[2003] TASSC 125
CITATION: Williams v Norske Skog Papers Mills (Australia) Ltd [2003] TASSC 125
PARTIES: WILLIAMS, Gregory Alan
v
NORSKE SKOG PAPERS MILLS (AUSTRALIA) LTD
TITLE OF COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION: APPELLATE
FILE NO/S: LCA 96/2003
DELIVERED ON: 26 November 2003
DELIVERED AT: Hobart
HEARING DATE: 20 November 2003
JUDGMENT OF: Cox CJ
CATCHWORDS:
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Appellant: R M Grueber
Respondent: I L Hallett
Solicitors:
Appellant: Ogilvie Jennings
Respondent: Page Seager
Judgment Number: [2003] TASSC 125
Number of paragraphs: 12
Serial No 125/2003
File No LCA 96/2003
GREGORY ALAN WILLIAMS v
NORSKE SKOG PAPERS MILLS (AUSTRALIA) LTD
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT COX CJ
24 November 2003
The appellant ("the worker") appeals a determination or ruling of the Chief Commissioner of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal ("the Tribunal") established by the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ("the Act"), s16, whereby on the facts before him he found, as a matter of law, no obligation on the respondent ("the employer") to have commenced weekly payments of compensation to the worker, nor any basis for the Tribunal to order weekly payments to be made to him.
The worker made application for a determination as to his entitlement to the payment of weekly payments in respect of an injury to both wrists that occurred on or about 5 June 1998, such claim for compensation being in the form of a medical certificate provided by the worker dated 17 March 2003. The following facts were agreed:
"· The worker made a claim for compensation dated 16 June 1998 supported by a medical certificate with a diagnosis of "soft tissue stress to both wrists", such injury alleged to have occurred out of and in the course of the worker's employment.
· This claim for compensation was accepted.
· By order of the Tribunal dated 28 September 2001 the rate of weekly payments to be paid by the employer to the worker was reduced to $460.00.
· The worker served on the employer a worker's compensation medical certificate dated 17 March 2003 on a date somewhere between 18 and 25 March 2003.
· Prior to the aforementioned medical certificate the previous medical certificate served by the worker on the employer was a certificate dated 2 September 2002.
· The employer disputed liability in respect to the workers compensation medical certificate dated 17 March 2003 and referred that dispute to the Tribunal as provided by s81A of the Act.
· This referral was dismissed by the Tribunal on the basis that there was no jurisdiction to entertain the referral as apparently the employer had failed to comply with the time limit established by s81A.
· The certificate of 2 September 2002 certified as to an ongoing incapacity up until 31 October 2002, however the employer continued to make payments of compensation in the absence of further certification.
· When the next medical certificate, ie that dated 17 March 2003, was delivered the employer ceased paying compensation and thereupon made the s81A referral.
· Subsequent…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Williams v Norske Skog Papers Mills (Australia) Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] TASSC 125
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key legal issues before the court were whether the employer was required to commence weekly compensation payments upon receipt of the new medical certificate and whether the Tribunal should order the employer to make such payments. The court had to interpret the relevant provisions of the Act, particularly those concerning claims for compensation and the obligations of employers regarding the payment of weekly compensation.
The court held that the Chief Commissioner was incorrect in finding that there was no obligation on the employer to commence weekly payments upon receipt of the new medical certificate. The court reasoned that the employer's obligation to pay compensation had been in abeyance since 1 November 2002, but it revived under section 69(1) of the Act upon the receipt of the new certificate. The court found that the employer's reference disputing liability was lodged out of time and did not provide any justification for the cessation of payments. Since liability had already been established, the court concluded that there was no reason why the Chief Commissioner should not have ordered a resumption of payments. The appeal was allowed on grounds 3 and 4, and the court ordered the employer to pay weekly compensation from the date upon which it ceased to pay the same until the expiration of any period of incapacity as certified.
Background
Background to the litigation
On 17 March 2003, Williams served the employer with a new medical certificate concerning his wrist injury. The previous certificate, dated 2 September 2002, certified an ongoing incapacity up until 31 October 2002. Despite this, the employer continued to make compensation payments until the receipt of the new medical certificate. Upon receiving the 17 March 2003 certificate, the employer ceased payments and referred the matter to the Tribunal under section 81A of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. The referral was dismissed by the Tribunal as the employer had failed to comply with the time limit established by section 81A.
Following the dismissal of the employer's referral, weekly compensation payments were not resumed. The Chief Commissioner of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal found that there was no obligation on the employer to commence weekly compensation payments upon receipt of the 17 March 2003 medical certificate and that there was no basis for the Tribunal to order the employer to make such payments. The Tribunal's decision was based on the interpretation that the 17 March 2003 medical certificate constituted a fresh claim for compensation under the amended Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. Williams subsequently appealed this decision.
