Wiggins v The Valuer-General

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[1992] QLAC 46

 
LAND APPEAL COURT,

BRISBANE

November, 1992.

Re:Appeal against determination of the Land Court - Valuation of Land Act 1944

AV91-1072.

Roy F and Edna A Wiggins v.

The Valuer-General

J U D G M E N T

Mr and Mrs Wiggins have appealed against the decision by the Land Court to dismiss their appeal against the determination by the Valuer-General of an unimproved value of $85,000 on the parcel of land situated at 34 Bayside Drive, Beachmere, which has erected upon it a dwelling house occupied by them. The relevant date for the annual valuation assessment is 31st March, 1990. The appellants contended before the Land Court that the unimproved value of their land should have been determined at "$78,000 or less."

The grounds of appeal in the notice of appeal to the Land Court are -

"Lots are being sold in Bayside Drive on a 1919 subdivision showing 1,012 square metres. Why so? Several of these lots (including mine) has been reduced in size by sea erosion to approx 800 square metres. It is necessary to put up barriers of rocks and build walls etc to stop further erosion, an extra expense to those affected by sea erosion (upkeep every 2 years). Yet other lots in the same street do not have this problem and have their 1,012 square metres as per contract and R.P. and yes have the same valuation. Recent sales show 1012 square metres on the contracts and recent buyers do not realise that the amount of sea erosion is 10m x 20m 1/5 of the original R.P. I am (paying rates) valued on land that does not exist, and is not reclaimable (Primary Industries Dept). An erection of rock wall to combat waves and erosion has cost me

$4,000 approx. Surely all these factors should be taken in consideration. 800 sq metres cannot have the same valuation as 1012 s.m. especially as the V.G. has inspected the properties in the same street. "

Under section 16J of the Valuation of Land Act 1944, an appeal to the Land Court is limited to the grounds stated in the notice of appeal and the burden of proving any and every such ground shall be upon the owner. In proceedings before this Court the owner is limited to the grounds stated in the original notice of appeal and cannot rely upon evidence relating to matters not referred to in the notice of appeal (Franklin v. The

Valuer-General (1978) 5 Q.L.C.R. 181 (L.A.C.); Pratt v. The Valuer-General (1981/82) 8

Q.L.C.R. 145 (L.A.C.)).

The subject allotment is one of a number of allotments created in a subdivision in 1919. Titles which have issued show the area of the subject land and a number of other allotments at 1012 square metres. With the passage of time erosion has reduced the area of the exposed land in the subject allotment and some other allotments fronting the sea to approximately 800 square metres. As appears in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wiggins v The Valuer-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] QLAC 46
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the appeal of Wiggins v The Valuer-General, Mr and Mrs Wiggins sought to challenge the valuation of their land by the Valuer-General, arguing that the unimproved value of their land was overstated at $85,000. The Wiggins contended that the value should be lower due to factors such as sea erosion, which had reduced the land size, and the costs associated with erosion control. They also argued that comparable lots in the same street did not suffer from these issues and were valued at 1012 square metres rather than the 800 square metres of their lot. The appeal was dismissed by the Land Court and the Wiggins now appealed to the Land Appeal Court.

The key legal issue before the Land Appeal Court was whether the Valuer-General had erred in determining the unimproved value of the Wiggins' land. The Court had to determine if the Valuer-General properly considered the sea erosion and other factors cited by the Wiggins, and if the sales evidence used to support the valuation was admissible.

The Land Appeal Court found that the Valuer-General had not erred in the valuation. The Court held that the Valuer-General was required to determine the unimproved value of the land as at the relevant date, 31 March 1990, and could consider sales evidence occurring before and around that date. The Court found that the sales evidence used was admissible and supported the valuation applied. The Court also found that the Wiggins had failed to prove that the valuation was erroneous based on the grounds of appeal.

Accordingly, the appeal was dismissed and the determination of the Land Court was affirmed. The Valuer-General's valuation of the Wiggins' land at $85,000 was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established