granted several adjournments and had been explicitly directed to provide medical certificates to substantiate his claims of inability to participate, which he had failed to do on multiple occasions. The Tribunal found that the applicant's explanations for his non-compliance, particularly his failure to attend the 17 December 2021 hearing, were not sufficiently compelling to warrant reinstatement, especially in light of the extensive procedural history and the prejudice that further delays would cause.

Consequently, the Tribunal determined that it was not appropriate to reinstate the applications. The applications for reinstatement were dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Set out below are the reasons for that decision.BACKGROUND It is appropriate to set out the procedural background to the substantive applications in some detail. The substantive applications brought by the applicant relate to two separate but connected matters arising out of the applicant’s bankruptcy. The applicant was made bankrupt on 6 September 2017. Application number 2021/1586 is an application for review of a decision made by the respondent on 18 February 2021 under section 149K of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (the Bankruptcy Act), whereby the respondent confirmed a notice of objection to the discharge of the applicant’s bankruptcy. Application number 2021/4561 is an application for review of a decision made by the respondent on 8 June 2021 under section 139ZA of the Bankruptcy Act, whereby the respondent refused to conduct a review of certain income contribution assessments. The procedural history of each of the applications leading up to the hearing on 17 December 2021 is as follows:Application number 2021/1586(a)The applicant was initially represented by solicitors, Hunt & Hunt, and a case conference was held on 16 June 2021. Consent orders were made requiring the applicant to serve further evidence by 16 August 2021, and the conference adjourned to 24 August 2021.(b)On 19 August 2021, the applicant’s legal representatives sought an extension of time for the provision of the further evidence to 29 September 2021 and a corresponding adjournment of the conference to a later date. The extension of time was granted, and the case conference was adjourned to 3 November 2021. (c)The applicant failed to comply with the direction to provide the further evidence within the extended time.(d)On 1 November 2021, Hunt & Hunt advised the Tribunal that it was no longer acting for the applicant. (e)The matter was listed for a non-compliance hearing on 19 November 2021.(f)On 18 November 2021, the applicant sought an adjournment of the non-compliance hearing on the basis that he was feeling unwell due to a suspected case of Covid19. No medical evidence was provided. The respondent opposed the adjournment in the absence of medical evidence.(g)On 19 November 2021, a further email on behalf of the applicant was sent to the Tribunal stating that the applicant was suffering the effects of a suspected case of Covid19. Again, no medical evidence was provided. The Tribunal adjourned the non-compliance hearing to 26 November 2021 and requested that the applicant provide a medical certificate in respect of any condition preventing him from participating in the hearing as soon as possible. (h)On 25 November 2021, the applicant sought an ‘indefinite’ adjournment of the non-compliance hearing listed for 26 November 2021 on medical grounds. The respondent opposed the request. The Tribunal granted a further adjournment to 17 December 2021 but directed that the applicant produce a medical certificate evidencing any condition that prevented him from participating in both the 19 November 2021 and 26 November 2021 non-compliance hearings, and for the further period of adjournment being requested. The Tribunal also advised the applicant that it did not consider it appropriate to continue to adjourn the matter indefinitely and emphasised the importance of the applicant providing a medical certificate explaining the basis of the applicant’s inability to participate in the non-compliance hearings. (i)On 10 December 2021, the Tribunal issued a further direction requiring the applicant to lodge medical certificates in respect of the 19 November 2021 and 26 November 2021 adjournments by 12 noon on 15 December 2021 and that any further requests for an adjournment should be accompanied by a medical certificate evidencing the basis for the request. (j)Again, the applicant did not comply with the Tribunal’s direction.Application number 2021/4561(a)The matter was initially set down for a case conference on 24 August 2021, to be considered concurrently with the other matter.(b)On 19 August 2021, in response to a Listing Notice, Hunt & Hunt advised that it had not previously been retained to act for the applicant in this matter.(c)On 22 August 2021, the applicant sought an adjournment of the case conference until October citing resourcing, Covid19 impacts, family responsibilities and personal health issues. The respondent opposed the adjournment. The request for an adjournment was rejected by the Conference Registrar on the basis that insufficient material had been provided by the applicant to support the request and a concern in relation to the lack of progress in the matter. The Conference Registrar also advised the Applicant that this matter, which had been set down to be considered concurrently with application number 2021/1586, would be administratively separated following the advice of Hunt & Hunt that it did not represent the applicant in this proceeding. The applicant indicated that he would attend the case conference. (d)The applicant failed to attend the case conference on 24 August 2021.(e)The Conference Registrar then issued directions requiring the applicant to provide materials in respect of the matter by 29 September 2021.