William Watson and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

[2014] AATA 823

Division SMALL TAXATION CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

File Number(s)

2013/3895

Re

William Watson

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal Professor R Deutsch, Deputy President
Date 4 November 2014
Place Sydney

The objection decision under review is affirmed.

...................[sgd]...............................................

Professor R Deutsch, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

TAXATION AND REVENUE – income tax – application for debt release – exercise of discretion – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) Sch 1 s 340-5

CASES

Powell v Evreniades (1989) 21 FCR 252

R v Trebilco; ex parte F S Falkiner & Sons Ltd (1936) 56 CLR 20
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Re Filsell and Commissioner of Taxation [2004] AATA 1012
Re Lipthay and Commissioner of Taxation [2005] AATA 224
Re Milne and Commissioner of Taxation [2005] AATA 633
Re Vagh and the Commissioner of Taxation [2007] AATA 32
Rollo v Morrow (1992) 23 ATR 477

Van Grieken v Veilands (1991) 22 ATR 655

SECONDARY MATERIALS

PSLA 2011/17 Debt relief

REASONS FOR DECISION

Professor R Deutsch, Deputy President

4 November 2014

INTRODUCTION

  1. In these proceedings the Applicant has applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) for a review of the Respondent’s objection decision dated 13 June 2013, which upheld the Respondent’s decision not to grant the Applicant release from the payment of certain taxation debts.

  2. Section 340-5(3) of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) (the “TAA 1953”) provides that the Respondent may release an individual, in whole or in part, from certain tax liabilities, which relevantly include the payment of tax, penalties and interest under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 or Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 if satisfying those liabilities would cause serious hardship.

    MATERIAL FACTS

    General

  3. The Applicant is currently 61 years of age and lives with his current partner, Ms Megan Formosa in a property owned by Ms Formosa.

  4. The Applicant has two children, currently aged 7 and 10, who live with his ex-wife at a residence rented by the Applicant. The Applicant has been separated from his ex-wife since 2008 and has visitation rights in respect of his children.

  5. At the time the application was lodged, the Applicant was self-employed as a sole trader in a site preparation services business.

  6. From 6 January 2013, the Applicant employed Ms Formosa for the stated purpose of assisting him in meeting his business obligations and business regulation requirements so as to continue to remain operationally viable as a business.

  7. The Applicant has indicated that he ceased working on 5 February 2014, under medical instruction.

    How the Applicant’s Taxation Debt Arose

  8. The Applicant’s taxation debt relates to his self-assessed income tax liabilities for the income years ended 30 June 2008, 2010, 2011 and 2012 (“the relevant periods”).

  9. For each of the relevant periods, the Respondent issued notices of assessment for income tax.

  10. The Respondent determined that the Applicant was liable for General Interest Charge (“GIC”) following the late lodgement of the Applicant’s income…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read William Watson and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 823
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves William Watson, who is appealing a decision by the Commissioner of Taxation to deny his application for a release from certain tax liabilities. The decision was made under section 340-5(3) of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), which allows for the release of tax liabilities if satisfying them would cause serious hardship. The Applicant, aged 61, had accumulated a tax debt of approximately $52,109.15, resulting from late lodgment of his income tax returns for the years 2008, 2010, 2011, and 2012. He claimed that paying this debt would cause him serious financial hardship.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Commissioner's decision to deny the release of the tax debt was justified. The court had to determine whether the Applicant's circumstances constituted "serious hardship" as defined by the relevant legislation, and if so, whether it was just and proper to exercise the discretion to release the debt. The Applicant argued that his current financial situation, which included a disability pension and limited income, made it impossible for him to pay the tax debt without causing serious hardship. The Commissioner contended that even if serious hardship was established, it did not necessarily mean that the debt should be released, and that other factors needed to be considered.

