William Buck (WA) Pty Ltd v Faulkner [No 3]

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

WILLIAM BUCK (WA) PTY LTD -v- FAULKNER [No 3] [2013] WASC 40



SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIACitation No:[2013] WASC 40
Case No:CIV:2995/201131 JANUARY 2013
Coram:KENNETH MARTIN J13/02/13
15Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Leave to lead expert evidence refused
Amendments into the amended statement of claim be disallowed
Request for further and better discovery refused
B
PDF Version
Parties:WILLIAM BUCK (WA) PTY LTD
WILLIAM BUCK HOLDINGS (WA) PTY LTD
CRAIG PETER FAULKNER
LEDGER FAULKNER PTY LTD
CSF CORPORATE PTY LTD
MARK PETER COLLINS
STEPHEN KENNETH BREIHL
CHRISTOPHER JOHN BROWN
FRANK DEL BORRELLO
DAMON ALLAN HARRIS
ROBIN BOYD JUDD

Catchwords:

Expert evidence
Leave
Statutory oppression action
Valuation evidence
Objection to inspection
Own case privilege
Further and better discovery of documents

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Case References:

Alba Nominees Pty Ltd v Cecil Bros Pty Ltd (Unreported, WASC, 12 December 1997)
Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles [2001] NSWCA 305
William Buck (WA) Pty Ltd v Faulkner [No 2] [2012] WASC 257


JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
    IN CIVIL
CITATION : WILLIAM BUCK (WA) PTY LTD -v- FAULKNER [No 3] [2013] WASC 40 CORAM : KENNETH MARTIN J HEARD : 31 JANUARY 2013 DELIVERED : 13 FEBRUARY 2013 FILE NO/S : CIV 2995 of 2011 BETWEEN : WILLIAM BUCK (WA) PTY LTD
    First Plaintiff

    WILLIAM BUCK HOLDINGS (WA) PTY LTD
    Second Plaintiff

    AND

    CRAIG PETER FAULKNER
    First Defendant

    LEDGER FAULKNER PTY LTD
    Second Defendant

    CSF CORPORATE PTY LTD
    Third Defendant

    (BY ORIGINAL ACTION)

    CRAIG PETER FAULKNER
    Plaintiff

    AND

    WILLIAM BUCK (WA) PTY LTD
    First Defendant

(Page 2)
    WILLIAM BUCK HOLDINGS (WA) PTY LTD
    Second Defendant

    MARK PETER COLLINS
    Third Defendant

    STEPHEN KENNETH BREIHL
    Fourth Defendant

    CHRISTOPHER JOHN BROWN
    Fifth Defendant

    FRANK DEL BORRELLO
    Sixth Defendant

    DAMON ALLAN HARRIS
    Seventh Defendant

    ROBIN BOYD JUDD
    Eighth Defendant

    (BY COUNTERCLAIM)
FILE NO/S : COR 174 of 2011
BETWEEN : CSF CORPORATE PTY LTD
    Plaintiff

    AND

    WILLIAM BUCK HOLDINGS (WA) PTY LTD
    Defendant

Catchwords:

Expert evidence - Leave - Statutory oppression action - Valuation evidence - Objection to inspection - Own case privilege - Further and better discovery of documents


(Page 3)



Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)


Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Leave to lead expert evidence refused


Amendments into the amended statement of claim be disallowed
Request for further and better discovery refused

Category: B


Representation:

CIV 2995 of 2011

Original Action


Counsel:


    First Plaintiff : Mr D H Solomon
    Second Plaintiff : Mr D H Solomon
    First Defendant : Mr M Bruce
    Second Defendant : Mr M Bruce
    Third Defendant : Mr M Bruce

Solicitors:

    First Plaintiff : Solomon Brothers
    Second Plaintiff : Solomon Brothers
    First Defendant : Bennett & Co
    Second Defendant : Bennett & Co
    Third Defendant : Bennett & Co

Counterclaim

Counsel:


    Plaintiff : Mr M Bruce
    First Defendant : Mr D H Solomon
(Page 4)
    Second Defendant : Mr D H Solomon
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read William Buck (WA) Pty Ltd v Faulkner [No 3] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] WASC 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of William Buck (WA) Pty Ltd v Faulkner [No 3] was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The primary issue before the court was whether the defendant, William Buck (WA) Pty Ltd, should be granted leave to lead expert evidence in the form of a valuation report concerning a 5% shareholding held by CSF Corporate Pty Ltd in William Buck Holdings (WA) Pty Ltd. The plaintiff, CSF Corporate Pty Ltd, sought a buy out order for its minority shareholding or alternatively, winding up of the defendant company. The court found that the expert valuation evidence was relevant to the action, however, the leave to adduce such evidence had not been granted as required under the rules. The court refused the application for leave to lead expert evidence, considering it unjust to allow only one side to adduce expert evidence at trial. The court also disallowed certain amendments to the statement of claim introduced by the plaintiff, which expanded the scope of the action to include conflict of interest allegations concerning a third party group. Lastly, the court ordered the defendant to provide inspection of certain loan transaction documents related to the third party group, but denied the request for employment contracts of the directors.

