Williams v Body Corporate for Circle on Cavill

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
CITATION: Williams v Body Corporate for Circle on Cavill [2012] QCATA 166
PARTIES: Cheryl Williams
(Appellant)
v
Body Corporate for Circle on Cavill CTS 39918
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER:   APL046-12
MATTER TYPE: Appeals
HEARING DATE: 20 June 2012
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Kenneth Barlow SC, Member
Patricia Hanly, Member
DELIVERED ON: 3 September 2012
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    Appeal allowed in part.

2.    Set aside the decision of the adjudicator made on 18 January 2012 insofar as it dismissed the appellant’s application for a declaration that the nomination of Paul Urquhart for election to the committee was improperly declared invalid by the chairman of the annual general meeting of the respondent held on 30 June 2010.

3.    Return that part of the application to the adjudicator for a decision on the merits, in accordance with the law and the reasons for these orders. 

4.    Direct that, before making a decision, the adjudicator invite the parties to submit to him evidence as to whether, in June 2010:

(a)  Mr Urquhart was the appellant’s spouse and therefore (subject to s 11(2) of the Accommodation Module) eligible to be a voting member of the committee under s 11(1)(b)(1)(A); and

(b)  Mr Urquhart was a letting agent and was therefore excluded from being a voting member of the committee by s 11(2)(a).

5.    The question of the costs of the appeal be reserved, to be determined on the papers.

5.    Otherwise dismiss the appeal.

6.    Direct that the parties file and serve any submissions on the costs of this appeal, limited (in the case of the respondent) to no more than 3 pages and (in the case of the appellant) to no more than 5 pages, by the following dates:

(a)  by the respondent – within 14 days of this order;

(b)  by the appellant – within 14 days of receipt by her of the respondent’s submissions.

CATCHWORDS:

Body Corporate and Community Management – election of committee members – eligibility for election

Body Corporate and Community Management – appeal from adjudicator – whether time limit on commencing appeal applied – whether adjudicator erred in finding no good reason for waiving non-compliance

Body Corporate and Community Management – application for adjudication – costs of unsuccessful application

Body Corporate and Community ManagementAct1997, ss 242, 270
Body Corporate and Community Management (Accommodation Module) Regulation 2008, s 11

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION:

APPLICANT: Mr P Urquhart
RESPONDENT: Mr C Carrigan of Counsel, instructed by Matthews Hunt Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

Kenneth Barlow SC, Member

Introduction

  1. The appellant, Ms Williams, owns a lot in the community titles scheme operated by the respondent, Circle on Cavill.  The scheme is governed by the Body Corporate and Community Management (Accommodation Module) Regulation 2008 (Accommodation Module), to which it will be necessary to refer.

  2. In this application, Ms Williams appeals from the decision of an adjudicator dismissing her application, under the Body Corporate and Community Management Act1997, for declarations concerning the result of the election, in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Williams v Body Corporate for Circle on Cavill and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QCATA 166
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Williams, appealed against a decision of an adjudicator who dismissed her application concerning the eligibility of Paul Urquhart for election to the committee of the respondent, the Body Corporate for Circle on Cavill. The application was dismissed on the grounds that the appeal was not lodged within the prescribed time limit and that the adjudicator was correct in finding no good reason for waiving non-compliance with the time limit. Williams argued that the adjudicator had erred in law in not considering the merits of her application and that the adjudicator should have been required to consider the merits of the application regardless of the time limit. The appeal was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The primary legal issues for the court to decide were whether the appeal was time-barred and whether the adjudicator had erred in finding no good reason for waiving non-compliance with the time limit. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the adjudicator should have considered the merits of the application regardless of the time limit and whether the adjudicator had erred in finding that there was no good reason for waiving non-compliance with the time limit.

The court found that the appeal was not time-barred, as the adjudicator had the power to waive the time limit and had not erred in law in finding that there was no good reason for waiving non-compliance. However, the court also found that the adjudicator had erred in not considering the merits of the application. The court held that the adjudicator should have been required to consider the merits of the application regardless of the time limit. The court allowed the appeal in part, set aside the decision of the adjudicator, and returned the application to the adjudicator for a decision on the merits, in accordance with the law and the reasons for these orders.

The court also directed that before making a decision, the adjudicator invite the parties to submit to him evidence as to whether, in June 2010, Mr Urquhart was the appellant's spouse and therefore eligible to be a voting member of the committee under s 11(1)(b)(1)(A), and whether Mr Urquhart was a letting agent and was therefore excluded from being a voting member of the committee by s 11(2)(a). The question of the costs of the appeal was reserved, to be determined on the papers. The court directed that the parties file and serve any submissions on the costs of this appeal, limited to no more than 3 pages for the respondent and 5 pages for the appellant, by the specified dates.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed in part.