The court examined the various factors relevant to determining whether the release of the tax debt should be granted, including the circumstances under which the hardship arose, whether the Applicant had over-committed financially, and his probable future financial position. The court found that the Commissioner's decision not to exercise the discretion to release the tax debt was the preferable decision in all the circumstances. The court concluded that even though the Applicant would suffer serious financial hardship if required to pay the debt, other factors such as the likelihood of the hardship being temporary, the Applicant's ability to repay the debt in the future, and the principle that taxpayers are generally obliged to pay their taxes in full, supported the Commissioner's decision. The court affirmed the Commissioner's decision and dismissed the Applicant's appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 340-5(3) of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) (the “TAA 1953”) provides that the Respondent may release an individual, in whole or in part, from certain tax liabilities, which relevantly include the payment of tax, penalties and interest under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 or Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 if satisfying those liabilities would cause serious hardship.MATERIAL FACTSGeneral The Applicant is currently 61 years of age and lives with his current partner, Ms Megan Formosa in a property owned by Ms Formosa. The Applicant has two children, currently aged 7 and 10, who live with his ex-wife at a residence rented by the Applicant. The Applicant has been separated from his ex-wife since 2008 and has visitation rights in respect of his children. At the time the application was lodged, the Applicant was self-employed as a sole trader in a site preparation services business. From 6 January 2013, the Applicant employed Ms Formosa for the stated purpose of assisting him in meeting his business obligations and business regulation requirements so as to continue to remain operationally viable as a business. The Applicant has indicated that he ceased working on 5 February 2014, under medical instruction.How the Applicant’s Taxation Debt Arose The Applicant’s taxation debt relates to his self-assessed income tax liabilities for the income years ended 30 June 2008, 2010, 2011 and 2012 (“the relevant periods”). For each of the relevant periods, the Respondent issued notices of assessment for income tax. The Respondent determined that the Applicant was liable for General Interest Charge (“GIC”) following the late lodgement of the Applicant’s income tax returns for the relevant periods. As at 2 September 2014, the Applicant owes the Respondent a taxation debt in the total sum of $52,109.15. The following table is a breakdown of the Applicant’s taxation liabilities and amounts for GIC and penalties, as at 2 September 2014. At the time of making the application for release, the Applicant’s stated fortnightly income was $3,388.00 before tax and $2,548.00 after tax. In updated information provided by the Applicant to the Respondent on 14 April 2014, and subsequently provided to the Tribunal by the Commissioner, the Applicant indicated that he was receiving a Disability Support Pension (DSP) from Centrelink of $589.43 after a payment of $45.87 for child support was deducted. Accordingly, the Applicant calculated the gross amount to be $635.30. The following table reflects the Applicant’s stated fortnightly income at the different stages outlined above: The Applicant has stated that his fortnightly living expenses are as follows: The Applicant has provided the following information regarding his assets and liabilities: Shortly before the hearing the Respondent conceded that the Applicant will suffer serious financial hardship if the tax liabilities in question were to be satisfied. Having regard to the evidence and the submissions, I agree.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Respondent further contended that:[33] To grant the Applicant a release from his taxation debt would frustrate the purpose of the release provision and the taxation legislation generally.[34] The Applicant will not be left without means to the basic necessities of life even in bankruptcy. It is also noted that the Respondent has offered to treat the Applicant’s debt as uneconomical to pursue. However, the Applicant is hesitant to accept the offer.THE TRIBUNAL’S CONCLUSIONS AND REASONING The Tribunal concludes that the Commissioner’s decision not to exercise his discretion to the release the taxation debt, either in whole or in part, was the preferable decision in all the circumstances. It is well-accepted that the finding of serious hardship does not oblige the Respondent, or the Tribunal, to exercise his or her discretion in favour of the Applicant: R v Trebilco; ex parte F S Falkiner & Sons Ltd (1936) 56 CLR 20; Powell v Evreniades (1989) 21 FCR 252; Van Grieken v Veilands (1991) 22 ATR 630; Rollo v Morrow (1992) 23 ATR 477. Where serious hardship is shown, the relevant question that must be asked in determining whether the discretion to grant relief should be exercised is “whether, in all circumstances, it is just and proper to provide the requested relief” (emphasis added): Re Filsell. The factors relevant to the second question, whether if serious hardship be shown the discretion to grant relief should be exercised, could be a great deal wider than the factors relevant to the first question: R v Trebilco; ex parte F S Falkiner & Sons Ltd (1936) 56 CLR 20; Powell v Evreniades (1989) 21 FCR 252. The Tribunal in Re Vagh and Commissioner of Taxation [2007] AATA 32 identified some relevant considerations:[39] Considerations relevant to the proper exercise of the discretion whether or not to grant remission when undue hardship is established will vary from case to case, however, relevant considerations are likely to include:(a) the circumstances under which the hardship arose;(b) whether those circumstances were within the capacity of the applicant to have foreseen and controlled;(c) whether the applicant has over-committed himself financially;(d) whether the applicant or any of his dependants has suffered serious illness or accident involving irrevocable financial loss to the applicant;(e) whether the applicant has been in regular employment;(f) whether the circumstance of the hardship are likely to be of a temporary or recurring nature;(g) whether a decision to remit the sum would as a matter of administrative justice and fairness be appropriate having regard to the fact that taxpayers are normally obliged to pay their taxes in full, including those who struggle with the payment of their taxes. (Ferguson (supra) at [34] applying Re Wilson v Minister for Territories (1985) 7 ALD 225 at 232-3; Filsell (supra) at [20]; Kirkman v Commissioner of Taxation (AAT oral decision, unreported, 14 April 2005, Ettinger, SM) at 4-5.[40] Other relevant considerations are:(a) the probable future financial position of the applicant; see Ferguson (supra) at [12];(b) whether the applicant has demonstrated that he or she is serious about repaying the tax debt, including whether funds were received which could have been applied towards the tax debt but were not so applied: Kirkman (supra) at p. 5-6;(c) the circumstances in which the taxpayer has arrived at the position wherein he or she would suffer severe hardship if required to satisfy the tax liability: Corlette v Mackenzie (1996) 62 FCR 597 at 598E per Wilcox J, Einfeld and Foster JJ agreeing at 600, 601.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established