(f)On 27 September 2021, the applicant contacted the respondent seeking its consent to an extension of time for the filing of his materials citing personal health reasons. The respondent opposed the request. The applicant undertook to provide a statutory declaration providing further details of the basis for his request for an extension of time by the next day, 28 September 2021. Again, the applicant failed to do so. (g)The applicant also failed to comply with the Conference Registrar’s direction in relation to the provision of materials by 29 September 2021. (h)On 4 October 2021, the respondent requested a non-compliance hearing.(i)The matter was subsequently listed for a non-compliance hearing by the Conference Registrar to be held on 20 October 2021.(j)By email dated 19 October 2021 the applicant advised that he would not be in a “fit state of mind” to attend the non-compliance hearing and advised that he has instructed Hunt & Hunt to represent him at the hearing. Hunt & Hunt corresponded with the Tribunal on the same day advising that it had not agreed to act in the matter and requesting that the applicant be contacted directly. (k)On 20 October 2021, the applicant requested an adjournment of the 20 October 2021 non-compliance hearing due to the impact of the recent death of his sister and advising that he was not in a “fit state of mind”. The Tribunal granted an adjournment of the non-compliance hearing until 5 November 2021 but advised that a medical certificate be provided for any further adjournment requests. (l)On 4 November 2021, the applicant emailed the Tribunal advising that he was unable to attend the non-compliance hearing and attached a medical certificate. The medical certificate noted that: This is to certify that Mr Anton Wilson is unfit to attend court [and] is receiving medical treatment and [sic] for the period 2 November 2021 to 16 November 2021 inclusive.(m)The Tribunal advised the applicant that it would grant the adjournment but that any further adjournment requests would require a more detailed explanation from the medical practitioner about the condition or ailment necessitating the request. The Tribunal also indicated to the applicant that it did not consider it appropriate to continue to provide adjournments indefinitely. On the following day, 19 November 2021, the matter was then relisted for a further non-compliance hearing to take place on 26 November 2021 on the same day as application number 2021/1586.(n)The matters were considered by the Tribunal concurrently from that point in time and the subsequent procedural steps are the same as for application number 2021/1586.Non-compliance hearing held on 17 December 2021

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having had careful regard to all of the circumstances, the Tribunal does not consider it appropriate to reinstate the applications. Accordingly, the Tribunal dismisses the applications for reinstatement.DECISION The applications for reinstatement are dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There have been a number of previous cases that have considered the approach to be adopted when applying section 42A(9).[1] The task for the Tribunal is to consider all of the relevant circumstances in making an assessment as to whether reinstatement is appropriate. In this particular case, that would include whether the applicant has provided a reasonable excuse for his non-appearance at the 17 December 2021 hearing; the prospects of the applicant succeeding in the substantive applications if reinstated; and a consideration of fairness and prejudice issues.CONSIDERATION[1] See for example Re Manoli and Secretary, Department of Social Security [1994] AATA 130; (1994) 35 ALD 133 and also Re Oates and Department of Social Security (1994) 37 ALD 241. Excuse for the applicant’s failure to appear at the 17 December 2021 hearing In his emails to the Tribunal on 11, 12 and 14 January 2022 the applicant stated that he has been dealing with a number of personal issues including “caring for a gravely ill family member”, “battling [his] own mental health issues” and that he was unable to attend the hearing on 17 December 2021 due to “personal health issues associated with severe stress and anxiety as a result of the death of a friend” and the “illness of close family members”. The applicant also indicated that he was having some resourcing issues but that he hoped to have representation in place in around March. The initial hearing of the reinstatement applications was held on 8 February 2022. Both parties attended the hearing by telephone. The applicant told the Tribunal that he was seeking to have the matters reinstated and that the reason he had been unable to attend the 17 December 2021 non-compliance hearing was due to him suffering from severe mental health issues, stress and pressure. He told the Tribunal that he had not previously fully understood his condition and had not previously had professional help but that he had since secured such help. He told the Tribunal that he had a lot of personal issues to deal with late last year and he had not realised that he needed to provide medical certificates previously but that he had medical certificates from September, October and November 2021 in his possession and he could provide them to the Tribunal “before 5pm”. He told the Tribunal that he could provide any further information required to explain his failure to attend the 17 December hearing in the coming days and requested an adjournment of the hearing to be able to do so. When the Tribunal pointed out to the applicant that it had previously issued a number of directions requiring the provision of the medical certificates, the applicant replied that he could “quite honestly not recall that because I have been in a difficult state”. The applicant went on to tell the Tribunal that he was now in a good mental health state and felt that he was now able to provide any information required and to progress the matters in a timely way, noting that he had good support from family and friends who were able to assist. The applicant also told the Tribunal that he was hoping to secure some legal representation to assist him by the time of the next hearing.