In summary, the court refused leave for the defendant to lead expert valuation evidence, disallowed certain amendments to the statement of claim, and ordered inspection of some documents while denying others. The decision highlights the importance of following proper procedures for leading expert evidence and ensuring that amendments to pleadings are not unduly prejudicial or expansive. The court also considered the principles of privilege and proportionality in determining whether certain documents should be inspected. The costs of the application were ordered to lie in the cause, except for the expert valuation report where costs were reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves two actions between William Buck (WA) Pty Ltd and Craig Peter Faulkner, with related entities as parties. The first action, CIV 2995 of 2011, involves claims by William Buck (WA) Pty Ltd and William Buck Holdings (WA) Pty Ltd against Craig Peter Faulkner, Ledger Faulkner Pty Ltd, and CSF Corporate Pty Ltd, among others, for statutory oppression and other relief under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The second action, COR 174 of 2011, is a counterclaim by CSF Corporate Pty Ltd against William Buck Holdings (WA) Pty Ltd for statutory oppression and other relief. The core dispute in both actions revolves around the value of a 5% shareholding held by CSF Corporate Pty Ltd in William Buck Holdings (WA) Pty Ltd and whether there has been oppressive conduct by William Buck entities towards Mr Faulkner and his associated entities.

The underlying facts stem from Mr Faulkner's contentious departure from the William Buck Group in September 2011, leading to disputes over the value of his shareholding, insurance policies, and other business dealings between the parties. The case has seen extensive pre-trial litigation, including objections to expert evidence, amendments to pleadings, and discovery disputes.

The matter was set down for an eight-day trial commencing on 18 March 2013. Prior to the trial, several interlocutory applications were filed and heard on 31 January 2013, including applications for leave to adduce expert valuation evidence, objections to amendments to the statement of claim, and a request for further and better discovery of documents. The court had previously rejected an application for a determination of preliminary issues and had directed the parties to attempt mediation, which was unsuccessful.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether leave should be granted to the William Buck parties to adduce expert valuation evidence concerning the 5% shareholding held by CSF Corporate Pty Ltd in William Buck Holdings (WA) Pty Ltd.
2. Whether certain amendments to the amended statement of claim in the statutory oppression action should be disallowed.
3. Whether further and better discovery of certain documents, including those concerning loan transactions with GNS and employment contracts, should be ordered.

Held
1. The court refused leave to the William Buck parties to adduce expert valuation evidence concerning the 5% shareholding held by CSF Corporate Pty Ltd in William Buck Holdings (WA) Pty Ltd.
2. The court disallowed certain amendments to the amended statement of claim in the statutory oppression action, specifically those concerning the 'GNS' Group and the assertion of a conflict of interest.
3. The court refused the request for further and better discovery of certain documents, including those concerning loan transactions with GNS and employment contracts, except for those related to loan transactions with GNS.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered three main areas of disputation between the parties. Firstly, regarding the admissibility of expert valuation evidence, the court found that leave to adduce such evidence should be granted on a bilateral basis rather than unilaterally. Given the circumstances, it was deemed unjust to allow only one side to adduce expert evidence at trial. Secondly, concerning the amendments to the amended statement of claim, the court disallowed certain amendments that expanded the scope of the statutory oppression action, particularly those related to the 'GNS' Group and the assertion of a conflict of interest, as they were considered to be beyond the scope of the statutory oppression action. Lastly, in regard to the request for further and better discovery, the court ordered the provision of documents concerning loan transactions with GNS, rejecting the claim of 'own case' privilege. However, the request for employment contracts was refused due to a lack of relevance and proportionality.

In reaching these decisions, the court applied principles of procedural fairness and the need for transparency in the litigation process. The court also considered the potential impact of the proposed evidence and amendments on the efficiency and fairness of the trial. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that leave to adduce expert evidence should be granted on a bilateral basis in statutory oppression actions, and amendments that significantly expand the scope of the action may be disallowed if they are deemed to be beyond the scope of the statutory oppression action. Additionally, the 'own case' privilege does not apply to documents relevant to the parties' case, but relevance and proportionality must be demonstrated for the discovery of employment contracts.