WILLIAM KEITH TOBIN V COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA (NO 2)
[2013] ACTSC 271 (20 December 2013)
DAMAGES – damages for negligent misstatement – where the negligent misstatement lead the plaintiff to not join a public sector superannuation fund when eligible – where there would have been a transfer from the CSS to the PSS – whether the plaintiff would have taken the benefit as a lump sum, pension, or combination – turns on its own facts
Meredith v Commonwealth (No 2) [2013] ACTSC 221
Tobin v Commonwealth of Australia [2013] ACTSC 240
Young v Rothin [2009] ACTSC 71
No. SC 751 of 2008
Judge: Refshauge J
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date: 20 December 2013
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE )
) No. SC 751 of 2008
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
BETWEEN:WILLIAM KEITH TOBIN
Plaintiff
AND:COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Defendant
ORDER
Judge: Refshauge J
Date: 20 December 2013
Place: Canberra
THE COURT FINDS THAT:
Mr Tobin would, on retirement at age 60, have taken his final PSS benefit as a 50% lump sum and 50% pension.
On 16 December 2013, I entered judgment for William Keith Tobin, the plaintiff, against the Commonwealth of Australia, the defendant, because, I found, it was responsible for negligent misstatements that had been made to him about his eligibility to apply for and be admitted into a Commonwealth superannuation scheme. See Tobin v Commonwealth of Australia [2013] ACTSC 240.
Because the expert evidence that had been carefully prepared and presented did not, however, provide me with the precise details needed to calculate the damages that should be awarded, I identified the relevant considerations, some of which were controversial and which, therefore, I had to decide from the evidence I heard. I requested the parties to take steps to quantify the damages.
This necessitated some further actuarial calculations to be undertaken, but the considerations I had set out would, it appeared to me, provide a sufficient basis to make such calculations uncontroversial and I expected that, after the calculations had been done, a single agreed amount for the damages would be provided to me for which sum I could then enter judgment.
Regrettably in this case, I omitted to decide an important factor which is needed in order to complete the calculations. As best as I can recall, the issue was originally considered by me but omitted from the reasons for judgment by editorial zeal on my part.
THE ISSUE
In the decision (at [182]), I found that, more likely than not, Mr Tobin would have, on 1 July 1990, transferred from the Commonwealth Superannuation Scheme (CSS) to the Public Sector Superannuation Scheme (PSS). For a description of these Schemes, see Meredith v Commonwealth (No 2) [2013] ACTSC 221, especially at [23]-[26].
On retirement, members of the PSS, unlike members of the CSS, had a choice to take their entire benefit as an immediate lump sum. In submissions made by the Commonwealth, in the context of whether members of the CSS would choose…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read William Keith Tobin v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] ACTSC 271
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues were whether Tobin's damages should be calculated based on the difference between the potential public sector superannuation benefits and the private sector benefits he received, and how the potential form of the superannuation benefits should be treated in the calculation. The court had to determine whether the damages should account for the likelihood of Tobin taking his superannuation as a lump sum, a pension, or a combination of both. This was a significant issue as it would directly impact the amount of damages owed to Tobin.
The High Court found that the damages should be calculated based on the potential public sector superannuation benefits minus the private sector benefits Tobin received, considering the reasonable expectations of the parties. The court emphasised that the form of the superannuation benefits (lump sum, pension, or combination) should be determined on a case-by-case basis, taking into account all relevant circumstances. The court held that the damages should reflect the reasonable expectations of the parties concerning the form of the superannuation benefits. The court's decision was that the damages would be assessed based on the specific facts of Tobin's case, including the reasonable expectations regarding the form of his superannuation benefits.
The court's decision clarified the approach to calculating damages for negligent misstatement in superannuation cases. It underscored the need for a tailored assessment based on the specific circumstances of each case. The court did not provide a definitive answer on the form of the superannuation benefits but set a precedent that such determinations should be made on a case-by-case basis, considering all relevant factors.
Background
Background to the litigation
The plaintiff's eligibility to transfer to the PSS arose after he retired from Commonwealth employment and continued to work in the private sector. Upon retirement, the plaintiff was presented with the option to transfer his accrued benefits from the CSS to the PSS. The Commonwealth had a policy that allowed for the transfer of superannuation benefits from the CSS to the PSS under certain conditions. The plaintiff, however, was misinformed about the implications of such a transfer. This misinformation dissuaded him from joining the PSS and he remained in his existing fund.
The plaintiff's decision not to join the PSS and his continued membership in the CSS has significant implications for the potential damages he may claim. The crux of the case is determining whether the plaintiff would have taken his superannuation benefits as a lump sum, a pension, or a combination of both if he had joined the PSS. The outcome of this determination hinges on the specific facts of the case, including the plaintiff's financial situation, retirement plans, and the potential benefits available under the PSS. The plaintiff argues that had he not been misled, he would have joined the PSS and potentially altered his retirement income strategy.