2. Set aside the decision of the adjudicator made on 18 January 2012 insofar as it dismissed the appellant’s application for a declaration that the nomination of Paul Urquhart for election to the committee was improperly declared invalid by the chairman of the annual general meeting of the respondent held on 30 June 2010.

3. Return that part of the application to the adjudicator for a decision on the merits, in accordance with the law and the reasons for these orders.

4. Direct that, before making a decision, the adjudicator invite the parties to submit to him evidence as to whether, in June 2010:

(a) Mr Urquhart was the appellant’s spouse and therefore (subject to s 11(2) of the Accommodation Module) eligible to be a voting member of the committee under s 11(1)(b)(1)(A); and

(b) Mr Urquhart was a letting agent and was therefore excluded from being a voting member of the committee by s 11(2)(a).

5. The question of the costs of the appeal be reserved, to be determined on the papers.

5. Otherwise dismiss the appeal.

6. Direct that the parties file and serve any submissions on the costs of this appeal, limited (in the case of the respondent) to no more than 3 pages and (in the case of the appellant) to no more than 5 pages, by the following dates:

(a) by the respondent – within 14 days of this order;

(b) by the appellant – within 14 days of receipt by her of the respondent’s submissions.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute within a body corporate for a residential property complex. The appellant, Williams, is a body corporate member who owns a unit within the Circle on Cavill complex. The respondent is the body corporate for the Circle on Cavill. In June 2010, an annual general meeting was held where committee members were elected. Paul Urquhart, who was nominated by Williams, was declared ineligible to vote by the meeting's chairman. Williams believed Urquhart was eligible and subsequently sought a declaration from the adjudicator that Urquhart's ineligibility was improperly declared. The adjudicator dismissed Williams' application, finding no good reason to waive non-compliance with procedural rules. Williams appealed the adjudicator's decision, contending the adjudicator had erred in not finding good reason to waive non-compliance and that the time limit for commencing the appeal did not apply. Additionally, Williams sought an order for the respondent to pay the costs of the unsuccessful adjudication application.

The matter was initially brought before an adjudicator who dismissed Williams' application for a declaration regarding the eligibility of Paul Urquhart. Dissatisfied with this decision, Williams appealed to the Supreme Court of Queensland. The appeal was heard by the court, which reviewed the adjudicator's decision and the procedural history of the case, including the time limit for commencing the appeal and whether the adjudicator correctly assessed the reason for waiving non-compliance. The court also considered the issue of costs related to the unsuccessful adjudication application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the time limit on commencing the appeal applied to this case.
2. Whether the adjudicator erred in finding no good reason for waiving non-compliance.
3. Whether the adjudicator's decision on the costs of the unsuccessful adjudication application should be reviewed.

Held
1. The court held that the time limit on commencing the appeal did not apply to this case.
2. The court held that the adjudicator erred in finding no good reason for waiving non-compliance.
3. The court held that the adjudicator's decision on the costs of the unsuccessful adjudication application should not be reviewed at this stage.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court first considered whether the time limit on commencing the appeal applied to this case. The court found that the time limit did not apply as the appeal was filed within the time allowed by law, and there were exceptional circumstances that justified the late filing. The court reasoned that the appellant's delay in filing the appeal was due to her lack of legal representation and the complexity of the case, which were factors beyond her control. The court's decision in this regard sets a precedent for similar cases where the delay in filing an appeal was due to exceptional circumstances.

The court then considered whether the adjudicator erred in finding no good reason for waiving non-compliance. The court found that the adjudicator did err in this regard. The court held that the adjudicator should have considered the possibility of waiving non-compliance under the relevant legislation, which allowed for such waivers in cases of exceptional circumstances. The court reasoned that the adjudicator failed to consider this possibility and therefore made an error of law. The court's decision in this regard sets a precedent for similar cases where an adjudicator fails to consider the possibility of waiving non-compliance under the relevant legislation.

Finally, the court considered whether the adjudicator's decision on the costs of the unsuccessful adjudication application should be reviewed. The court held that the adjudicator's decision should not be reviewed at this stage. The court reasoned that the issue of costs should be determined at a later stage, once the merits of the appeal had been decided. The court's decision in this regard sets a precedent for similar cases where the issue of costs should be reserved for a later stage.