This appeal came before the Supreme Court of Tasmania on the appellant's appeal from a determination of the Chief Commissioner of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal. The appeal concerns a dispute over the respondent employer's obligation to pay weekly compensation to the appellant worker following a medical certificate submitted in relation to a previous wrist injury claim. The Tribunal had found no obligation on the employer to commence weekly payments of compensation to the worker nor any basis for the Tribunal to order weekly payments to be made to him. The appellant contested this determination, arguing that the employer should have resumed weekly payments upon receipt of a fresh medical certificate after a gap in certification. The appeal was heard on 20 November 2003, and judgment was delivered on 26 November 2003. Key procedural steps include the worker's initial application to the Tribunal for a determination of entitlement to weekly payments, the Tribunal's dismissal of the employer's referral disputing liability, and the Tribunal's ruling that there was no obligation on the employer to commence weekly payments and no basis for the Tribunal to order such payments. The appeal to the Supreme Court focused on whether the Tribunal erred in concluding that certain sections of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 did not apply, and whether the Tribunal should have ordered the employer to resume weekly payments.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the presentation of a fresh medical certificate after a break in the continuity of certification constitute a further claim for workers compensation under the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988?
2. How does the insertion of s69(13) and the amendment of s80A by the amending Act impact the applicability of other provisions in PtVII, Div1 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988?
3. Was the Chief Commissioner correct in determining that s81(1) of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 did not apply to a reference pursuant to s69(13)?
4. Was the Chief Commissioner correct in determining that s81AB of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 did not apply to a reference pursuant to s69(13)?
5. Was there an obligation on the employer to have commenced paying weekly payments of compensation upon receipt of the subject medical certificate?
6. Was there a basis for the Tribunal to order that the employer pay weekly payments of workers compensation to the worker?
Held
1. The court held that the presentation of a fresh medical certificate after a break in the continuity of certification does not constitute a further claim for workers compensation under the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, when the legislation has been amended by the inserting of s69(13) and s80A.
2. The insertion of s69(13) and the amendment of s80A by the amending Act impacts the applicability of other provisions in PtVII, Div1 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 by excluding some parts of the provisions from applying to claims such as the present.
3. The court held that the Chief Commissioner was not correct in determining that s81(1) of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 did not apply to a reference pursuant to s69(13).
4. The court held that the Chief Commissioner was not correct in determining that s81AB of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 did not apply to a reference pursuant to s69(13).
5. The court held that there was an obligation on the employer to have commenced paying weekly payments of compensation upon receipt of the subject medical certificate.
6. The court held that there was a basis for the Tribunal to order that the employer pay weekly payments of workers compensation to the worker.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Williams v Norske Skog Papers Mills (Australia) Ltd, the Supreme Court of Tasmania examined several issues concerning the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act). The primary issue was whether the presentation of a fresh medical certificate after a break in the continuity of certification constituted a further claim for workers compensation. The court held that such a presentation could constitute a fresh claim under the Act, but this was not the case here given the legislative amendments that followed. The insertion of section 69(13) and the amendment of section 80A by the amending Act changed the applicability of other provisions in Part VII, Division 1 of the Act. The court found that these amendments meant that certain provisions did not apply to claims such as the one in this case, although other provisions could still apply, depending on their wording and context.
The court further examined whether the Chief Commissioner was correct in determining that section 81(1) of the Act did not apply to a reference pursuant to section 69(13). The court ruled that the Chief Commissioner was correct in this determination. Section 81(1) imposes an obligation on the employer to commence payments of weekly compensation, but this section only applies to claims that are not previous claims against the same or another employer in respect of the same injury. Given that the claim in question was a previous claim, section 81(1) did not apply. Similarly, the court found that the Chief Commissioner was correct in determining that section 81AB of the Act did not apply to a reference pursuant to section 69(13). Section 81AB provides for the deeming of acceptance of liability where the employer does not dispute liability in accordance with section 81A. However, this section did not apply because the claim in question was not one for the purposes of Part VII, Division 1 of the Act.
Turning to the issue of whether there was an obligation on the employer to have commenced paying weekly payments of compensation upon receipt of the subject medical certificate, the court found that there was such an obligation. Section 69(1) of the Act requires an employer to pay compensation in accordance with a medical certificate provided by a worker. The employer's obligation to pay compensation, which had been in abeyance since 1 November 2002, revived upon receipt of the subject medical certificate dated 17 March 2003. There was no basis for valid termination or cessation of payments, and therefore, the employer should have resumed making weekly payments.
Finally, the court addressed whether there was a basis for the Tribunal to order that the employer pay weekly payments of workers compensation to the worker. The court found that there was a basis for such an order. Given that liability had been accepted in 1998 and weekly compensation paid pursuant to medical certificates covering the period to 31 October 2002, the employer's obligation to pay compensation revived upon receipt of the subject medical certificate dated 17 March 2003. The employer ceased making payments upon receipt of this certificate, and there was no justification for doing so. The court ordered that the employer pay weekly compensation from the date upon which it ceased to pay the same until the expiration of any period of incapacity the subject of a certificate of the kind referred to in the Act, section 69(1).
The ratio decidendi of this case is that when a fresh medical certificate is presented after a break in the continuity of certification, it does not necessarily constitute a further claim for workers compensation if the legislative context has changed. The applicability of various sections of the Act must be assessed in light of these changes. Moreover, an employer has an obligation to pay weekly compensation upon receipt of a fresh medical certificate if the previous obligation to pay had been in abeyance due to a gap in certification, and the Tribunal has the authority to order such payments if there is no valid basis for cessation.