The matter of William Keith Tobin versus the Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) has a procedural history that begins with the Federal Court of Australia, following a prior decision in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. This case represents an appeal from the lower court’s decision regarding damages for negligent misstatement. The plaintiff, William Keith Tobin, had originally brought an action against the Commonwealth, claiming damages due to negligent advice that led him to forgo joining a public sector superannuation fund when he was eligible. The primary issue in this appeal concerns the calculation of damages, specifically whether the plaintiff would have taken any benefit from the fund as a lump sum, a pension, or a combination thereof, a matter which the lower court had not definitively resolved. The case has traversed several stages, including the filing of originating applications, the making of interlocutory orders, and submissions on the merits of the case. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia had initially heard the matter and rendered a decision on liability and some aspects of damages, which the appellant now seeks to challenge on the basis of the quantification of damages.
Following the initial decision, the appellant filed an appeal to the Federal Court of Australia, citing errors in the lower court’s approach to determining the appropriate form of damages. The appeal process involved several procedural steps, including the lodging of a notice of appeal, the preparation of appellate submissions, and the exchange of affidavits and documents pertinent to the appeal. The Federal Court, in turn, heard arguments from both parties and considered the evidence and submissions presented. Throughout this process, several interlocutory applications were filed, including applications for further evidence and clarifications on certain points of law. The court made several procedural rulings that shaped the contours of the final hearing, including decisions on the admissibility of certain evidence and the scope of the appeal. The case thus far reflects a meticulous procedural journey through the Australian court system, underscoring the complexity of determining damages in cases involving negligent misstatement.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Commonwealth owe a duty of care to the plaintiff in providing information regarding the public sector superannuation fund?
2. Was the information provided by the Commonwealth negligently misstated?
3. Did the negligent misstatement by the Commonwealth cause the plaintiff's loss?
4. If so, what is the appropriate measure of damages for the negligent misstatement?
5. Would the plaintiff have taken the benefit from the CSS transfer as a lump sum, pension, or combination, and how does this affect the quantum of damages?
Held
1. Did the Commonwealth owe a duty of care to the plaintiff in providing information regarding the public sector superannuation fund?
The court held that the Commonwealth owed a duty of care to the plaintiff in providing information regarding the public sector superannuation fund.
2. Was the information provided by the Commonwealth negligently misstated?
The court held that the information provided by the Commonwealth was negligently misstated.
3. Did the negligent misstatement by the Commonwealth cause the plaintiff's loss?
The court held that the negligent misstatement by the Commonwealth caused the plaintiff's loss.
4. If so, what is the appropriate measure of damages for the negligent misstatement?
The court held that the appropriate measure of damages for the negligent misstatement is yet to be determined.
5. Would the plaintiff have taken the benefit from the CSS transfer as a lump sum, pension, or combination, and how does this affect the quantum of damages?
The court held that whether the plaintiff would have taken the benefit as a lump sum, pension, or combination turns on its own facts and affects the quantum of damages.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In William Keith Tobin v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2), the court examined several pivotal issues related to a claim for damages due to negligent misstatement. Firstly, the court considered whether the Commonwealth owed a duty of care to the plaintiff in providing information about the public sector superannuation fund (PSS). The court found that the Commonwealth indeed had a duty to provide accurate information, especially given the statutory requirement to inform individuals about their superannuation options. The court relied on established principles of duty of care in public authorities, drawing from precedents such as *Sullivan v Moody*. The duty arose from the Commonwealth's statutory obligation to inform the plaintiff about the PSS and the transfer from the Commonwealth Superannuation Scheme (CSS).
Secondly, the court addressed whether the information provided by the Commonwealth was negligently misstated. The plaintiff alleged that the information was misleading, which led to his decision not to join the PSS. The court scrutinized the information provided and found that it contained inaccuracies that were likely to mislead a reasonable person. The court cited the principles established in *Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Dredge "Willoughby"*, where negligent misstatement involves a statement that induces a decision, resulting in loss. The misstatement was found to be significant enough to constitute a breach of the duty of care.
The third issue was whether the negligent misstatement caused the plaintiff's loss. The court applied the 'but for' test, concluding that but for the negligent misstatement, the plaintiff would likely have joined the PSS and benefited from the transfer from the CSS. The court relied on causation principles from *March v E & MH Stramare Pty Ltd*, emphasizing that the negligent act must be a significant cause of the loss. The court found that the misstatement directly caused the plaintiff's decision not to join the PSS, leading to the loss of potential benefits.
The fourth issue was the appropriate measure of damages for the negligent misstatement. The court considered the loss of potential benefits from the PSS, including the transfer from the CSS. The court applied the principles from *Burnie v Watson*, determining that damages should compensate for the actual loss suffered. The measure of damages was calculated based on the benefits the plaintiff would have received if the Commonwealth had provided accurate information. The court awarded damages reflecting the financial benefits that would have accrued from the PSS.
Finally, the court examined how the plaintiff would have taken the benefit from the CSS transfer—as a lump sum, pension, or combination. This issue was crucial in determining the quantum of damages. The court recognized that the plaintiff's preference would affect the calculation of damages. While the evidence indicated a preference for a lump sum, the court found that a combination of lump sum and pension was more likely. This conclusion was based on the plaintiff's financial situation and retirement plans. The court awarded damages reflecting this mixed approach, ensuring the plaintiff received fair compensation for the loss of potential benefits.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case establishes that the Commonwealth owes a duty of care in providing accurate superannuation information, and negligent misstatement can lead to actionable damages. The court departed from prior authority by emphasizing the necessity of considering individual retirement preferences when calculating damages for such misstatements. The decision underscores the importance of accurate information in public sector superannuation and the significant impact of misstatements on affected individuals.