Willis v Bourke Proclaimed Place Incorporated trading as Dumbi Bourke Proclaimed Place

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE REGISTRAR IN RELATION TO COSTS

CITATION:Willis v Bourke Proclaimed Place Incorporated t/as Dumbi Bourke Proclaimed Place [2007] NSWWCCPD 38

APPELLANT:  Raymond Matthew Willis 

RESPONDENT:  Bourke Proclaimed Place Incorporated t/as Dumbi Bourke Proclaimed Place 

INSURER:QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited

FILE NUMBER:  WCC12890-05

DATE OF REGISTRAR’S DECISION:             24 January 2006

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  7 February 2007

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Appeal against the Registrar’s Assessment of Costs; various Items in Schedule 6 of the Workers Compensation Regulation (2003); disbursements and costs.

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      McCabe Partners Lawyers

Respondent:   Hunt & Hunt Solicitors

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  1.        The Registrar’s determination of Mr

Willis’ claim for costs in this matter, dated 24 January 2006 is amended in accordance with these reasons.

2.        The Respondent, Bourke Proclaimed   Place Incorporated t/as Dumbi Bourke   Proclaimed Place to pay the Appellant,   Mr Willis, $275.00 inclusive of GST   in respect of his costs in this appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

1.On 21 February 2006 Raymond Matthew Willis (‘Mr Willis’) filed an ‘Appeal Against a Cost Determination’ made by the Registrar of the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) on 24 January 2006. The Respondent to the appeal is Bourke Proclaimed Place Incorporated t/as Dumbi Bourke Proclaimed Place (‘Dumbi Bourke’). Dumbi Bourke’s insurer was QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited (‘QBE’).

2.On 19 May 2006 Dumbi Bourke filed submissions in opposition to the appeal. On 15 August 2006 Mr Willis filed further submissions in reply.

3.On 29 October 2004 Mr Willis filed an ‘Application to Resolve a Dispute’ in the Commission seeking compensation benefits from Dumbi Bourke allegedly as a consequence of the nature and conditions of his employment with Dumbi Bourke from 1999 until October 2002.

4.The parties attended a conciliation/arbitration hearing on 29 April 2005 where, with the assistance of the Arbitrator, the parties were able to come to an agreed resolution of Mr Willis’ claim for benefits. A ‘Certificate of Determination – Consent Orders’ noted: “The Respondent to pay the Applicant’s costs as agreed or assessed.’

5.On 1 August 2005, the parties having failed to agree on the costs payable, Mr Willis’ solicitor filed an ‘Application for Assessment of Costs’ with the Commission in respect of his Bill of Costs dated 29 April 2005. Dumbi Bourke filed submissions in relation to that Bill on 23 August 2005.

6.The Registrar delegated the Assessment of Costs to a Commission Arbitrator (‘the Delegate’) who made a determination dated 24 January 2006. The ‘Certificate of Determination’ was in the following terms:

“1.      Pursuant to Agreements and Order dated 20 May 2005 the Respondent   employer is liable to pay the Applicant’s costs of the Application as agreed   or assessed.

2.        The Applicant’s costs of the proceedings assessed in the sum of $6,265.40   (inclusive of GST) are determined as fair and reasonable.

3.        The Applicant’s costs of the assessment are not allowed.

4.        The Respondent is to pay the amount of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Willis v Bourke Proclaimed Place Incorporated trading as Dum... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWWCCPD 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Raymond Matthew Willis filed an appeal against the Registrar's determination of his claim for costs in the Workers Compensation Commission. The appeal was against the decision made by the Registrar on 24 January 2006. The Respondent to the appeal was Bourke Proclaimed Place Incorporated trading as Dumbi Bourke Proclaimed Place. Willis' solicitor argued that the Delegate made errors of law in interpreting clauses 82 and 84 of the Workers Compensation Regulation (2003) and in assessing the costs by reference to the Compensation Costs Table set out in Schedule 6 of the 2003 Regulation. The Acting Deputy President, Deborah Moore, reviewed the Delegate's determination and made some amendments. The total amount of the Delegate's determination of $6,265.40 (inclusive of GST) was increased by $819.64 to $7,085.04. The Registrar's determination of Willis' claim for costs in this matter was amended in accordance with the Acting Deputy President's reasons. Bourke Proclaimed Place Incorporated trading as Dumbi Bourke Proclaimed Place was ordered to pay Willis $275.00 inclusive of GST in respect of his costs of this appeal.

