Willmington & Anor v. Cassidy

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Willmington & Anor v Cassidy [2007] QDC 073

PARTIES:

DAVID MORRIS WILLMINGTON
First Plaintiff

and

KATHRYN DEBORAH WILLMINGTON
Second Plaintiff

v

WAYNE ROBERT CASSIDY
Defendant

By counterclaim

WAYNE ROBERT CASSIDY
Plaintiff

v

DAVID MORRIS WILLMINGTON
First Defendant

and

KATHRYN DEBORAH WILLMINGTON
Second Defendant

and

SCOTT OWEN McDONALD
Third Defendant

FILE NO/S:

BD1253/2005

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

24 April 2007

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

19, 20, 21, 23 March 2007

JUDGE:

Rafter SC DCJ

ORDER:

1. Judgment that the defendant Mr Cassidy pay the first
    plaintiff Mr Willmington $19,400.40

2. Judgment that the defendant Mr Cassidy pay the
    second plaintiff Mrs Willmington $12,374.65

3. Judgment that the plaintiff by counterclaim Mr Cassidy
     pay the third defendant by counterclaim Mr McDonald
     $16,149.50

4. The action for assault by the plaintiff by counterclaim
     Mr Cassidy against the first and third defendants by
     counterclaim Mr Willmington and Mr McDonald is
     dismissed

5. The action for harassment by the plaintiff by
     counterclaim Mr Cassidy against the first and third
     defendants by counterclaim Mr Willmington and
     Mr McDonald is dismissed

6. The action for intentional infliction of harm by the
     plaintiff by counterclaim Mr Cassidy against the first  
     and second defendants by counterclaim Mr and
     Mrs Willmington is dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

ASSAULT AND BATTERY – Credibility of witnesses

AMENDMENT – Amendment of Defence and Counterclaim to add cause of action outside limitation period - Harassment and intentional infliction of harm

DAMAGES – Compensatory damages - Aggravated damages – Exemplary damages – Assessment

COUNSEL:

P W Hackett for the plaintiffs and defendants by counterclaim

A J Kimmins and K A M Greenwood for the defendant and plaintiff by counterclaim

SOLICITORS:

Frank Carroll for the plaintiffs and defendants by counterclaim

Ryan & Bosscher for the defendant and plaintiff by counterclaim

Introduction

  1. These proceedings largely arise out of an incident that occurred at the Wishart Shopping Village on Tuesday, 24 October 2000 at about 11.50 pm.  There are claims and cross-claims for damages made by all parties.

  1. The defendant, Mr Cassidy, makes an additional claim for damages for harassment and intentional infliction of harm caused by conduct of the plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Willmington, and the third defendant by counterclaim Mr McDonald, caused by conduct arising after 24 October 2000.  The plaintiffs and the third defendant by counterclaim contend that the claims for harassment and intentional infliction of harm are statute barred.

  1. Mr David Willmington is the first plaintiff and first defendant by counterclaim.

  1. Mrs Kathryn Willmington is the second plaintiff and second defendant by counterclaim.

  1. Mr and Mrs Willmington are the directors of DK Pty Ltd, the lessee of Shop 16 at the Wishart Shopping Village.  The company operates an Italian restaurant called “Donini’s byo Wishart”.  DK Pty Ltd acquired the restaurant as a going concern in December 1999.  It commenced operating the restaurant from 1 December 1999.

  1. Mr Wayne Cassidy is the defendant and plaintiff by counterclaim.  He is a chartered accountant.  He conducted his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Willmington & Anor v. Cassidy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] QDC 73
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Willmington & Anor v. Cassidy, the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia heard a dispute involving allegations of assault, battery, harassment, and intentional infliction of harm. The plaintiffs, Mr Willmington and Mrs Willmington, sought compensation for injuries and distress caused by the defendant, Mr Cassidy, who also raised counterclaims against the Willmingtons and a third party, Mr McDonald. The court had to determine whether the defendant's counterclaims were admissible, given they were outside the limitation period, and assess the merits of the claims and counterclaims, including the credibility of the witnesses.

The legal issues before the court included whether the defendant's late-filed Defence and Counterclaim, which added causes of action outside the limitation period, were permissible. The court also had to decide the merits of the claims and counterclaims, assess the credibility of the parties' evidence, and determine the appropriate compensatory, aggravated, and exemplary damages. Furthermore, the court had to consider the admissibility of the counterclaims given the delay in filing them.

The court held that the defendant's Defence and Counterclaim were not admissible as they were filed outside the limitation period. The court found the plaintiffs' claims of assault and battery to be credible and awarded them damages. Specifically, the court ordered Mr Cassidy to pay Mr Willmington $19,400.40 and Mrs Willmington $12,374.65. In relation to the counterclaim, the court found in favour of the third defendant, Mr McDonald, ordering Mr Cassidy to pay him $16,149.50. The court dismissed all the counterclaims brought by Mr Cassidy against the Willmingtons and Mr McDonald.

The court's final orders included judgments for the plaintiffs against Mr Cassidy for compensatory damages, dismissal of all counterclaims, and an order for Mr Cassidy to pay Mr McDonald. This outcome reflected the court's determination of the credibility of the evidence and the admissibility of the claims and counterclaims.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Judgment that the defendant Mr Cassidy pay the first

plaintiff Mr Willmington $19,400.40

2. Judgment that the defendant Mr Cassidy pay the

second plaintiff Mrs Willmington $12,374.65

3. Judgment that the plaintiff by counterclaim Mr Cassidy

pay the third defendant by counterclaim Mr McDonald

$16,149.50

4. The action for assault by the plaintiff by counterclaim

Mr Cassidy against the first and third defendants by

counterclaim Mr Willmington and Mr McDonald is

dismissed

5. The action for harassment by the plaintiff by

counterclaim Mr Cassidy against the first and third

defendants by counterclaim Mr Willmington and

Mr McDonald is dismissed

6. The action for intentional infliction of harm by the

plaintiff by counterclaim Mr Cassidy against the first

and second defendants by counterclaim Mr and

Mrs Willmington is dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.