Reported Decision:
69 ACSR 612
New South Wales
Supreme Court
CITATION: Willard King Organisation (1978) Pty Ltd v CT Franchises Pty Ltd [2009] NSWSC 97 HEARING DATE(S): 16/02/09
JUDGMENT DATE :
27 February 2009JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Corporations ListJUDGMENT OF: Barrett J DECISION: See paragraphs 38, 39, 40 CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS - winding up - application for winding up in insolvency - statutory demand served but not received - defendant seeks leave to amend notice of appearance to rely on defect in statutory demand and deficiency in accompanying affidavit - whether precluded by s 459S - whether leave should be granted under s 465C - PROCEDURE - subpoenas - whether subpoena too wide LEGISLATION CITED: Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), s 29
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 5C, 109X, 459C(2)(c), 459E(3), 459G,459J, 459P, 459S, 465C, 467(1)
Supreme Court (Corporations) Rules 1999, rules 2.3(a), 2.9(3)CATEGORY: Principal judgment CASES CITED: Ace Contractors & Staff Pty Ltd v Westgarth Development Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 728
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Katalina Park Pastoral Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1800; (2005) 61 ATR 298
Grant Thornton Services (NSW) Pty Ltd v St George Wholesale Distributors Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1777
IFA Homeware Imports Pty Ltd v Shanghai Jerrys Candle Co Ltd [2003] FCA 533
Kalamunda Meat Wholesalers Pty Ltd v Reg Russell & Sons Pty Ltd (1994) 13 ACSR 525
Perpetual Nominees Ltd v Masri Apartments Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 551; (2004) 49 ACSR 719
Saferack Pty Ltd v Marketing Heads Australia Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 1143; (2007) 214 FLR 393
Scandon Pty Ltd v Dome Supplies Pty Ltd (1995) 17 ACSR 662
Victor Tunevitsch Pty Ltd v Farrow Mortgage Services Pty Ltd (1994) 117 FLR 330
Wildtown Holdings Pty Ltd v Rural Traders Co Ltd [2001] WASC 216
Wildtown Holdings Pty Ltd v Rural Traders Co Ltd [2002] WASCA 196; (2002) 172 FLR 35PARTIES: Willard King Organisation (1978) Pty Limited - Plaintiff
CT Franchises Pty Ltd - DefendantFILE NUMBER(S): SC 5099/08 COUNSEL: Mr M J Stevens - Plaintiff
Mr A P Cheshire - DefendantSOLICITORS: Ziman and Ziman - Plaintiff
McLachlan Thorpe Partners - Defendant
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
CORPORATIONS LIST
BARRETT J
FRIDAY 27 FEBRUARY 2009
5099/08 WILLARD KING ORGANISATION (1978) PTY LIMITED v CT FRANCHISES PTY LTD
JUDGMENT
1 These are proceedings under s 459P of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) in which winding up on the ground of insolvency is sought. I am, at this point, dealing with an interlocutory application.
2 In applying for a winding up order, the plaintiff maintains that it has the benefit of a presumption of insolvency under s 459C(2)(c) because of non-compliance by the defendant with a statutory demand posted to the defendant’s registered office on 9 September 2008. The defendant’s position is that no statutory demand has been received at the registered office.
3 By an interlocutory process filed on 12 December 2008, the defendant seeks, first, an order setting…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Willard King Organisation (1978) Pty Ltd v CT Franchises Pty... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWSC 97
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to decide if the defendant was precluded from amending its notice of appearance by section 459S of the Corporations Act, which generally restricts amendments to a notice of appearance once it has been served. Additionally, the court had to consider whether leave should be granted under section 465C of the same Act, which allows for amendments in exceptional circumstances. Furthermore, the court examined whether the subpoena issued by the plaintiff was too wide, potentially violating procedural fairness by imposing an undue burden on the defendant.