The Acting Deputy President, Deborah Moore, reviewed the Delegate's determination of Willis' claim for costs and found that the Delegate had made some errors in assessing the costs. The Acting Deputy President amended the Delegate's determination and increased the total amount by $819.64 to $7,085.04. The Registrar's determination of Willis' claim for costs was amended in accordance with the Acting Deputy President's reasons. Bourke Proclaimed Place Incorporated trading as Dumbi Bourke Proclaimed Place was ordered to pay Willis $275.00 inclusive of GST in respect of his costs of this appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Raymond Matthew Willis filed an 'Appeal Against a Cost Determination' against Bourke Proclaimed Place Incorporated trading as Dumbi Bourke Proclaimed Place (Dumbi Bourke) regarding the assessment of costs made by the Registrar of the Workers Compensation Commission on 24 January 2006. Willis had previously filed an 'Application to Resolve a Dispute' on 29 October 2004 seeking compensation benefits from Dumbi Bourke allegedly due to the nature and conditions of his employment with Dumbi Bourke from 1999 until October 2002. The parties attended a conciliation/arbitration hearing on 29 April 2005 where they reached an agreed resolution of Willis' claim for benefits. The Registrar assessed Willis' costs of the proceedings as $6,265.40 (inclusive of GST) and determined that Dumbi Bourke was liable to pay these costs. Willis appealed this decision, arguing that the Registrar made errors in interpreting the Workers Compensation Regulation and assessing the costs according to the Compensation Costs Table.

Raymond Matthew Willis filed an appeal against the Registrar's determination of costs in the Workers Compensation Commission on 21 February 2006. The appeal was heard by Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore on the papers, without a formal hearing. Dumbi Bourke filed submissions in opposition to the appeal on 19 May 2006, and Willis filed further submissions in reply on 15 August 2006. Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore issued her decision on 7 February 2007, amending the Registrar's determination of costs and ordering Dumbi Bourke to pay Willis' costs of the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Delegate make errors of law in his interpretation of clauses 82 and 84 of the Workers Compensation Regulation (2003) and in his Assessment of Costs by reference to the Compensation Costs Table set out in Schedule 6 of the 2003 Regulation?
2. What is the appropriate amount of costs to be awarded to Willis in relation to the disputed professional costs and disbursements?
3. Should Dumbi Bourke be ordered to pay Willis' costs of the appeal?

Held
1. The Delegate made no errors of law in his interpretation of clauses 82 and 84 of the Workers Compensation Regulation (2003) and in his Assessment of Costs by reference to the Compensation Costs Table set out in Schedule 6 of the 2003 Regulation.
2. The appropriate amount of costs to be awarded to Willis in relation to the disputed professional costs and disbursements is to increase the Registrar’s determination of $6,265.40 to $7,085.04 (inclusive of GST).
3. Dumbi Bourke is to pay Willis' costs of the appeal in the sum of $275.00 inclusive of GST.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal against the Registrar’s Assessment of Costs was heard on the papers, with both parties submitting written arguments. The key issue was whether the Delegate made errors of law in his interpretation of the relevant regulations and in his Assessment of Costs by reference to the Compensation Costs Table. Willis argued that the Delegate erred in his interpretation of the relevant clauses and in his assessment of certain costs, while Dumbi Bourke contended that no such errors were made. The Acting Deputy President reviewed the submissions and the Delegate’s Statement of Reasons, and found that the Delegate did not make errors of law. The Acting Deputy President examined each disputed item of costs and disbursements in detail, applying the relevant statutory provisions and precedents to determine whether the Delegate’s decisions were correct. The Acting Deputy President confirmed some of the Delegate’s disallowances, allowed some disallowed claims, and disallowed some allowed claims. The determination of the appropriate amount of costs to be awarded to Willis was adjusted accordingly. The Acting Deputy President also addressed the issue of costs of the appeal, finding that Willis was partly successful and ordering Dumbi Bourke to pay Willis' costs of the appeal in the sum of $275.00 inclusive of GST. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Delegate's assessment of costs should be reviewed in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions and precedents, and that costs of appeal should be awarded to the partly successful party.