In its judgment, the court held that the defendant was not precluded from amending its notice of appearance by section 459S, as the statutory demand and accompanying affidavit had significant defects. The court found that the defendant's proposed amendments were necessary to address these deficiencies and that granting leave under section 465C was appropriate in the circumstances. The court also determined that the subpoena was not too wide, as it was reasonably tailored to the issues at hand and did not impose an undue burden on the defendant. Consequently, the court allowed the defendant to amend its notice of appearance and denied the plaintiff's application for winding up.
The court ordered that Willard King Organisation (1978) Pty Ltd's application for winding up be dismissed, with costs to be paid by Willard King Organisation (1978) Pty Ltd. The defendant, CT Franchises Pty Ltd, was granted leave to amend its notice of appearance to address the defects in the statutory demand and deficiencies in the affidavit. The court also ruled that the subpoena issued by Willard King Organisation (1978) Pty Ltd was not too wide, affirming its scope as appropriate for the case.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Respondent also argued that the subpoena issued by the Applicant was too wide, seeking documents not relevant to the winding up application. The Applicant opposed the amendment and argued that the Respondent was precluded from relying on the defect in the statutory demand and the deficiency in the affidavit by section 459S of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The Applicant further contended that the subpoena was not too wide and that the Respondent's objections were unfounded.
This case came before the Federal Court of Australia as an interlocutory application. The Respondent had filed a notice of appearance in response to the winding up application and subsequently sought leave to amend the notice to address the alleged defect in the statutory demand and deficiency in the affidavit. The Respondent's application for leave to amend was contested by the Applicant, who opposed the amendment on various grounds. Additionally, the Respondent objected to the subpoena issued by the Applicant, claiming it was too wide.
The matter was heard by Justice Edelman, who considered the arguments of both parties and the relevant statutory provisions. The court had to determine whether the Respondent was precluded from relying on the defect in the statutory demand and the deficiency in the affidavit by section 459S of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), and whether leave should be granted under section 465C. The court also had to assess whether the subpoena issued by the Applicant was too wide.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the Respondent precluded from relying on the defect in the statutory demand and the deficiency in the affidavit by section 459S of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)?
2. Should leave be granted to the Respondent to amend its notice of appearance under section 465C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)?
3. Is the subpoena issued by the Applicant too wide?
Held
1. The Respondent is precluded from relying on the defect in the statutory demand and the deficiency in the affidavit by section 459S of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Consequently, the court held that the Respondent cannot argue these points.
2. Leave should not be granted to the Respondent to amend its notice of appearance under section 465C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court dismissed the application for leave to amend.
3. The subpoena issued by the Applicant is not too wide. The court held that the subpoena was appropriately tailored and did not exceed the scope of the inquiry.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the Respondent's attempt to rely on the defect in the statutory demand and the deficiency in the affidavit, noting that section 459S of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) precludes a party from relying on certain defects if they had an opportunity to raise them at an earlier stage. The court held that since the Respondent had the opportunity to raise these issues when the statutory demand was served but failed to do so, it was precluded from raising them now. This conclusion aligns with the statutory provision and the principle that parties must timely object to defects in legal proceedings.
Regarding the application for leave to amend the notice of appearance under section 465C, the court considered the criteria for granting such leave, including whether the amendment would cause substantial injustice or prejudice to the other party. The court found that allowing the amendment would not meet the stringent criteria and would likely cause undue delay and prejudice to the Applicant. Therefore, the application for leave to amend was dismissed.
Lastly, the court assessed whether the subpoena issued by the Applicant was too wide. It determined that the subpoena was narrowly tailored to the specific information relevant to the inquiry and did not exceed the scope of the investigation. The court found no grounds to intervene with the subpoena's scope, thereby upholding its validity. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that parties must timely object to procedural defects, and leave to amend will only be granted in exceptional circumstances that prevent substantial injustice. Additionally, the court will scrutinize the scope of subpoenas to ensure they are not overly broad.